2 ms·
US senators propose law to require bare minimum security standards
- ETH_start 2y agoThis violates the freedom to contract (I should be free to use a hospital that doesn't have these security features) and is totally outside of the federal government's constitutionally enumerated powers.
- sokoloff 2y agoI am also frustrated by the dramatic increase in scope of the federal government versus the Enumerated Powers in the Constitution, but even given that background, I think this very likely falls within the power to regulate interstate commerce.
- ETH_start 2y agoThe interstate commerce clause was essentially a requirement on states to allow free trade across their borders with other states. "Regulate" had a different meaning in 18th century English than it does today.
- sokoloff 2y agoAfter Gonzales v Raich*, I don't think the interstate commerce clause has any practical limits. * - https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/545/1/ https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/545/1/
- dcrazy 2y agoConsumer protection is a well established power of the federal government. “Freedom to contract” is a kooky libertarian theory not grounded in reality.
- ETH_start 2y agoThe federal government suppressing contract liberty in the name of consumer safety has no constitutional basis. It's only established because the constitution has been routinely ignored since the FDR administration undermined SCOTUS's independence in the 1930s. And freedom to contract is a critical component of freedom of association. If you think living in a free society with your contract liberty intact is "kooky", you reject the foundation of a free society.
- andrewmcwatters 2y agoThe usage of specific NIST guidelines should probably be federal law based on industry.
- jandrewrogers 2y agoThe NIST guidelines are among the most competent from a government source that exist in my opinion. A practical issue is that even if we legislated those guidelines, many other national governments demand compliance with their own published guidelines which often directly contradict NIST. This creates challenges for companies that operate in multiple countries. I’ve seen the situation multiple times where “security requirements” that span borders were mutually exclusive yet are mandated on both sides of the border. It is impossible to comply yet compliance is expected. Fortunately, the audits are purely superficial; you do your best to comply with whichever bureaucracy is fussiest and no one looks too closely. This is a suboptimal outcome on many levels. Trying to harmonize these contradictory requirements through an international treaty organization like ISO would produce something so watered down as to be pointless theater. I would generally endorse the NIST guidelines as a standard. Unfortunately, many other countries reject that standard and require you to comply with some other guidelines to do business in their country. This is a problem.
- nunez 2y agoThey already are for any federal software that you use and are all but required by many regulating bodies in the private sector.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]