4 ms·
Absolutely: if copyright is slowing down innovation, we should abolish copyright. Not just turn a blind eye when it's the right people doing it. They don't eve
by immibis 2y ago
Absolutely: if copyright is slowing down innovation, we should abolish copyright.
Not just turn a blind eye when it's the right people doing it. They don't even have a legal exemption passed by Congress - they're just straight-up breaking the law and getting away with it. Which is how America works, I suppose.
- blackqueeriroh 2y ago> Absolutely: if copyright is slowing down innovation, we should abolish copyright. Is this sarcasm?
- immibis 2y agoNo. If something slows down innovation and suffocates the economy, why would you (an economically minded politician) keep it?
- noitpmeder 2y agoBecause the world shouldn't be run primarily by economically minded politicians?? I'm sure China gets competitive advantages from their use of indentured and slave-like labor forces, and mass reeducation programs in camps. Should the US allow these things to happen? What about if a private business starts? But remember, they're just trying to compete with China on a fair playing field, so everything is permitted right?
- redwall_hp 2y agoYou might want to look at the constitutional amendment enshrining slave labor "as a punishment for a crime," and the world's largest prison population. Much of your food supply has links to prison labor. https://apnews.com/article/prison-to-plate-inmate-labor-investigation-c6f0eb4747963283316e494eadf08c4e https://apnews.com/article/prison-to-plate-inmate-labor-inve... But don't worry, it's not considered "slave labor" because there's a nominal wage of a few pennies involved and it's not technically "forced." You just might be tortured with solitary confinement if you don't do it. We need to point fewer fingers and clean up the problems here.
- JoshTriplett 2y agoExactly. They rushed to violate copyright on a massive scale quickly, and now are making the argument that it shouldn't apply to them and they couldn't possibly operate in compliance with it. As long as humans don't get to ignore copyright, AI shouldn't either.
- Filligree 2y agoHumans do get to ignore copyright, when they do the same thing OpenAI has been doing.
- slyall 2y agoExactly. Should I be paying a proportion of my salary to all the copyright holders of the books, song, TV shows and movies I consumed during my life? If a Hollywood writer says she "learnt a lot about writing by watching the Simpsons" will Fox have an additional claim on her earnings?
- dijksterhuis 2y ago> Should I be paying a proportion of my salary to all the copyright holders of the books, song, TV shows and movies I consumed during my life? you already are. a proportion of what you pay for books, music, tv shows, movies goes to rights holders already. any subscription to spotify/apple music/netflix/hbo; any book/LP/CD/DVD/VHS; any purchased digital download … a portion of that sales is paid back to rights holders. so… i’m not entirely sure what your comment is trying to argue for. are you arguing that you should get paid a rebate for your salary that’s already been spent on copyright payments to rights holders? > If a Hollywood writer says she "learnt a lot about writing by watching the Simpsons" will Fox have an additional claim on her earnings? no. that’s not how copyright functions. the actual episodes of the simpsons are the copyrighted work. broadcasting/allowing purchases of those episode incurs the copyright as it involves COPYING the material itself. COPYright is about the rights of the rights holder when their work is COPIED, where a “work” is the material which the copyright applies to. merely mentioning the existence of a tv show involves zero copying of a registered work. being inspired by another TV show to go off and write your own tv show involves zero copying of the work. a hollywood writer rebroadcasting a simpsons during a TV interview would be a different matter. same with the hollywood writer just taking scenes from a simpsons episode and putting it into their film. that’s COPYing the material. —- when it comes to open AI, obviously this is a legal gray area until courts start ruling. but the accusations are that OpenAi COPIED the intercept’s works by downloading them. openAi transferred the work to openAi servers. they made a copy. and now openAi are profiting from that copy of the work that they took, without any permission or remuneration for the rights holder of the copyrighted work. essentially, openAI did what you’re claiming is the status quo for you… but it’s not the status quo for you. so yeah, your comment confuses me. hopefully you’re being sarcastic and it’s just gone completely over my head.
- tpmoney 2y ago> they're just straight-up breaking the law and getting away with it. So far this has not been determined and there's plenty of reasonable arguments that they are not breaking copyright law.