3 ms·
I've seen a few articles on the Yotta/Synapse situation that focus on the people that have lost money while completely ignoring any of the prize-linked type of
by dylan604 2y ago
I've seen a few articles on the Yotta/Synapse situation that focus on the people that have lost money while completely ignoring any of the prize-linked type of setup. The people are quoted as being told it was FDIC insured, it was a normal bank, etc. Then the articles describing the prize drawings started to surface.
Was the prize-linked stuff part of the fine text or are people twisting the story as an attempt to lessen their shame? I don't trust any of the fintech apps at all, but I've never looked at any of their sites to see how blatant or how hidden their "oh yeah, we're not a real bank" details are.
- financetechbro 2y agoThe prize aspect of Yotta is irrelevant to the issue of missing funds. Theoretically this could happen with any fintech
- dylan604 2y agoIt's not exactly irrelevant, as it does signal someone gamifying finance which just raises all sorts of red flags for me. At that point, I'd be much more suspicious of anything else they said. This isn't a free toaster. This is someone playing with money in a way that is just suspect. After all of that to then find out that the company isn't a bank yet claims FDIC insured while using a 3rd party to handle to the money because they aren't actually licensed for that while still claiming to be a bank? It's so bewildering I'm typing run on sentences
- kiba 2y agoIt's literally just interest rate disguised as prizes. A real bank is handling the money behind the scene and that's where the money is insured.
- dylan604 2y agoSeriously? If it was insured, we wouldn't be in this place of customers losing all of their money. So whoever claimed they were insured lied.
- bot403 2y agoThe money is insured by the FDIC against bank failure. The actual banks holding the money didn't fail. The money is still there. The problem is its in a big unlabeled pile so they don't know whose money is whose and how much each person has. Note that fail here has a very specific meaning - as in the banks doesn't have the funds to give you your deposit back. Not fail as is "something went horribly wrong".
- dylan604 2y agoYour fine parsing of the words does nothing at all about getting the customers access to their money.
- jowea 2y agoI only superficially paid attention to this news but didn't Yotta end up going from "bank with sweepstakes" to "bank with a casino" quite quickly?
- wat10000 2y agoThe prize stuff was front and center, the whole point of it. It functioned mostly like the interest from a savings account, but with a small chance of doing much better. The effective interest rate was quite good even without winning big. It was quite clear that Yotta was not itself a bank. It was also quite clear that it used real banks to store your funds and your funds were as safe as they would be in a normal account. That last part just turned out to be a lie. What “shame” would there be to lessen here?
- snypher 2y agoThe shame is the consumer putting savings into a space bank lottery scheme instead of t-bills or whatever. If Yotta passed the sniff test of being a real bank, people are less likely to shame the people who lost their savings.
- wat10000 2y agoYotta claimed to be functionally equivalent to having a normal interest-bearing account with an excellent interest rate, and using a small portion of the interest to buy some lottery tickets. Buying lottery tickets might be dumb, perhaps even shameful (although I disagree as long as it’s not to excess), but it by no means implies that you deserve to lose your savings.
- kgwgk 2y agoFor what it's worth, some countries also offer "lottery bonds": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lottery_bond https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lottery_bond
- multjoy 2y agoIn the UK, those are Premium Bonds backed by HM Government. The day that they can't be redeemed is the day you have significantly bigger problems.
- 2y ago
- foxglacier 2y agoPrizes as interest aren't uncommon or scammy in themselves. My bank used to have a savings account like that https://www.westpac.co.nz/accounts-cards/savings-accounts/save-and-win/ https://www.westpac.co.nz/accounts-cards/savings-accounts/sa... . I inherited a UK government bond from my dad that had cost 1 pound many decades ago and would go into an annual prize draw. Turned out it never won a prize and the bank/government sent a cheque for 1 pound.
- rsynnott 2y agoThe prize-based thing is quite common in some countries, for instance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Premium_Bonds https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Premium_Bonds (in countries which don't tax gambling winnings, it's a tax dodge; if you have a choice between a bank account that pays 4% taxable interest or a prize bond scheme which in the long term pays an average of 3.5% in untax-able winnings, you might take the prize bonds.) I'm not sure that it should necessarily be seen, in _itself_, as a major red flag.