4 ms·
If you can write data to someone's hard drive it is simpler to just dump some child pornography.
by adrianN 14y ago
If you can write data to someone's hard drive it is simpler to just dump some child pornography.
- nathan_long 14y agoOK, but suppose you're trying to frame them for bank fraud. Coming up with incriminating data is a lot trickier than just making it look like they have something.
- mseebach 14y agoRefusing to decrypt under this law will be the crime. It's not proof against you in the original charge. So you won't get them for bank fraud anyway, and then it might as well have been child porn (or a stash of stolen credit card number or compromised online banking accounts etc)
- hemancuso 14y agoI'm a bit disturbed that you suggest it's easier dump child porn onto somebody's hard drive than it is to dump a random bitstream onto the drive. It implies you've got a huge cache of it hanging around ready to go.
- nathan_long 14y agoMe too. Also, it's not "easier" even if you have it. To dump data, you have to have and transmit data; to dump noise, you just need a tiny script.
- ihuman 14y agoI think he's saying it's easier to dump unencrypted vs encrypted.
- Blara 14y agoThe point was that it doesn't have to be real data, just random data.
- pyre 14y ago> It implies you've got a huge cache of it hanging > around ready to go. In the US at least, just a single image is illegal, so there is no need for a huge cache.
- pavel_lishin 14y agoI imagine that a single image wouldn't quite motivate the police the same way that two gigabytes' worth would.
- pyre 14y agoI remember a story about the FBI going after some college kid with a single thumbnail in his browser cache, though the other circumstances were: - Somehow they came up with his IP in a sting where a link to a file was posted somewhere. I don't know if this was posted to a kiddie porn forum (or someplace where just hanging out there is enough to make you suspicious) or just someplace like 4chan (where there's a number of people that will click the link out of curiosity). - He had 'recently' re-installed Windows. They claimed that he had obstructed justice (or some other B.S.) b/c he had destroyed evidence. (Evidence that they couldn't prove even existed, IIRC.) - He had a single thumbnail of kiddie porn in a browser cache. I think that he just settled with the Feds, but cases like this stick out in my mind because it makes it seem like we're all riding the razor's edge and could fall into the Federal justice system at any moment for some random, stupid reason. [ Plus taking down a pedophile is brownie points to local politicians, which may (or may not) be pressuring them about crime statistics. ]
- TazeTSchnitzel 14y agoLet's just say it's not especially difficult to access on the darknet. (I've never done it myself, though) And getting onto the darknet is but a simple download away...
- JonnieCache 14y agoHe means simpler as in "simpler to get them locked up" rather than "simpler to execute." Having lots of child porn is a sure fire way to go to prison, whereas as has been demonstrated in this thread, the laws surrounding this entropy-of-doom attack are convoluted and highly suspect.
- pbhjpbhj 14y agoIf you're caught though the consequences are terrible whilst encrypted Shakespeare given names to look like something illegal would only really have you under unauthorized access charges.
- pyre 14y agoI don't know. I would think that attempting to frame someone with it shows some amount of malicious intent. There's got to be something else to charge them with other then the equivalent of "breaking and entering" to plant evidence.
- pbhjpbhj 14y agoviola-12-hot.zip looks tasty to a police officer who thinks they found illegal images but is just a keyword + title word + one-word review of a favourite play when you find the contents are Twelfth Night ... maybe?
- e40 14y agoBut then you'd need to be in possession of it, and that has many issues that merely writing random data to a file does not.