5 ms·
An ad giant wants to control your next TV's OS
- willio58 2y agoThis is already extremely common. For example, my TV uses some sort of Roku-branded OS. They literally have ads on the home screen when you first turn on the TV. It's something I've struggled to work around, and eventually gave up. I just kind of avert my eyes until my Apple TV kicks in. I feel like this should be illegal. It's kind of like billboards on the side of the road, it's something I never want to say but it's forced upon me. I bought your product, why is it allowed that you can just throw ads on it? I understand they sometimes sell these TVs at a slight loss to make up for that, but I feel like they should be required to sell the same TV without Ads for the same 3% margin added on. I bet most people would pay for the latter if it was provided.
- dartos 2y agoJust buy a TV without ads. Free market at work. /s
- tencentshill 2y agoYou can for an excessive price. Most commercial outdoor-rated panels are just simple HDMI or network inputs.
- KerrAvon 2y agoNonsense. Buy an LG TV of any kind. Never connect it to the internet. Plug in an Apple TV (or Linux HTPC box of your choice). Ad-free TV at consumer prices. edit: not just OLED
- lstodd 2y agoWhy even buy a TV? Buy a screen and a projector.
- adamredwoods 2y agoTVs are more compact for smaller rooms, brighter in sunlight.
- lancesells 2y agoApple TV kind of has ads in the form of their streaming service. Not egregious yet, but it gets worse with every iteration.
- lotsofpulp 2y agoIf you move the tv+ app down from the top row, you should never see it.
- lancesells 2y agoUnfortunately I've purchased movies from iTunes over the last ~15 years.
- lotsofpulp 2y agoPretty sure all new TVs have HDMI CEC, so you can just buy any TV, connect it to a $100 to $150 Apple TV/Nvidia shield/google thing or whatever and have no ads (from tv manufacturer).
- somerandomqaguy 2y agoNope, at least last I saw around 2021, Samsung and LG were moving their commercial displays to include Tizen and WebOS as well. I don't know about the other supliers though.
- CamperBob2 2y agoI bought your product, why is it allowed that you can just throw ads on it? I think you've answered your own question here.
- scarface_74 2y agoYou can change the settings to switch directly to the HDMI port connected to your AppleTV. The AppleTV remote will also turn your TV on and off automatically
- add-sub-mul-div 2y agoRoku is the worst thing to happen to television since motion smoothing.
- pier25 2y agoThe solution is to not connect the TV to the internet. This not only removes ads but also content capturing and tracking.
- smitelli 2y agoThe solution for now. I fully expect future TVs to ship with cellular modems that connect to any carrier willing to jump into bed with the manufacturer.
- uneoneuno 2y agoOr they will have agreements to jump through passing phone networks or via the ISP's "CoxWiFi" network that they resell as a backhaul
- pier25 2y agoCould be but seems like it would be expensive. IIRC the content scanners send 1 image per second.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 2y agoSurely they just send an image hash.
- pier25 2y agowould that work with different resolutions etc?
- 0cf8612b2e1e 2y agoOn device or in the cloud, the advertisers need some method to match images. Might as well fully exploit your advertisees and have the client device calculate the hashes. As to the actual matching strategy, I would guess a perceptual hash that is robust to some amount of noise and varying resolutions. Since you are comparing repeated hashes, say at 1Hz, you have multiple chances over the observation window to match a fingerprint to the lookup database. 30 minute show x 60 frames per minute = 1800 hashes to make the id
- wannacboatmovie 2y agoWhat a coincidence, an ad giant (Google) controls my current TV's OS and I had to accept a EULA to use it.
- barkerja 2y agoIf you didn't accept the EULA, does it render the entire TV inoperable? Or just the "smart" features?
- wannacboatmovie 2y agoNot my TV and this is Roku but I imagine they all have similar language: "If you do not agree to this EULA, you do not have the right to use the Television or the Software" https://www.tcl.com/us/en/roku-tv/eula https://www.tcl.com/us/en/roku-tv/eula
- mysterydip 2y agoIt should be required to have the EULA on the box before purchase, like the nutrition label for food.
- observationist 2y agoEULAs like this should be illegal. Comparable to "Warranty void if this sticker is damaged" type scenarios. The enormous "gotcha" games being played under the guise of "if it's not illegal, we're going to exploit it" are grotesque. TVs are just one of hundreds of examples of products and services being used to invade and exploit privacy with no commensurate return on value for what's being exploited. We need a law constraining this shit to 100% opt-in voluntary features with no dark patterns, with penalties for anything that even vaguely looks like a dark pattern. Fines and jail time time for c-suite for any violations, enough that they'll stop playing the stupid games.
- andremedeiros 2y ago
- dartos 2y agoCan my TV not have a whole OS? I’m just going to use the hdmi ports.
- daemin 2y agoMaybe it's time people started hacking the TVs and getting custom OSes running on them. Though I suspect that the processors inside TVs don't have publicly available datasheets, and the actual boards get changed pretty often, so it will be a lot of work for little payoff. One thing to look at though is to see if your TV has a signage or commercial mode, and switch to using that instead.
- ramon156 2y agoWould be nice to have a "minimal OS" that just does what u want. Select a hdmi port, change volume, yada ya.
- mxuribe 2y agoOne would think that this would represent an opportunity in the market to, you know, sell TVs that only do their basic function, and not try to tack on ads and such, right? Or, is it that not enough people care about this stuff...so the masses simply put up with it, and move about their lives...and Tv makers (and other device manufacturerers) go with the flow of taking as much advantage as possible?
- wannacboatmovie 2y agoOur idiocracy would decry that as some sort of antiquated Luddite device and it wouldn't sell in enough volume to make a profit.
- Spivak 2y agoThat's not why, it's because the most important factor for people is price and tv with ads can sell for cheaper than the one without. I would never dream of touching a streaming service with ads but I'm clearly in the minority since I'm the only one paying the premium for ad free.
- wannacboatmovie 2y agoAre you saying TV prices dropped sharply once they started including the adware? It sounds more like the adware is selling at the same price point normal TVs were in years past, and the ad-free were relegated to a higher priced tier that didn't previously exist.
- Spivak 2y agoIf you're talking nominal prices then I think we're agreeing. The ads made it possible to sustain the current price in the face of inflation.
- acdha 2y agoThe problem is that ads and tracking data represent recurring revenue for the manufacturers, and they know full well that many people are going to Walmart or Best Buy and picking the cheapest one. That changes the decision considerably: not many people feel strongly enough about this to pay more, and even people who do care about privacy or find ads annoying usually aren’t willing to pay much more for it. An Apple TV is the clear market leader on streaming devices but even there you see people talking like it’s exorbitant to pay an extra $50 for something which will last twice as long as a FireTV or Google TV, and for TVs it’s even less favorable because the people who care enough to buy our hypothetical safe TV are going to need one of those anyway so they’re probably going to pick the cheaper (advertiser subsidized) one and never connect it to the internet.
- vincent-manis 2y agoI have a smart TV running Roku. I still use cable (for news), so the other 2 sources I see are the 2 computers I have connected. The only time I ever see Roku is when I'm selecting a source. The TV is smart, but I'm smarter: no Ethernet cable.
- davesmylie 2y agoI haven't seen any ads on my HiSense TV (low end/budget brand), though I have been concerned about updates eventually bringing me this feature. The TV is pretty much exclusively used as a 85" monitor for a media PC so I think the risk is low, but this was the final prompt to finally block internet access for the TV at the router. I didn't want to completely block it from the network as it's useful being able to hook into it from Home Assistant
- geor9e 2y agoI will never use a TV's OS for more than the first 5 minutes it takes to turn on HDMI CEC as default. That lets the device on the other end turn it on and off, change the volume, etc. I recently had Best Buy deliver a 75 inch, only cost me $350, probably because the little garbage computer inside is loaded with ads. I'll never know.
- adamredwoods 2y agoI was wondering about current work-arounds. I was also thinking hacker-sponsored OS overrides for various TVs are coming (similar to rootMyTv).
- netsharc 2y agoI had an old LG TV, I played around with MITMing it by telling my DNServer to return my NAS's IP for *.lg.com, etc servers, and I was recording the HTTP requests it was making (this was last decade and I guess lack of HTTPS wasn't shameful yet). I got rid of this TV, but never fixed the DNS settings, and it seems my new LG TV has never been able to phone home to show me the EULA to accept.. in return I do get a more limited experience, but I can switch inputs just fine. So TL;DR: it's probably possible to configure Pi-Hole (or dnsmasq) to block the ads/phone-home behavior of the TV.
- amatecha 2y agoI think their eventual hack to circumvent this kind of stuff is leveraging stuff like "Amazon Sidewalk" where everyone is unwittingly providing free internet for the IoT-enabled things they buy >_>
- netsharc 2y agoThis "They're going to have built-in wireless modems!" trope is old, boring, and hasn't happened yet.
- 2y ago
- m0llusk 2y agocustomers do not want this, thus this is a business opportunity
- layer8 2y agoThat’s unfortunately not how the market works in practice.
- from-nibly 2y agoThe customers aren't the consumers, thus this is a business opportunity.
- hiisukun 2y agoI recently bought a TV (HiSense) after a very quick bit of research about the dimensions and the fact that it had GoogleTV as the OS. Unfortunately for me, the operating system for many TVs is region specific! Once the product appeared on Hisense's Australian page it did mention having VIDAA instead of GoogleTV, but this was after I had purchased it. I can confirm that VIDAA is quite bad, demanding agreement to several fairly ad-driven user agreements before you can use any smart features. "Enhanced Viewership Program" or something, which in the text says that VIDAA will monitor what you are watching on the screen, then use that information to display relevant ads. Yuck. Fortunately it does switch to HDMI when you turn it on, but I've got to decide what system I get to drive that HDMI port. I wanted not to have to bother with an additional device, but that's how it is I guess. As a bonus comment, VIDAA's kid-mode- content includes a very large number of purported TV programs - but they are actually Youtube playthroughs of video games, cut into "episodes" and presented as a "season".
- JohnFen 2y agoAt least we're warned and so can make sure to avoid anything using this stuff.