6 ms·
Misinformation fuels outrage and mindless social-media shares – study
- jpk 2y agoI'm glad this is something we're starting to figure out. The more something you read or hear makes you immediately mad, the less you should share or repeat it without additional verification. Our instinct is of course the opposite, which is why some are looking at Free Speech as a hindrance when attempting to address bad faith reporting and demagoguery. But our instinct when someone else has more food than us is to go bash them over the head with a rock and take it... however, we've spent great effort to raise all children not to do that, for obvious reasons. So the answer has to be that we preserve Free Speech, knowing that misinformation and demagogues will exist, but broadly train our critical thinking to override those instincts to the end that we can effectively divide truth from lies. We've had millennia to suppress our aggressive tendencies to the point where civilization is possible. But the retweet button is, like, 20 years old? We'll get there, but probably on generational timescales.
- Uehreka 2y agoLately I’ve come up with a heuristic that I think anyone can use: Before reposting something, ask yourself “have I heard about this website before today (or before this news event/cycle)?” If you haven’t, google the thing you just read about, and see if you can find an article from a source you’ve heard of before today. This isn’t to say that mainstream news doesn’t get things wrong, they definitely do sometimes, but so much of the real garbage I see on social media is people all sharing the same post from some random site called like newsline.xyz or something. In fact there’s so much low hanging fruit like that that I think a large amount of disinformation would go away if people just checked if anyone at all was reporting the story other than the source they’re reading.
- seattle_spring 2y agoPart of the problem with that approach is that a lot of people are getting their dis/misinformation from very large sources. Infowars, Breitbart, Zerohedge, The Free Press, Turning Point USA, etc: the list is endless of total nonsense sources that tend to spread around the same polemical and heterodox disinformation. People will cycle through the same content shared by each of these sources as "proof" of their claim when behind the scenes it's all just covering a single person's errant Tweet.
- mattlondon 2y agoYep was going to say something similar. Probably best to stick to something like the BBC news for most things IMO - they're not funded by advertising or some billionaire trying to influence things, not politically aligned (some people will argue against that though), and do generally decent journalism.
- Uehreka 2y agoThis technique won’t stop those people, but then idk what will. I’m mostly talking about the kinds of things I get frustrated at seeing my liberal friends post. Usually if I see one of them post something that’s total BS and I point out that it’s BS, they’ll apologize and take it down. But I don’t have the energy to constantly be “that guy” all the time. I think if more of my friends did this (since their reactions show that they are in fact interested in sharing things in good faith) then at the very least my own facebook timeline would have less junk in it.
- vixen99 2y agoWhen we single out publications, let's ensure we're not biased against the Right or the Left. https://gatewayjr.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/Media-Bias-Chart-5.1-Licensed-1.png https://gatewayjr.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/Media-Bias-...
- PierceJoy 2y agoDespite the intent to show an equal distribution visually, if you actually pay attention to the individual outlets you see a few things. Nearly all the outlets in the summit block, over 40 reliability score, are considered left or far left by republicans. The most extreme fringe of low reliability score are all right wing. I’m honestly not sure how any critical thinker could believe both sides are equally bad at spreading misinformation. Both sides do it to an extent, but the right is clearly worse, and that’s what your chart shows. Believing that is not bias. It’s reality.
- thunky 2y agoI would say that the chart somewhat limited based on the score that CNN is getting. Every single day for years if you were to turn on CNN at any time of the day you would see stories about Trump + Russia. Sure you can call that "analysis" but I think it under-represents how much of an effect the repeated beating people over the head with one-way "analysis" has. You probably wouldn't call this misinformation, but I belive it is deception because CNN markets itself as fact-based "news" (https://www.cnncreativemarketing.com/project/cnn_factsfirst/ https://www.cnncreativemarketing.com/project/cnn_factsfirst/), but in fact it's just entertainment disguised as news. And like Fox News, CNN tries to bait it's viewers into emotional reactions and team-choosing, which ends up causing more division between us. Anyway, that's why I get all my news from the Weather Channel.
- lowbloodsugar 2y agoLet’s say this idea is brilliant. How you gonna get that in front of people and then persuade them to use it?
- mym1990 2y agoHad a fun experience at work this week: tsunami warning goes off on the west coast while we are all in a remote meeting. I say that there has been a large earthquake off the coast. 30 seconds go by and coworker posts a link to a news article with the headline that "tsunami warning tests were being conducted that week" and goes on to tell everyone it is just a test. I open the article and immediately see that it is from 8 months ago. Its an easy mistake and I do it all the time as well, nevertheless it was interesting to see how quickly the wrong thing gets out.
- XorNot 2y agoIronically this used to be one of the better uses of Twitter.
- mmooss 2y ago> Before reposting something, ask yourself “have I heard about this website before today (or before this news event/cycle)?” Here's a better heuristic: Stop wasting your precious time and mind on low-grade crap. Read/watch high-value sources only - you won't run out; there are too many to read them all.
- ahartmetz 2y agoIt's not only the source, it's also the kind of content. It's of course not 100% reliable, but most bad content is pretty lurid stuff. Wedge issue content of any type can be safely ignored as well, or rather it's unsafe not to ignore.
- mmooss 2y ago> most bad content is pretty lurid stuff That is the badly executed bad content. Well-executed disinfo/misinfo is what gets you. Believing we can tell the difference just by looking at qualities such as luridness is the critical error. It's like people who think they can spot fake reviews - they can spot the reviews that don't fool them, not the reviews that do fool them.
- ahartmetz 2y agoIt's not a perfect filter, but I think it's useful.
- randysalami 2y agoGot some good aggregate tips?
- mmooss 2y agoI'm not sure what you mean by 'aggregate', but there are still serious journalistic organizations: * NY Times: Ignore the politicization of their reputation, and the demonization. Ignore that it's the boring, status quo answer - it is for a reason. Just look at the articles, which describe their methods for that article: The research is extensive, statements are made carefully, and they offend everyone on all sides equally. Their claims tend to be born out in the long run (though nothing is perfect and certainly they've made mistakes). * Financial Times: Very expensive, but very good if you can afford it. * The Guardian: Certainly a liberal point of view, but quality research for their journalism. With the recent corruption of the Washington Post and CNN, and MSNBC (though that was always biased), we are running out of top quality, credible news.
- 0xbadcafebee 2y agoI never could understand how misinformation gets spread so easily via social media, until the pandemic. My friend basically had a slow breakdown, getting more and more scared and angry and upset. She'd be hooked to the social feeds, and re-share the scary ones that sounded plausible, but often they were fallacious, misleading, exaggerated. She was just trying to cope, and she thought she was helping other people by re-sharing them. Eventually she had to quit socials entirely, and it took a while for her to emotionally recover, but she's better now. I know this is just one example, but it feels very much like an endemic problem I call "media sickness". The media [in all its forms] is set up to make us ill. It scares us, misleads us. It invents and inflates controversy, focusing on things that don't really matter, yet making them seem imminent and life-threatening. It shows us only what we want to see, or what we want to believe. Or what someone else wants us to see, the way they want it seen. And then it tells us to buy things, which is the ultimate goal of all of this manipulation. And we do, because the movies, podcasts, Doritos, and sneakers from Amazon, are the only things that soothe our frazzled nerves and distract us before the next media blitz. Our whole American culture today has an epidemic of media sickness. It's worse than the obesity and opioid epidemics, because it's even infecting the halls of power and changing geopolitics. It crosses every class and infects every home. I think the only solution is to go cold turkey. Cut the social media, the TV, the news. Live your life free of influence. You might find that it's especially hard to do that, to live without the consumption, without the constant presence of advertiser-driven content. Even here on HN, we are subjected to the manipulation machine. It's so hard to get free of it.
- lm28469 2y ago> Our whole American culture today has an epidemic of media sickness. It's everywhere, I often go to rural eastern europe, ~200 inhabitants town without municipal water type of beat, families stop meeting for christmas &co over political BS they read online, it's probably even worse because half of the topics are imported from the US and don't even exist locally
- roenxi 2y agoI'm a lot less worried about misinformation than I am about whether we're letting reasonable, educated or informed people speak up. One of the interesting parts of COVID was it seemed like anyone with a PhD and a YouTube channel was contorting to try and avoid ... I want to call it something less inflammatory than a censorship regime but I'm not sure what else to call it. They were often making points that were technically correct and held up reasonably well in hindsight about possible origins of the disease, likely efficacy of different strategies and going through scientific studies in real time. I never found out what the qualifications of the YouTube Trust & Safety team had. I doubt they were mostly PhD holders. I don't mind YouTubers being wrong from time to time, but the systemic suppression of complaints based on some central office's opinion on whether they are legitimate can't work. It didn't seem to work in practice either.
- stevenAthompson 2y agoI see why you might be concerned, but your freedom of speech does not include a right to force others to repeat it for you. YouTube is a business. If they don't want to use their platform to spread your ideas the government shouldn't force them. Besides, YouTube is not a reputable peer reviewed journal. Actual science was not hindered.
- dboreham 2y agoLet's all go yelling FIRE in crowded rooms then.
- logicchains 2y agoThat's legal in the US if someone actually believes there's a fire.
- stevenAthompson 2y agoLegal and moral are not synonyms.
- 2y ago
- hvsc6 2y agoSocial media/ad tech architecture has to change. Dont tell people to change. Its a red flag of intellectual bankruptcy. Its a get out of jail free card for mindless corporate robots. The clergy used to provide these cards to feudal lords once upon a time. Today the media and edu system provide it to corporations. More content = more ad real estate. If you have a magic machine that produces more and more rent collecting real estate what happens to the value of real estate? Meanwhile the total pool of available human Attention doesnt grow. If you further filter that pool by global avg disposable income you find its a very small pool. And its being over fished massively. (Check the UN report on the Attention Economy) This is a bizarre abnormal system that produces accumulating consequences. Revenue of ad tech keeps growing. Content keeps growing. It keeps getting more addictive. Outrage is the natural output of such an enviroment that has been imposed on everyone. Politicians have to spend mpre and more on Ads to get elected. Becoming more and more on dependent on money to win. So they are struggling to counter balance these forces. We have to treat Attention the same way we treat Land, Air, Water or Natural Resources. Companies cant pollute or exploit things without limit. Ads cant be injected in every 2 mm of space available and every 2 ms of time.
- 23B1 2y agoThese are all banal platitudes built on the same basic rage that you purport to dislike; the solution you imply requires centralization and censors. The only solution is also the easiest; switch it off.
- sho 2y ago> Dont tell people to change. Its a red flag of intellectual bankruptcy. But people do have to change. The core problem is a transition from: - sources being few and somewhat reliable (traditional media), and had reputations to uphold - normal people faced significant barriers to sharing information widely to a world in which neither of those constraints still holds. And there's no going back, no putting the genie back in the bottle. It turns out that when you give everyone unlimited communication, it exposes weaknesses in how people and societies consume and manage information that were present before but didn't have the environment they needed to materialize. Well, they have that environment now. There's no going back really unless you want to clamp down on free sharing of information and the "peer to peer internet" in general. People will just have to change their relationship to information. It will take time, but I'm sure we can manage. Social media and ad tech certainly aren't helping but the root cause is basically technological change and unless you want to roll that back, targeting the companies won't fix it.
- EGreg 2y agoThis goes deeper than you think. It is an inevitable product of profit-driven lTe stage capitalism If you want to know the solution, and not just lament the problem, here it is: https://www.laweekly.com/restoring-healthy-communities/ https://www.laweekly.com/restoring-healthy-communities/ Also building things like https://rational.app https://rational.app
- RGamma 2y agoJust one more app and everything's alright. One of these days now...
- tomxor 2y agoThis same relationship between emotion and inhibition of critical faculties plays a large part in the high error rate of justice systems around the world. In the extreme resulting in the bizarrely illogical "someone has to pay" sentiment of vengeful victims and jury, almost to the point they are aware their instinct is wrong but would prefer to live in the fantasy of the closure it offers. Perhaps some good can come out of a technology over exploiting this human weakness, by forcing society to learn how to combat these weaknesses where it's even more important.
- ImHereToVote 2y agoIn many ways, vigilantism helped build higher societies. No tribe emerged from the primordial aether with bureaucratized and abstracted concepts of legality and ethics which in any way resembled high civilizations. Vigilantism was one of the costs "priced in" by social codes. If you screwed a man hard enough, he might just come for you. You can see this reflected in folk wisdom such as "nothing more dangerous than a man with nothing to lose". That cute little adage isn't saying "oh, those with nothing on the line try harder", it's warning that once someone has no chips left on the game board, they might flip the table. History is replete with this echo: "surrender with honor", "allowing an exit", "chose to retire", etc. In our very safe, very insulated, very civilized world, these might seem quant or be accepted as received moral precepts, but they are based on a firm inherited calculus: every man, no matter how reasonable, has a point where he'll turn to tooth and claw, if only to make you bleed with him. We might think of our age as one built on these costs, but so managed that we no longer pay them. Unjust words no longer result in duels, but we say slander is bad. The shopkeeper no longer has to beat thieves, because the justice system punishes theft. And the tribe doesn't have to mob-justice the degenerate who wrecked the common green, because social shame makes the idea of transgressing abhorrent, well before the thought of violence arises. Or rather... our society was functional. For a blip of time in the late modernity, the West managed to reach an amazing peak. We'd priced in vigilantism to our social systems so efficiently that the vigilantism was no longer ever actioned. Unfortunately, over time this lead to virtuous violence being classed as mere violence, and morally equal to unjust violence. Like many modern ills, this wasn't felt at first, as the moral inertia of the old system propelled behavior that was no longer incentivized by the current market. Slowly, though, new actors came about in an age with new incentives, and they better adapted to their environment. If a powerful CEO can get ahead with profit maximization through legal murder, and the only penalty is a fractional hit on a rocketing upward graph? Why not? The only external cost is some disapproval from people he doesn't care about. He's optimized for his environment, because he's recognized that the formerly "priced in" vigilantism behind that disapproval has been replaced with a memory of said vigilantism, like a vestigial clause in a defunct contract. We've been at this point for some time. The grinding inhumanity of our era would have brought our ancestors to violence long before. We've constrained this through the anti-agentic "all violence is (equally) bad" propaganda. So yes, this murder, and moreover, the general public acceptance, is indicative of social degeneration. But it's not a descent from normality. It's a return. A ball was thrown into the air, and for a time (the late twentieth and early twenty first centuries) it seemed to hang suspended at its apex, but it has now begun to fall. The proper response is to recognize where we are, what we are, the historical anomaly we are exiting, and decide how to proceed.
- jongjong 2y agoWe cannot have accurate information in a highly unequal, unjust society. Inequality requires a lot of misinformation to uphold; such amount of misinformation coming out of institutions will necessitate that people craft potent counter-narratives to fight back for their survival. Institutions cannot keep taking wealth and expect people to top themselves one by one as they run out of opportunities and resources. Some people will top themselves, but most will fight back. We should all be grateful that they do it with words. If things keep going the way they have, fast forward 10 to 20 years and people will look back at today as a wonderful, peaceful time that it is (at least it should be for some people). A lot of people don't realize how good they have it right now. Their desire to uphold a deeply flawed system which they benefited from (past tense), without any reforms, comes across as extreme greed. If you see people with pitchforks outside and think the solution is to ban pitchforks, then your worldview is flawed.
- mattlondon 2y agoI think inequality just stems from human nature. People are unconsciously selfish, and life is unfair. We have not been forced into it by misinformation - we are, by nature, looking out for our own selfish self-interest. Sure we can and do help people out, but the default from nature is survival of the fittest, and some people just get delt a shit hand in life (where in the world they were born, luck, events outside of their control etc) It has been like this for millenia - not just since mass media has been a thing. Removing misinformation will not suddenly lead to universal global equality, it will not "break the spell". Life will still suck for a lot of people in the world if we turned Twitter off tomorrow.
- ChrisArchitect 2y agoRelated: Browsing negative content online makes mental health struggles worse: Study https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42353944 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42353944
- nelblu 2y agoConfirmation bias alert: About 8 years ago, I deleted all social media precisely because I intuitively felt this way: >“The misinformation ecosystem is not just driven by user behavior, it’s also driven by algorithms,” he says. “When you engage with misinformation—even in disagreement—you’re actually contributing to the increase of misinformation in the ecosystem because you’re letting the algorithm know that it’s drawing engagement.”
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 2y agoI love to bash social media as much as anybody, but, how different is this from the hoaxes, crazes and hysterias that society went through before social media was ever a thing? Even if we were to eliminate social media, people would just figure out another way to spread viral memes. Humans are wired to rapidly spread ideas the same way they spread the cold virus, not much we can do about it unless we isolate ourselves from each other, or introduce some kind of a govt (or AI) reviewer in between us and every piece of information we receive.
- mattlondon 2y agoThe major difference in my mind is the volume and speed. A constant fire-hose of it being beamed at you 24/7 I don't think it is hard to ignore the outrage and drama on social media if you want to, but do people really want to?
- forgetfreeman 2y agoI feel like the question answers itself. We know what the world looked like before widespread adoption of social media, and what it looks like now. Before: obvious bullshit struggled to gain any audience at all and fringe stuff was largely contained by the cost of stamps and labor. After: one rando successfully convinced untold hundreds of thousands (if not millions) of individuals globally that lizard people exist, probably from their phone, in their spare time.
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 2y agoYou really don't need social media for that. The Rwandan genocide was triggered by one shitty radio station. People will always find a way to easily distribute propaganda.
- forgetfreeman 2y agoEasily? To replicate that you'd need to at minimum hijack a radio station. Compare/contrast with the relative difficulty of fishing your phone out of your pocket. There is also the minor issue of instant global reach, so yeah, hijacking radio stations on several continents should keep one busy a while I'd imagine.
- gmerc 2y agoWe knew this at Facebook a decade ago…. and goaled everyone on shares and engagement.
- renewiltord 2y agoOn Twitter I’ve started to block anyone who posts outrage stuff, even if they’re “debunking” it. I couldn’t care less. I just want to not read it. It’s actually nicer for me.
- tjpnz 2y agoThat's not a good longterm solution on a platform which will continue to subject you to it - by design.
- renewiltord 2y agoWhether it's a good solution or not is dependent on your effort/utility curves. And it's a social network with low switching cost: I don't need a long-term solution. One day I will stop using it and it will cost me nothing to do so. So it only matters that it works now.
- seydor 2y agoSocial media should take a page from LLM applications and warn humans that humans can make mistakes and hallucinate etc. But Oh no! our precious unique snowflake opinions? but yeah, everybody has one
- est 2y agoYes there's a problem and it's bad. The question is: how to fix it? More specificaly, who is to decide which information is "correct"? Do we need a "Ministry of Truth"? China does tackle this problem with a government branch called "Cyber Administration Office". Compared to this "100% authentic information", I'd rather to endure misinformation as noise, thanks.
- enaaem 2y agoThe biggest problem are state actors. They have infinite resources and have completely different motives from most normal users. I follow football (soccer) news, and it's refreshing and interesting to see news that is not contaminated by state actor bots. There is definitely bias and fake news, but fake news hardly ever spreads far and lingers long.
- RajT88 2y agoAlso, Water Wet.
- mikewarot 2y agoCuration of sources is the key skill for dealing with this change. In areas where you have no expertise, it's helpful to observe their predictive power over time and use that as a proxy for competence.