5 ms·
The article’s headline is rather misleading (I assume unintentionally), because it omits that the actual seizure and data access was done pursuant to warrants.
by rayiner 2y ago
The article’s headline is rather misleading (I assume unintentionally), because it omits that the actual seizure and data access was done pursuant to warrants. Only the repair and firmware update was performed during a donut hole when one warrant had expired before another was granted.
Here, the government obtained multiple, time-limited warrants to search the device, but was unable to get into it. They sent it to be repaired. After the warrant extension expired, the repair guy fixed it and updated the firmware. (The record doesn’t say what version the firmware was, but it seems like it was standard firmware, not some special forensic firmware.) The next day, the government again obtained a warrant. Only after doing so did the government perform the search.
In this unusual situation, it’s reasonable to conclude that the device repair wasn’t a search. The seizure and the data access were both performed pursuant to a warrant. The only part that wasn’t covered by the warrant was just fixing the device in a seemingly conventional way to get it working again.
Original decision here, pages 3-4 has the relevant facts: https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/25423841/no-disassemble.pdf https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/25423841/no-disassemb...
- chefandy 2y agoI agree that most readers won’t really ‘get it’ by reading the headline, and appreciate your useful addition so we all can get some context without the click, but in defense of the author, I think writing layperson-accessible headlines for technical legal articles is often impossible. Having attempted to make interfaces and applications that made raw legal data useful for laypeople, including with NN summaries and such, if there’s a meaningfully better solution, I sure couldn’t find it after a few years of work. For the same reason reading case law doesn’t effectively help laypeople represent themselves in court, you need context and background knowledge to make sense of legal concepts. (If you’ve ever seen an overconfident ‘sovereign citizen’ cite opinions in court while representing themself, you’ve seen why. And while most are obviously under-educated for the task, they’re probably not unintelligent and they clearly put a lot of effort into it.) To people used to reading legal texts and familiar with the trajectory of decisions in this space, the headline makes sense, and I think that’s probably the best you can do. Trying to construct a headline that’s representative while also giving laypeople the background and context they need to make sense of the topic becomes way too long to be a headline long before it accomplishes it’s goal.
- rayiner 2y agoYes, I wouldn’t know how to explain all that in a headline either! Unfortunately the word “misleading” has multiple connotations—I wasn’t saying the author was trying to deliberately mislead, but rather that the reader shouldn’t conclude too much based on the headline alone.
- chefandy 2y agoSure, that makes sense. Additionally, whether something is misleading had as much to do with the person reading it as the person writing it.
- throwup238 2y agoThe author probably didn’t come up with the headline, the editor did. It’s one thing if the Office of Legislative Counsel tries and fails to come up with a succinct one liner, it’s another when an editor driven entirely by clickbait economic incentives does it. The latter rarely even try to be accurate.
- pc86 2y agoI do sometimes wish articles had information in the byline about who wrote the headline as well as just the article, or that it became standard practice for authors to write the headlines as well.
- dcrazy 2y agoIt’s Techdirt. The author and editor are the same person.
- chefandy 2y agoCan you propose a more appropriate one? I can’t think of one that is still headline length.
- Bjartr 2y ago"Federal court says merely repairing a seized device isn't a search" I think that's a bit better
- throwaway984393 2y ago[dead]
- stonemetal12 2y agoIt doesn't seem misleading to me just overly technical for no reason. Something like "Court Says Repairing Seized Phone isn't a Search" conveys the same meaning with fewer technical details, but is a little no duh. To me that is just as click bait-ish, because I would want to know who was dumb enough to try that as a defense, or wonder what the actual situation was.
- thayne 2y agoWas it just a repair, or did they install custom firmware? It isn't really clear from the article, and that seems like it would make a big difference.
- rayiner 2y agoThe forensics report suggests the device was reflashed with its normal firmware, and a different set of forensics tools were used to access the device once it was repaired. > I brought both devices to the Newberg-Dundee Police Department Digital Forensics Lab and evaluated the iPhone 6 for function. I connected the device to power via the lightning connector and found it drew electrical current indicating it was attempting to charge the battery however the screen remained black. I attempted to power the device on with no change on the device screen. I located an identical model donor phone an A1549 and verified the donor device functioned properly. To eliminate the possibility of a hardware issue on the evidence device, I swapped the circuit board from the evidence device into the housing of the known good donor device. I attempted to boot the device however the screen remained black. I could tell the device was booting because it drew current when powered directly from a power supply however it was not booting normally. I was able to cycle the device between DFU mode and recovery modes but was unable to get to boot into a normal state and there was no change on the devices screen. Because the device would not boot normally or light the display, I believed there was likely and issue with the device firmware. I used a repair tool to re-flash the devices firmware. After the re-flashing repair process the device booted normally to the screen requesting the passcode. The board swap and firmware re-flashing processes do not change the user data on the device. During the board swap process, I only reassembled the device to a condition sufficient to make the device function. > After receiving the copy of the search warrant, I connected the iPhone 6 to an advanced forensic extraction tool (Graykey). I used the passcode 070106 obtained from the previous extraction of the iPhone XS to unlock the device and obtained a Full File System extraction from the iPhone 6.
- BurningFrog 2y agoSince I had to look it up: pursuant: in accordance with (a law or a legal document or resolution). "conversations that they wiretap pursuant to court order"
- Suppafly 2y agoAre you new to learning English or have you managed to not come across it before?
- BurningFrog 2y agoIt's my second language, but I've lived in the US since 1995. I probably see the word once a year at most, and kinda vaguely understood it from context, but I wanted to look it up.
- Suppafly 2y agoI suppose I've learned it from context from watching a bunch of those action-lawyer type tv shows.
- WarOnPrivacy 2y ago> The only part that wasn’t covered by the warrant was just fixing the device in a seemingly conventional way to get it working again. By 'the only part that wasn't covered', I think you meant "The only part that wasn't within a warrant period" (as opposed to not falling the scope of one of the warrants). Assuming that, this is what I think you are considering. Are the constitutional safeguards of these warrants reasonably satisfied here? Instead, I believe the following is the matter for concern here. By declaring a repair [a repair which occurred to enable and assist a search for incriminating evidence] to not be a search (to not be an action that merits 4th amendment protections) a court establishes that LEO are now free to forcefully perform certain evidence gathering actions on private devices without a warrant - as long as those actions can be construed as a 'repair'.
- Suppafly 2y ago>In this unusual situation, it’s reasonable to conclude that the device repair wasn’t a search. I'm more comfortable concluding that it's an illegal search than I am concluding that it's not a search at all. During the period that the warrant(s) didn't apply, it should have been sitting in a sealed evidence bag and not being modified by a 3rd party. The law doesn't and shouldn't make provisions for "eh, it's probably not a big deal, we'll probably get another warrant".
- d0mine 2y ago[uneducated impressions:] Sure, it sounds like technicality. It is a shame it is not treated as such. The right solution would be to force government officials to do their job and get warrants on time next time. Just physical access not mentioning firmware update means your device is compromised. It sets a bad precedent. It is not like people have too many rights as it is.
- hn_acker 2y ago> They sent it to be repaired. After the warrant extension expired, the repair guy fixed it and updated the firmware. These sentences you wrote are just as misleading, if not more so. The "repair guy" was a government detective who performed the repair by re-flashing firmware at a forensic laboratory during a period when no search warrant was active [1]: > Detective Sheldon Clay, an HSI Task Force Officer at that laboratory was able to repair the iPhone 6 by replacing its circuit board and re-flashing the device's firmware. Mot., ECF 106, EX. D at 2. At that time, Detective Clay also determined that new forensic software was likely able to bypass the iPad's passcode. The headline of TFA claims that the reflashing of firmware was for the purpose of facilitating a search. [1] https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/25423841/no-disassemble.pdf https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/25423841/no-disassemb...
- EPWN3D 2y agoAuthor chose to take a jab at "walled gardens" which made absolutely no sense. They basically implied that because both iPhones and iPads were accessed in this way, Apple's ecosystem is worthless. Or something. Clearly had an agenda.