6 ms·
Taxpayers spend 22% more per patient to support Medicare Advantage
- toomuchtodo 2y agoMedicare Advantage is a siphon from Medicare funds to corporate shareholders under the guise of for profit efficiency.
- jmyeet 2y agoNo argument from me other than to say: you've just described every public-private partnership, ever. The seemingly inevitable part-privatization we're now facing for Social Security and Medicare is nothing more than the wealthy looting the public purse.
- WarOnPrivacy 2y ago> No argument from me other than to say: you've just described every public-private partnership, ever. This is patently untrue. The entity that paid for my 2yr college was a public-private partnership. It was administered by the Dept of Labor. The private end was a mix of businesses and philanthropy that wanted to better align education and careers. Funding was predicated on students completing degrees and a period of related employment. It was tremendously successful. It was also immediately axed when the 'Contract with America' took effect.
- relaxing 2y ago“Public-private partnership” normally refers to public money going to private enterprise. I’m not sure what private money going to quasi-public higher ed, publically administered(?) would qualify as.
- jmyeet 2y agoI can't speak to the specifics of whatever program you went through. Whatever it is, I'm glad it worked out for you. But my question is: why does college cost anything? Particularly more vocational courses, which 2 year Associate's degrees tend to be. We have a model for this: the military. You pick a job, they train you to do that job and then you do that job. There is absolutely no reason why education can't be this accessible to everyone.
- zihotki 2y agoIt's a description of a toxic partnership. Not all partnerships are toxic.
- Loughla 2y agoI don't know why you're being downvoted. Public private partnerships at the Federal level have historically just been elaborate grafts to enrich the already wealthy at everyone's expense. Ever read The Shock Doctrine?
- orwin 2y agoAll PPP have levels of grift. The only ones that don't have overwhelming bureaucracy oversight that makes them really, really inefficient and costly. In almost all cases, it's better for the state to build themselves, then lease/rent to private companies, or operate themselves in some cases. Basically free market is shit at central planning, and the state is shit at offering diversity and finding out preferences.
- jmyeet 2y agoWe know why. There are an awful lot of people who are either the wealthy who are exploiting the working class or, way more likely, they think they someday will be: > “John Steinbeck once said that socialism never took root in America because the poor see themselves not as an exploited proletariat but as temporarily embarrassed millionaires. Why else would people fight so hard against Jeff Bezos paying slightly more in taxes? Jeff would use you as fertilizer or reactor shielding if it ticked up profits. You are not and will never be Jeff Bezos. HN just skews to people who aspire to be the exploiters.
- frmersdog 2y agoThis is why I groan when people talk about, say, how the government needs to "incentivize" increased building volume in order to solve the housing crisis. If you accept the argument that there's a shortage of physical units (and not just a shortage of affordable units that haven't been converted to rentals, or just simply kept off the market)... the real estate market is never going to kneecap itself. No matter how much money we give them. The government needs to start building houses. Directly. Whatever loss is incurred will pale in comparison to the costs (social and otherwise) of another few decades of paying private corporations not to solve the problem. We REALLY should have learned our lesson after what happened with the broadband rollout in the early 2000s.
- KumaBear 2y agoI always believed a good president would declare a national emergency. Deploy the military, national guard, ect and begin a massive housing campaign. Imagine what can be built in 5 years time.
- spondylosaurus 2y agoYou'll never guess which corporate entity got caught siphoning too much federal money via Medicare Advantage fraud... https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/16/business/dealbook/unitedhealthcare-improperly-took-money-from-medicare-suit-says.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/16/business/dealbook/unitedh... Also, here's a longer read about the same topic. The fraud wasn't limited to a single insurer, but some have been more blatant than others. https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2019/02/04/the-personal-toll-of-whistle-blowing https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2019/02/04/the-personal-t...
- kstrauser 2y agoI am shocked, shocked!
- xyst 2y agoWith recent events in the American healthcare industry, let’s hope this can be a rallying call to end privatization of healthcare. Profiteering by holding patients and their families hostage with overly complex payout schemes, “deny, delay, defend” policies aimed at squeezing max profits, and complicating the relationship between patient care, doctors, and hospitals/clinics is beyond unethical. It’s inhumane.
- tokioyoyo 2y agoNot to be a doomer, but we have very short attention span. News will move on roughly within 2 weeks once we have something more “fun” to discuss. Most of the NA capital understands this, so no change will be experienced. There are very rare exceptions, but if I was a betting guy, i’d bet against.
- stackskipton 2y ago>Not to be a doomer, but we have very short attention span. Yea, fixing this would require decades long effort that is extremely difficult without catalyst. Most of European Health Care came about after periods of extreme difficulty like WWI, Great Depression or WWII. Closest US ever came was Great Depression and unlike Europe, US didn't experience massive hardship after WWII.
- tokioyoyo 2y agoPretty much, yeah. Also, since the system technically works, and produces decent results compared to other countries' results... it's a hard sell to rile up super majority of the population for some change.
- OnlineGladiator 2y ago> and produces decent results compared to other countries' results What metrics are you looking at?
- 2y ago
- whoitwas 2y agoTrump has promised to end social security and medicare. We can't believe anything he says, buy maybe ending medicare could somehow end private insurance and the indentured servitude of Americans? Currently most Americans have to be employed to have access to the worst system in the first world ...
- ethbr1 2y agoThis is about Medicare Advantage [0] specifically, and how it's apparently more costly than traditional Medicare, even after accounting for confounding factors. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medicare_Advantage https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medicare_Advantage
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- whoitwas 2y agoi don't understand why you would reply to me with a definition of MA. it's laid out plainly in thousands of words in the article.
- ethbr1 2y agoBecause Medicare and Medicare Advantage are two different systems, only one of which is hybrid-private? So you might want to be more specific in what you're talking about in your original comment, re: Medicare.
- whoitwas 2y agoWhy? If medicare is ended and there's no more private insurance, MA also would cease to exist. You're just bad at comprehension and probably didn't read the article based on context.
- computably 2y agoWhat logical leap am I missing here? Ending Medicare would do absolutely nothing to change the fact that most Americans receive private insurance through their employer, it would just result in 67 million people losing their insurance.
- ethbr1 2y agoGreat article that does justice to the complexity and nuances of the system. From the underlying report that's cited [0]: >> We include uncorrected coding intensity and favorable selection in our analysis so that the MA and FFS populations are comparable. Because benchmarks do not account for these adjustments, it is also unlikely that plan bids assume the effects of uncorrected coding and favorable selection. With these adjustments, we project that benchmarks in 2024 are 132 percent of [traditional Medicare fee-for-service / FFS] spending (i.e., the amount that would have been spent on MA enrollees if they were in FFS). >> Overall, plan bids — 14 percent of which are projected to be nonmedical expenses for administration and profit — in 2024 are an estimated 101 percent of FFS spending. >> Thus, though MA plans have lower medical costs than FFS, these projected efficiencies are offset by plans’ projected administration costs and profits. >> In total, we project that plans will offer the standard Medicare benefit at about the same cost as FFS in 2024, which implies that the majority of extra benefits for MA enrollees are not financed by plans offering the benefit at lower costs than FFS, but rather by the taxpayers and beneficiaries who fund the program. Overall, we estimate that coding and selection cause MA payments to be 22 percentage points above FFS spending in 2024. That difference translates into MA payments that are a projected $83 billion above FFS spending in 2024. [0] p373 https://www.medpac.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/Mar24_Ch12_MedPAC_Report_To_Congress_SEC-1.pdf https://www.medpac.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/Mar24_Ch12...
- Animats 2y agoTraditional Medicare plus a type F supplement covers just about everything at 100%. Except hearing aids, glasses, and dental work. You can go to any doctor that accepts Medicare. "Medicare Disadvantage" is an HMO scheme, with limited doctor lists and lots more limiting rules. Avoid.
- onetokeoverthe 2y agopublic greenbacks (that got lincoln wacked), privately printed fedmoney with taxes as part of the scam, or sam altman types hitting the 'make more crypto' send key.
- MilnerRoute 2y agoTLDR: Medicare Advantage's payment rules "overpay insurance companies," according to the article, "on the taxpayer’s dime."
- prirun 2y agoThe ACA lets people get healthcare insurance who are not otherwise eligible for it, for example: part-time workers, independent contractors, employees of companies with fewer than 50 employees, temporarily unemployeed (fired, laid off, switching careers or jobs), people who have lost coverage because their spouse lost coverage. That's a pretty broad swath of people! Some people qualify for a tax subsidy that can be anywhere from $0 to the entire cost of a plan, depending on their income. A unique feature is that the subsidy is based on your expected income for the upcoming year, but if you make less than that (are laid off for example) or more (independent contract gets an unexpected contract), the subsidy is adjusted when you file your taxes. Currently the ACA does not accept anyone who has a policy through work. IMO, every should have the option of getting ACA healthcare coverage. If their work coverage is better or cheaper, they can stick with that, but if their work coverage is worse or more expensive, employees should be allowed to get ACA coverage, with the employer paying part or all of the subsidy (what they would have paid to a private insurance company for the employee) instead of just the government.