6 ms·
The Birthday Paradox Experiment (2018)
- chrismorgan 2y ago(2018)
- bsimpson 2y agoIt's interesting how uniform the birthday distribution at the end looks. I'd expect more seasonality (e.g. more babies conceived in the cold, dark months).
- kibibu 2y agoWeird how, coincidentally, 3x as many people are born on Nov 15 as any other day
- boomboomsubban 2y agoNope, Jan 1st has about the same amount. So the lazy liars and those wondering what the dialogue says if they share a birthday with the prompt.
- senectus1 2y agois that US Nov 15th? Cause I was born in Australia on Nov 14th :-D
- sevg 2y agoWouldn't that be US Nov 13th?
- unsnap_biceps 2y agoI wonder if modern living has pretty much made this a non-factor. We have things to entertain ourselves regardless of the duration of light outside and so we're no longer left sitting at home in front of the fire bored, we're sitting at home in front of the fire playing with our phones. Less likely to bow-chicka-bow-wow out of boredom.
- kqr 2y agoRemember that the seasons are inverted on the other side of the equator. (Granted, the population splits something like 90/10 but still.)
- ropejumper 2y agoThere are relatively few people living south enough to have "cold and dark winters," anyway. The northern hemisphere is much more concentrated towards the north. Most people live above 35°S where, at the most extreme, winter days are about 10 hours and a half long (plus about an hour of decent twilight). Temperatures obviously vary depending on region but they don't really get much below 10°C as far as I know. So really, it's more like mostly bright and somewhat chilly.
- bambax 2y agoYes, it's also extremely unlikely. The actual distribution in developed countries is not uniform: there is a spike at the end of September (because many more people make babies at or around New Year's Eve) and a considerable drop on Dec. 25th (because people will avoid that date and provoque the birth some days before in case it might happen). Also, on the site there is a huge spike on Nov. 15 which, incidentally, is the birthday of the author: maybe they tested it many times?
- profsummergig 2y agoWhy do people not like having their child be born on Xmas?
- mrandish 2y agoIt's that some small percentage of births are intentionally induced for various medical reasons. Sometimes because the baby is full term but labor is not starting on its own yet. Other times an OB will attempt to rotate a full term baby that's in breach position to avoid needing a C-section surgery. Successful or not, this rotation procedure has a chance of triggering labor (which is why they wait until the baby is at or close to full term before trying it). Bottom line: hospitals are short staffed on Xmas so they set scheduled procedures which may induce labor for the day before or the day after whenever possible which preserves their limited capacity on Xmas for unscheduled births and emergencies.
- KineticLensman 2y agoMy sister’s birthday is a few days after Christmas. She hated this as a child because once her birthday was over there was almost a whole year without any prezzies
- Miraltar 2y ago15th november are valentine's babies, I'm not surprised about this spike
- boomboomsubban 2y ago
- phito 2y agoI really like the fact that it's using the previous user birthdays. Unfortunately today is my birthday and I think a lot of people are entering today's date as their birthday, I got 6 matches... :)
- notduncansmith 2y agoHappy birthday :)
- zeristor 2y agoNothing unfortunate about having a birthday today. Happy Birthday!
- block_dagger 2y agoHappy birthday to you and me, fellow Scorpio.
- jll29 2y agoPlenty of November birthdays because it's cold in Februrary (11 - 9 = 2).
- rukuu001 2y agoI have FOUR significant people in my life with November 15th birthday, so I just groaned when I saw the author’s birthday. And happy birthday phito :)
- phito 2y agoThanks for all your birthday wishes <3
- zero0529 2y agoIncredible site that also is very mobile friendly!
- jmclnx 2y agoThat would not be a surprise to me :) Most people access they WEB via the phone, I would expect it is up to 80% browse on their phone.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- nuancebydefault 2y agoI'm a bit confused. Maybe i did not pay enough attention but... Does it stop the first simulation when there are _any_ 2 people with a same birthday, or when someone has _my_ birthday? I think the latter will take more people on average.
- dvt 2y agoThe website is being purposefully obtuse and the birthday paradox is a "paradox" because it's sometimes formulated in the same way as the website. In other words, you are completely correct that the intersection of any two birthdays is significantly more likely than the intersection of a particular birthday.
- unklefolk 2y agoThe Birthday Paradox is about a group of people sharing at least one birthday between them. If it was at least 1 person out of 23 people sharing YOUR birthday then the odds would be 1 - (364/365)^23 which is around 0.06 (or 6% chance). So, yes, this scenario is a lot less likely.
- nuancebydefault 2y agoThanks for that. I believe the fact that it asks for a birthday puts people's brain in a mode where the awe at the end is bigger. Related, having flat tires on a car seems to come in little bursts,like 10 years none and then 2 in a year.
- Cthulhu_ 2y agoCan confirm, but both times it was a screw or something in my tire so I presume someone dropped some at a point of my commute.
- jyounker 2y agoI'd expect flats on cars to be correlated. People tend to buy tires in sets, so age related factors affect them all. Similarly they tend to get driven on the same roads, so are subjected to similar environmental damage. Also, people are good at noticing patterns that don't exist, so that's a possibility too.
- zeristor 2y agoI was going to try it again with February 29th
- teew 2y agoI tried it and it just gives the same continuation that talks of a shared birthday.
- revskill 2y agoScripted.
- tosser0001 2y agoAn analog of the birthday paradox that gets me all the time is what I think of as The Locker Room Paradox. This is where when I go into the locker room after working out and the guy who comes in behind me ends in the locker right next to mine. So there’s two of us in a big empty room awkwardly jostling away.
- DiscourseFan 2y ago>awkwardly jostling away I imagine it’d be more fun in a group setting?
- quietbritishjim 2y ago(Apologies for the fun-ruining comment.) For it to be a true analogue if the birthday paradox, it would have to happen rarely to you individually, but surprisingly often to one pair of people in the locker room when there are a smallish number in there.
- xydone 2y agoAssuming you don't have an automated system to give away locker keys, wouldn't this be explained by the fact that gym front desk is more likely to give out the lowest number available and as you took X, they will give out X+1 for the next person?
- dustincoates 2y agoI've never been to a gym where you're assigned a locker for the day (or given a key). Either you have one permanently assigned (rare) or you go in and find one that isn't occupied.
- xydone 2y agoOhh, I see! At my gym, locker keys are given to you by the front desk and you put in something as deposit (such as your gym card or whatever you wish) and on your way out you give the key and you get your deposit back.
- tmountain 2y agoI had a hard time believing the birthday paradox when I first heard about it years ago, so I modeled it with Clojure/Incanter and the results were spot on. Really interesting and fun paradox.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- k__ 2y agoAren't there birthdays that are more likely than others?
- tromp 2y agoThere is one birthday that is far less likely than others, courtesy of leap years. All other are roughly similar, with small seasonal variation.
- nicoco 2y agoAnd no moon cycle related variations, despite a popular (false) belief. It always amazes me that the superstition is spread even among (some, of course not all) midwifes!
- badcppdev 2y agoI was going to say that I was disappointed that the page didn't show the formula for the probability and show how it changes as you change the number of people in the room. Then I checked the wiki page and understood that some of the maths is actually quite fiendish (for non mathematicians anyway) - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Birthday_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Birthday_problem
- emmelaich 2y agoAlso https://matt.might.net/articles/counting-hash-collisions/ https://matt.might.net/articles/counting-hash-collisions/
- lukol 2y agoWhile the math is clear, I'm a bit annoyed by the label "paradox" as the whole setup is too simplistic and reductionistic. The actual chance of being in the same room with someone who shares your birthday needs to include other factors like your socioeconomic background, the cultural environment you are in, your present location, and certain historical facts. Without having done the math, I'm fairly certain that a member of the baby boomer generation in New York has a higher chance of meeting their birthday sibling than a 12-year-old in a rural part of Australia.
- wodenokoto 2y agoWait, what? Are you saying that income influences what time of the year you are born? The paradox doesn’t talk about meeting your birthday sibling, but meeting two people who are birthday siblings. So by the time the 12 year old has met ~20 people, there is a 50/50 chance that amongst those 20, there’s a birthday pair.
- lukol 2y ago> So by the time the 12 year old has met ~20 people, there is a 50/50 chance that amongst those 20, there’s a birthday pair. If you randomly choose the ~20 people from the global population then yes, this will be the case (especially after a number of rounds). And yes, I'm aware this is also the definition of the paradox. But if you choose the people from your vicinity (i.e the people you are actually likely to meet), the chances will vary based on your individual parameters (which defines the number and quality of the sample size).
- tomtom1337 2y agoCould you explain more what you mean? Other than certain holidays perhaps causing a higher chance of alone time for future mom and dad, I don’t see what you mean, and I don’t understand your last paragraph.
- seritools 2y ago> While the math is clear, I'm a bit annoyed by the label "paradox" as the whole setup is too simplistic and reductionistic. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox#Veridical_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox#Veridical_paradox (also https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ppX7Qjbe6BM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ppX7Qjbe6BM for a 40min video discussing the weird usages of the word "paradox")
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Balgair 2y agoOkay, that was about as clear as mud to me. Maybe I just need more coffee, but nothing about it led me to understand why there is a 50% chance with 23 people. Can someone else explain this? The odds that someone else shares just your birthday out of 23 people sounds crazy still. It should be 182.5 to get to 50%, right?