27 ms·
Small AI Chip Maker Marvell Now More Valuable Than Intel
- bookofjoe 2y agoGift link: https://www.wsj.com/tech/marvell-ai-chip-manufacturing-faa89cb6?st=ebwjih&reflink=desktopwebshare_permalink https://www.wsj.com/tech/marvell-ai-chip-manufacturing-faa89... https://archive.ph/kCPUx https://archive.ph/kCPUx
- joe_the_user 2y ago[flagged]
- tgv 2y agoThe WSJ pays it journalists. It's not free. It needs money. Bezos' interference may have left a bit of a bad taste, it's still a reputable paper that doesn't need exposure here.
- bookofjoe 2y agoHey, wait a sec! Last week when I didn't use the descriptor "Gift link" I was roundly thrashed here for failure to identify it as such. Even though I thought the criticism was unwarranted, I decided to do what the commenter said I should do — thus today's identification as such. FWIW I pay $38.99/month for a subscription, which enables me to provide gift links to HN. No good deed goes unpunished, or at least uncriticized here.
- tyre 2y agoIf you don’t love being attacked for word choice no matter what you do, you don’t love Hacker News commenting
- bookofjoe 2y agoTruth
- Wowfunhappy 2y agoFwiw I sincerely appreciate the gift link!
- impish9208 2y ago> FWIW I pay $38.99/month for a subscription You’re paying way too much, man. Who’s your WSJ guy? They’ll give it to you for much less if you go through the motions of cancelling it on the website.
- bookofjoe 2y agoI'm an old man, 76 years old. The time it takes to go through the motions... is way more than I want to pay, considering each day is more likely to be my last. But I agree with your sentiment.
- gjsman-1000 2y agoOne Taiwanese invasion or blockade, and Intel is immediately back on top, no longer considered incompetent, and Marvell’s fighting bankruptcy. Which goes to show how quickly everything can change. Everything’s built on sand, literally.
- BonoboIO 2y agoYou mean intel that uses TSMC to manufacture their chips, because they can not create top of the line chips themself?
- walterbell 2y agoThe older Intel chips used by the defense industrial base are Made in America.
- tester756 2y agoThose decisions are usually made years in advance
- wtallis 2y agoThat doesn't actually change the fact that Intel is now significantly relying on TSMC for several important product lines, nor does it change the fact that even if TSMC were destroyed in a war, Intel would still be struggling with a shortage of competence.
- scrlk 2y ago> Murphy, who has served as chief executive officer of Marvell Technology since 2016, has been among the few names floated as potential replacements for the recently ousted Pat Gelsinger at Intel’s corner office. As an aside, it's funny to read "Intel's corner office". Andy Grove eschewed a private office and other executive perks, opting to work in a standard cubicle: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrew_Grove#Egalitarian_ethos https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrew_Grove#Egalitarian_ethos
- stn8188 2y agoThank you so much for this comment, detail and link. I was not aware of this aspect of his management style. The current CEO of my company has spoken highly of Andy Grove (I believe he was at Intel during Grove's tenure) and learning these details has helped me to see some similarities in my own company leadership.
- zooweemama 2y agoIf you want to go even deeper, I recommend Andy Grove’s books “High output management” and “Only the paranoid survive”.
- bsder 2y agoGrove is, in fact, mostly responsible for the current problems at Intel. Because of Grove's management style, information is ammunition--you do not share it. This is anathema to problems that need heavy R&D to solve. The corollary to this is that if you know someone is making a mistake, you let them as it improves your political position.
- IntelMiner 2y agoThe "job-centric" American economy feels...harrowing now "While Grove supported helping technology startups, he also felt that America was wrong in thinking that those new companies would increase employment. "Startups are a wonderful thing," he wrote in a 2010 article for Bloomberg, "but they cannot by themselves increase tech employment."[40] Although many of those startups and entrepreneurs would achieve tremendous success and wealth, said Grove, he was more concerned with the overall negative effect on America: "What kind of a society are we going to have if it consists of highly paid people doing high-value-added work and masses of unemployed?"
- int0x29 2y agoAI chip maker? Not everything needs to be branded AI. They make networking ASICs.
- wtallis 2y agoCalling Marvell an "AI chip maker" is bizarre. They're mostly a networking company, with a fair bit of storage stuff, too. Like any tech company these days, they're trying to jump on the AI bandwagon, but that hasn't actually changed what markets they're operating in.
- dlcarrier 2y agoThey are mostly a chip maker though, both directly selling semiconductors and selling products based on them. Sure, they call their processors an AI product, but so do Intel, AMD, and pretty much every other ARM licensee. The real kicker is that they picked up their ARM license from Intel, when they bought the XScale line (now Armada) in 2006.
- wtallis 2y agoIt's been a long time since Marvell was seeing any lingering benefits from that XScale acquisition. Their more compute-oriented products owe a lot more to the Cavium acquisition.
- lolinder 2y ago> that hasn't actually changed what markets they're operating in. Actually, if you look at their quarterly report, the breakdown of their revenue by market has changed dramatically in the last year. Revenue from the data center market went from 36% to 71% of their revenue, a change which they attribute to AI creating demand. Meanwhile networking dropped from 24% to 10% of their revenue, and other categories have gone down as well. From the report: > Net revenue in the third quarter of fiscal 2025 was $1.5 billion and was 7% higher than net revenue in the third quarter of fiscal 2024. This was due to a 98% increase in sales from the data center end market compared to the three months ended October 28, 2023. The increase was partially offset by decreases in sales from the carrier infrastructure end market by 73%, from the enterprise networking end market by 44%, from the consumer end market by 43% and from the automotive/industrial end market by 22%. > We have seen strong revenue growth from our data center end market, driven by robust demand for our electro-optics and custom compute products from AI applications. https://app.quotemedia.com/data/downloadFiling?webmasterId=101533&ref=318767044&type=PDF&symbol=MRVL&cdn=d112c955f290337b28e70dd8f5bc9923&companyName=Marvell+Technology+Inc.&formType=10-Q&dateFiled=2024-12-04 https://app.quotemedia.com/data/downloadFiling?webmasterId=1...
- buildbot 2y agoAI chip or even networking chip maker is somewhat incorrect. Marvell makes every kind of chip, will design you a chip, sell you IP, whatever you want. They started with disk drive controllers, recently they’ve made a decent NVME controller. They bought global foundries custom asic devision in 2019 and that’s when they really got into the custom chip business (according to wikipedia).
- mugivarra69 2y agoits not a small maker at all, and it is not an ai chip maker.
- lysace 2y agoIntel: 130k employees Marvell: 6.5k employees
- dlcarrier 2y agoNvidia: 30k employees AMD: 26k employees For Intel, the number of employees is a liability, not an asset.
- gpapilion 2y ago... Fab + design... its apples to oranges. TSMC for example has 77k employees and looking to add 23k more. Packaging and testing are labor intensive, and require folks to be added in different geographies.
- dlcarrier 2y agoGlobalFoundries: 12k employees SMIC: 20k employees UMC: 20k employees TSMC only has that many employees because they have a nearly 2/3rd market share of all ASIC production.
- tptacek 2y agoMarvell has a fraction of the revenue, so I assume this is just a verdict on which company has better growth prospects? I mean, that's always true of market valuations, but: could have been the case whether or not Intel was hitting its marks?
- orliesaurus 2y agoDoes anyone know if the US military has a preference on Intel chips vs other manufacturers?
- dlcarrier 2y agoThe US military has a preference for whichever manufacturer can specialize in filling out the paperwork. Intel is one of them, but so is Marvell: https://www.marvell.com/products/custom-asic/marvell-government-solutions.html https://www.marvell.com/products/custom-asic/marvell-governm...
- pavlov 2y agoIn an ironic twist, Intel used to make the highest-performance ARM chips until 2006. They were popular in PDAs and early smartphones, but not x86 and therefore strategically embarrassing. So Intel sold the Xscale family, just before iPhone and Android happened… To Marvell.
- wtallis 2y agoIntel sold just one of the XScale product lines to Marvell, who almost immediately dropped the XScale CPU cores in favor of their own CPU cores and later ARM's CPU core IP.
- bgnn 2y agoMarvell isn't a small company. It's not an AI chip maker either.
- fulafel 2y agoTinkerers might remember Marvell from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SheevaPlug https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SheevaPlug
- nine_k 2y ago"More valuable than" is exactly the mindset that likely has ruined Intel. "Stock must go up" is often a great example of Goodhart's Law in action. Markets, especially speculative markets like the stock market, are known to behave irrationally time and again. Also, it's rational to buy a growing stock, so the stock market actively punishes activities like internal restructuring, which an ailing company that Intel is has been needing for years, and was / is undergoing now. NVidia's P/E is currently about 120, that is, the market values NVDA as 120 years of its current earnings. I'm not even certain that NVidia will last as long, or will be in an equally good shape. E.g. IBM has lasted 120 years, and it had wild fluctuations of its market position in these years; toda it's hardly comparable to what it was a century ago. I would say that Intel is now easier to buy in a large acquisition, without using words like "valuable".
- bcrl 2y agoIs it worth the risk? Any company buying Intel would have to deal with the internal cultural rot that has taken hold. Would the buyer be able to survive and make things better or would it turn out like the McDonnell Douglas merger with Boeing?
- iamleppert 2y agoIntel is no longer relevant. Time to move on. Intel is not inside any phones, gaming consoles, Apple laptops or the plethora of other devices we use daily. The only people still using Intel are old legacy companies with a penchant for overspending on a noisy, hot data center. They will soon be out of business themselves because of the rise of AI. Intel is no longer relevant and should be shut down, and the money invested in other more promising ventures with a future.