5 ms·
Economics and Homemakers
- K0balt 2y agoThis is an incredibly important topic that is hugely underserved because it can be seen as sexist, as well as because it deviates from the narrative that non-commercially exploitative work is not valuable to society. To be clear, being a homemaker is a gender-agnostic career, and there is even data that implies than men may be more ideal homemakers, with statistically superior social outcomes. Especially when children are involved, I don’t think it is an exaggeration to say that homemakers perform one of the most important and critical jobs in society, with a social value on par with or higher than firefighters, police, doctors, and the like. It is a tragic poverty that homemakers have been systematically and in many cases intentionally undervalued for their critical and life changing work.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 2y ago[flagged]
- s1artibartfast 2y agoI dont think it is sexist to question who receives the value. I am very skeptical of nebulous attributions to society. Homemaking is self serving in a way that working in a factory (for example) is not.
- K0balt 2y agoI agree that homemaking has strong direct benefits for the people involved, but reduced criminality, better education, and better socioeconomic outcomes for children raised with parents as primary caregivers is not a nebulous attribution to societal benefit.
- rayiner 2y agoNo. Raising children is the central function of society. The factory and everything else exists in service of that function.
- lapcat 2y ago> All the throat clearing you feel the need to do is sexist. This reply seems unnecessarily hostile, especially since you both agree that taking care of children is socially necessary and valuable. According to the poll, 50% of women with children under 18 prefer a homemaker role, while 29% of men with children under 18 would prefer a homemaker role. That's a significant difference, to be sure, but 29% is far from 0%. It shouldn't be dismissed, and neither should the 45% of women with children under 18 who prefer to work outside the home.
- rayiner 2y agoI’m not trying to be hostile to OP. I’m addressing the fact that he feels the need to engage in a bunch of throat clearing just to say that it’s bad to devalue work that women disproportionately do and want to do.
- lapcat 2y ago> I’m not trying to be hostile to OP. You called the OP sexist, or at least the OP's so-called "throat clearing". An accusation of sexism is hostile, regardless of whether the accusation is warranted, and to be clear, I don't think it was warranted.
- rayiner 2y agoPlease note the context. OP stated that the discussion is difficult because “it can be seen as sexist.” In other words, he feels the need to engage in throat clearing because others will perceive his point as sexist. My response is that it’s those other people—the ones creating the circumstances which make OP feel the need to engage in all the preliminaries—are being sexist. Being a mother is very important to most women. Most women will have kids, most women who do consider it important work, and a majority of women would prefer not to work while their kids are under 18. We can just go ahead and say that it’s bad to devalue their work in home making without dancing around the point.
- lapcat 2y ago
- s1artibartfast 2y agoI think there is a huge and completely rational gap between social valuation and family valuation. Homemakers provide most of the direct value to the household. Your firefighter, doctor, ect provide their value directly to those outside their household. My neighbor might be a great cook and parent for their child, but I am much more thankful to plumber, who benifits me directly.
- paxys 2y agoSure, but someone still needs to raise the firefighters and doctors and plumbers. One's success at age 50 is directly tied to their family dynamic and financial situation at age 0-18. Saying you value a doctor but not the circumstances that made them a doctor isn't quite rational.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoI think that is double counting. I don't pay both the butcher and the pig farmer for my bacon.
- K0balt 2y agoHere I’m talking primarily about effects in society in the form of child rearing outcomes. The gap between outcomes where there is a stable division of a full time breadwinner and homemaker during formative years vs those where there is heavy involvement of daycare services is a very stark chasm. But the economic stability has to be there as well, as this breaks down significantly in poverty. Moving both partners in a domestic life into the workforce also creates strong downward pressure on wages, since it supplies an extra 30% or so employees into the workforce. All in all the breakdown of a stable domestic workforce has been good for corporations but bad for children, employees, and stable home relationships. And if we look at the current state of affairs of partnering, it’s been bad for just about everyone.
- lapcat 2y ago> Moving both partners in a domestic life into the workforce also creates strong downward pressure on wages, since it supplies an extra 30% or so employees into the workforce. By this argument, wouldn't having children and thereby increasing the population also supply extra employees and drive down wages?
- gruez 2y ago>To be clear, being a homemaker is a gender-agnostic career, and there is even data that implies than men may be more ideal homemakers, with statistically superior social outcomes. Source? Without proper controls this could easily be a case of "households who are in a situation where the man can be homemaker are better for kids", rather than "men being better homemakers".
- K0balt 2y ago“data that may imply” is very clearly speculative, I think, but the data I am referring to concerns single parent outcomes. It is difficult to say how that would translate to partnered men, and there is probably selection bias built in to this kind of study, but still, it supports the idea that men can be proficient homemakers. This isn’t an assertion of a conclusive study in any way, but I encourage you to look into it and share what you find.
- exac 2y agoJust FYI, "TheTrumpet" article linked to and used as corroborating evidence is a religious site. The post links to a article that ends with this summary: > God created the family to excel by taking advantage of specialization of labor between husband and wife. > The Trumpet explains the real meaning behind world events. We are a news organization that connects world events with biblical prophecies. Just because household labor is not taxed, does not mean it does not happen.
- paxys 2y agoIMO a government subsidy for homemakers will in reality be a subsidy for corporations who can now pay the working parent even less. What needs to be normalized is a single salary being enough to support a family of four, like it used to be.
- Kinrany 2y agoNormalized how?
- Spartan-S63 2y agoI was thinking about this the other day. What we need is a tax on businesses that don't pay the area's single-income, livable wage. If companies pay more, they get out of the tax. If they pay less, they pay the tax. That tax then goes into making things like childcare more affordable. It's a way of forcing companies to internalize the externalities of paying below-livable wages.
- ljlolel 2y agoWhy is this downvoted? This is similar to Bernie Sanders’ idea to tax companies whose employees are on welfare
- paxys 2y agoThis is just a roundabout way of saying raise the minimum wage.
- Retric 2y agoThere’s some subtle differences. The minimum wage is a hard floor, bumping it to 10$/hour isn’t going to destroy a significant number of jobs, but 25$/hour might. If you set the minimum wage at say 10$/hour and the livable wage at say 20$/hour then you might tax the company 30% of the difference between your livable wage and the actual wage. (Effectively minimum wage becomes 13$/h, but that doesn’t all go to the worker.) It’s still adds upward wage pressure because higher pay attracts better workers and your out a significant percentage of the difference either way but it reduces the risk of a big spike in unemployment when you raise the livable wage. It also means systemic wage theft more strongly attracts the attention of the IRS.
- EPWN3D 2y agoOutside of economics, raising children is in society's interest. We need the next generation to grow up, become productive, and pay taxes. If a family elects to have one parent stay home, that parent is doing valuable work for society and should be compensated. At the very least they should be eligible for unemployment for the first two years of a child's life. I don't care about the externalities.
- vouaobrasil 2y ago> We need the next generation to grow up, become productive, and pay taxes. I think it would be even better if the next generation grew up, became productive, and learned to contribute to society in new ways outside of just the obvious monetary one. Overall, we need more non-monetary contributions to be recognized.
- mgh95 2y agoYeah but then how do you pay for social benefits such as SSDI, medicare, medicaid, etc.?
- EPWN3D 2y agoI don't really have an opinion on that one way or another, but in modern society the current working generation pays for the last generation's retirement. We literally need the next generation to be productive and pay taxes. If they're too busy doing economically unproductive work, taxes on everyone who does work will go up and retirement benefits will go down.
- tmpz22 2y agoSFSU had to declare a financial emergency due to declining enrollment [1]. [1]: https://www.sfchronicle.com/sf/article/sf-state-declares-fiscal-emergency-19964419.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/sf/article/sf-state-declares-fis...
- vouaobrasil 2y agoI think one of the biggest disasters of modern society is to relegate almost every sort of community task such as homemaking, assisting neighbors, etc. to the economic system. The immediate effect of such a relegation is the breaking apart of communities for the sake of economic efficiency: the person who takes care of the children is no longer the parent, the person who helps you fix your porch is no longer your neighbour, and the person you ask for a ride is now an Uber. Yes, it may make for a more convenient society in some ways but I wonder if the cumulative effect is worth it? I don't think so. Economists hail efficiency and comparative advantage as a good thing, but it is also a reduction of true value to a single variable (money) which is a dimensional collapse that strips humanity from human beings. The short-term results seem good, but because in the long-term, the process never stops, the END result is a transformation of human beings from people into cogs in an economic machine that has no soul.
- osigurdson 2y ago>> the person who takes care of the children is no longer the parent Perhaps efficient, but the ultimate result is fewer children.
- jmyeet 2y ago> I think one of the biggest disasters of modern society is to relegate almost every sort of community task such as homemaking, assisting neighbors, etc. to the economic system That's... capitalism. Every aspect of your life needs to be financialized and exploited to generate profits for somebody who isn't you. Paid childcare is a profit opportunity. Community childcare is not. The whole point of hyperindividualism is to destroy community because class consciousness, community, unions and class solidarity are an unacceptable threat to the economic order.
- EasyMark 2y agoThere is a price for everything. I think there are plenty communes that people can join if they want to retire from the typical modern life and have a simpler existence.
- exmicrosoldier 2y agoIn capitalism, society gets what it rewards. If it wants more children it must pay the market price, just like everything else. If it wants educated, productive children, it must also pay the market price and that price is exorbitant. At some point, US tech companies will (maybe have already outspent) the US education system k-12 and at some point surpassing all the ivy colleges just for training some ai models.
- paxys 2y agoThe USA spends close to a trillion dollars annually on K-12 education, so you are only off by about 3 orders of magnitude.
- xivzgrev 2y agoThis was a strange sentence: “Two such expenditures — Social Security and Medicare — are directed towards the care of the elderly.” Erhm no? They are directed toward living expenses and medical expenses, both of which are huge. Some % may be elderly care taking but likely a relatively small % in any given year vs all seniors drawing benefits.
- throwup238 2y agoThat’s what “taking care of the elderly” means to me at a societal level. It’s not literally just old folks’ homes and hospice care, it’s how we provide for people who have aged out of the workforce in general.
- jmyeet 2y agoThis either fetishizes the 1950s and "traditional" values or will be used to people who do. What never gets mentioned is: 1. The existence of a permanent underclass of low paid help that made this existence possible; 2. The postwar "traditional" existence was actually a very short period in history; 3. The "traditional" homemaker role was largely because people had no choice; and 4. The top marginal tax rate in the 1950s was 91%. The author is correct that the capitalists want us working so they can take our surplus labor value as profits. Additionally, if we have to work, even better. Coercion is a necessary and desirable condition for capitalism. However, fetishizing "traditional" values is a common Trojan horse for radicalizing people into fascism. Hitler sold himself as a moral crusader. He told German women their role was to create more Germans. German women would get medals from the state if they had enough children. The public had to be sold on the fear of "moral decay". Does that sound familiar? It should if you've been paying attention. This sort of thing has infected spaces inhabited by young men too. Julius Evola, the philosopher to Mussolini before graduating to the major leagues of Hitler, extols the virtues of traditional values and gender roles. He is a darling of the 4chan suburban latch key kids. The government doesn't need to subsidize homemakers specifically. We simply need to pay people enough so that 2 people don't need 5 jobs between them to make ends meet. As wealthy inequality worsens, population growth stagnates. South Korea is really the poster child for that now (~0.7 children per woman, the lowest of any nation). What we do now is subsidize corporations. Walmart employees are huge recipients of food stamps. Walmart has a grossannual profit of ~$150B. Why are they being subsidized by the government instead of, you know, just paying their workers a fair and living wage? All of these problems come down to economics, specifically capitalism. This is capitalism working as intended. I'm amazed how often I see pieces like this that recognize the problems created by capitalism without capitalism ever being blamed.
- nataliste 2y agoI'm a stay at home dad and have some thoughts. By staying at home, my children receive a bespoke education and my family bespoke consumer products (e.g. food and entertainment) that far exceed anything my family can access through the market economy. Just because I don't directly participate in the entrepreneurial system through taxable wages doesn't mean that I only marginally participate in it. My role is simply that of competing with business (in terms of efficiency and quality)--I find areas where I can do it better and more efficiently, then acquire capital and raw materials, use the capital to add value to the raw resources, provide those resources to the singular market that is my family, and then pocket the profit, which will inevitably be reintroduced back to the broader economy as investment and additional outlays, all of which are taxable. The ultra-wealthy are afforded the right and ability to have exclusive access to personal assistants, au-pairs, tutors, professional chefs, gardeners, housecleaners, etc. I do all of these and more for my family (at well below market rate), using the same methods, tools, and products that they do, but the wages I receive and any profit (or losses) generated remain within my household such that it can be used for further consumption and investment. I still pay sales taxes on the capital and raw materials, but try to lower my tax burden and vertically integrate like any other business. That I am free to choose to engage in this mutual exchange with my wife is the bedrock foundation of liberal capitalism and a free society. Frank Hyneman Knight, one of the forgotten architects of the Chicago School of Economics and the teacher of Milton Friedman frequently stated in his works that the individualism of liberalism should be more accurately called familism, because the basic effective economic unit is not the individual, but the family. And he's absolutely right.
- jacknews 2y ago"there is no evidence that children benefit from parental care, rather than institutional care" I think that quote tells you all you need to know, to judge how much economists should influence the way we live.