5 ms·
14-Year-Old Casper Wind Farm Has Not Turned a Blade in at Least 3 Years
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- xenadu02 2y agotl;dr: Chevron owns the turbines. They originally signed an agreement with PacifiCorp to buy the power generated. When the agreement was up Chevron decided not to renew it and instead pursue registering as a generator to sell the power directly to buyers on the Western Interconnect. As a result they have nowhere to send the power right now for the same reason you can't install a 50MWh generator on your property, toss some wires up, and start pumping electricity into the grid - even if you wanted to do it for free. This is a great example of garbage journalism. The story reports "the facts" but completely fails to put anything in context. The story completely misses this point and acts like the government is at fault for approving the permit to install the turbines and that the nay-sayers and NIMBYs were correct because it turns out wind turbines are just a boondoggle after all. The actual story is Chevron made incompetent business decisions by failing to sign up as a generator earlier and failing to temporarily renew their PacifiCorp power purchase agreement, thus forcing them to idle an expensive asset while they fix their mistake.
- gwbas1c 2y ago> The actual story is... Is that connecting renewables to the grid is time consuming, and shouldn't be. A few years ago, I determined that they payoff of grid-scale batteries is extremely fast, BUT, connecting to the grid is so frustrating that I decided I didn't want to peruse the opportunity. I don't know if I'd use the word "incompetent."
- margalabargala 2y agoI would expect a company whose business is building and operating power plants, to be more adept at navigating the red tape surrounding the grid that they operate than you are.
- scblock 2y agoNo, they have an interconnection agreement. They're already connected to the grid.
- scblock 2y agoChevron did everything wrong on this wind farm even before they built it. This is not a wind issue, this is not a government issue, and this is not a PacifiCorp issue. This is Chevron being garbage, which should surprise no one.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y ago> Chevron did everything wrong on this wind farm even before they built it. This is not a wind issue, this is not a government issue, and this is not a PacifiCorp issue. What do you mean by all this? Anything specific? The parent comment seems to imply they just haven’t built interconnect yet
- chiffre01 2y agoThis is Cowboy State Daily, one of the few news sources from Wyoming.They publish a lot of stories with a significant amount of bad faith, particularly concerning energy and environmental issues. wyofile.com is a better source for energy and environmental reporting.
- LinuxBender 2y agoThankyou. I will use more articles from that site from now on.
- happosai 2y agoWind power is not their core business, so they don't even seem to be trying. Someone decided that doing some wind power would be good publicity, and then did a token effort with this farm. Someone's friend who needed a job but couldn't be trusted to run anything serious in Chevron was then hired to run wind business with predictable results.
- Denzel 2y agoDo you have any book recommendations to help understand the electrical grid and why you can’t just start pumping electricity into it? I find these type of systems fascinating.
- jasonjayr 2y agoFundamentally, Grid operators have to realtime-match demand + generation, and have a bunch of grid-scale devices along the way to sink excess generation temporarily, or have (expensive) peaker plants to ramp up generation temporarily. For example, natural gas can respond quicker to demands, but nuclear power plants typically cannot. Typically nuclear plants will feed into the average 'base load' and the more responsive plants will handle temporary peaks. In order to financially make this work, there are a whole litany of agreements + commitments in place, as well as some "free market magic". (Remember a few years ago when spot prices for electricity spiked into obscene territory?) Renewables provide unique challenges for these operations, as you cannot simply turn sun and wind off and on. Similarly, you can't just pump uncontrolled electricity into the grid w/o the operator's coordination.
- Denzel 2y agoHuh, thanks for that explanation, I didn't consider what happens when a grid generates excess energy that has nowhere to go. Makes sense that bad things would happen once you've exceeded your storage capacity, hence the real-time matching.
- jasonjayr 2y agoYou may have already seen it, but this timely story from Grady/Practical Engineering also goes into these details: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42183747 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42183747
- salynchnew 2y ago"Don't trust an oil company to disrupt their own business model with renewables" seems to be the lesson here.
- anon291 2y agoWhy? They're all energy companies, not oil companies. Companies pivot all the time. As long as there's profit to be made, they'll even engage in both.
- giwook 2y agoExcept probably 99% of their profits come from oil. 99% of their infrastructure is setup for oil which has been honed and put into place over decades. Can you imagine the cost of revamping all of that? And then they have to explain to their shareholders why their profits are a fraction of what they normally are, otherwise their stock price will sink which will affect the company in myriad ways. There's so much to this space that I'm ignorant of, but I know enough to know that it's really not that simple.
- anon291 2y agoThey don't need to revamp. They have access to billions in revenue that can be put in to setting themselves up as key players in yet another industry. Many of them are doing just that. Eventually, they all probably want to dominate the battery / grid renewables industry as well. Why wouldn't they? They are uniquely positioned to do so.
- burnte 2y agoLogically, yes, but it doesn't always happen. Ballmer forgot MS was a software company, thought it was only a Windows company, and wasted a decade. Oil execs look at the cost of change, and decide they're not energy companies, only oil because that's what they know.
- JamesBarney 2y agohttps://danluu.com/ballmer/ https://danluu.com/ballmer/ For the argument Ballmer didn't waste a decade but setup MS up for the success it's seeing today.
- PreInternet01 2y ago[flagged]
- schmichael 2y agoThe government, local, state, or federal, should have the opportunity to nationalize unused infrastructure like this. Give Chevron an opportunity to tear it down or turn it on, but otherwise pay a market rate just like with eminent domain and let the turbines spin. I'm guessing this was just some greenwashing by Chevron to avoid being forced to actually cleanup their nuclear waste.
- impossiblefork 2y agoMaybe one could even say that this is a kind of blight and a reason to use eminent domain, so that it could be done without any changes in law.
- altairprime 2y agoNote that Texas has a long history of taking a “hands off” approach to energy companies abusing the public commons: https://www.texastribune.org/2024/02/28/abandoned-oil-wells-west-texas-railroad-commission/ https://www.texastribune.org/2024/02/28/abandoned-oil-wells-... The people that complain about water table corruption and the people that complain about view corruption are in the same boat: the governments of Texas don’t care. Perhaps they’ll vote in a government more interested in regulation someday, but until then — or, at least, until four years from now — Texas voters are the sole group able to take action to change that approach. 40% didn’t vote this month, so there’s lots of opportunity there!
- wbl 2y agoThe same government that is prohibiting construction of the transmission lines to move that power to where it would be used?
- jtmarl1n 2y agoI have a little experience on this aspect. There are tons of local governments who weigh in on the location of these lines and that can be a contentious process to get buy-in from them.
- oldnetguy 2y ago
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- neom 2y agoPretty unrelated outside of it's about wind turbines, but couple days ago I watched this and it was super fascinating + fun, recommend it as somethingto put on in the background - Why Toronto has that one, weird wind turbine https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tn-w_zohw6Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tn-w_zohw6Y (~16 minutes)
- greasegum 2y agoPart of the subtext seems to be that constructing these turbines was a greenwashing campaign on Chevron's part. This kind of project helps to bolster the naive impression that these are "energy companies", as one commenter alluded, not just "oil companies". So in a sense these turbines have fulfilled their purpose. Even more insidiously, the fact that the wind farm is now sitting idle achieves oil companies' secondary goal of making green energy look bad and unreliable. Thus keeping people divided on whether to support other green power initiatives and allowing our reliance on oil to continue. Profits protected. I don't think I'm giving them too much credit.
- briandear 2y agoNuclear energy is green and it’s very reliable. The problem is that people seem to think wind is a good idea, when it’s really a highly visible form of greenwashing.
- olddustytrail 2y agoHow's the nuclear power production in Spain?
- SECProto 2y agoFrom a quick Google, seems fine? Other than Public perception messing with the market
- olddustytrail 2y agoSeems fine? I actually wanted some level of detail from someone living in Spain. But thank you for your valuable contribution.
- SECProto 2y agoSorry, it felt like some kind of a leading "gotcha" question. Why are you wondering about nuclear power in Spain, specifically? And why only from someone living there? Both seem entirely out of context with the discussion thread, which didn't mention Spain before your comment. If you want details from someone who can do a quick Google search, instead, I offer: It seems like there was a politically led moratorium for several decades, then allowed but regulated into impracticality. Meanwhile the reactors they built have operated well for about 40 years and provide a large portion of the country's annual electrical generation.
- VincentEvans 2y ago“Now, some say they are an eyesore that has idled for at least three years.” Yeah, on that headline picture - it’s the turbines that are the “eyesore”, sure. Somebody’s agenda is showing.
- 0xbadcafebee 2y ago“Partial non-operation occurred because there are transmission constraints and firm transmission service in not available to transmit power generated at Casper Wind Farm.” You don't need to know anything else. There's no transmission capacity and nobody wants to pay for it.
- mcphage 2y ago> There's no transmission capacity What is "transmission capacity"?
- alwa 2y agoInfrastructure to physically carry the energy away from the power station, aggregate it with other stations’ energy, and transmit it safely to the customers who can use it. To tie in a major new source of energy, you need to make sure the wires and stuff can handle it, which involves physical construction and planning at a level above an individual operator. The US regulator estimates that 2,500GW of clean energy projects, like this one, are already built and stuck in the backlog of interconnection requests. [0] https://www.energy.gov/eere/wind/articles/transmission-interconnection-roadmap-offers-plan-clear-queues-clean-energy https://www.energy.gov/eere/wind/articles/transmission-inter...
- mcphage 2y agoSo you're saying that they built a power plant, but didn't build enough infrastructure to transmit the power from that plant to the main power grid? That does seem to fit in with the idea that this was merely a greenwashing project, and not an actual effort.
- itishappy 2y agoI'd love to know why an "energy company" was unable to surmount these hurdles.
- 0xbadcafebee 2y ago