3 ms·

Ken Paxton brings lawsuits against everything, though. Does this one have any merit?

• mminer237 2y ago
  This lawsuit was filed by a bunch of small entities, most importantly the Libertarian Part of Mississippi, but not including Ken Paxton, and a judge already granted the injunction, so at least he thinks it has merit. By the letter of the law, it's pretty clearly unconstitutional, but under the last hundred years of precedence of allowing almost anything under the commerce clause, it's less clear. The biggest issue with the CTA is definitely that it affects some non-profits. Arguing that requiring local non-profits to report their managers to the feds is "regulating interstate commerce" is a stretch for even the most liberal courts.
• sjtgraham 2y ago
  Do you think a judge would grant a preliminary injunction without merit? To win a preliminary injunction you must show: 1. Likelihood of success on the merits 2. Irreparable harm without it 3. Balance of harms favors you 4. Injunction is in the public interest.
  • gamblor956 2y ago
    Or find a judge who will disregard that and rule on ideological grounds regardless of the facts and law...
    • sjtgraham 2y ago
      Which will the be appealed. The system has many layers of protection.
      • deleted 2y ago
        [deleted]
  • deprecative 2y ago
    Is that a trick question? They do all the time in Texas.