6 ms·
January 1928: Dirac equation unifies quantum mechanics and special relativity
- hdivider 2y agoIf our society were sane, rational, advanced, the headlines would be all about scientific and technological progress. The fusion power breakthrough of 2022 by Lawrence Livermore National Lab would still dominate the news. Large corporations would compete to create the first Star Trek replicator (at least for organic matter, food, etc) by advancements in nanofabrication. Politicians would debate R&D topics and strategy, figuring out which path leads to greater broad-sector economic progress. One can dream. :) Instead, we have a society almost entirely dependent on many kinds of technology, and yet very few understand any of it, nor care to. Wonder how long this trend can persist until some sort of phase transition appears on the horizon.
- readthenotes1 2y agoSome many years ago some people collected some negative traits to describe the foibles of people. Unfortunately, these negatives seem to dominate much of the news: Pride, Greed, Lust, Anger, Gluttony, Envy, Sloth. If we could somehow dim the influence of these human traits, we might get closer to the world you described
- heresie-dabord 2y ago> Pride, Greed, Lust, Anger, Gluttony, Envy, Sloth The greatest popular innovation of our time appears to be to have extended the above list with Falsehood, Cruelty, and Pollution.
- terminalbraid 2y agoI assure you falsehood, cruelty, and pollution have existed long before our time.
- Jensson 2y agoFalsehood Cruelty and Pollution are results of the 7 sins. Cruelty is typically caused by Anger or Envy, Pollution from Gluttony and Sloth, Falsehood from Pride and Envy etc.
- ggu7hgfk8j 2y agoWe aren't spherical philosophers in a vacuum. We are emotional animals trying our best. This fact requires constant consideration and management lest it all come crumbling down.
- antonvs 2y ago> The fusion power breakthrough of 2022 by Lawrence Livermore National Lab would still dominate the news. If our society were sane, rational, advanced, it would recognize that that "breakthrough" was a minor, arbitrary improvement in reaction efficiency, that realistically brings us no closer to commercially viable fusion power, and doesn't prove anything about the possibility of that. That reaction still consumed something like 100 times the power that it produced, and the "power" that it produced was just heat energy, which would still entail losses when converted into usable form. On top of that, the nature of the Livermore reaction is not one that's even intended or suitable for commercial power production. At this point, we simply don't even know whether controlled, commercially viable fusion will ever be able to produce more power than it consumes. There's no guarantee that it will. If you're not aware of what I'm referring to, this article is a starting point: "Why the nuclear fusion ‘net energy gain’ is more hype than breakthrough": https://whyy.org/segments/why-the-nuclear-fusion-net-energy-gain-is-more-hype-than-breakthrough/ https://whyy.org/segments/why-the-nuclear-fusion-net-energy-... While this might all seem like an irrelevant aside to the point being made above, it's relevant because it shows how pervasive misinformation is, even when coming from supposedly scientific sources.
- elashri 2y agoThe announcement was correct and precise. I am not sure what misinformation you are describing here. Regarding your 100 more energy claim. It overlooks key facts about the NIF breakthrough. The fusion reaction itself achieved net energy gain, producing 3.15 MJ compared to 2.05 MJ of input laser energy - far from consuming "100 times the power it produced." While the total facility power usage was indeed higher due to laser inefficiencies, this misses the crucial scientific achievement. This was basically humanity's first controlled fusion reaction producing more energy than was directly input to the fuel. Dismissing this as a "minor, arbitrary improvement" understates its significance. This wasn't just about efficiency metrics - it demonstrated fusion ignition was possible, a fundamental physics milestone that had eluded scientists for decades. Though challenges remain for commercial fusion power, the breakthrough proved a critical theoretical concept that many thought impossible. Many critics before that were referring to this point as the reason why it isn't worth it to keep researching. And they were proved wrong. Trying to redefine the announcement and experiment result to mean something else so that you can attack is a dishonest behavior.
- mikhailfranco 2y agoThe LLNL fusion result was not a breakthrough. The fusion output was about 1% of the energy input. The exaggerated press release was just a PR ploy to get support for continued DoE funding, which was expiring at the end of 2022.
- orwin 2y agoAnd while we talk about fusion, even when the energy output surpass the energy input and the reaction is stable enough, how to you harness the energy? Because the reaction happen within a vacuum, the only way is to capture expelled neutrons and make electricity from it somehow.
- mikhailfranco 2y agoYes, they forgot that part, so there will be further energy losses (at least 70%). They also have to up the repetition rate from once a week to at least 1k /s. Note that ASML lithography machines accurately dilate and irradiate molten tin droplets with lasers at ~ 50k /s. https://www.asml.com/en/technology/lithography-principles/light-and-lasers https://www.asml.com/en/technology/lithography-principles/li...
- jojobas 2y agoNIF is first and foremost a thermonuclear weapons research facility. The "breakthrough" you're talking about doesn't bring us an inch closer to fusion power.
- 8bitsrule 2y agoI think that a 'breakthrough' would be to realize that harnessing fusion outside of a solar environment is a hopeless dream that, carefully fed, is very good at provoking research grants.
- bckr 2y agoDon’t worry, we can create a priesthood caste with secret knowledge of technology whose purpose is to guide the human race toward a brighter tomorrow! Maybe someone could write a foundational science fiction novel about this.
- _s_a_m_ 2y agoNo they would not. Not all and probably most progresses are not technological. Are you living under a rock?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- exe34 2y agowhat are you talking about? the most important thing is to make sure senators use the correct bathroom!
- teleforce 2y ago> Yet the technique employed to make the theory useful — renormalization — repulsed Dirac because he found it mathematically ugly. Perhaps if he had used quaternion the solution will not be mathematically ugly or can even be beautiful [1]. [1] A quaternion formulation of the Dirac equation: https://mauritssilvis.nl/research/publications/silvis-rug10.pdf https://mauritssilvis.nl/research/publications/silvis-rug10....
- elashri 2y agoDirac was not working in vaccum . Klein-Jordan equation was the simplest and the most obvious extension of Schrodinger equation in relativistic manner. So historically, Dirac was focused on correcting the Klein-Gordon equation, which had issues with negative probabilities and describing electron behavior. His goal was to find a relativistic equation that resolved these problems while maintaining consistency with his own matrix mechanics formulation of quantum mechanics. By extending his matrix mechanics formalism, Dirac derived an equation that not only addressed the issues with the Klein-Gordon equation but also predicted the existence of antimatter. I would argue that Dirac's approach was consistent with his established framework, and while he found renormalization mathematically unsatisfactory, it does not diminish the validity of his method in deriving the Dirac equation. I doubt he focused on any elegant solutions, he was actually quite happy working with matrix mechanics framework.
- jesuslop 2y agoBohr was a big shot, Nobel prized establishment authority. In Weimberg QFT book he recalls a fragment of Dirac's memoirs: "I remember once when I was in Copenhagen, that Bohr asked me what I was working on and I told him I was trying to get a satisfactory relativistic theory of the electron, and Bohr said 'But Klein and Gordon have already done that!' That answer first rather disturbed me. Bohr seemed quite satisfied by Klein's solution, but I was not because of the negative probabilities that it led to. I just kept on with it, worrying about getting a theory which would have only positive probabilities."
- phkahler 2y ago
- JPLeRouzic 2y ago> Quaternions I know nothing of physics, but it seems to me that rotation fingerprints are everywhere in physics. Is this just me or is there something more tangible in this remark?
- Ono-Sendai 2y agoIt's not just you. Dirac fields are constantly rotating. In fact the solutions are called spinors. (e.g. things that spin). There are a lot of rotations at the quantum level. It's also why complex numbers show up a lot in q.m.
- ValentinA23 2y agoI've been trying to get an intuitive understanding of why multiplying by e^ix leads to a rotation in the complex plane, without going into Taylor series (too algebraic, not enough geometric). I tried to find a way to calculate the value of e in a rotational setting, maybe there is a way to reinterpret compound interests as compound rotation. Any insight ?
- dboreham 2y agoIANAM but I'd go with "it's implicit in how complex numbers are defined". Complex numbers are a thing made up by humans (as are negative numbers), and we got to define i as "up the y-axis". Once you do that, and note that a rotation is therefore cos angle plus i sin angle, add in that e^something is an eigenfuncion of differentiation, and you're pretty much there. Fwiw I think it's Maclaurin series for this. Edit: obviously should be j not i.
- empiricus 2y agoOne possibility: take the unit circle, and a vertical line tangent to the circle at (1,0). Then e^ix takes that line and wraps it around the circle. This
- ColinHayhurst 2y agoComplex numbers and (Pauli/Dirac) matrices not required if you use Geometric Algebra. I highly recommend the book by Doran and Lasenby [0], or you can get the details from their papers, notably [1]. [0] Geometric Algebra for Physicists, CUP, 2003 [1] https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/0509178 https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/0509178
- gsf_emergency 2y agoLooking for possible citations for >... renormalization — repulsed Dirac because he found it mathematically ugly. I found https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/375209/dirac-once-said-that-renormalization-is-just-a-stop-gap-procedure-and-there-had https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/375209/dirac-onc... (2019) for the "Cosmic Galois group" (edited) as well as Anixx's comments/Neumaier's responses
- peter_d_sherman 2y ago>"Months later, Schrödinger — inspired by Louis de Broglie’s idea that matter behaves like a wave — proposed an entirely different, but mathematically equivalent, formulation of particle behavior based on the better-known mathematics of waves." [...] More surprising results unfurled when Dirac extended his equation to describe an electron interacting with an electromagnetic field. Experimentalists had confirmed that the electron’s intrinsic angular momentum, or spin, was equal to 1/2, but theoreticians couldn’t figure out how to properly incorporate it into their theories. With his new equation, Dirac had found, almost as an afterthought, that the spin emerged naturally. [...] The Dirac equation was simple and elegant, yet dense with implications. Perhaps its most profound feature was that, instead of producing two components for negative and positive spin states, it produced four: a negative and positive spin state for each of two particles with positive and negative energy states." Related: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chirality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chirality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Angular_momentum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Angular_momentum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noether%27s_theorem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noether%27s_theorem
- magicalhippo 2y agoFor those enjoying the history of early quantum mechanics, I've been following Dr. Jorge S. Diaz on YouTube[1]. He has a great video series going on the people, experiments and discoveries that lead to quantum mechanics. The videos are very accessible, but he does go into some details like various key derivations and such. Well worth watching for casual physics fans IMHO. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/@jkzero/ https://www.youtube.com/@jkzero/
- CamperBob2 2y agoDiaz is awesome. For me, he manages to strike just the right balance between making the topic interesting in a historical/human-interest sense and including enough technical detail to cultivate actual insight. Both his Franck-Hertz and Stern-Gerlach videos are the best I've run across on YouTube (and I see the latter has a part 2 now, so that'll be next on my watchlist.) Hugely underrated YouTuber.
- itishappy 2y agoI also just love his energy. He's unapologetically excited about the stuff that excites him, and even if I don't share all his interest, it makes his videos an absolute joy to watch.
- penguin_booze 2y agoThank you. Just in time for the weekend!
- NoOn3 2y agoI very like this playlist https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xLfFWXUNJ_I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xLfFWXUNJ_I It's good introduction in quantum mechanics with minimum posible math. It's on Russian but as I see It has English subtitles.