6 ms·
> so why not agree to leave it unmarred by any obvious act of humanity, forevermore? How some people hate humanity. Personally, I'd love to see the lights from
by WalterBright 2y ago
> so why not agree to leave it unmarred by any obvious act of humanity, forevermore?
How some people hate humanity. Personally, I'd love to see the lights from a lunar colony on the moon.
This reminds me of the people who don't want to "pollute" Mars. Sheesh, it's a dead rock. There is no environment to pollute. It could desperately use people on it, just like the moon.
The solar system is ours, and we can and should do what we want to it. Not cower in self-hatred and loathing.
- vacuity 2y agoIs it an act of hatred to say that humans shouldn't expend huge amounts of effort and energy to try to populate Mars so that humans can escape the very human act of polluting the Earth? When this human pollution kills millions a year and plenty of other organisms? Is it a celebration of humanity to continue buying chocolate or clothing or rugs, even if they are clearly the result of exploited or downright slave labor? Or is it just that you suppose that we, as humans who have privilege and comfort, deserve to continue and expand those qualities? You "personally" want to see lights from the moon? You think Mars "desperately" needs habitation? I'm not sure how you're any less self-important about this topic than your opposition. I'm not really sure what you mean when you say "humanity", because it sure doesn't seem like the same kind of "humanity" that MLK Jr. described. I'm sure there are plenty of people you could speak for. Don't presume that's everyone worth considering.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoWhy not both populate Mars and improve earth? I dont think they are mutually exclusive.
- vacuity 2y agoI would be (grudgingly) fine with populating Mars if I felt that we as a race were remotely trying our best to improve Earth. By opening up Mars, incentives are wrong and we will probably become even more lax.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> By opening up Mars, incentives are wrong and we will probably become even more lax The history of conquest on Earth shows no such example. If anything, given a choice, humans will happily push the unsavoury to the periphery. I'd much rather e.g. risky biological, chemical and nuclear research happen on the Moon or Mars than Earth. The honest truth is our first colonies on Mars will be Jamestowns. Unlike the Jamestown in our past, however, this one's horrors will be broadcast real time. The deadliness of space almost promises that we'll be keenly reminded of how special our safe harbor. Not that we'll forget it.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoWhy do you thinking settling mars would have any impact on our efforts to improve earth? What are the incentives that are wrong with Mars?
- vacuity 2y agoMy belief is that many people will think "Oh good! A safe harbor where we can fix our mistakes!" My problems with this: 1) Is everyone going to Mars in a reasonable time frame, or are people going to be left behind? Permanently? 2) Are we actually going to fix the Earth? Let's assume many people will be there for a while longer. 3) Are we going to not wreck Mars?
- s1artibartfast 2y ago#1 That is an extremely dumb thought to project on everyone else. Mars isn't an a replacement for earth, and wont support even a tiny fraction of the population in the foreseeable future. Why do you believe people will think this? #2 I hope we fix earth, but we either will or wont completely independent of Mars policy. Again, I dont see how they are related. Is the idea to prevent Mars activity as a motivating punishment (e.g. Birthday parties are cancelled until you clean your room)? #3 What does "wrecking Mars" mean? What is a good Mars and what is a bad Mars?
- 2y ago
- freejazz 2y agoOne of those is actually an urgent need. The other one presupposes any utility at all, let alone the massive leap in technology required to solve the other problem.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoSure, but why do you think that matters unless the two are in major competition?
- freejazz 2y agoBecause one is an urgent need, the other isn't and also presupposes a solution to the first problem. Perhaps you can explain why this doesn't matter.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoI dont see that way at all. Space exploration in no way hampers or restricts our ability to improve earth. The two can be done in parallel. Do you think that all non-urgent activities should/must be halted until the earth is improved?
- freejazz 2y agoI didn't say they couldn't be done in parallel. >Do you think that all non-urgent activities should/must be halted until the earth is improved? No, I'm not sure how that follows at all.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoI asked why not do both, and you responded that "One of those is actually an urgent need". If you arent arguing against doing them in parallel, what point are you trying to make. If you agree they can both be done in parallel, and dont think we should wait, what is your objection?
- 2y ago
- WalterBright 2y agoI did not suggest otherwise.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoI was responding to vacuity, not you. They hold the position that Mars activities should not take place until we fix earth, if ever.
- fsckboy 2y agohuman pollution kills millions a year? the only thing reducing the human population is decreased desire to have children by people who can afford them. Otherwise, more people are born, live longer, and die than ever before.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- vacuity 2y ago> Air pollution accounted for 8.1 million deaths globally in 2021 [0] > In 2019, air pollution caused about 6.7 million deaths. Of these, almost 85% are attributable to noncommunicable diseases (NCDs), including ischemic heart disease, stroke, lung cancer, asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), and diabetes. This makes air pollution the second leading cause of NCDs globally after tobacco. [1] [0] https://www.unicef.org/press-releases/air-pollution-accounted-81-million-deaths-globally-2021-becoming-second-leading-risk https://www.unicef.org/press-releases/air-pollution-accounte... [1] https://www.who.int/news/item/25-06-2024-what-are-health-consequences-of-air-pollution-on-populations https://www.who.int/news/item/25-06-2024-what-are-health-con...
- fsckboy 2y agomy point was that all of the activities that we humans engage in are the activities that create the pollution; but they are also the activities that extend our life expectancies. You can't separate them. Claiming that pollution is killing without point out the benefits of what is creating the pollution is lying. Industrialization created the world we all enjoy, the largest population of humans enjoying their lives at the same time as have ever lived. It is the essence of intellectual vacuuity to miss that.
- vacuity 2y ago> Industrialization created the world we all enjoy, the largest population of humans enjoying their lives at the same time as have ever lived. It is indeed true that we have unprecedented life quality among more people than ever. It is also very true that industrialization has played a gigantic part in that. However, from one line of history does not come them all. We do not know that this exact path of industrialization was or continues to be necessary. If, in an alternate history, there were less humans with very high quality of life for longer and then they discovered less polluting forms of industry to reach this point, were they worse off? Are you saying we are already minimizing pollution to the level necessary for progress, or quickly working on it? If you're trying to justify the current level of pollution with the current level of progress, you have a lot of explaining to do. Cutting down plastic bag usage alone would probably be high impact for reducing pollution/environmental harm and low impact on impeding progress.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> we, as humans who have privilege and comfort, deserve to continue and expand those qualities Cutting down forests for farms asserts a human privilege. Arguing for colonies on the Moon or Mars isn't asserting a human privilege, it's arguing for a biological one: the privilege the living should enjoy over the non-living.
- vacuity 2y agoAre you saying that farmland production is unnecessary (at least at its current rate) but spce colonies aren't? If your concern is that humans need the latter to live, shouldn't the former be justified too? Is the Earth too doomed for the former to work? I don't follow.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Are you saying that farmland production is unnecessary (at least at its current rate) but spce colonies aren't? When we cut down forests for farmland, we're saying our (human) need for that land supercedes the needs of the creatures living on it. That the needs of humans trump those of other living things. (While cute to debate, this isn't ever actually in doubt. Effective arguments for conservation, et cetera, come down to decidedly human systems of values and ethics.) When we build a colony on the Moon, we aren't taking land from Moon people. That tabula rasa makes the previous discussion about humans versus other living things moot. Instead, the practical trade-offs aren't about any inherent rights dead things have (they don't), but how it impacts life on Earth. In particular, for humans.
- vacuity 2y agoThat makes a lot of sense. I acknowledge there is an asymmetry that favors Moon development. I think "while cute to debate philosophically" is itself an amusing stance, given you presuppose that humans come first even metaethically, but not the main point. My main gripe is that, if you think the farmland/Moon settlement must be done for human survival, why is human-human wealth redistribution not on the table? (If you don't, your motivation is just shallow greed.)
- mulmen 2y agoColonizing the moon and improving life on Earth are not mutually exclusive pursuits. Both are possible and the space program has given us constant technological improvements to help improve life on Earth. We’re more likely to do both together than picking only one.
- goatlover 2y agoDoubt MLK Jr had much to say about Mars colonization. Why would he be opposed to it as long as Martian settlers were treating each other equally? I don't like the view that we shouldn't go to space as long as there are problems on Earth to fix. There are always problems to fix. It's an excuse to never explore space. There's no reason that going to Mars would prevent addressing pollution on Earth. I don't even see how they're related. If anything, trying to live on Mars would probably help us deal with climate change on Earth.
- vacuity 2y agoI invoked MLK Jr. in pointing to problems on Earth, including pollution, as an example of how we are not serving "humanity" in MLK Jr.'s spirit. I think your technology advancement argument is far-fetched, even though I acknowledge the historical basis. In part due to reasoning in another comment of mine: > I would be (grudgingly) fine with populating Mars if I felt that we as a race were remotely trying our best to improve Earth. By opening up Mars, incentives are wrong and we will probably become even more lax.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- freejazz 2y ago> I don't even see how they're related You can't see how terraforming Mars and solving Earth's climate crisis could be related? And you want us to consider your opinions at all?
- goatlover 2y agoI don't care, but I did say it might in my last sentence.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- WalterBright 2y agoI don't see where you inferred these questions from my statement.
- erik_seaberg 2y agoEscaping pollution is not a reason for going. Creating habitable areas on/under Mars is clearly harder than maintaining habitable areas on/under Earth. We have people who are much more motivated to do it and we might learn more from it, though.
- vacuity 2y agoGranted, I overstated the escaping pollution part. It seems like people are not alarmed enough about climate change and pollution to believe extinction[0] will happen anytime soon. That would mainly be the motivation for rich people, and not just pollution but many other issues they are not interested in solving. Frankly, the least selfish reason to go to Mars is to avoid extinction. Barring that, is it such a great thing for "humanity" to explore Mars for curiosity, commercial ventures, and leisure? Apparently many of the commenters here seem to extol things that can be great for "humanity" while lashing out at mentions of real issues not getting enough attention right now. I'll restate what I said: is it so important that we with privilege continue to have greater privilege? Or if you believe we can just fix these issues and get our space exploration too: do you really think that will happen with reasonable likelihood? The feel-good narrative of having our cake and eating it too is just too delectable. And to those of you saying I would shut down everything for one cause, you're blatantly wrong. I'm saying we should focus on this cause and look to the remainder for things like space exploration. What we have in reality is focusing on things like space exploration and hoping. We are misallocating resources. Yes, perhaps we will get magical technology from the money currently going into it, or from space exploration. I ask you if you think the likelihood is reasonable. If you're here to talk about mere possibilities, don't complain when others bring up feasibility. [0] Or just a lot of people dying, doesn't have to be nearly everyone.
- erik_seaberg 2y agoThe resources are 0.004% of the population of one wealthy country, who devoted themselves to shaping about 400 tons of stainless steel. Nothing constructive comes of starving a project that size, certainly not the global carbon sequestration I'd like to see.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> it's a dead rock. There is no environment to pollute I used to share this view until I read Kim Stanley Robinson's Red Mars. There is aesthetic value to preserving Mars in its pristine form, within reason, if only so future generations can enjoy it. That doesn't mean full space NIMBY, as this article suggets. But it does argue against being cavalier about an alien landscape simply because it's lifeless.
- fsckboy 2y agothat aesthetic value of preservation exists basically in every choice we make. Or maybe we can stop believing the ancient superstitions that consider us not to be part of nature.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> maybe we can stop believing the ancient superstitions that consider us not to be part of nature What part of any argument in this thread requires this? Also, being part of something doesn't mean you can't also be distinct from it, for the most part.
- fsckboy 2y agothe comment I replied to, and the comment he was replying to. Both are talking about the entropy humans hasten being somehow different from the entropy that is occuring without humans.
- itishappy 2y agoWould you consider NYC as a candidate for a new national park? > National parks are designated for their natural beauty, unique geological features, diverse ecosystems, and recreational opportunities, typically "because of some outstanding scenic feature or natural phenomena." Fits the bill, don't it?
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Would you consider NYC as a candidate for a new national park? Have you seen our zoning and construction codes? It might actually be simpler to erect a structure in a national park.
- skibz 2y agoI think a more charitable interpretation of the suggestion you're quoting would be the opposite: how some people love nature. As for Mars, suggesting that it is merely a "dead rock" with "no environment" grossly oversimplifies its geology. It's a seismically active planet with an atmosphere.
- WalterBright 2y agoA dead rock means no life. > It's a seismically active planet with an atmosphere. It's still a dead rock. There's nothing sacred about it.
- olddustytrail 2y agoYou have no idea whether Mars is a dead rock or not. Even if it now is, you have no idea whether it used to be alive or not. So no, we shouldn't just dump random crap on Mars based on your ignorance.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- WalterBright 2y ago> You have no idea whether Mars is a dead rock or not. Sure we do. It's a dead rock. All investigations have turned up nothing. > you have no idea whether it used to be alive or not. Scientists have given up on it being alive. They're reduced to looking for evidence of ancient life.
- freejazz 2y ago> desperately I don't think those floating rocks have any urgent needs at all.
- giraffe_lady 2y agoManifest destiny but with secular scientism this time.
- goatlover 2y agoOr we beat grabby aliens to the punch.
- giraffe_lady 2y agoYou can take care of the monster under my child's bed while you're at it.
- goatlover 2y agoOr you could recognize the possibility that space might be treated as territory to be developed by more advanced intelligences that we could run into someday. There is a paper as a solution to the Fermi Paradox and YT videos under the term "grabby aliens".
- giraffe_lady 2y agoI recognize the possibility I just don't accept it as a justification for a rerun of manifest destiny.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- itishappy 2y agoHumanity as the great filter. A dark version of The Culture. Solid sci-fi premise!
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago
- itishappy 2y agoI personally think it would be amazing to visit the stars, but I'm also disappointed that human development currently makes it hard to even see them. My children will be unable to view the Milky Way with their eyes like I have. Is it "hating humanity" to mourn this loss a little, to want to preserve something like it for future generations? It feels a bit like natural parks to me. Of course they contain resources! We can tear all the trees out and strip mine the land, but I'm glad we don't! They're pretty in ways the lit Coca-Cola billboard that replaces them can't imitate. I'm honestly a bit depressed to hear this preservation framed as "self-hatred" and "loathing." Also, we should be super freakin' sure that these rocks are actually devoid of life before we start moving all our stuff in (and the recent asteroid sample contamination shows we move in hard and fast). I don't think we're anywhere near as certain about this as you imply, and it would suck to burry the evidence for abiogenesis before we understand it. > There is no environment to pollute. The moon has an environment. "We towed it outside the environment" was a joke!
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Is it "hating humanity" to mourn this loss a little, to want to preserve something like it for future generations? It strikes me as naively presumptuous more than hateful. We don't have the capability, today, to ruin a celestial body by any reasonable defintion of those terms. Maybe we figure out what we can do and what's over there before we loop in the space NIMBYs. > it would suck to burry the evidence for abiogenesis before we understand it What threshold of sureness would you propose for what amount of activity? Even massive (1mm+) colonisation wouldn't ruin evidence planet-wide.
- itishappy 2y ago> We don't have the capability, today, to ruin a celestial body by any reasonable definition of those terms. I don't think we all agree here. The author seems to think that lights would be inappropriate, and Native American tribes have claimed that burials and even human waste desecrates the moon. I'm of a somewhat different mind, I think seeing lights would be neat, but I can't justify blasting the eye off the man-in-the-moon to make it easier to roll the lunar megatrucks in easier. > What threshold of sureness would you propose for what amount of activity? Great question. I see this as an argument for cautious incremental progress rather than immediate resource extraction. I'd actually agree that a small human settlement focused on samples and surveys is a logical next step here. We're just so much more efficient than single-purpose robots. I would just urge caution.
- jfactorial 2y agoI don't hate humanity but I'm firmly on the side that says the lit side of the moon should be left untouched from here on out. The night sky belongs to all of Earth's inhabitants. None of us has any right to decorate the moon anymore than a technocrat with the means could claim the right to make all the oceans glow. If we do allow building on the lit lunar surface though, props to the first telescope company to build a sign that says "You'd be able to read this better with a Celestron."
- WalterBright 2y ago> I'm firmly on the side that says the lit side of the moon should be left untouched from here on out I'm firmly opposed to your proposal. Having lit cities on the moon does not impinge in any way life on earth. Are you also firmly opposed to airplanes?
- jfactorial 2y agoI'm opposed to airplanes flying in the airspace of a country whose people have outlawed them for whatever reason. Do you propose any one group can have the right to put whatever they want into the sky of every human on Earth? > does not impinge in any way life on earth A good portion of the life on Earth looks up at the Moon, often with magnification. Treating it like a nature preserve would be a gift to all posterity and they would praise us for it. Treating it like another resource to harveest will ultimately mean covering it in colonies and forever changing the face of an astral body that has remained virtually untouched for all of our species' history. Presuming to utilize it for industry or colonization is so short sighted a view I can't believe anyone harbors the thought.