3 ms·
What if the languages available do depend on what the lesson is about? That would require the composed form. Skipping it entirely is not the way to go. You c
by Dylan16807 2y ago
What if the languages available do depend on what the lesson is about? That would require the composed form. Skipping it entirely is not the way to go.
You could start with decomposed and then compose it, I guess. I don't think either order is inherently easier to learn.
I agree that the wording of the normal forms, before getting to examples, is usually confusing.
- petalmind 2y ago> What if the languages available do depend on what the lesson is about? Then it would be a completely different schema that would just be in 3NF. If you look at Kent's variations you will see that they work hard (graphically) at making sure that you do not assume dependency between language and lesson.
- Dylan16807 2y agoThe point is, the schema is not inherently unreasonable as the article is implying. There's a reason to make the comparison and take both versions seriously, not just show off the normalized version.
- petalmind 2y agoYes, absolutely, just present it in "historical misunderstandings" section. My only concern is that it is presented as if it was something natural to begin with.