7 ms·
OpenAI seeks to unlock investment by ditching 'AGI' clause with Microsoft
- tim333 2y agoArchive version https://archive.ph/pmudc https://archive.ph/pmudc
- tim333 2y ago> “We’ve also said that our intention is to treat AGI as a mile marker along the way. We’ve left ourselves some flexibility because we don’t know what will happen,” added Altman Musk accusing Altman of “deceit of Shakespearean proportions.”
- F7F7F7 2y agoI’ve had AI influencers reaching out to inquire about the bridge I have for sale, everyday for the past 2 years. We’ll never see AGI in its original definition in our lifetimes. It doesn’t take being a rocket…company buying billionaire.
- bbor 2y agoHe started the company - I’m no Elon fan myself, but that’s the case. Also, you’re disagreeing with him anyway; he’s saying that starting a company who’s defining purpose was to avoid a for-profit race to AGI and then immediately pivot to ruthless for-profit competition as soon as you have a real shot at your goal (+ an advantage) is deceptive. And yeah, I’ve gotta give it to him: tragic. Tho I guess that’s “Homeric” or “Hellenic” deceit?
- Spooky23 2y agoElon got out-Eloned. I think the bigger tale is how Microsoft is essentially getting swindled here, and Zuckerberg looks like a man of the people somehow.
- ToucanLoucan 2y ago> He started the company - I’m no Elon fan myself, but that’s the case. Point out what he did that couldn't be done by Bill Gates, Larry Ellison, or Mark Zuckerburg, or in fact that was done by Jeff Bezos with his own company. And I don't mean some ephemeral "well he wanted to!" yeah big fucking deal. I want to convert a DeLorean to an EV powertrain to commute to work. I want to have a garage big enough for 5 cars and a shop. I want to have a sex bot that me and the wife can share. Anyone can fucking want something. What did Elon bring to the table besides wanting it, and money? Being an investor is not a skill. Paying for things is not a job. Buying stuff or people is not a trade. And I'm sick to death of people buying his and other's PR saying that paying someone else to do cool shit is the same thing as doing cool shit.
- CamperBob2 2y agoPoint out what he did that couldn't be done by Bill Gates, Larry Ellison, or Mark Zuckerburg, or in fact that was done by Jeff Bezos with his own company. "If you were going to start Facebook, you'd have started Facebook." - apocryphally credited to Zuckerberg. You do know that Bezos started his rocket company before SpaceX, right? If he could beat SpaceX, why hasn't he? As for sex bots, that'll happen soon enough, be patient. At this point there is nothing but a few incremental advances in robotics and material science standing in the way of implementing the bots from Garland's Ex Machina or Spielberg's AI. The software side is basically working now.
- ToucanLoucan 2y ago> "If you were going to start Facebook, you'd have started Facebook." - apocryphally credited to Zuckerberg. No, I wouldn't, because I have a soul and I don't want to light the mental health of the entire world on fire no matter how much money it makes me. > You do know that Bezos started his rocket company before SpaceX, right? If he could beat SpaceX, why hasn't he? I don't know what "beat" means in this context nor am I particularly interested in billionare's dick measuring contests which are funded in part by the taxpayer. My point isn't that someone did it. I'm sick to death of Elon's mythmaking and I'm going to shout into the void every time it comes up until the day I die that that man hasn't done shit besides write checks. Say what you will about Fuckerburg, and I've said plenty, but at least he actually wrote some of Facebook's code.
- ToucanLoucan 2y agoI wouldn't be comfortable saying we'll never see AGI in our lifetimes. I've seen incredible progress since I was a kiddo and computers were these huge machines that took up an entire desk, not to mention that only a decade prior to that, they were machines that took up entire warehouses. And now, I carry around a computer who's primary function is organizing my life and helping me kill time, and it has hundreds of times more power stuffed into a little rectangle that runs the entire day in my pocket. I wouldn't say it's impossible by any stretch. That said, I think it strains the hell out of credulity to say a fancy chatbot is getting anywhere close to that, especially since we apparently had to give it every word mankind has written up to this point just to get it to a stage of "mostly good at grammar, still makes tons of shit up." I just don't think this is the route there.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- danielbln 2y agoWhile I agree with your general sentiment, let's not sell LLMs short. These things would be firmly scifi not even 5 years ago and they are significantly more powerful than "mostly good at grammar". They do still make shit up, I give you that.
- CamperBob2 2y agoWe’ll never see AGI in its original definition in our lifetimes. It doesn’t take being a rocket…company buying billionaire. No, because whenever somebody says they've achieved it, someone else -- maybe you -- will say they haven't. The question will never be settled to everyone's satisfaction. We don't know what intelligence is, or how to measure it objectively, much less how to define "general intelligence." So it's hard to say whether current approaches to AI will get there or not. I see it as a tool to be used by people, one that may evolve into the most powerful tool we've ever built. I don't find the question of "intelligence" all that interesting.
- Barrin92 2y ago> whenever somebody says they've achieved it, someone else -- maybe you -- will say they haven't And as long as that discussion still makes sense it's pretty obvious that we haven't achieved it. There's a very clear inflection point, when anything deserving that label actually exists we'll have 50% economic growth a year, the 50 most popular professions will be done by machines, the cost of science will fall by magnitudes because everyone can spawn a hundred scientists with the click of a mouse, and you'll walk out the door and the world will look to you like the 1950s looked to someone from 1500. We aren't even going to be capable of haggling about arcane theoretical differences.
- IshKebab 2y agoBold prediction. Only 15 years ago state of the art was barely more than recognising digits. Now you can have a full on voice conversation with an AI.
- ALittleLight 2y agoWe have AGI, in it's original definition, now - it's just human level rather than superhuman. ChatGPT, without being specifically programmed to, can summarize a text, write a program, play chess, explain a joke, translate, explain or create a poem, and just handle arbitrary inputs in text. On some measures ChatGPT is better than human, on some measures, like ARC, it's worse - but even there it's not worse than the worst human. ChatGPT is artificial, certainly, general, in the sense that it handles a wide range of inputs, and intelligent in the sense that it can solve problems and make predictions. The intelligence of LLMs is likely to increase in the near term future - better hardware, better training, distilling to smaller models, architecture improvements, better augmentations (like RAG), better use of test time computer etc.
- heresie-dabord 2y ago> “deceit of Shakespearean proportions.” It is true that some of Shakespeare's characters exhibit grotesque exaggerations of human frailties. They go mad with ambition, cruelty, and delusion, imposing their whims on victims around them. They typically show no sign of compunction until they have brought themselves to a miserable, self-inflicted end in tragedy. It is ironic to read such recriminations from this particular character.
- neilv 2y agoNon-paywall summary: https://www.reuters.com/technology/openai-seeks-unlock-investment-by-ditching-agi-clause-with-microsoft-ft-reports-2024-12-06/ https://www.reuters.com/technology/openai-seeks-unlock-inves...
- IAmGraydon 2y ago> As per the current terms, when OpenAI creates AGI - defined as a "highly autonomous system that outperforms humans at most economically valuable work" - Microsoft's access to such a technology would be void. That’s their definition of AGI? What does that have to do with actual intelligence?
- bbor 2y agoIt’s the so called “economic” definition. You’re absolutely right to call out that it’s not very philosophically valuable, but they were trying to be pragmatic — and it was kinda hard to imagine, anyway. Of course it’s being thrown out the window now that money’s on the line… drives one to cynicism! No wonder Altman is a paranoid prepper.
- heresie-dabord 2y ago> "highly autonomous system that outperforms humans at most economically valuable work" As you note, this has nothing to do with actual intelligence, but with the for-profit calculus. The disturbing aspect of such a definition is that economically-valuable work/activity may be grossly unsustainable and directly detrimental.
- etna_ramequin 2y agoThat’s a self-defeating definition. Work that can be automated at no marginal cost is economically worthless. Edit for clarity: “worthless” as in “no value add”, its worth is only capital investment and energy input.
- kelseyfrog 2y agoWork that can be automated is worth exactly at the price it's sold at, not at what it costs. Besides, the marginal cost of AGI isn't zero - servers still cost electricity to run.
- fixprix 2y agoImagine someone from 4 years ago reading this comment and being like… what?
- rgbrenner 2y agoGPT is insufficient for AGI. It might be part of the solution one day, but it's fundamentally incapable of bridging the gap by itself. Despite what Altman/OpenAI says in public, I think he knows this too... That's why they dissolved the Superalignment safety team; and dropping the AGI clause just confirms that. As time goes on, the "AGI is coming" hype machine gets harder to sustain... and their work/company will begin to be valued on the actual value it produces.
- guluarte 2y agoyep, it is just a glorified markov chain
- bloomingkales 2y agoThis glorified Markov chain educates me better than many things. Why are people so intent on calling bullshit on AI? It might be a disease honestly.
- joshdavham 2y ago> Why are people so intent on calling bullshit on AI? I hate to be an armchair psychologist, but I think it’s insecurity.
- tsunamifury 2y agoAnd preference for deferring to historical authority which I find so laughable in this forum. Everything said here has been said the same about the internet and Wikipedia but now those are the authorities.
- flipthefrog 2y agoAnd flying cars
- tiahura 2y agoI think to most people, AGI means KITT or at least Data. AI via word probability matrices is super cool and well worth $20/mo, but it’s not AGI.
- CityOfThrowaway 2y agoOpenAI really does seem to embody the idea that all contracts are renegotiable if you're Machiavellian enough.
- aleph_minus_one 2y ago> OpenAI really does seem to embody the idea that all contracts are renegotiable Why aren't they renegotiable? Of course you can attempt to renegotiate basically every contract; the question is whether this will be successful or whether this is a good idea. There is no need to appeal to Machiavellianism.
- CityOfThrowaway 2y agoOf course everything is renegotiable. But after reneging on every serious promise you've ever made, I do think it's worthwhile pointing out that this organization is shamelessly Machiavellian. They have mistreated all of their constituencies pretty rapidly!
- easeout 2y agoSo then, they can claim something is AGI when it isn't, just for the hype benefits, because there's no downside to saying so.
- paxys 2y agoSo basically they want to have a "we reached AGI!" marketing moment without pissing off their largest partner/money bank.
- iainctduncan 2y agoSo does this mean after mocking him for two years they are admitting Gary Marcus is right and that LLMs achieving AGI is complete horseshit?
- rvz 2y agoIt appears that the definition of "AGI" just means "raise more money" until we do. Even if they never reach "AGI". Looks like a complete scam.