8 ms·
Grifters, believers, grinders, and coasters
- encoderer 2y agoPeople are multi-dimensional. I’m 42 and I’ve been all of these things at different times.
- _gmax0 2y agoI'll buy someone a coffee if they propose a state-space model that identifies a location on the author's plane as a function of time and incentives :^)
- mckn1ght 2y agoI was thinking about how to describe the interactions between all possible pairings under a variety of circumstances, like on an axis of virtuous vs conflicting.
- datameta 2y agoThree dimensional chart, not kidding. We sell outselves short. With good design and color coding those are quite readable.
- m463 2y agoJust plot your sincerity against your energy level (which might track time of day) Probably could make a garmin watch function to plot "stress level" vs "body battery"
- conqrr 2y agoSame for me at different time. But I also believe I have a natural state to gravitate if the environment provides for.
- syntheticnature 2y agoI think the article sort-of says this near the end, mainly in hinting that continuous grinding can be a problem.
- koasterz 2y ago> I’m 42 and I’ve been all of these things at different times. Believer - When you first join the company and they sell you on the vision Grinder - You work hard for a year or two to make a difference Coaster - You realize you wont get promoted, they company will always have no money on the bonus pool, except for the execs. And that the company will go on by sheer force of momentum, not by your grinding. Grifter - You see the company hire friend after friend of execs, friends' kids as interns, friends' wives as Executive Directors, execs' girlfriends as "Chief of Staff" - and you realize you need to get something too, so you use company time to form your own startup. Now you repeat the cycle, except you are the person at the top and someone else goes thru these stages.
- dmarlow 2y ago> You see the company hire friend after friend of execs, friends' kids as interns, friends' wives as Executive Directors, execs' girlfriends as "Chief of Staff" - and you realize you need to get something too, so you use company time to form your own startup. They do this because no one wants to work at their startup. How do you see this being solved then?
- krta 2y agoNo, certain startups (not from YC!) hire a pool of grinders (50%) and the rest is family, academic friends, LDS church members etc. The rest gets the cozy positions and does nothing.
- PaulHoule 2y agoI find it really funny to be in some place where there is a privileged class, particularly when I discover it gradually. I can see how some people would find it infuriating.
- koasterz 2y ago>> They do this because no one wants to work at their startup. How do you see this being solved then? Not really. Startups cannot really operate without doers, and most doers want something out of the experience -- equity, money, promotion, etc. I've seen two start-ups (one Series A SF startup with bigname VCs) which promoted VC-frields' kids while the doers waited and waited. In one case, the "child" was 25yo, became manager 6mo later, became Director 6mo after that, became senior Director 6mo after that. Some facebook stalking revealed the relationship, some photos at Lake Tahoe. Eventually the startup collapsed because there were so many senior folks w/o real experience. I saw the same individuals follow leadership to a new company, which also had a huge implosion.
- joefigura 2y agoThe author makes this point. "These aren’t immutable aspects of your personality. They’re more categories for how you approach the job of software engineering - you’ll move around between quadrants as you change your approach to work, for all the usual reasons."
- HPsquared 2y agoIt's all contextual. Just like all the "alpha' etc stuff.
- red-iron-pine 2y ago"alpha" stuff isn't contextual, it's just bs. unless you're talking about the stock measure, in which case it is less contextual (but sorta), but very real and sought after.
- maartenscholl 2y agoThe chart in the article is multi-dimensional, it has two dimensions: what you mean is time-varying.
- crdrost 2y agoIn addition to people being multidimensional, this sort of diagram usually has a sort of "internal motion" to it. That is, this is an instance of a diagram that you'll see repeated over and over in business texts; I personally call it a "fourbox" but I suppose "business matrix" is more common and "quadrant analysis" or something like that is even more descriptive. The idea is that you identify two different things, graph those as separate axes, label the quadrants and then tell a story about the four different labels. The Eisenhower matrix is the usual example (one axis is how close is the deadline, near vs far, the other is how much is lost by missing the deadline, a little vs a lot. The immediacy is called "urgency", the stakes are called "importance," things that are important-and-urgent should be done by you now, things that are important-not-urgent should be scheduled, things that are urgent-not-important should be delegated to someone else, and everything in the last quadrant should be safely ignored). A "true" fourbox in my view should tell a particular story, which I call "cynefin flow" after a different iconic fourbox that told this story compellingly. According to this flow, there should be motion in a circle about the center of the axes, except that it gets interrupted at one transition between the quadrants and becomes stuck in a U-shape, unless some outside stimulus pushes it over that edge. So there is a motion I -> II -> III -> IV around the quadrants but then things get stuck in IV unless an outside stimulus pushes it back into I. The cynefin story for the Eisenhower matrix ends with things getting stuck in not-important-not-urgent, so that is your IV quadrant. Of the two stories you can tell from there, the more compelling story is that, "Things that are important but not urgent, become important-and-urgent as the clock runs down, but then the deadline will pass and the pain becomes a sunk cost and they become unimportant-and-urgent, only to eventually fade to being unimportant-and-not-urgent, until an external stimulus acts to suddenly attach additional stakes to them and make them important again." So you have a bill (I), that bill comes due (II), you miss the deadline but still have a chance to pay it (III), and finally it gets sent to collections and impacts your credit (IV). And it sits there until either the debt expires or you're trying to get a new house, in which case it becomes Important again (I) to clean up your credit history. Similarly with the BCG matrix, which is a fourbox with your capture of a market on one axis, the market's growth rate on a separate axis. Then the businessfolk carefully write "cash cow, question mark, star, dog" on each of these four quadrants. But what makes it a true fourbox is that your "question marks" that you invest in become "stars" as you capture their markets, then become "cash cows" as growth dries up, then become "dogs" as the market itself stagnates, until some external stimulus creates the opportunity for growth and more question marks again. OP's diagram has "work intensity" on one axis, and a sort of "idealism-vs-pragmatism" axis for the other, and they have identified the intense pragmatist as naturally falling under a Cynefin flow into being a coasting pragmatist as they burn out. Presumably this is the accumulation point and those are the III and IV of the system, in which case some external stimulus causes coasting pragmatists to become coasting idealists, at which point they will naturally become intense idealists as their aspirations come to the fore, and then naturally become intense pragmatists as the organization fails to reward their idealism?
- tarsinge 2y agoYeah I’m only in my late 30s and I’m in the same boat. Many things and mindsets can be good, it’s not about finding the absolute but finding the most appropriate one for the current context of your life.
- dboreham 2y agoThe believer/grifter axis might be what psychologists call "external" vs "internal" locus of control.
- dingnuts 2y agoit's the cynicism axis both extremes are insane the middle should be labeled "realist"
- parpfish 2y agoThat chart is confusing because they’ve put the quadrant labels on the axes so a) the axis dimensions are unknown and b) there are two labels on each quadrant
- wccrawford 2y ago0 is in the middle of the chart. The extremes are the words on that axis.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- gipp 2y agoThose are the labels for each end of each axis, not for the quadrants. Believer/grifter is one axis, coaster/grinder is the other.
- ryandrake 2y agoYea, the quadrant visualization does not make sense. What is the bottom-left quadrant? Coaster or Grifter or both? What about the top-right? None of the above? I can't figure it out.
- dylan604 2y ago"and this article is really aimed at people who are trying to have a bit more empathy for the assholes they work with." and now you have my attention. only, i'm reading it from the asshole's perspective.
- wccrawford 2y agoThe trick is that there's actually assholes in all 4 quads. And nice people, too.
- dowager_dan99 2y agoor that depending on where you position yourself right now, there's assholes in 3 quadrants, but since you can simultaneously be in multiple quads, you're an asshole too.
- Aeolun 2y agoI think the real problem is that it's impossible to work as a believer/grinder in any large organisation (e.g. filled with grifters). It's not sustainable to work as a grinder for a long time in the first place, but it's especially terrible when it's unrewarding.
- SpaceManNabs 2y ago> it's especially terrible when it's unrewarding you just described the angst of every phd student.
- wiseowise 2y agoWhy would someone grifting prevent you from griding?
- bbqfog 2y agoUnless you're a founder, it only makes sense to be a coasting/grifter. Everything else is exploitation/for suckers.
- throw646577 2y ago"Grifter" is a terrible word choice for the "personality type" in the description. Grifting is always a form of aberrant behaviour -- manipulative, cruel, deceitful, larcenous. Unless you are Humpty Dumpty, I don't know why you would choose a word for a quadrant that requires you to clarify that you do not mean to associate its actual meaning with the behaviours in that quadrant. "Politician" (albeit with a small p) is a much, much better word for the personality type in the description. Politics is only sometimes a form of aberrant behaviour.
- syntheticnature 2y agoGiven the description in the article, I'd say Cynic/Idealist instead of Grifter/Believer.
- gchamonlive 2y agoOr maybe even loyalist/idealist to purge any hint of negativity from the first category
- __MatrixMan__ 2y agoDoes it? Loyalty is for henchmen. You only need it if you have a habit of asking people to do something slimy.
- gchamonlive 2y agoCould be but > They respect the company mission as written, but what they really value is what the leaders of the company show they care about. > Grifters aren’t very good at changing the culture of their organizations. They tend to go with the current instead. To me loyalist fits this well, not because they are necessarily going to do dirty work, but because they are loyal to the rules that are in place.
- __MatrixMan__ 2y ago
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jameson 2y ago> I think a lot of programmer arguments bottom out in a cultural clash between different kinds of engineers True. Also it should be the managements'/team leads' role to act as a midiators. It's a waste of time to constantly argue over what is "right" when all proposed solutions are functional. Should we spend more time flushing out the unknowns? Should we launch ASAP and interate fast? Should we automate the process? Do we have data to back our assumptions? The "culture fit" is not superficial and I've always been advocate of fire fast if one is culturally unfit because it slows down everyone
- mckn1ght 2y agoYou are talking about a third dimension that I thought of immediately upon reading this, which is risk aversion, mentioned long ago in https://gist.github.com/cornchz/3313150 https://gist.github.com/cornchz/3313150 (the original is no longer accessible, thanks Google+) I'm just trying to imagine the different traits for liberal vs conservative grifters (thought leader vomit vs machiavellian connivance), believers (thought leader vomit vs constant market research), grinders (ship lots of code vs write lots of tests) and coasters (shitpost all day on random slack channels vs do the bare minimum to appear to be working)
- jameson 2y agovery interesting read
- GuB-42 2y agoYou can see your "coaster score" on Hacker News, it is the number on the upper right, next to your username ;)
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- adamc 2y agoI would say that I'm a "believer" in this terminology, but I don't think either coaster or grinder fits; depending on the task, I might be either. It's determined by how hard I find it to get going on the task, which often reflects ambiguity and lack of direction. When the task is vague, it can take a while to figure out an approach to try. Which is, I guess, a way to say that often when I'm "coasting", I'm working -- just not as effectively as I would like. I usually feel guilty when I'm unsure what to do. I've definitely burned out a few times.
- dartos 2y agoHumans are complex.
- bryanlarsen 2y agoI believe that's consistent with the author's "coaster" description. "They work enough to get the job done" which is sometimes very little, but can sometimes be a lot if that's what's necessary. They're also a good source of slack -- "They’re also good for teams that have a lot of last-minute requests or questions". Coasters can do more work when that's what's needed. OTOH, a grinder always working at 100% can never give more.
- alganet 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Barrin92 2y ago"Why do engineers get mad at each other so often?[...]a cultural clash between different kinds of engineers: believers vs grifters, or coasters vs grinders" Engineers don't get mad at each other often, the issue is that none of those four archetypes are engineers. Engineers have a common formal training, certification and can build things to specification and timelines which avoids most of the culture clashes. If you want to resolve what's described here the solution is to work somewhere that looks more like Lockheed and less like a frathouse. And if you really care about software engineering as a discipline, avoid an organization that sounds like this: "In most software companies, you really want a handful of engineers obsessing about issues like accessibility, security and performance all the time, even when the organization as a whole doesn’t care about it"
- SoftTalker 2y agoCompanies like Lockheed are rather famous for blowing time and budget estimates in spectacular fashion. I don't know if the engineers are to blame but not necessarily a great example.
- unobatbayar 2y agoIt's one big tragedy from my experience.
- mckn1ght 2y agoAll models are wrong but some are useful and all that. Now I just want to see a megamodel combining this, the software "political" axis w.r.t. risk aversion (that I mentioned in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42320862 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42320862), and finally, a summary of how each node interacts with each other node given various circumstances like whether it's a collaborative or conflicting situation (a concept I learned from a required Strength Deployment Index workshop; mentioned in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42321007 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42321007), to prescribe various incentives or strategies to unstick the participants and keep them flowing. Maybe throw in some flavor from the 6 types of working genius (WIDGET: wonder, invention, discernment, galvanizing, enablement, tenacity) and meyers-briggs personality types for fun.
- jollyllama 2y agos/Grifter/Professional/g
- SpaceManNabs 2y agoyeah i agree. grifter has a connotation of scammy, and author is using the term differently.
- eweise 2y agoIs it only in the software fields that people who 'They work enough to get the job done, but typically no further' are coasters? Someone who gets their job should be an excellent employee.
- mrnotcrazy 2y agoI think in engineering maybe you can have different levels of doneness? At my job closing a ticket means the job is done but better than closing a ticket is documenting the solution. Even better is automating a solution for the future so maybe coasters are more likely to be close tickets and move on.
- acuozzo 2y agoMany managers leave the definition of "done" up to the programmer.
- intelVISA 2y agoWeird kind of 'management'
- acuozzo 2y agoI'm inclined to agree, but it depends on the context. This kind of 'management' is suitable for R&D. It's additionally suitable for any company in which software is a means to an end rather than the end itself. A textile factory manager, for instance, doesn't care if you write documentation for the changes you're making to the 40 year old Pascal program which runs the machines.
- 03024753382 2y ago[dead]
- dave333 2y agoNatural career progression is through initial growth (believer/grinder), plateau (slow transition to coaster/grifter), mid-life crisis (believer/grinder in different area/personal life), crash landing/retirement (coaster/grifter).
- JohnMakin 2y agoIME grifter/grinders get rapidly promoted in large companies that allow upward movement. I've not worked with many principals that were not like this.
- dowager_dan99 2y agogrinders - really? I've seen the opposite. They tend to be taken for granted and not recognized is my experience.
- JohnMakin 2y agoPer the article I think that type of person is a grinder/believer.
- dowager_dan99 2y ago"aimed at people who are trying to have a bit more empathy for the assholes they work with." I love it!
- oldnewthrowaway 2y agohttps://www.ribbonfarm.com/2009/10/07/the-gervais-principle-or-the-office-according-to-the-office/ https://www.ribbonfarm.com/2009/10/07/the-gervais-principle-... Said another way, with one fewer category, but with a clearer and more general approach. I've never read anything better to describe nearly all organizations of a certain size.
- red-iron-pine 2y agoProbably one of the best, must humorous, and dark takes on industrial psychology I've seen. I've spent a lot of time trying to disprove it, and kinda did. It's like Freud where it doesn't really stand up to serious empirical evaluation, yet there are so many uncomfortable truths. The author kinda loses the plot after the part about power talk, though.
- xianshou 2y agoAha! Finally, a perfect spiritual complement to the Gervais principle: https://www.ribbonfarm.com/2009/10/07/the-gervais-principle-or-the-office-according-to-the-office/ https://www.ribbonfarm.com/2009/10/07/the-gervais-principle-... According to Rao, every company survives by blending some combination of the following populations, varying by stage of lifecycle: - Sociopath = people who know the game and play it to win - Clueless = people who buy and spread the story the company is selling - Loser = people who accept the wage bargain, generally exchanging low devotion for minimal advancement This maps nicely to OP's quadrants: - Sociopath = grinder-grifter - Clueless = grinder-believer - Loser = coaster-grifter - (Coaster-believers get fired.)
- oldnewthrowaway 2y agoagreed! (see my other parent comment). one day Rao will get the recognition as the leading modern worklife philosopher he so richly deserves.
- PaulHoule 2y agoI am not a fan of assigning labels to people because I'm a fan of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_semantics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_semantics A taxonomy of partial engagement in software development would be an interesting topic. I've worked at quite a few places where there was something pathological I couldn't change or where I could have worked harder but it would have created a lot of strife with people who (don't work as hard|don't work as smart|don't see the big picture|aren't careful|don't know how to write joins in SQL|learned to design software by learning answers to interview questions|...) In a case like that you can still get stuff done with 50% engagement, getting a lot more done might not be feasible without getting the support you need from your co-workers and if you lower your standards your life gets easier and you still get something done. It can sometimes feel pretty good and it can sometimes feel like dying inside.
- Der_Einzige 2y agoQuintessential example of the "Grifter" in action right here ("General Semanticists") Why are these people always flirting with psudoscientists and charlatans? Seriously? Why is this linking to Wilhelm Reich? Why does this look like some shit Lacan would have written? Why does this link to the devils NLP (Neuro-linguistic programming) Why couldn't scientists in this era just stay in their fking lane and not say dumb shit? I'm so tired of having to debunk yet another crack-pot stupid ideology from this era. This is psychoanalysis for the STEM-lord, and just as full of nonsense.
- PaulHoule 2y agoI have met a few of the luminaries of the third generation of "the devil's NLP" and I've learned enough speed hypnosis to call up people like that and get them to send me a free copy of their latest training materials but this does not help me with picking up girls. On one hand I am trained as a physicist and work as a computer programmer and have a lot of respect for arch-reductionists like Forester and Minsky but I also have an a schizotypal brain that causes me to have unusual experiences: I have a knack for dowsing rods, pendulums, ouija boards and the like even if I don't believe in them. Korzybski is an interesting case because you cannot get a good edition of his Science and Sanity so it is not possible to evaluate his work as a whole. I'd agree with L. Ron Hubbard (half jokingly) that Korzybski did not develop a workable system but Korzybski asked interesting questions and in some sense has less bullshit per mile than most approaches to getting more out of the human nervous system (e.g. I had a therapist who gave me CBT worksheets that Korzybski would have been giving out had he attained the "workable system")
- indoordin0saur 2y agoThe definition of 'grifter' here just didn't sense to me and I tried. Interesting idea on the article but I don't think it was a great execution.
- debacle 2y agoPlease don't try and redefine terms like "grifter." It is a very important word, especially in today's political climate.
- isk517 2y agoYeah, grifter is a term for someone running a scam. Using a term like 'Ladder Climber' or even 'Ostentatious' would be a better fit with the definition provided.
- rvz 2y agoLots of "grifters" and con-artists in AI these days.
- paradoxyl 2y agoHe should've thought harder about the names, particularly "grifter." What he describes is not even remotely close to what grifting means.
- hasbot 2y agoNo mention of all the "deadwood:" people that don't contribute anything at all. People you're loath to assign anything to because they've repeatedly shown that they're incapable of finishing the simplest task. People one would think would be first on the cutting block at the next layoff.
- pmg102 2y agoIs it not just a question of what you're optimising for? Excluding the outliers (the lazy, incompetent, or geniuses), most can choose what to optimise for: - free time, low stress, calm life - fulfillment through delivering functionality - fulfillment through pride in the craft - money and status through career progression - social validation through relationships with coworkers/bosses