8 ms·
Fish have a brain microbiome – could humans have one too?
- myfurends 2y ago[dead]
- nwatson 2y ago[flagged]
- cbsmith 2y agoShort answer: yes. https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2024/dec/01/the-brain-microbiome-could-understanding-it-help-prevent-dementia https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2024/dec/01/the-bra...
- ch4s3 2y agoLet's not jump to conclusions. That guardian article is about a pre-print study that used frozen brain samples from a single tissue bank, and RNA sequencing was done on a single machine. There's a lot of controversy around this[1], because contamination is possible and it's known that the blood brain barrier weakens with age. The sample are all from older individuals. [1] https://www.news-medical.net/health/Is-there-a-brain-microbiome.aspx https://www.news-medical.net/health/Is-there-a-brain-microbi...
- cbsmith 2y agoContamination is possible, but it's hard to explain the results that way. Definitely needs replication, of course. I don't see the point of the samples all being from older individuals. Even if it exclusively occurs in older individuals (unlikely), it would still mean that the blood-brain barrier is not 100% effective (which we already know to be true).
- outworlder 2y agoThat doesn't seem to be that clear cut. Evidence is scarce and the article is talking about brains with active illnesses. It could be that there isn't any microbiome normally but if the safety mechanisms fail and bacteria colonize the brain, that would cause the illnesses described.
- cbsmith 2y ago> Evidence is scarce and the article is talking about brains with active illnesses. They compared them to control brains, which also had microbes. > It could be that there isn't any microbiome normally but if the safety mechanisms fail and bacteria colonize the brain, that would cause the illnesses described. That would describe a scenario where the blood-brain barrier isn't 100% effective, no? If it's not 100% effective (which we know to be true), it is also seems unlikely that 100% of the things that cross the blood-brain barrier cause something that we currently consider a disease. Heck, in healthy individuals, latent taxoplasmosis' effects are often so minimial I don't think we'd call it a disease (otherwise 30%+ of the world has the disease).
- Aloisius 2y agoFrom the article: > When microbes have been found in the human brain, they are associated with active infections or typically linked to a breakdown in the barrier due to diseases such as Alzheimer’s. I think the question is whether there is a brain microbiome in healthy people, which seems to still be an open question.
- cbsmith 2y agoI mean, we know about all kinds of microbes that can be in the brains of "unhealthy" people, and we've known that for ages (taxoplasmosis and CJD come to mind). The association in the article isn't a case of "we didn't find it in healthy people", but "we found it in more in unhealthy people". From the article: "It found that, while there was a remarkable diversity of species in the control brains, there were often overgrowths of certain bugs in Alzheimer’s brains."
- CatWChainsaw 2y agoBiology and binary do not play nice.
- cbsmith 2y agoIndeed.
- _tom_ 2y agoWow. If true, that would be fascinating. We know that non-brain microbiomes can influence behavior. What might something in brain tissue itself do?
- debacle 2y agoInfluence behavior.
- londons_explore 2y agoPretty sure all parts of our bodies are riddled with viruses and fungi, and maybe bacteria too if we look hard enough. They'll just be in low concentrations so they're hard to detect.
- devops99 2y ago[flagged]
- XorNot 2y agoThat rather speaks against it being a microbiome - it could just be incidental contamination the body is in the process of cleaning up. To be a microbiome I would expect to a diverse, well-adapted quorum of species that find some type of symbioses. Absent that evidence, well biology is probability - something is always happening somewhere just by chance and statistics, but it doesn't make it a feature.
- biofunsf 2y agoAren’t viruses much harder to detect than bacteria? Viruses are generally smaller and are completely inert without a host cell. Bacteria, besides be larger, also have their own metabolic processes and distinct structures you can do things like grow them in a laboratory culture until the colony is much obvious. Your comment makes it sound like bacteria are harder to detect but if we’re already identifying viruses, locating bacteria seems easier. (Though some viruses are bigger than the smallest bacteria, like Mycoplasma at 200nm, viruses are generally smaller)
- londons_explore 2y agoBoth are hard to detect if there are only hundreds of them amongst trillions of human cells. At that point, 'just look with a good microscope' becomes infeasible, and you end up needing biological tricks like DNA amplification.
- eleveriven 2y agoAnd it makes me wonder how much we’re still missing or overlooking in the microbial landscape of our own bodies.
- devops99 2y agoSome do and it has a huge impact on human behavior. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toxoplasmosis
- velcrovan 2y agoIn case it helps others: to find out what the above comment’s “huge impact on human behavior” is supposed to refer to, you’ll need to dig into references/footnotes #23, #25, #27, #28 and #29 on the linked Wikipedia entry.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- lolinder 2y ago> Matthew Olm (opens a new tab), a physiologist who studies the human microbiome at the University of Colorado, Boulder and was not involved with the study, is “inherently skeptical” of the idea that populations of microbes could live in the brain, he said. But he found the new research convincing. “This is concrete evidence that brain microbiomes do exist in vertebrates,” he said. “And so the idea that humans have a brain microbiome is not outlandish.” It's interesting to me that it would ever have been considered outlandish. In light of everything we now know about microbiomes and microbiology in general, it seems to me as a layman that the more radical proposition would be that the blood-brain barrier would be 100% effective at keeping out all bacteria, rather than the proposition that it probably isn't but that the bacteria it does let in tend to be symbiotic.
- dr_dshiv 2y agoSo, what does that say about the possibility of fungal symbiotes?
- outworlder 2y ago> it seems to me as a layman that the more radical proposition would be that the blood-brain barrier would be 100% effective at keeping out all bacteria, Bacteria is not usually found in most organs in the body though. Even more so in an organ as important as the brain that even our own immune system doesn't have access. The brain has its own cells to do that job. In order for bacteria to cross the blood brain barrier you need bacteria in the blood first, where they aren't normally found without getting under fire. Having bacteria in the gut is more obvious and makes more sense.
- eleveriven 2y agoBut bacteria are incredibly adaptable
- lolinder 2y agoThe lungs, mammary glands, uterus, ovaries, vagina, placenta, semen, eyes, skin, and nasal cavity all have their own documented microbiome so far, and we've been finding out about new microbiomes about once a year. They are not a thing that is reserved for the digestive tract.
- j6m8 2y agoA few years ago my team mounted what I think was the largest-(to-date) scale search for this in electron microscopy brain tissue volumes [1]. I STRONGLY believe there is a substantial central nervous system microbiome, but (spoiler alert) no evidence found in that search :) If you're excited about this work, the datasets are all freely available from BossDB [2] — well over a dozen petavoxels of it! I'd be so curious if models these days could pick up on something we missed! [1]: https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2022.07.12.499807v1 https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2022.07.12.499807v1 [2]: https://bossdb.org https://bossdb.org
- outworlder 2y agoSince I don't have enough information on the topic... how would one distinguish a microbiome that was present while the organism was alive, from contamination after death?
- j6m8 2y agoThat's a question more suited to a microbiologist or bacteriologist than to me, but my educated guess, at least in the electron microscopy case, is that you'll see the bacteria inside the depth of the slices, rather than sitting "atop" the slices. i.e., if you cut open an apple and find half a worm, the worm was in the apple. If you cut open an apple and then see a worm on top of the slice, it's possible it arrived post-cut.
- lovich 2y ago> I STRONGLY believe there is a substantial central nervous system microbiome, but (spoiler alert) no evidence found in that search :) What gave you reason to believe this if you found no evidence of it in your own search?
- attemptone 2y agoThis might be too nitpicky, but isn't believe exactly what one has in absence of evidence?
- vasan 2y agoGut microbes affect brain too
- andai 2y agoI recall reading about this 1 or 2 years ago! But I don't remember details. Has there perhaps been tentative evidence?
- b800h 2y agoIf this were to be the case in humans, I wonder what effect antibiotics would be having on behaviour.
- AlfredBarnes 2y agoHow much of the thinking/feeling would be due to this microbiome? Is this how people develop mental illnesses? Such an interesting topic! I hope it gets the funding it needs!
- PartiallyTyped 2y agoand conversely whether probiotics for the brain might exist.
- singlow 2y agoCountdown until the nutrition influencers start pushing them.
- sethammons 2y agoI was very surprised that just last year, 2023, we discovered a whole ass thin membrane covering the brain we didn't know was there. The thin membrane discovered, again, just last year, is called the Subarachnoid Lymphatic-like Membrane (SLYM), and apparently acts as a protective barrier separating "clean" and "dirty" cerebrospinal fluid among potentially other things. We don't know a lot.
- hirenj 2y agoOn this topic, you might be interested in this article and the related discussion regarding novel anatomy. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41517059 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41517059
- eleveriven 2y agoJust how much we still don’t know about the brain and its protective systems... It’s crazy to think that a major part of the brain’s anatomy was essentially hiding in plain sight for all these years.
- AvAn12 2y agoAren’t there some kinds of amoeba that can cross the BBB and take up residence in the brain? And fungal infections? (Or am I just thinking of horror movie plots?)
- lamename 2y agoThe one I know of is terrifying and usually lethal. It gets in through the nose/cribriform plate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naegleria_fowleri https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naegleria_fowleri
- mr_toad 2y agoIt’s rare, but viruses, bacteria, fungi, amoeba, worms and other parasites can get into the brain and cause meningitis. Amoeba can get in via the nose from contaminated water. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naegleriasis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naegleriasis You really don’t want that happening because they’ll literally eat your brain.
- codethief 2y agoTwo months ago we had almost the same topic here on HN and I posted a question that no one seemed to be able to answer: > I mentioned Adam Savage's "Scariest [Podcast] Episode Yet" in a different context the other day[0] in which I remember Joe DeRisi[1] saying something along the lines of brain & spinal fluid being "absolutely pristine" when it comes to the presence/absence of a microbiome (in healthy individuals) and that it'd be real problem if there were one. > I'm just a layman but can anyone ELI5 how this can be squared with the OP, specifically with statements like > > It turns out our grey matter is teeming with bacteria, viruses and fungi Can anyone explain this? [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41765112 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41765112
- mmmrtl 2y agoProbably the vast majority of studies are correct and a few misinterpret artefacts, and then a journalist uses an evocative word like "teeming" without knowing that what they're saying doesn't pass the sniff test. Same reason these papers languish for years and don't pass peer review in rigorous journals
- nborwankar 2y agoNot sure if this article provides enough definitive info - happened to see it yesterday. https://www.newscientist.com/article/mg26335104-500-the-brain-has-its-own-microbiome-heres-what-it-means-for-your-health/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/mg26335104-500-the-brai...
- Esmeralda46 2y ago[dead]
- Esmeralda46 2y ago[dead]
- dukeofdoom 2y agoMost people will read this headline as a question. I read it like a proposition for bio weapon lab research. Post covid. Parasites can live there. I think, Toxoplasma gondii and malaria and a brain eating ameba exists. If you planted a bean in the brain of a beagle, it would grow too. Though I hope we don't ever do that.
- jexe 2y agoIf this were also true for humans, what would the implications be?
- unnouinceput 2y agothat a bacteria decided to "lemme make this dude ask a question on HN". On a serious note, it's already answered in the article - it means that our behavior is not only influenced by the gut bacteria (already proven), but the brain ones too.
- jexe 2y agoWell finally I have a new excuse to ask dumb questions here... But what I mean is, what are the downstream consequences of this knowledge? Does it change how we can reason about health, cognition, etc?
- unnouinceput 2y agounknown. they barely suspect this, to your question is another leap in science for future generations of researchers
- Vaslo 2y agoWhat would this say about taking antibiotics? Would the blood-brain barrier keep them out?
- unnouinceput 2y agono. they are molecules, and they are let in by the barrier.
- biofunsf 2y agoIt depends. Some antibiotics pass the BBB easier than others. Some are used especially when passage through the BBB is desired.
- aaron695 2y ago[dead]
- piombisallow 2y agoThe whole microbiome thing is way overblown. It's like studying a great city by looking at rats in the sewer. And yeah, maybe some people have rats in their houses too. That's doesn't really tell you much about the city.
- amit9gupta 2y agoThere has been some research on this, establishing the presence of microbiome in the brain: https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2023.02.06.527297v1 https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2023.02.06.527297v1
- mmmrtl 2y agoWhy hasn't it passed peer review yet? Maybe because they only used techniques prone to artefacts. IMO if a brain microbiome exists in healthy people it would have been seen already, with all the microscopy and sequencing done
- eleveriven 2y agoSooo our brain might not be sterile (frighteningly). And we might see a shift in how we approach even mental health in the future.
- pvaldes 2y ago> Is possible that the bacteria were swallowed by the white cells Then this would hardly count as brain "microbiome". Do wolves have a macrobiome of deer inside wolves guts?.
- skirge 2y agoleft-handed and right-handed bacteria determining political beliefs
- Pigalowda 2y agoI’m skeptical but there’s plenty of intracellular bacterial pathogens. Perhaps there’s an intracellular commensal bacteria/symbiote. I think if it was extracellular we would see it more often in CSF - which is collected quite a bit in healthcare. Regular histology/pathology slices and staining would detect as well. I could imagine an intracellular commensal bacteria that is small and virtually indistinguishable from an organelle like a mitochondria or lysosome that may exist. Mitochondria were already bacteria at one point. Could there be another endosymbiont? Mitochondria have circular DNA and phage like polymerase. Perhaps our secret symbiont can be found through DNA studies. Examples of intracellular bacterial pathogens include: Brucella abortus Listeria spp. Chlamydia spp. Rickettsia spp. Ehrlichia spp. Anaplasma spp. Coxiella spp. Mycobacterium tuberculosis Salmonella spp.
- m0ose 2y agoDr Salinas is awesome. She did an interview on "The Children's Hours" about lung fish that was so interesting. Her fish research is leading to a ton of human immunology understanding.