4 ms·
How do you protect a power grid from state actors?
by amelius 2y ago
How do you protect a power grid from state actors?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- libertine 2y ago> How do you protect a power grid from state actors? I think one of the best ways is mutual destruction assurance. Ukraine should be given the capacity and clearance to also take down Russia's power grid.
- bluGill 2y agoIt doesn't matter if they get the capacity and clearance - they are not stupid enough to do it. Modern war has done a lot of studies and things like taking out the enemy power grid just make the enemy more inclined to fight. Ukraine wants to take out things that would make Russia less willing to fight on (or lacking that things that would make Russia unable to fight on)
- libertine 2y ago> Modern war has done a lot of studies and things like taking out the enemy power grid just make the enemy more inclined to fight. Russia is pretty inclined to fight, so I'm not sure if I understand your point here.
- bluGill 2y agoFor how long? Russia isn't doing a mobilization despite needing it because they are afraid of the blacklash.
- libertine 2y agoThey've been killing Ukrainians for almost 3 years. So if they're not inclined to fight, they sure don't mind the killing and destruction of Ukraine, which is more of an entrepreneurial motivation than anything else: - Some want to try to enrich themselves by killing Ukrainians; - Others don't want that risk, but they're ok with it;
- FpUser 2y ago>"... studies and things like taking out the enemy power grid just make the enemy more inclined to fight" Is this why NATO did it in Yugoslavia? /s
- bugtodiffer 2y agodecentralization
- dbtc 2y agoand diplomacy
- xattt 2y agoHave everyone take a chunk of nuclear fuel to keep in their home? That’s technically decentralization.
- ragebol 2y agoI got a SMR on my roof: Small Modular Receiver, for fusion energy.
- ragebol 2y agoCan be done up to some level, but you still need a stable source of ~50Hz frequency to keep everything synced.
- 15155 2y ago50Hz is so low that peaks can be synchronized via atomic/GPS-sourced clocks if it were ever necessary to decentralize.
- bluGill 2y agoYou only need to synchronize when you are connecting two different generators. If you house is getting 51 hz, or 50hz but out of phase you won't care because everything works anyway (some clocks will run too fast but otherwise you won't even notice). Only when you want to connect two grids (because one can't make enough power and the other is making more than they need) do you need to synchronize. Even then they only need to synchronize to each other, not the rest of the world.
- 2y ago
- mrweasel 2y agoThat is a big question, a few things you can do: * Air gap EVERYTHING. * Extremely careful screening of employees. * Constant security training of staff. * Anti air defence. * Bury your cables.
- grues-dinner 2y ago> Bury your cables. This goes both ways. If the enemy can get a ground-penetrating missile to hit a buried cable, it's a huge issue to repair it, needing heavy machinery, and all the long while you're digging it out, presenting a juicy double-tap target.
- sam_lowry_ 2y agoThe grid had some redundancy from Soviet planners, but has been optimized over 30 years. It is now back to being overly redundant, with extra connections to the West What Ukrainian engineers achieved by swiching to EU frequency is heroic [1]. I hope they were decorated. [1] https://www.entsoe.eu/news/2022/03/16/continental-europe-successful-synchronisation-with-ukraine-and-moldova-power-systems/ https://www.entsoe.eu/news/2022/03/16/continental-europe-suc...
- throwaway2037 2y agoThis is a nice link share. I am surprised something like that did not make HN front page. Was Ukraine and Moldova previously 50Hz, but not synced with EU grid?
- sam_lowry_ 2y agoYes, 50Hz but synchronized to the Russian or rather Soviet grid.
- grues-dinner 2y agoDirectly, you don't. You hope that the adversary isn't able to strike hard enough or at enough targets, or is unwilling to go all in on war crimes by destroying civilian infrastructure. Iraqi and Yugoslavian grids were taken down almost entirely in days in the 90s and they only came back because there was a very careful use of weapons and tactics that didn't completely annihilate the gear. And modern equipment is far, far, far less field-repairable then whatever an average Iraqi substation had installed in 1990. It's only going to get worse in conflicts where there's willingness to attack infrastructure because energy infrastructure is fixed in place, delicate, physically large and easy to detect and locate and vulnerable to even small drone-sized attacks, let alone missiles. And that's assuming you have to attack it physically at all and not just remotely disable it somehow. If you have to harden the infrastructure, all you can do really is simplify hugely so you can repair it when attacked (fewer imported Infineon IGBTs, fancy Siemens PLCs, and networked UHVDC switchgear on 2 year lead times) and decentralise to minimise single points of failure and avoid cascading failures. Which is hugely inefficient in physical terms like wasted capacity and losses as well as the human effort required to keep it running, but some places might have some power. Even then, in the next decades, against a state level adversary who could make and deliver, say, drones that can autonomously recognise and attack anything that looks like a ceramic insulator disk or a solar panel, if you can't threaten grave retaliation, you're back to the good old tutting about war crimes.
- DanielHB 2y agoI fear such civilian attacks are going to become more commonplace over time. It is well hypothesized that should China invade Taiwan, Taiwan would destroy the three gorges dam and completely annihilate a good chunk of China. It is just as much a deterrent as nuclear weapons, probably worse in this specific case. This is why you can't go for the throat of a regime anymore, even if you have overwhelming force. Because if you do then, well, you are already going to jail for war crimes anyway.
- gpderetta 2y ago> if you do then, well, you are already going to jail for war crimes anyway. realistically, only if you lose the war.
- InDubioProRubio 2y agoYou make it mobile- aka nuklear barges or small nuklear power plants on trucks. Also there seem to be minimal - Tit for Tat rules of engagement - you do not hit the reservoir upriver of moscow, i do not blow up zhaporischia. But moscow is running out of hostages and time. All the dams are gone in ukraine- so moscow could be flooded, unless they take the nuclear power plants hostage. Which ukraine could do to btw- no reason why warcrimeas shouldnt go both ways, now that the west is betraying them
- ashoeafoot 2y agoon the day trump pulls us support, the gloves come off and moscow gets it
- ben_w 2y agoThey're probably both fighting at maximum capability already. That said: While we all know that Russia isn't fighting all of NATO, it does claim that it is fighting all of NATO. Do they believe what they say? I don't know. I think if Ukraine attempts Hail-Mary tactics, if you assume the hypothetical that Russia really does believe that Ukraine is only capable of such things with NATO support, it is still bad for NATO. There's certainly Ukrainians who want nukes now, who think giving them up was a mistake. Some say it would only take them months to get nukes… and they said that months ago. If they do develop their own independent capability, and Russia just assumes it's an American or French or British nuke, that's still bad for the rest of us, even if Trump is shouting about how the USA didn't do it.
- throwaway2037 2y ago> They're probably both fighting at maximum capability already. Absolutely not. In my view, NATO should be supplying 1M+ artillery shells per month, so that UA can unleash scorched earth tactics on Russian positions inside UA territories.
- ben_w 2y ago
- amenhotep 2y agoCredibly establish that for every strike they make against your power grid you'll make several against theirs.
- amelius 2y agoIn view of what others said here, that would be answering war crimes with more war crimes.
- amenhotep 2y ago"attacking electrical infrastructure is a war crime" is quite a woolly and interpretable thing. It's not blanket, there are questions of purpose and proportionality. If, for example, you strike a single civilian substation because by doing so you take out the power supply to a critical defence radar and are then able to attack an otherwise defended military target, then it's hard to argue that's a war crime. Any more than bombing civilian infrastructure like roads and railways. Doing it as part of a deliberate campaign of terror whose main purpose is to harm and intimidate civilians is probably a war crime, although it's very easy to fig leaf it if there's any way that attacking the infrastructure impedes war production directly. Doing it proportionately in retaliation is less likely to be.
- EasyMark 2y agoI suspect we may see a tit-for-tat rider added to modern warfare since the big guys no longer bother trying to live within the spirit of the Geneva conventions. Russia is literally raping and geocoding all through their controlled areas of Ukrainian territory. Saw a video just last week were they ordered POWs to lie on the ground and they just shot them for no reason, this is common place. Why should Ukraine just throw up their hands and say “nothing we can do!”
- preisschild 2y agoBuild large nuclear power plants and protect them with good layered Air Defense Systems