7 ms·
Exploring the Cost and Feasibility of Battery-Electric Ships
- tonymet 2y agoFerry service in the Puget Sound (Seattle Area) has suffered due to delays with electric ferries. The state refuses to maintain their existing fleet. Every line has frequent delays, and the international route which was suspended for “a couple years” in 2021 is now delayed until 2030. The frustration people have with electric isn’t the technology – it’s the dogmatic commitment to technology that isn’t quite ready, based on false promises of it solving climate change .
- dboreham 2y agoI've traveled on a battery electric ship in Norway, quite a few years ago. It recharged while docked loading passengers using two high voltage high current cables slung from a crane.
- euroderf 2y agoThis sounds like a great way to keep consumer e-vehicles from hogging charger spots.
- seatownferryman 2y ago[dead]
- hwillis 2y agoIt looks like that is a conversion and retrofit of ships that were already unmaintainable: https://washingtonstatestandard.com/briefs/conversion-of-washington-ferry-to-hybrid-electric-power-is-delayed/ https://washingtonstatestandard.com/briefs/conversion-of-was... Modernizing all the control systems etc is the nightmare. The ferries were already electric- all ferries are; they have diesel engines driving generators which drive electric motors. They still have the exact same generators running the same motors. The batteries are installed and ready even though they won't be used until the port is electrified years from now: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hkgT9Z8Z2RU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hkgT9Z8Z2RU
- tonymet 2y agoSure but you have to think of the entire system which includes staff, training , charging infrastructure, power supply, possibly fuel for the charging infrastructure, backup/redundancy, maintenance, parts / distribution etc. An entire infrastructure network that had been operating for decades. Diesel is more than just fuel, it’s an entire system.
- itake 2y agoI also heard the power companies just don't have the extra power to supply the ferries. The terminals need to be redesigned to receive and emit that much juice.
- Already__Taken 2y agothis? https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/transportation/electric-conversion-of-wa-ferry-delayed-a-year-and-the-cost-is-rising/ https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/transportation/ele... interesting they're struggling to get ship builders to bid. Seems like a lesson learned is to build new boats until service is over capacity before refitting old boats where the unknown unknowns lurk.
- laurencerowe 2y agoMeanwhile Norway has 80 electric commuter ferries in service. https://businessnorway.com/articles/norway-showcases-award-winning-electric-ferry-technology https://businessnorway.com/articles/norway-showcases-award-w...
- nickff 2y agoThe Norwegian ferries appear to be much smaller than the Washington state ferries. Here is the largest e-ferry: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E-ferry_Ellen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E-ferry_Ellen And a guide to the WA fleet: https://wsdot.wa.gov/sites/default/files/2021-10/WSF-FleetGuide-May2020.pdf https://wsdot.wa.gov/sites/default/files/2021-10/WSF-FleetGu...
- laurencerowe 2y ago> Here is the largest e-ferry: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E-ferry_Ellen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E-ferry_Ellen Norway's largest e-ferry is three times larger. https://www.electrive.com/2021/03/02/worlds-largest-electric-ferry-yet-goes-into-service-in-norway/ https://www.electrive.com/2021/03/02/worlds-largest-electric...
- nickff 2y agoAccording to your link (and all other articles I found on that vessel), that ferry is capable of operating all-electric, but actually operating as a hybrid.
- wongarsu 2y agoThe Seattle ferries GP was talking are also retrofitted to be hybrid-electric, so that does seem very comparable
- nickff 2y agoI was initially responding to a post stating that there were many all-electric ferries, and my point was that there were none (operational) of a size comparable to WA state ferries. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42197763 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42197763 There are many large hybrid vessels; notably, this has been common for submarines for a very long time. The largest currently operational diesel-electric (hybrid) submarine seems to be the Chinese Qing-class, of ~3800 tons surfaced displacement.
- Gibbon1 2y agoThe frustration should be that in the US management is functionally incompetent. Proposal: If we do it this way we won't have to spend as much money. Counter: That's really hinky and it probably will blow up in our face. Proposal: Yes but you can't prove it will. So it's what we're going to do. Later: Blows up and goes over budget and takes two to three times longer.
- shermantanktop 2y agoyou forgot the part where "Proposal" has been promoted twice based on a hurried launch and only "Counter" is left to take the blame for the messups.
- ajford 2y agoIt also doesn't help that the bid/contract process is skewed to select the lowest bidder. You can always forget to add some margin here or there, or fail to plan for problems that might pop up. It's easy to game the system because sunk costs make it nearly impossible to switch once you've started.
- Epa095 2y agoTechnology won't become ready without users unfortunately.
- Panzer04 2y agoI don't know what you mean by dogmatic. Alternatives to electric are still the primary workhorses in most industries, but falling prices for batteries mean they are rapidly becoming more competitive. My experience is that people don't have a good grasp of how effective electric is, and think it's somehow worse than the alternatives and winning via subsidies, which is not really the case today. Likewise for things like solar. I imagine many businesses are hoping to put off their next replacement cycles for more effective, cheaper technology rather than incur big Capex expenses on soon to be obsolete and more expensive technologies.
- tonymet 2y agodogmatic in this case refers to tolerating critical service disruptions despite strong signal that electric is not yet ready, when you could easily continue service with diesel, the mature technology.
- tonymet 2y agoHackernews needs a better way to highlight stimulating comments. This one generated a healthy discussion, still 0 points. I advocated for a controversial ranking before and it’s still relevant.
- hwillis 2y agoWow, this is a really good paper. Supplementary info is really great too- they get into details down to floating charging port stations as part of the infrastructure. Surprising how much demand is from tugboats. I have questions about how you'd safely hook up 5 MW connections, but it's definitely solvable.
- Epa095 2y agoHere is a LinkedIn post from my friends in Plug with a video! It's for connecting to a cruise ship, which are often around 5MW https://www.linkedin.com/posts/plugport_some-great-insight-into-the-operation-of-ugcPost-7222186653010808834-JDWV https://www.linkedin.com/posts/plugport_some-great-insight-i...
- ianburrell 2y agoThere are IEC 60309 industrial power connectors that can handle 8MW (1000V, 800A). There are also power connectors for cruise ships while they are in dock that handle lots of power. It looks like they use IEC 80005 for shore power. It looks like it is AC only but probably could be made to use DC.
- bittercynic 2y agoIsn't that 0.8MW?
- telgareith 2y ago8001000=800,000. (81 and 5 zeros). looks like 800kW to me. Nice catch.
- sitharus 2y agoTugboats are a perfect use for battery electric boats! Most tugs work close to a port, they don't need to travel very far, need to be extraordinarily powerful for their size, and they need to change power output rapidly to manoeuvre a ship. A harbour tug internally is almost entirely engine. Well, two engines, because an engine failure during tug operations is almost always disastrous.
- Already__Taken 2y agoI support this idea but I stopped reading when the costs factored included the social costs of CO2 emissions. which I'm sure are important, but shipping operates on the actual cost of fuel and equipment, until CO2 tax is in that aren't we just making up economics? They're also factoring in the value of the batteries second life, which seems at best, speculative. ships should be electric, they're filthy to be around with 24/7 diesel generators running even on the quayside. if ship electrification prompted better port facilities of shore side hookup just that would be a win.
- hwillis 2y agoThey split the emissions cost out separately, FWIW: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41560-024-01655-y/figures/3 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41560-024-01655-y/figures/3
- seatownferryman 2y ago[dead]
- akira2501 2y agoThe reason those generators run is because the cargo requires them, or ships would not be able to take anything refrigerated or frozen, removing a large part of very profitable cargo from them. If the power to those boxes fails for a long enough period of time the load is completely destroyed. Ships use power for all sorts of things. Steering, ventilation fans, and water pumps just to name a few. Motor power is only a fraction of what a boat can do, and most boats connect a generator to the main shaft, because the power is more important than the motive force.
- nwah1 2y agoEnergy density of batteries is much lower than that of fossil fuels. Which means that the weight of the ships would increase. In addition to the high price of the batteries, potential risks of electrocution, etc. There are intermediate options. Moving away from diesel towards natural gas would dramatically reduce emissions (including sulfur emissions), while retaining high energy density.
- laurencerowe 2y agoElectric is an immediate option. Norway has 80 electric ferries in service. https://businessnorway.com/articles/norway-showcases-award-winning-electric-ferry-technology https://businessnorway.com/articles/norway-showcases-award-w...
- nwah1 2y agoIt may be an immediate option for places that have a very strong desire to reduce carbon emissions, but for profit-driven entities the push towards natural gas ends up as both more economical and more ecological. https://www.lngindustry.com/special-reports/21112023/the-rise-of-lng-powered-vessels-in-container-shipping/ https://www.lngindustry.com/special-reports/21112023/the-ris...
- ajford 2y agoIt seems like the profit-driven attitude put us in the ecological situation and maybe it's time to put the environmental impact first.
- ViewTrick1002 2y agoNot going to work in the EU. Fossil fuels like natural gas are assumed to be the baseline in the Fuel EU directive entering into force in 2025. All required reductions will have to come on top. https://transport.ec.europa.eu/transport-modes/maritime/decarbonising-maritime-transport-fueleu-maritime_en https://transport.ec.europa.eu/transport-modes/maritime/deca...
- 2y ago
- nominatronic 2y ago> The researchers analyzed US-flagged ships less than 1,000 gross tonnage, which includes primarily passenger ships and three types of tugboats. This is the buried lede. They are excluding basically all cargo shipping. - Very little of the shipping industry is US-flagged. Most commercial ships sail under flags of convenience such as Panama and Libera, because of their reduced regulations and costs. - Nobody carries cargo any distance in vessels of less than 1000 gross tons, because that scale would be uneconomical to operate. Modern seagoing cargo ships have about one crew member per 8000 tons of cargo.
- toomuchtodo 2y ago~40% of cargo tonnage is moving fossil fuels (coal, oil, gas) around [1] [2]. I would expect this volume to decline as the global energy transition continues to ramp. China's economy and EVs are already depressing global oil prices [3] [4] [5], for example. Also consider global decoupling and repatriating of supply chains [6] [7]. My analysis: We're potentially going to require much less marine transport capacity in the future. How much of that can be electrified is the question, imho (versus "green ammonia" produced from low carbon energy [8]). [1] https://thelastdriverlicenseholder.com/2022/01/12/almost-40-of-all-ship-cargoes-are-oil-coal-and-gas/ https://thelastdriverlicenseholder.com/2022/01/12/almost-40-... [2] https://unctad.org/system/files/official-document/rmt2019_en.pdf https://unctad.org/system/files/official-document/rmt2019_en... [3] https://www.iea.org/commentaries/china-s-slowdown-is-weighing-on-the-outlook-for-global-oil-demand-growth https://www.iea.org/commentaries/china-s-slowdown-is-weighin... [4] https://theprogressplaybook.com/2024/09/18/chinas-ev-and-high-speed-rail-boom-is-curbing-global-oil-demand-data-shows/ https://theprogressplaybook.com/2024/09/18/chinas-ev-and-hig... [5] https://www.energypolicy.columbia.edu/chinas-slowing-oil-demand-growth-is-likely-to-persist-and-could-impact-markets/ https://www.energypolicy.columbia.edu/chinas-slowing-oil-dem... [6] https://www.axios.com/2024/11/14/companies-global-trade-china-trump https://www.axios.com/2024/11/14/companies-global-trade-chin... [7] https://www.bain.com/about/media-center/press-releases/2024/businesses-accelerate-reshoring-and-near-shoring-amid-heightened-geopolitical-uncertainties-and-rising-costs-bain--company-finds/ https://www.bain.com/about/media-center/press-releases/2024/... [8] https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&query=ammonia&sort=byDate&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...
- elzbardico 2y agoA Lithium fire battery in a cruise ship in the middle of the Pacific would be a truly unique experience.
- mcswell 2y agoAlmost as bad as a fuel oil fire on a cruise ship.
- Polizeiposaune 2y agoLithium batteries are more prone to self-immolation/thermal runaway; heavy fuel oils aren't prone to spontaneous ignition at typical temperatures & pressures.
- beedeebeedee 2y agoUse lithium ferrophosphate instead- no fire
- 1234letshaveatw 2y agoI would think that preventative measures would be much easier to realize on big ships with lower density demands
- EricE 2y agoFurthermore, oil fires can be extinguished by water and/or CO2 - Lithium battery fires can't be smothered and require exponentially more water to bring under control (producing copious amounts of heavily contaminated water too). And once put out can easily re-ignite.
- elzbardico 2y agoThere's no need to lie. Lithium battery fires are a fucking nightmare.
- samplatt 2y agoThere's hope that sodium-ion tech will come to the rescue, here. The energy-density is bordering on 'good enough' but it's not quite there, yet. There's other technologies that they're trialing for boats that seem silly but works on paper at least. We're currently building a ferry with a massive flywheel to store lots of rotational inertia to convert to electricity, which on the face of it is bonkers but again, the maths says it's good.
- coding123 2y agoYou've been sitting at port a week past unloading please move along! Sorry doc command, were still charging, should be on our way in 8 more days.
- entropicgravity 2y agoThe future of shipping is ammonia. It has, pretty much, all the attributes of fossil fuels but being NH4 it doesn't produce an earth warming byproduct.
- lstodd 2y agonow imagine a leak of it. fuel oil.. you just fence it off and scoop up. ammonia.. evacuate the port and city
- entropicgravity 2y agoStudies have been done comparing gasoline vs. ammonia and while there are differences overall the dangers and mitigations are about the same.
- DanielHB 2y agoI wonder how viable an autonomous single-container electric cargo ship would be, instead of massive ships you could have thousands of tiny ones. With automated loading/unloading it could massively simplify logistics A solar panel covering the ship and one of those flaps to generate power from wind with a EV-scale battery could be enough for containers moving light non-time-sensitive stuff. Probably wouldn't be able to run the engine at night for long though. Heck throw some wheels at it and fast charging at docks and it could even potentially drive down the road as a truck directly from sea.
- thworp 2y agoWhile I don't have any deep foundational knowledge, I do know that: - the energy required for moving in a fluid grows sub-linear with the vessel's volume - larger motors tend to be more efficient - your autonomous swarm will be a gigantic waste of steel and batteries. Not to mention the problems around the autonomous part, without which you'd also have a huge waste of manpower. See also https://engineering.stackexchange.com/questions/38252/why-one-big-cargo-ship-is-more-efficient-than-10-or-100-smaller-ships https://engineering.stackexchange.com/questions/38252/why-on... for some points by people I assume know a bit more than me.
- HeyLaughingBoy 2y agoThat sounds like a nightmare in port. Instead of one ship, now you have thousands arriving one after another.
- DanielHB 2y agoIf they are that small and autonomous the concept of a port would likely be very different than what it is today. More like thousands of small drop-off points around the coast.
- specialist 2y agoMy dream variant of this notion is a waveglider. Super efficient, if a little slower. Bonus points for adding a big scoop, to slurp up trash and filter out microplastics.
- Const-me 2y agoFor marine applications, I think propane fuel cells will work better than batteries. Unlike batteries, energy density of liquified propane is good. Unlike hydrogen, logistics of propane is solved by now as it’s already widely used to fuel vehicles. Currently people usually burn propane in combustion engines, instead of oxidizing in fuel cells. In theory, fuel cells are more efficient than combustion engines. There’re commercially available fuel cells used for marine applications https://wattfuelcell.com/ https://wattfuelcell.com/ however it seems low powered, not enough power for propulsion. And there’re different ways being researched to synthesize propane: some biotech bacteria, traditional industrial chemistry with new catalyzers like trimolybdenum phosphide nanoparticles, etc.
- strawhatguy 2y agoFor their comparisons, they used the "social cost" of CO2 emissions, I presume a detriment to combustion engined ships, a benefit to battery powered ones? Also they used the "2nd life" of the battery too, batteries that have not been repurposed at any meaningful scale yet? I'm becoming more skeptical of reports, especially government reports, like this; there's a thumb on the scale toward solutions that are politically favored. Clearly this report was trying to find any way to boost the appearance of EVs.