8 ms·
Tip pressure might work in the moment, but customers are less likely to return
- graton 2y agoI'm more likely to pay cash at those type of businesses. As then there is no tip screen. And as the article states I have also avoided some businesses because they have them.
- muzika 2y agoLet’s have restaurants raise prices to cover employee salaries, and make it illegal for them to ask for tips. Customers who want to tip need to do so without solicitation. (Not sure how this would work with credit card terminals though).
- kevin_thibedeau 2y agoThe terminals are the problem. If people would abandon a cashless lifestyle they can tip normally without the electronic shame box.
- gedy 2y agoI normally pay cash for food anyways as I don't want my eating habits data-mined for some future insurance penalty, etc.
- paleotrope 2y agoAll that will happen is people will develop scar tissue and just not tip anymore. People used to be polite and be nice when they picked up the phone from some number they didn't recognize. Scam artists USE this old custom to scam people. Well, most people don't even pick up the phone any more and for people that have to, like myself, the instant I recognize a cold call, I just hangup. I don't feel guilty about it anymore, in fact, I feel empowered. Tipping at terminals is going to happen the same way. The idea that some minimum wage person is gonna recognize you, let alone still working at these places will key you in on this is just something that will go away. Tip at a sitdown restaurant, that's normal. Tipping at a terminal for takeout, screw that.
- cafard 2y agoThat cold calls are typically IVR removes any residual embarrassment over just hanging up.
- esperent 2y agoAs the owner of a bakery/cafe - thankfully in a country where tipping isn't normal - changing prices to cover costs isn't a simple thing to do, unfortunately. Customers are extremely sensitive to price changes, and expect certain price points. We have 7% inflation, and our suppliers have no problem raising their prices to reflect that. But we can't match them easily. 50k and 100k VND are prices that customers orient around here. In the US the equivalent might be $10 and $20, where one is cheap for a meal, the other is expensive. Notice that those are just round numbers rather than specific values. What happens when inflation means that $10 is no longer sustainable for a meal? You can either increase the price and weather all of your regulars complaining, and new customers viewing you as an expensive location. Or, you can cut costs. The same applies if you have a sudden new expense. Say, taxes go up. Or you decide to stop requesting tips and start paying staff a living wage (something I'm strongly in favor of). Then you'll need to increase all prices by 30%. Do you think your customers will be happy? No way! And even those customers who do support and agree with you, subconsciously they'll still be comparing you to other places that haven't done this and your place will be comparatively expensive and they'll come less often. Yes, even if they end up paying less after factoring in tips. Customers (in general) are not rational that way. Then the only option is legislation so that everywhere changes at once. And good luck with that!
- valval 2y agoYou either raise prices, cut costs, or go out of business. All are valid options.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- dismalaf 2y agoTipping is a tough problem: if you pay customer facing employees more, you'll need to raise prices. If your competitors still have a tipping expectation, their menu prices will be lower. And let's be real, most customers aren't savvy enough to think about that ahead of time, which is why most restaurants that have attempting no-tipping systems in North America have failed (or reverted back to accepting tips). There's also a segment of the population that enjoys the perceived power of holding a tip over an employee's head.
- acdha 2y agoMost people do think about pricing - not to the penny, sure, but you have to be really rich not to have an idea about roughly where going out will fit in your budget. There are two reasons why tipping is popular: restaurant owners think it motivates employees to flatter/put up with customers and/or allows them to skim some extra income, and there’s a certain type of diner who loves the power imbalance (e.g. every guy who sexually harasses waitresses loves pushing to see how much they can get away with, or the demanding people who calibrate their behavior just below the level where someone’s going to decide that the chance of a tip isn’t worth it). The first group likes to tell high-income service workers that their pay will go down without tipping, which is fairly effective at finding people to be the media front saying workers don’t want to get rid of tipping instead of the other 90% who are guaranteed to benefit.
- dismalaf 2y ago> Most people do think about pricing No offence but you're kind of proving my point. I said nothing about a difference in pricing because there isn't unless you actually tip $0 (which statistically very few people do). $24 (restaurant includes tip in price in order to pay servers a fair wage) is the same as $20 + 20% tip. Most of the rest of your comment is what I said with different wording. > high-income service workers There's very few high-service income workers. I served tables through university, even if you make $400 in one night there's not enough of those nights for you to be "high income". If you're a stellar server working full time you can maybe equal what an average accountant makes in a year (which is pretty mediocre), but with more stress.
- rabuse 2y agoI'll never tip on those things if it's not your typical tipped position, like a bartender, waitress, etc. Pay your employees.
- dataflow 2y agoWhat do you do for coffee shops? Or restaurants that ask for payment & tip first, then bring you your food, and don't do anything else?
- rabuse 2y agoI don't go to any of those personally
- HDThoreaun 2y agoI dont tip.
- xscott 2y agoThe other one I'm seeing lately is a semi-stealth "service charge" on the bill. Something like 18% to 20% added to the bill without really standing out. This used to be something they'd do for "larger parties", but now I'm seeing it even when I'm eating solo. This makes for an uncomfortable situation where I now have to ask the waiter or bartender if they receive this as a tip. Then I need to decide if I want to tip something like 5% to 7% extra, which would be a good 25% tip in total, but looks like a crappy 5% tip. So after dealing with that, I just don't go back to those pubs or restaurants. There was one bar where the waitress told me she doesn't get that service charge. It just goes to the house. So if she was telling the truth, all of the prices on the menu are just a lie.
- add-sub-mul-div 2y agoSix months ago I was at a burrito place and saw as I was paying that there was a new 3% fee for paying with a credit card. I have not gone back there since. Asking $11 for a burrito was already iffy and by then I'd started to curtail fast food purchases. I can't even imagine paying an 18-20% fee that isn't meant to be the entirety of the tip.
- Buttons840 2y agoThe Visa terms of service forbid charging extra for payments using a Visa. Other credit cards have similar terms I think.
- bdangubic 2y agoexactly. you’d get banned from visa and then you may as well close the shop
- add-sub-mul-div 2y agoYeah I thought there was some kind of rule like that which is why I was so surprised, I'd never seen it in food service before.
- PlunderBunny 2y ago
- Karupan 2y agoI dread the day I have to eat at US restaurants, or even get something delivered. Part of the reason is cultural: I’ve never lived in a country where a tip is mandatory and you’ll be called out if you don’t. The other reason being it involves a degree of social pressure and shame, if one doesn’t tip enough. Both don’t sit well with me. But I can attest that if I’m forced to tip, I’ll not return to that establishment.
- acchow 2y agoIt's a broken system but it will never go away since tips are tax-advantaged (there's no sales tax on the tip). The mental block can be helped a little by adding 1/3rd to all the menu prices as you read them.
- sgc 2y agoSpeaking for myself, it is not a mental block, it is disgust with the social design of tip culture. Including tips, waiters are better paid than teachers, and many other more essential professions that require higher qualifications. The pressure is disproportionate to their financial situation. Let's normalize paying everybody what they are worth and do away with the tortuous guilt trips. To be clear, I am promoting eliminating tips, and paying everybody in the lower 90% of wage earners more for their work. I have no interest in shortchanging waiters.
- dataflow 2y ago> tips are tax-advantaged (there's no sales tax on the tip) Someone please correct me if I'm wrong, but the bigger tax that's avoided here is corporate taxes, I think. The tip goes directly to the employee, and it's thus not taxed as corporate income, is my understanding. EDIT: Ah, I missed that corporate taxes were on net earnings rather than gross, so this wouldn't make any difference. Thank you!
- hattmall 2y agoNo wages are deducted so they don't pay income taxes on them anyway.
- btilly 2y agoThe worst service that I ever received was in France, where tips were mandatory and could not be varied. I've never been so offended at being asked to tip as when it was done by the smug jerk who had just arranged to make sure that I didn't enjoy my meal, and who knew that they would get their full cut of my unhappy experience. I have no problem tipping in the moment. And sometimes for very different amounts than expected. But if you expect a tip and didn't earn it...?
- LudwigNagasena 2y agoA mandatory tip is an oxymoron. What do you mean exactly?
- jmknoll 2y agoTips are mandatory in France? This is news to me. I’ll sometimes round up to the nearest 5, but nothing like the US.
- dataflow 2y agoDo you have more than 1 data point here?
- GuB-42 2y agoYou probably fell in some tourist trap or something. I hope you didn't tip. Tips are absolutely not mandatory in France. You pay for what you order at the price you see on the menu and nothing more. Small tips are appreciated but not expected. I am French, I have eaten in many restaurants of all kinds and I have never been asked to tip and I tip only occasionally. As for surcharges, they sometimes happen, for example if the restaurant is part of a club and you are not a member, but never at regular restaurants, it may even be illegal. I am sorry for your experience, they probably noticed that you weren't a native and attempted to trick you. Was it in Paris? It seems like such unacceptable behavior is more common in Paris. Note: I interpreted "mandatory tip" as having to pay a surcharge. Of course, part of the bill goes into paying the waiting staff, but it shouldn't appear on the bill, that part is between the employees and their boss.
- 2y ago
- speakfreely 2y agoCustomers actually do have a way to retaliate against establishments they feel are abusive: leave a bad review. Businesses depend on the organic traffic they get from Google and Yelp listings, so sustained feedback against abusive tipping pressure will get noticed if people start to make a point to write reviews about it.
- Der_Einzige 2y agoIt’s trivial to have reviews removed
- acdha 2y agoDo you have any confirmed evidence of that? There have been rumors for years about Yelp but I’ve never seen stronger evidence than forum posts.
- arealaccount 2y agoStill delivers a message to the establishment owner who may not realize that people hate it.
- dataflow 2y ago> Customers actually do have a way to retaliate against establishments they feel are abusive: leave a bad review. What do you do if you don't want that review tied to your account/identity, or prefer the fact that you've gone to that establishment to not be published to the whole world?
- tomatotomato37 2y agoI've always wanted to ask for those who worked as a cashier or waiter in those restaurants with the ipad style payment platforms if they actually receive the tips on those things. It always seemed like such a generic default option that was always left on in those apps that I wondered if the business even acknowledged them
- jaco6 2y agoI work at a Dominos and we of course accept and expect tips on delivery, because without tips the drivers would make <$5 an hour after paying for gas and their vehicle’s depreciation. But at checkout for carryout orders the card terminal also now opens a tip menu. I would never tip on this screen because the employees are already paid a true hourly wage, albeit a low one, not a server rate that is below minimum wage. Furthermore there is no way for the customer to know if the employee they are tipping is even one of the bottom paid line cooks or a manager or driver who are already making $20/hour at my restaurant—what most servers make after tips. I am a driver and sometimes accept payment for carryout orders and end up receiving credit card tips that should really go to the line cooks. When we aren’t busy I make an effort to reach over and click “no tip” for the customer, as checkout employees at other restaurants sometimes do for me, but sometimes it’s busy and I get tips anyway. As others have said I think doing away with tips altogether would be best but it seems unlikely that will ever happen. A compromise would be to somehow ban “customer facing” tipping for things other than delivery—no tips at cash registers, only for “pay at the table” establishments.
- rootusrootus 2y ago> I work at a Dominos and we of course accept and expect tips on delivery, because without tips the drivers would make <$5 an hour after paying for gas and their vehicle’s depreciation. The business should own the cars and pay for the fuel. Or they need to be at least compensating drivers by the mile at the current IRS rate. Especially considering Dominos charges a delivery fee. Where is that going to if not to the drivers?
- anal_reactor 2y ago>the drivers would make <$5 an hour Not my problem
- bdangubic 2y agoI feel the same way and if EVERYONE felt the same way things would change rather quickly. if everyone stopped tipping every pizza delivery driver most would quit shortly thereafter and dominos/papa johns… would have no choice but to pay adequate wage. however, since most people are tipping the ones that don’t are as the assholes :)
- woodruffw 2y agoI've noticed a related phenomenon to this, one that (I assume) comes more from POS providers like Square than from businesses themselves: the default "flow" on these tablet-style POS systems doesn't distinguish between culturally tip-able transactions and ones that are not conventionally tip-able. As a result, people feel pressured to tip on things that weren't previously considered. A concrete example: a bakery near me uses the same POS terminal for both cafe sales and bread sales, meaning I get asked to tip on loaves of bread. I've seen people get flummoxed and tip $1-2 on bread sales because of this.
- paulpauper 2y agoit's like choose one of three options: 20%, 30% or more.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- richbell 2y agoSquare is the most egregious offender of this in my neck of the woods. Outrageous tip options (usually starting at 20%) and a large screen that make your selection obvious leave a bad taste in my mouth. I've witnessed multiple businesses switch to Square and the suggested tips skyrocket. I don't know if it's a default or just a coincidence.
- nicbou 2y agoThese kinds of behaviour change the entire relationship between you and a business from transactional to adversarial. You're no longer engaging in a clear transaction, but in a negotiation that involves guilt tripping and fear of judgement. I just want a beer; why do I have to defend how much my interaction is worth on top of the retail price?
- uptown 2y agoWent bowling yesterday. A tip prompt turned up when it was time to pay with no obvious way to avoid tipping. To do so you just had to hit enter instead of picking one of the preset choices but I couldn’t fathom why I’d ever tip the guy who hands me my one shoe back after knocking down some pins.
- britzkopf 2y agoIn Canada, there is no longer any special wage below the minimum for servers. They receive the same minimum as many other blue collar workers. It's over, there is no longer any reasonable argument for tipping servers but not a whole host of other low wage earners.
- rootusrootus 2y agoThere is effectively no special below-minimum wage in the US either. The servers have to be paid at least minimum wage, with tips or not.
- ThePowerOfFuet 2y agoOn paper, this is true. In effect, however, it often is not.
- britzkopf 2y agoHow does this rule get circumvented?
- kelipso 2y agoWaiters getting fired (or some other consequences) if they don't make the minimum wage through tips.
- rootusrootus 2y agoThe problem with that claim is how tight the correlation is between low tips and poor performance.
- alephnerd 2y agoFYI - The tipping option on Square POS is a default setting that automatically generates default tip ranges. In a lot of cases, the vendor just enables tips and doesn't care to optimize. Alternatively, you could always tip in cash or just not tip. I've never been in a situation where I've been forced to tip and I've eaten at restaurants at all ranges of quality.
- memset 2y agoIs there a relationship between revenue for the restaurant? Or total tips earned? If low-privacy tipping decreases loyalty, is it overall positive from the business’ perspective?
- gullywhumper 2y agoI've been seeing more and more places also include the taxes and other fees in the total used to calculate the suggested tip. That seems pretty slimy to me.
- kernal 2y agoThey’re finding new and creative ways to add extra costs to your meal in addition to asking / demanding / shaming you to tip. I’ve solved this problem by not going out to any restaurants and cooking at home. And when I do eat out it’s usually at take out places. It has gotten so out of hand that I think a USP for a new or existing restaurant would be to advertise as a no tipping establishment. Pay your employees a fair wage and adjust your meal prices accordingly. Who knows? It just might catch on.
- add-sub-mul-div 2y agoSince eating out got excessively overpriced I've started cooking more consistently than I ever had before in my life. The food is much better, besides being obviously cheaper as well. And I'm not even saying I'm good at it, it's just easy to find a few basic things you like that aren't hard to do well.
- aomix 2y agoTip awkwardness has played a surprisingly big role in me eating healthier. No I don't want to tip you for handing me a prepackaged muffin. But you're paid like shit with an eye on making up the difference in tips. So I guess the choice is to just not shop there. Which takes out almost all places I'd get a snack at during the day.
- abeppu 2y agoNot the main topic, but the article is in part on how people respond to changing normative pressures so I think it's fair: I'm surprised at the low level of information in this article given that it's written by the original researchers! In many other fields I would have expected greater specificity and care from academics presenting their work to a lay audience. For example they say "our results were clear" but then only describe the direction of the effect -- they give no numbers about magnitude or significance! And following the link to their paper ... it seems pretty bad? Study 1a was done at a single brewpub, which uses 2 POS systems from the same provider, one counter-based and one hand-held. They say nothing about what kinds of customers or transactions get the hand-held (presumably table-side?) POS system instead of the counter-based one. Are these different group sizes? Different seating areas? Food vs not? It's not a random assignment? So (a) it's hard to know whether the effect is real in the one business they measured with or if it's just that different kinds of customers are more or less likely to return and (b) it's hard to know whether this actually generalizes to other businesses. What was the effect size? During a 1 year period, customers whose first visit used a handheld POS had 1.1 subsequent visits vs 1.46 for customers whose first visit (within the period) used a counter-based POS. They're grouping people by their first visit in the period, as if that's going to be determinative of how they think about the business, but they don't know which customers were actually new (i.e. one month before the captured period, did you go and use a hand-held POS and then in the 3rd month of their period you went and used a counter-based POS? You're in the counter-based group.) All the rest of the 'studies' in their paper are market-research surveys.
- tzs 2y agoWalmart has an interesting option when it comes to tips on grocery delivery. If you have a Walmart+ membership ($98/year or $12.95/month) you get free home delivery on grocery orders of $35/month or more, and tipping is handled just like most delivery services--you don't have to but most people will feel guilty if they don't. But if you add the Walmart InHome add-on to Walmart+, which adds $40/year or $7/month, then the delivery people are not allowed to accept tips. If you want to show your appreciation Walmart says you can leave a note or comment on your delivery survey. Note that if you just have groceries delivered once per month, and order the minimum amount for free delivery ($35), and leave a 10% tip (the minimum most people who tip out of guilt will probably leave) that will come to more than $40/year in tips so InHome might actually be a decent deal. BTW, it is called InHome because no tipping is not actually the main point. The main point is that instead of just dropping your delivery off outside they will put it where you want, including inside your house. They will even unpack it and put things away in your fridge and cupboards if you want. I think I'd find that kind of creepy because I really don't like other people in my home, but I can see how some people could find it useful.
- Animats 2y agoWaymo customers seem to like that they don't have to tip the Waymo Driver.[1] [1] https://www.theregister.com/2024/09/07/uber_driver_waymo https://www.theregister.com/2024/09/07/uber_driver_waymo
- dredmorbius 2y agoTo generalise the observation: I've definitely shifted my own behaviour where I find coercive, obnoxious, or toxic patterns. "Loyalty coupons" where the number of items bought to receive one free escalated on subsequent purchase? Stopped shopping at that store. I'm not someone's Skinner Box experiment. Websites with increasingly user-hostile experiences (or moderator-hostile), o hai reddit and googs, yeah, eff that noise. Manufacturers selling shoddy products and failing to support them? Bad reviews and shop elsewhere (though that's often quite difficult). As the poet notes, "Rage, rage against the dying of the light." <https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/46569/do-not-go-gentle-into-that-good-night https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/46569/do-not-go-gentl...> (Dylan Thomas, whoever he was: <https://genius.com/Simon-and-garfunkel-a-simple-desultory-philippic-or-how-i-was-robert-mcnamarad-into-submission-lyrics https://genius.com/Simon-and-garfunkel-a-simple-desultory-ph...>.) I suspect metrics show benefits amongst those who tolerate such abuse. I'm curious how well exits are measured and assessed. A.O. Hirshcman, Exit, Voice, and Loyalty: <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exit%2C_Voice%2C_and_Loyalty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exit%2C_Voice%2C_and_Loyalty>.
- polotics 2y agoOne of the reasons why I hate visiting the USA. There were several instances where the choice of vacation destination was influenced by previous bad experiences like with tipping in some obnoxious restaurant, we just went elsewhere.
- GaryRaymond 2y agoJust came back from Spain, France and Italy. None of the restaurants have tipping. It makes for such a better and more relaxed experience. The U.S. needs to get with it.
- ac29 2y agoYep I was in a different part of Europe recently and it was the same. This wasnt about cultural norms, there was literally no way to tip when paying with a card most places (aside from leaving cash).
- JohnFen 2y agoI have certainly reduced my patronage at places where there is pressure to tip, including those tip prompts. Tipping was already an obnoxious aspect of US culture before, and it has become much worse. Increasingly, it's just not worth putting up with it.
- anotherevan 2y agoAmerican tipping culture is getting exported because of the software, too. Here in the Antipodes, tipping is not the norm at all, but the American produced point-of-sale software has tipping options on by default and they don't get adjusted. Hang around Australian Reddit groups long enough and you'll see the occasional rant about it.