4 ms·
I'm glad to see this word getting wider exposure. I hope people will expand it's use to describe all kinds of content beyond the narrow/extreme aesthetic it ref
by xnx 2y ago
I'm glad to see this word getting wider exposure. I hope people will expand it's use to describe all kinds of content beyond the narrow/extreme aesthetic it refers to in short form video. Once you start looking, you recognize brainrot content everywhere: daytime TV, talk radio, reality TV, cable news, Facebook AI slop, etc.
- xyst 2y agoOn the topic of brain rot, content creators with longer form videos often include a video playing in the background which has no relevancy to the narrated content. The video itself isn’t necessarily brain rot content but rather a side effect of a majority of people’s short attention spans. In some cases, the content can include relevant video content but split viewed with something irrelevant (ie, random subway surfers gameplay). It’s quite annoying and distracting for me.
- cwillu 2y agoA lot of those are actually spam accounts that repost popular content with an extra video in order to still have enough apparent originality to get paid.
- kiba 2y agoI don't see this in my youtube feed.
- Gigachad 2y agoIt’s done on YouTube shorts a lot. Usually the audio is someone talking, and the video is Minecraft parkour or similar.
- xnx 2y agoYes. I think the extra/unrelated content may also have roots in trying to defeat copyright content detection.
- Uehreka 2y agoThere was an AI news/analysis channel that I had to unfollow because of this. The guy did a good job distilling down the news, but half of the length of each video would be random AI-adjacent videos (like footage of someone testing a drone or a self driving car) that had nothing to do with what he was talking about, and I found it difficult to focus when I couldn’t be sure if the stuff on screen was supposed to be relevant or not (he’d often cut to charts or samples of a video output). Lately in slop-land I’ve also seen shorts where the creator will take an old boomer joke (one of those “and then the student stumped the teacher” kind of stories) and have an AI voice read it while the video is cuts from “satisfying animations”-genre videos.
- Cthulhu_ 2y agoThe split view subway surfers thing is definitely brainrot content, it's often retelling a story from Reddit or Twitter but since a voice reading something out isn't stimulating enough (nor is reading it) they add visual distraction. A lot of non-brainrot content still has something in it though, jump cuts so you getSentences that kindaSound like this butWritten out toGet more words inLess time, camera changes, background music, graphics, etc.
- Spivak 2y agoCan't forget video games, video game streamers, variety podcasters, pornography, sports tv and sports commentary, edutainment, documentaries, cartoons, comics, fanfic, romance novels, action movies, Vince Flynn books, political masterbation such as Last Week Tonight and Sean Hannity, news farms like NYT and WSJ, or smoking weed. You chose a cross-section of content that that is universally derided by the average HN user; if you're not willing to use the front facing camera you're just taking potshots at your outgroup.
- teractiveodular 2y agoDon't forget link aggregator sites run by venture capitalists to advertise their investments.
- Spivak 2y agoOf course, how could I be so forgetful?! Probably the brainrot of being on here so long.
- anon-3988 2y agoYou lump a lot of things into this bucket. I am curious what you consider as not a brainrot?
- Spivak 2y agoI mean I came up with the list by going through the kinds of mindless passive entertainment that has little to no to negative intellectual or artistic value that either I or my coworkers (who are mostly Dads hence Vince Flynn) enjoy that I think intersects with HN types. It's easy to call out the kinds of low-value activities that you don't personally enjoy or partake in. It's a lot harder and more uncomfortable to see them in yourself and have some empathy and not judge others too much for their brain-off vices. Only when I die and see the big stats board do I want to know how many hours I've wasted on Slay the Spire. And while I love it dearly I can't really delude myself that it's anything other than Candy Crush for nerds.
- carimura 2y agoit ends up being a zero-sum game for depleting attention spans....
- cedws 2y agoPolitical brainrot is arguably the most sinister because it trains people to abandon logic and base all of their beliefs on feelings. And there is a huge incentive for companies to inject this into discourse to polarise and swing people one way or another.
- tourmalinetaco 2y agoI‘ve been using brainrot to describe content since about 2016, but apparently its been used as early as 2003 online to describe shows like The Bachelor. Brainrot is everywhere, even among what one may consider “high culture”. The play Hamilton is a prime example of this. Theater is regularly considered high culture, however due to a combination of poor historical accuracy, oversimplification of the events involved, and, in my opinion, very commercialized sounding music, leads to what is very effectively “high culture brainrot”.
- t-writescode 2y agoDo you have a similar opinion of Jesus Christ Superstar? Or the Technicolor Dreamcast? And if not, what makes them different?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- tourmalinetaco 2y agoI am not familiar with either, so this was hardly the “gotcha” you may have expected. If you have disagreements with what I posted I urge you to actually focus on said post rather than whataboutism.
- t-writescode 2y agoYou seem angry that a play is historically inaccurate. I am curious if it's because there's something special about the American Revolution to you that perfect historical accuracy in a musical is required. Seems like a strange thing to find sufficiently frustrating as to call it "brain rot"
- tourmalinetaco 2y agoHistorical inaccuracy was simply one of a handful of points I made, and I am hardly “angry” that a brainrot musical, written by a man with no historical background, was inaccurate. Additionally, I am willing to suspend my desire for accuracy for certain plot-related reasons, for instance there is no historical backing behind Angelica’s infatuation with Hamilton, but plotwise it created a compelling, albeit poorly expanded upon, narrative. The definition of brainrot is, in my mind, something that you cannot learn from and may even teach you misinformation. Hamilton’s lack of historical backing and poor narrative lead to a situation where it fails to teach you history or have an in-depth story worthy of inaccuracies. They essentially took the setting of late 18th century Boston, put a slew of modern-thinking historically-named figures in it, and wrote a simple story using those caricatures. Add in very inconsistent “hip pop” music, leaning into simpler choruses that paint in large strokes, and it’s no wonder that it achieved mass appeal. That’s simply how brainrot works. Less cognitive processing required means that its easier to digest and share. It’s also why “low culture” contains fart humor and why “high culture” contains books such as Don Quixote.
- Cthulhu_ 2y agoI've watched American TV a few times, over ten years ago now, it was definitely brainrot-like in that there was a lot of repetition, visuals, and smooth / uninterrupted transitions to frequent ads. I don't believe tiktok was the one that introduced it, it started decades before. Pre-TV people would get a stack of newspapers and only skim the headlines.