5 ms·
I think the unauthorized sale concern is overblown, but do believe "assault weapons" are uniquely dangerous; this is a debate I've had on HN a number of times,
by tptacek 2y ago
I think the unauthorized sale concern is overblown, but do believe "assault weapons" are uniquely dangerous; this is a debate I've had on HN a number of times, and tends to start with a courtly dance of someone saying "that's because you don't know how firearms work" and the history of semi-automatic long guns, and end with ballistics reports and the machining simplicity of automatic sears.
I don't necessarily want to have that whole debate again, which I guess I could do by pressing the point, so much as to make space in this subthread for "maybe that one part of your strong comment is not as settled as you're making it out to be".
- gweinberg 2y agoIt absolutely is though. Guns are classified as "assault weapons" because of cosmetic features like barrel shrouds and bayonet lugs, and the fact that most people don't know this doesn't make it less true. The term "assault weapon" was deliberately chosen to confuse people into thinking it means the same as or something similar to "assault rifle", and that fact isn't really in dispute either.
- tptacek 2y agoAnd then I come back with 3 paragraphs about the legislative history of the assault weapons ban, which began by singling out a bunch of weapons by name but with a catchall of semi-automatic weapons with detachable clips, and got lobbied down to its cosmetic definition by the NRA. You might believe I'm completely wrong about all of this, and that's OK. That's how message boards work. But do you think "you haven't read the assault weapons ban and don't know how silly it is" is going to work as a rhetorical strategy here? Or we can just accept that reasonable, informed people might disagree on these points, and there's no winning this.
- gruez 2y ago>And then I come back with 3 paragraphs about the legislative history of the assault weapons ban, which began by singling out a bunch of weapons by name but with a catchall of semi-automatic weapons with detachable clips, and got lobbied down to its cosmetic definition by the NRA. Where is this?
- tptacek 2y agoThere's an older thread where I pasted a link to it, but I'm not going to dig it up right now (you can; I promise you it's there). I'm pretty comfortable with the idea that people will take my word on stuff like this. I'm really not trying to convince people that I'm right about this, only that the question is unsettled.
- jplona 2y agoI'm actually quite interested in your N paragraphs about why the category is written the way it is, and especially about the principles under which it is (or was meant to be) effective.. Frankly it's something I've always wondered about, but as mostly a spectator of these kinds of discussions I've never seen anyone explain. Like a lot of folks, from my surface-level knowledge it seems arbitrary and likely meaningless. But so much so that it feels like I must be missing something. Or any chance of a link to your previous cpmments on the topic?
- oooyay 2y ago"Assault weapon" doesn't mean anything outside of New York and New Jersey. For New York it's an arbitrary combination of "features". For instance, threaded barrel + removable magazine. The M1A I'm looking to buy, a modern garand, is considered an assault weapon under the SAFE act. I want it as a ranch rifle, but because threaded barrels are a no-no I'll have to store it in another state when and if I have to move to NY. Statistically speaking, based on shootings and crime, pistols are much more "dangerous". For whatever reason we've made laws solely on long gun features though.
- llamaimperative 2y ago> For whatever reason we've made laws solely on long gun features though. You must be well-aware that handguns are much more tightly controlled than long guns pretty much across the board, totally aside from the fuzziness of "assault weapon" designation.
- oooyay 2y agoAh, let's be specific about what you're talking about: Handgun modifications are more tightly controlled. For instance if I try to turn a hand gun into a long gun. That was always true of federal law. What I'm pointing out is that a stock long rifle is arbitrarily made a felony only in New York and New Jersey law, which logically leads to a more dangerous outcome: I have to store said gun somewhere else while I live there for work.
- llamaimperative 2y agoNo, handguns are more tightly controlled than long guns.
- kasey_junk 2y agoIllinois law makes many stock rifles, some of them by name, a felony.
- JoeAltmaier 2y ago
- wl 2y agoYes, you've argued this with me before. The issue of "assault weapon" bans boils down to the question of whether or not restricted features like pistol grips and adjustable stocks make magazine-fed semi-automatic firearms more dangerous than those without. People who shoot these kinds of weapons tend to be unconvinced. Gun control advocates generally believe this distinction makes sense. There's also the issue of how restricted magazine-fed semiautomatic weapons should be, apart from the baggage of "assault weapon" features, which I feel could be a more productive debate.
- tptacek 2y agoNo, my argument has literally nothing to do with pistol grips and adjustable stocks, as you know.
- wl 2y agoYes, I recall you argued for an older proposal regulating "weapons of war" unmoored from any functional criteria as determined by cabinet appointees + a banned list from the legislature instead of the feature tests that have actually become law. I don't recall you arguing for any functional distinction between banned and not-banned magazine-fed semi-automatics.
- tptacek 2y agoI dispute that characterization but my bigger question is: stipulating what you say here, if you knew that to be my position, why did you write a comment about pistol grips and adjustable stocks?
- 15155 2y agoHow many peacetime bayonet attacks have happened in the last 100 years to make a bayonet lug a restrictive criteria?
- tptacek 2y agoI do not care about bayonet lugs.
- Glyptodon 2y agoIt's not really a courtly dance. It's a near impossible conversation to have because "assault weapon" doesn't have any kind of clear or helpful meaning. Even the expired AWB didn't do a decent job of defining. And arguably many "features" usually shoehorned in are just silly. Like there's nothing especially bad about pistol grips on rifles.