7 ms·
Added sugar intake and its associations with incidence of cardiovascular disease
- jal278 2y ago> High intake of sweetened beverages was associated with higher risk for most of the studied outcomes, for which positive linear associations were found. In contrast, a low intake of treats was associated with a higher risk of all the studied outcomes. Not sure what to make of this -- some kind of other latent explanation (e.g. that many of those with the lowest intake of treats were on a diet due to bad health?). From the discussion section: > One aspect to take into consideration is however that there is a social tradition of “fika” in Sweden, where people get together with friends, relatives, or coworkers for coffee and pastries (41). Thus, one could hypothesize that the intake of treats is part of many people's everyday lives without necessarily being related with overall poor dietary or lifestyle patterns, and that it might be a marker of social life.
- lolinder 2y agoIsn't a simple possible explanation that people who are at high risk of (or already diagnosed with) these diseases make up a disproportionate chunk of the lowest sweets consumption bracket, simply because they're the ones who are actively restricting intake on advice from doctors? I'd naively expect most healthy people to fall in the second-to-lowest bracket—they're not actively restricting, but they don't have the pervasive bad habits of the highest consumers.
- kristjansson 2y agoThis is exactly what happened with the “red wine is good for you” claim
- ricardobeat 2y agoThat was my first thought as well, but the paper says that after excluding all people with a previous condition, that association remains unchanged. There might be something else, like particular diets, at play.
- lolinder 2y agoThat would rule out pre-existing conditions but not rule out people who already knew they were high risk for reasons other than a previous diagnosis (such as blood work, family history, etc.).
- dylan604 2y agoCould it be that the type of sugar used in the soft drinks is different than the type of sugar used in baking and where the body processes them differently? Yes, I'm questioning if high fructose corn syrup is worse for the body than table sugar. From everything I've ever seen, that tends to be the case. Or could it be that the non-fructose corn syrup artificial sweeteners are having more of a negative impact as people do not limit their in-take of those beverages since there's "no sugars" or "0 calories"?
- Wolfenstein98k 2y agoThere is not much evidence that it does any unique harm when you calorie-match it to regular sugar.
- shlant 2y agoyea I think people concern themselves too much with glucose vs fructose vs sucrose etc.
- analog31 2y agoThere might be a dietary difference, even though it seems superficially like there shouldn't be. This is my summary of the reaction from a chemist who did her master's degree in sugar chemistry: "Complex sugars (sucrose) and starches are broken up into glucose and fructose quite efficiently by enzymes in your digestive tract. Only glucose and fructose are absorbed into the bloodstream." That chemist is my mom. So I'm biased. ;-) The puzzle is whether table sugar and high fructose corn syrup have different dietary effects, and if they do, why. I don't think it's a settled matter.
- djtango 2y agoI'll go one step further. A gram of sugar in an orange is not the same as a gram of sugar in a teaspoon. Medium matters - that sugar in an orange is dissolved in the juice which is locked in the pulp. Who knows what the bioavailability of the sugar is in that messy fibrous orange you partially chewed? I guarantee it'll be less than that pure refined sugar in the spoon. Our "datafication" of nutrition and stuff like calories has led to so much silly pseudoscience. Calories are my biggest pet peeve of BS to take with a grain of salt. Why are we basing our nutrition and diet on the performance of the food in a bomb calorimeter?
- zug_zug 2y ago> that many of those with the lowest intake of treats were on a diet due to bad health I haven't read this study, but any study that isn't complete garbage normally would examine the to groups across all variables (age, gender, weight, health, etc) and deliberately control for any systematic differences between groups.
- tuukkah 2y agoYou can never control for all variables when humans are involved. (You can only control for variables that your data contains.) EDIT: From the article: "[There's a] need for future research to incorporate more accurate measures, such as urinary sodium excretion, to more precisely assess the impact of sodium intake as a potential confounding factor."
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 2y ago> Negative linear associations were found between treats intake (pastries, ice cream, chocolate, and sweets) and all outcomes, and between toppings intake (table sugar, honey, jams, and marmalades) and heart failure and aortic stenosis. Is all I wanted to know, study confirms my beliefs. Back to the pastry shop for me.
- Wolfenstein98k 2y ago1) I always read this publication's name as "Frontier Sin". 2) "Added sugar intake was positively associated with ischemic stroke and abdominal aortic aneurysm, although the highest risks of most outcomes were found in the lowest intake category." ????
- devmor 2y agoDoes not surprise me at all - just because too much of something is bad for you does not mean that some amount of it isn’t essential for bodily function.
- 1209412comb 2y ago>highest risks of most outcomes were found in the lowest intake category If I am reading this right, it means small amount is even worse than a lot of it.
- mrcode007 2y agoYou’re reading it wrong. Our body requires no added sugar consumption to function properly. Period. I know, it may come as a shocker to many (most?) people. https://www.heart.org/en/healthy-living/healthy-eating/eat-smart/sugar/added-sugars https://www.heart.org/en/healthy-living/healthy-eating/eat-s...
- shlant 2y ago> I know, it may come as a shocker to many (most?) people. Who argues that added sugar is required by the body? I think you might be conflating people who argue that the body requires glucose to function.
- mrcode007 2y agoIndirectly saying lower sugar intake had higher risks and so on but we know you can live just fine without any added sugar consumed without any risks. Some comments above asked if that is the correct reading and the science provided us the answers to this question a long time ago and the answer is no; eating no added sugar is healthy and you will be fine. You don’t have to take my word for it; you can take one of UCSF professor Lustig. https://robertlustig.com/metabolical/ https://robertlustig.com/metabolical/ Edit: yes of course, glucose is the energy of life but you don’t need to consume it. I think all(?) carbohydrates break down into glucose; ergo you can get it from broccoli. Simple test is blood glucose finger prick test after eating. But I did mean that there are people that argue that you need added sugar for proper nutrition. These people exist.
- nerdjon 2y agoOne of the best things I did for my diet was to try to rein in all of the places that sugar was snuck into my diet so when I want to get a candy bar or a soda I can not feel bad about it. My best example of this is peanut butter. I love peanut butter but started making my own with just dry roasted unsalted peanuts and a small amount of salt. Still enjoyed the things I wanted and fully sustainable. Didn’t actually eliminate anything and no “cheat” days. Somewhat recently I had a PB craving so I got a jar. Was shocked at how sweet it was.
- russell_h 2y agoDoes peanut butter often have added sugar? I’ve got Kirkland and Adam’s in my closet and am 99% sure neither lists that on the container.
- PaulStatezny 2y agoYes, at least in the USA it almost always has added sugar.
- holler 2y agoNot true, you can find unsalted organic peanut butter w/o any other ingredients at WholeFoods and elsewhere.
- russell_h 2y agoAt a glance I think you’re both right. Apparently I’ve been buying the good stuff by accident.
- tuukkah 2y agoYour statements are not contradictory: products at WholeFoods etc. are a minority in the big picture.
- PaulStatezny 2y agoTotally! And it's all upside (your body feels better afterward) no downside. (Ok, it's more expensive.) Especially when combined with other sweet ingredients, e.g. a banana – equally if not more delicious.
- didibus 2y agoThese are such interesting results. The plot only thickens. - Sweetened beverage were linked to cardiovascular disease - Table sugar, honey, jams, and marmalades were a little linked - Pastries, ice cream, chocolate, and sweets were negatively correlated Certain sugars were good for your heart. Obviously, this is not causation, but it's an interesting finding. I can't wait to learn more.
- forgotoldacc 2y agoAs a person who loves pastries and ice cream but drinks no sweetened beverages, while I have doubts whenever I see studies that say "XYZ food proven to be healthy", I'm going to hope this is true.
- vineyardmike 2y agoI wonder if this is more correlation with the “transport” medium. Pastries, ice cream, etc are high in fats, and thick, so they may break down and get absorbed by the body slower while soda is just sugar water so it may flood the body faster. Alternatively, maybe it’s a time-of-day thing? A dessert you eat after a meal means you’re consuming it on a full stomach while a snack is consumed empty.
- resoluteteeth 2y ago> Pastries, ice cream, etc are high in fats, and thick, so they may break down and get absorbed by the body slower while soda is just sugar water so it may flood the body faster. It's definitely not impossible this is the reason. Fat massively affects how fast sugar gets absorbed and this is something that seems to not have gotten much attention in terms of nutrition in general despite things like gi index (which just looks at individual foods in their own). If the thing that makes sugar bad is spiking blood sugar too much, it could be that how/when people consume it isn't being considered enough because of the assumption that it's always bad and needs to be eliminated as much as possible in general and so there's no point in trying to identify situations where it's not as harmful. But it could also just be some sort of issue with this study.
- anon234234208 2y ago
- vouaobrasil 2y agoI still believe in reducing added sugar intake as much as possible, simply because cardiovascular disease is not the only metric that we should be judging sugar. Eating it less for instance has made my energy levels much more stable. And of course, reduces dental problems.
- hombre_fatal 2y agoI wonder how many HNers accept this evidence but reject the converging lines of evidence across very different study designs (mendelian randomization, prospective cohort, RCTs) that cholesterol (more specifically, apoB) causes heart disease: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5837225/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5837225/
- shlant 2y agoalso pay attention to how most of the big names who discount the causality of LDL regularly criticize questionnaire-based studies (or Nutritional Epidemiology as a whole), but only when it goes against their personal beliefs.
- hombre_fatal 2y agoTrue, it's a common theme. But even someone who dies on the hill of FFQs has to contend with mendelian randomization and controlled trials.
- AnthonBerg 2y agoThanks for the paper! For other readers: To expand on this, the paper in the parent comment is “Low-density lipoproteins cause atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease. 1. Evidence from genetic, epidemiologic, and clinical studies. A consensus statement from the European Atherosclerosis Society Consensus Panel” (2017) – https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5837225/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5837225/ It refers to a second then-upcoming publication, which I believe is this one: ”Low-density lipoproteins cause atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease: pathophysiological, genetic, and therapeutic insights: a consensus statement from the European Atherosclerosis Society Consensus Panel” (2020) – https://academic.oup.com/eurheartj/article/41/24/2313/5735221 https://academic.oup.com/eurheartj/article/41/24/2313/573522... The difference between the titles: The 2017 paper discusses genetic, epidemiologic, and clinical studies and the 2020 one looks at pathophysiological, genetic, and therapeutic insights. (Personally, I’m in the pathophysiology-and-molecular-biology-or-GTFO camp. And these papers are good to have.) Thanks again! Just thought I’d share this second paper as I’d gone to look for it anyway.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- erie 2y agoIs it the type of added sugar that matters more, because I think they use the cheapest sugars to maximize their profits. But it is not that simple. 'Naturally occurring sugars in fruits and vegetables come with fiber, vitamins, and minerals, which can mitigate some of the negative effects3 Added sugars, whether from table sugar or other sources, provide empty calories without nutritional benefits Sweeteners like fruit juice, honey, molasses and maple syrup contain natural sugar and have some nutritional benefits. Fruit has fiber, vitamins and antioxidants. Even raw honey and maple syrup can contain antioxidants and minerals like iron, zinc, calcium and potassium. https://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/health/wellness-and-prevention/facts-about-sugar-and-sugar-substitutes https://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/health/wellness-and-preventi...
- soramimo 2y agoMy kid goes to school in LA. While in theory it's great that they get free food (breakfast, lunches etc), however, I'm absolutely shocked by how much sugar is in everything they offer to kids, in particular for breakfast.
- fud101 2y agoI believe it. What if you take sugar around and during exercise for performance reasons? Is that still bad or not? I have 30g sugar powder (gatorade).
- 0_____0 2y agoI have this question as well. I drink hi-carb beverages during exercise (had 200g of carb on the bike yesterday). I replace calories at or below parity. I suspect the benefits of cardio outweigh the issues introduced by sugar, but I don't have the knowledge base to do anything more than speculate.
- Etheryte 2y agoI've spent some time living in Sweden and I think there's a number of important details here that are not sufficiently highlighted that can radically change how to interpret the results. Swedes have a tradition of eating candy once a week on Saturdays. It's incredibly common for them to not have candy all week, then go buy an assortment bag on Saturday, eat it all, and then not have any again for a week. We don't know how this affects health outcomes compared to say, having a bit of candy every day, the glycemic load profiles will be widely different and we don't know if that matters or not. Fika, a coffee break with pastries, is a very strong cultural phenomenon. The pastries Swedes have are generally of very high quality and many of them also contain a considerable amount of fat, which as we know, helps buffer glycemic load. While it's mentioned in the study in passing, I think it should instead be one of the core focus points, it's hard to assess the effect of this as opposed to plain added sugar. And lastly, Swedes are very outdoorsy people. On any day of the week, you can see people strolling on nature trails, of which there are plenty, and spending a lot of time active in general. I would not be surprised if a large part of the health outcomes we see in statistics can be attributed to variance in this. So to summarize, while these results are interesting, I think there are too many hidden influences here that are not controlled for to really generalize these results in any way.
- ecmascript 2y agoAs a swede myself I agree somewhat but also I don't think what you're saying is the case anymore, even if it used to be. Today I think swedes in general consume a lot more sugar and much more in a super processed way that we used to. The culture of only eating candy on saturdays is probably alive and kicking among many children but I think isn't that strong anymore with grown ups. A lot of swedes, including myself, struggle with overweight and I think it is mostly how the food culture has changed to go from european to american inspired. It's basically impossible to find a restaurant close to a highway that doesn't serve ultra processed food that is cooked in some other kitchen far away or simply fast food where it used to be common place to have basically home cooked meals everywhere you went. Now it's mostly low quality crap food just like the USA. Also the pasteries to the fikas have changed to be more processed. Everything is made with vegetable oil instead of butter etc. Even things that are supposed to be healthy like yoghurt and similar things are filled up with thickener additives or unnecessary added sugars. Unfortunately Sweden goes along to be more and more americanized (especially food-wise) and I think it sucks. I wish Sweden would be more like the rest of europe and keep it's food culture. TL;DR: It used to be like the OP said, but it isn't anymore. It is hard to eat healthy because manufacturer keep pushing so much crap in their products and the availability of crappy food items is just insane.
- donatj 2y agoAbout ten years ago I gave up sugary sodas "for my health" at the behest of my doctor. Almost immediately, I gained a pretty significant amount of weight, rather than losing any. The opposite of what I was told would happen. I am near certain that the rest of my diet didn't shift in any significant fashion, certainly not enough to replace the caloric intake of 2 to 3 sodas per day and the soda itself was largely replaced with black coffee. Anyway I don't know what to take from this. I have not gone back to drinking soda, and I never really lost that weight. I suspect that our diets might be more complex than we realize though. I am not a doctor, your mileage may vary.
- CharlieDigital 2y agoI didn't buy this at all. Weight is a function of calories in and calories out. If you removed the calories from sugary drinks from your diet and kept the same level of activity, you will lose weight. Conversely, if you replaced those calories or reduced your activity, you will maintain weight. More than likely you unconsciously compensated for the loss of calories elsewhere in your diet.
- dbspin 2y agoI see this repeated all the time on Hackernews and this is absolutely not the case. Aging, gut microbiome changes and an enormous variety of medications can directly induce weight gain - while diet and exercise remain the same.
- infecto 2y agoI would have a hard time understanding how other factors would make up a heavier weighting than calories in vs calories out. I am certain there are other factors but I am not certain that those factor have make up the majority.
- dbspin 2y agoSure, happy to explain. Here's one example. "The mechanism of antipsychotics-induced weight gain (AIWG) is generally hypothesized by the alteration of glucose metabolism and increasing cholesterol and triglyceride levels." https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9170991/#:~:text=The%20mechanism%20of%20antipsychotics%2Dinduced,syndrome%20(4%E2%80%936) https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9170991/#:~:text=Th.... The problem seems to be that people confuse psychical activity with metabolic activity. The body isn't some kind of linear internal combustion engine. Numerous disease processes, medications etc will alter metabolic activity. A classic example is weight loss due to hypothyroidism.
- maerF0x0 2y agoStudy is loaded with confounding factors, and problems relating it as general advice vs cohort: here's a bunch quickly of the top of head, simply for discussion's sake -- not as a direct criticism of the authors / study. > Questionnaire-based diet and lifestyle assessments were administered in 1997 and 2009 These kinds of studies are not good because of a number of factors -- Morality of foods (people often answer questionaires with ideals or what they "ought" rather than fact), People are very bad at estimating their intakes, the data is ~15 yrs ago meaning lots of things can change in the interim > One aspect to take into consideration is however that there is a social tradition of “fika” in Sweden, where people get together with friends, relatives, or coworkers for coffee and pastries (41). Thus, one could hypothesize that the intake of treats is part of many people's everyday lives without necessarily being related with overall poor dietary or lifestyle patterns, and that it might be a marker of social life. Consumption of sweetened beverages, one the other hand, has been linked to lower overall dietary quality (42). Note that the positive associations were correlated with a _social_ form of eating. We already know folks with strong social connections, and distracting ways to slow life and eating, have better health outcomes. Also consider the zero sum form of eating whereby 100 calories of sugary beverage crowds out 100 calories of nutrient dense food (eg: broccoli). My own personal bias is that this is why vegetarians enjoy some health benefits -- they're simply eating a lot more vegetables (and not because meats are themselves deleterious). > No mention of adiposity (body fat percentage) A person with low and stable fat% is likely to have a very different response to sugars than someone with a high fat% (insulin resistance) and instability (yoyo-ing seems to matter albeit unclear how) > Cohort Unless you're a Swede of the average genetic profile ~97-09 then there's a gradient of issues related to your differences.