3 ms·
The hatred is largely misdirected, based on an outdated misunderstanding of how the health insurance industry works. A lot of people still have the mental model
by nradov 2y ago
The hatred is largely misdirected, based on an outdated misunderstanding of how the health insurance industry works. A lot of people still have the mental model that health insurance works something like auto insurance, where they pay in premiums every month and the insurer bears financial risk for paying claims — and thus has a financial incentive to deny claims. But most health plans no longer operate that way. The bulk of the industry has now moved to large self-funded employer-sponsored plans in which the health "insurance" companies no longer provide any real insurance or bear any risk. Instead they act as administrators, constructing provider networks and processing claims. The actual risk has been transferred to employers who pay the claims. Large employers prefer this model because it ends up being cheaper for them.
In the short term at least, health insurance companies have no direct financial incentive to deny any claims. In fact, due to the minimum medical loss ratio imposed by the Affordable Care Act (Obamacare) they actually make more profit by approving more claims. The coverage policies which lead to denied claims, step therapy, and prior authorization are really set by employers in order to hold down their costs. In other words, health insurers are really just doing the bidding of their customers.
If you don't like your health coverage then the fault most likely lies with your employer's HR department. To explain it another way, if a large company wanted to they could ask a health insurer to offer a custom plan which would pay every claim for any service, no questions asked. This would be enormously profitable for the insurer, but no employer wants to pay that much.
This is one of the reasons why tying healthcare access to employment via tax incentives was a bad idea. Unfortunately, for historical reasons it's politically difficult to move away from that coverage model.
- capybaraStorm 2y agoThis is a fascinating insight. Can you walk me through, at what point the HR department has the power to delay and deny claims for medical care covered under the insurance contract? It is my understanding the hatred doesn't extend so much in the denial of claims but rather the denial of claims for covered events.
- nradov 2y agoHR departments generally have no authority over individual claims. Rather they work with insurers and independent employee benefits consultants to construct a health plan with certain benefits and coverage rules which they think will minimize costs (based on predictive analytics) without hurting employee retention too much. Large insurers offer employers a menu of options with various provider networks (narrow versus wide), negotiated rates, deductible / co-insurance / co-payment amounts, carve outs, special extra benefits, etc. Once the plan rules are set at the beginning of the year, the insurer just enforces the rules as written and passes the claim charges on to the employer. Of course, sometimes health plans just make errors in claim processing and deny a claim that should have been approved. Or the provider makes an error and submits a claim with incorrect codes or lacking the necessary documentation to establish medical necessity as per coverage rules. Or there are gray areas where it's not always clear whether a certain service should be covered or not, and it comes down to a judgment call by a nurse or doctor employed by the insurer (medicine is still more art than science and the best treatment plan isn't always clear). This can be a huge hassle for patients dealing with serious medical conditions.
- capybaraStorm 2y agoI think this gets to part of the issue at UHC. People are filing claims, thinking it is covered, but it gets denied. I have read anecdotal reports that people working in government roles with UHC insurance have switched to identical plans in the private sector and got much worse denial rates with UHC plans offering the same coverage. This fuels a completely speculative view that UHC might shift the 85% required healthcare costs towards favoring places where they may gain more market share and really shafting hard in other parts of the market. They can shit-can something like 15% of premiums so unequal allocation of that could lead disproportionately to some very pissed off people, even working within a system where profit is bounded by accepted claims. All of this would fit in well with a profit optimization strategy.
- nradov 2y agoI'm not an expert on this but my understanding is that CMS enforces the MLR for each insurer on a per-state basis. So insurers don't have much opportunity to chase market share by shifting claim costs around between plans. Regular federal government employees are all on private insurance plans, unless they're in the military or old enough to be covered by Medicare. So your comment about "switched to identical plans in the private sector" makes no sense. But the different private insurance plans offered to federal employees do have different benefits and different claim processing policies.
- forgetfreeman 2y agoThis sounds pretty good but there's still some friction between what you're describing and observed reality. If all if this is accurate what incentives exist for insurance providers to even consider policies like this: https://www.cnn.com/2024/12/05/health/anthem-blue-cross-blue-shield-anesthesia-claim-limits/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2024/12/05/health/anthem-blue-cross-blue...
- nradov 2y agoSo I'm obviously not privy to internal Anthem discussions but I'll speculate on what happened there based on industry trends. There has been a huge increase in anesthesia costs over the past several years and I suspect that Anthem's self-funded employer customers are pushing Anthem to find ways to cut those expenses. Most anesthesiologists work in private practices rather than as employees of hospitals or surgery centers. Private equity firms have been buying up those practices and establishing effective monopolies in some regions, then jacking their rates up. Anthem handled the messaging around this issue horribly but I kind of understand why they tried to impose some limits. It's not like patients would be denied necessary care or anesthesiologists wouldn't be paid, the insurance would just cap the maximum charges for certain procedures. https://www.beckersasc.com/anesthesia/private-equity-has-a-grip-on-anesthesiology-heres-why.html https://www.beckersasc.com/anesthesia/private-equity-has-a-g... Ultimately only a small percentage of the total money in the healthcare system goes to payer (insurance company) profits. Much larger portions flow to providers, pharmaceutical companies, and device manufacturers. So as far as reforming the system we can maybe get a little savings by squeezing insurers but it's not going to solve any of the fundamental problems.
- forgetfreeman 2y agoYour point about insurance industry profits is well-made, but I feel it slides rather smoothly past the gargantuan overhead the industry's mere existence demands. Given the industry does not provide healthcare services it seems straightforward to me that every penny spent either on insurance premiums or maintaining headcount to manage claims is money wasted.