8 ms·
The problem is this: - the browser is undeniably critical as everyone's window through which they view the online world; - the user gains a huge amount of val
by pjc50 2y ago
The problem is this:
- the browser is undeniably critical as everyone's window through which they view the online world;
- the user gains a huge amount of value by a browser being integrated into the OS, webviews in other applications, etc
- browsers aren't really a self funding product
- having a single for-profit US advertising company control everyone's view of the online world, however slightly (e.g. by obstructing adblockers), is Not Good
Splitting it off solves the latter problem but immediately raises the question of how to pay for it. A very artificial arrangement where Google pay "arms length browserco" to maintain Chrome?
- niutech 2y agoHow does splitting off Chrome as a separate company solve anything? They would still rely on Google for funding (like Mozilla) and being close friends they would do whatever Alphabet tells them to do. A better solution is to implement a bill like DMA in the EU to enforce competition among web browser vendors and fight monopolies.
- verve_rat 2y agoBut now Bing would have a chance of becoming the default search engine of the most used browser in the world. That's the difference.
- crazygringo 2y agoBing is already the default search engine on the default browser of the most used OS in the world. If they're not competing well, then that's entirely their fault. Microsoft is not at any kind of disadvantage here.
- bee_rider 2y agoI don’t think Bing is the default search engine for Android’s browser. I could be wrong though. Is it? That would be a surprisingly fair-minded move of Google.
- EasyMark 2y agoBy context I’m pretty sure they mean Windows OS and not android, sometimes you have to take things in context. Depending on context one could easily argue that linux is the most common operating system depending on where you draw the line on operating system
- bee_rider 2y agoI am pointing out that Windows is not the most common OS, and Android is. The original comment was saying that Google is able to perform anti-competitively because they control the most popular browser. The followup (which I responded to) is saying that the existence of Windows as the most popular OS, and Microsoft’s control over the default browser there, mitigates this anti-competitive potential. The fact that Windows is not the most popular OS (and that, in fact, the most popular OS is controlled by Google) undermines that argument. Linux is not the most popular OS in any context that includes doing searches with the thing, unless you include Android, but Android just uses Linux for the kernel mostly, and an OS is more than a kernel.
- nightski 2y agoIt's the most common desktop OS. No one was confused by what the parent meant since Windows is not a mobile operating system and doesn't compete in that market.
- bee_rider 2y agoBing and Google are competing in the market of search engines, not some device specific search engine market.
- lukas099 2y agoI think it's fair for them to point out (however snarkily) that Windows is not the most popular OS. In the context of the discussion, I think it matters that there is another OS, Android, that is more popular.
- firefax 2y ago>Bing is already the default search engine on the default browser of the most used OS in the world. It's actually more embedded in Windows than Google is in Android. If you change your default engine in Android it changes across the OS. In Windows, there are dialogs that say "search bing for" embedded into places like the right click menu when you have text highlighted that remain even after attempting to express a different search choice. Another example is the search bar in a new tab.
- PittleyDunkin 2y agoFrankly, who cares. The important part is that google doesn't own a browser.
- scarface_74 2y agoIs the justice department then going to stop Google from using the open source Chromium project to create a new browser?
- efitz 2y agoAlmost certainly that would be part of a consent decree, which would prohibit Google from creating or controlling a browser for some period of time, and would include court supervision.
- scarface_74 2y agoSo Google could also not ship a browser with Android devices? Chromebooks?
- placardloop 2y agoSelling devices with a browser installed or available for installation is completely tangential to creating and/or controlling the development of said browser.
- scarface_74 2y agoWould Google not be allowed to make any changes to the open source Chromium browser before installing it on its own hardware?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- kernal 2y ago
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 2y ago> A better solution is to implement a bill Not that I disagree with the overall point, but this is something the DOJ does not do. They would just look at the current laws and decide who to prosecute based on their interpretation of events.
- scarface_74 2y agoUnless you own a Chromebook, if you have Chrome on your computer, you made a choice to download it. How would a browser choice screen help?
- throwaway888889 2y agoLook at the effects of breaking up the bells into smaller companies....
- Ferret7446 2y agoWhich of the bells provided a valuable free product that could only be funded via other product revenue streams?
- throwaway888889 2y agoBSD Unix comes to mind.
- lofaszvanitt 2y agoBrowsers should be developed by an intercountry nonprofit. Funded by all the countries' governments.
- dartos 2y agoIt works out so well for the UN!
- water9 2y ago[flagged]
- cyborgx7 2y agoWhy is efficiency the guiding metric of our decision making?
- madeofpalk 2y agoIn what way? Google seems like the perfect example of profit obscuring inefficiency.
- PittleyDunkin 2y agoProfit is, by definition, inefficiency.
- robertlagrant 2y agoAt the end of the day every employee is the most granular bit of profit-making - I trade my time and zero money for money. 100% profit. If you removed the money you paid me could say you're being more efficient, but I don't know if that's a useful definition of efficient. Just as you could steal some raw materials and say you're being efficient.
- PittleyDunkin 2y agoWell yes, if you find a way to generate value with no input costs, anything you charge people will be pure inefficiency and you'll be put out of "business" by the first person who gives this idea away for free. I'm not sure what sort of insight you can glean from this.
- DeusExMachina 2y agoThey could sell a lot of the data that Google now gets for free and uses for its ranking algorithms, like Clickstream sells data to SEO tools like AHrefs and SemRush.
- IX-103 2y agoGoogle doesn't use Chrome data for Ads or Search. They're not allowed to based on the TOS, and also they have government regulators watching carefully to make sure they don't make a mistake like that.
- placardloop 2y agoThe regulators in question are pushing for divestiture of Chrome because they don’t believe that the current structure prevents using Chrome data, so it seems that Google did “make a mistake like that”.
- DeusExMachina 2y agoA data leak from earlier this year suggested that they do, although there is no definitive proof. https://www.theverge.com/2024/5/31/24167119/google-search-algorithm-documents-leak-seo-chrome-clicks https://www.theverge.com/2024/5/31/24167119/google-search-al...
- mmh0000 2y agoAnd what legal enforcement of the TOS is there? None. And what are the consequences of Google ignoring their own TOS? None.
- asadotzler 2y agoWe have actual Google documentation leaked that proves you wrong and that they absolutely do use Chrome data for ads. Catch up please.
- binkHN 2y ago> A very artificial arrangement where Google pay "arms length browserco" to maintain [a browser]? Sounds almost like Firefox.
- moffkalast 2y agoGoogle to Mozilla: "I'm gonna pay you 400M a year for antitrust to fuck off" Seems like it didn't work though.
- binkHN 2y agoMaybe it needed to be a cool billion.
- marcosdumay 2y agoIt worked until they decided to unfairly compete with Firefox and get all the market share.
- wongarsu 2y agoFirefox lost too much market share. And while some of that is due to bad leadership at Mozilla, Chrome running big advertising campaigns and Google advertising Chrome on their own properties (hints to download Chrome on Google Search, Drive, etc. when you visit with other browsers) were also a big driver. Google flew too close to the sun.
- neodymiumphish 2y agoI wish the result of the case was just “you can’t pester users to switch browsers. Unless the browser they’re using isn’t meeting an open standard that’s necessary to the proper function of the site you’re pestering them on.” If another entity buys Chrome, they’re only doing so based on the belief of increased future value/revenue from it. Google doesn’t want to sell it because they see more future value in it. If Chrome sucked, there’d be no antitrust case. So this is all a “you’ve done too good a job, now give it all up.” I don’t use Chrome or Chromium based browsers because Safari works well for all of my use cases. But I want to see alternatives prosper. I don’t think needing Chrome gets anyone there.
- BeefySwain 2y ago> browsers aren't really a self funding product Yeah... Because massive companies use them anti-competitively as a moat against other companies, and as a loss leader to enable massive data collection and vendor lock in. "browsers aren't really a self funding product" is a symptom of dysfunction, not the inevitable conclusion of a fair market.
- pjc50 2y agoI'm not sure that software entirely obeys normal market theory. So much of it is zero-cost free. The synergistic effects are so strong that most users would prefer there to be The System, in which everything works together and there's no risk of incompatible choices. They don't necessarily care which system. The market in things like, say, file explorers is tiny. There's a few shell replacements (free), Midnight Commander and clones, and maybe over in the corner someone making a few thousand dollars a year from an Explorer replacement.
- marcosdumay 2y agoWell, things with open source alternatives tend to fare badly when sold.
- eastbound 2y agoLike Jira vs Mantis? There are probably plenty of such examples.
- lolinder 2y agoAny potential buyer will have to be looking to use Chrome to accomplish the same kinds of synergies that Google is using it for, to get ahead in some adjacent market. Depending on the buyer that could be good for competition, at least in the short term, but it's not clear that it will be better for us as users.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- nfw2 2y agoHypothetically, why would some buyer using Chrome's monopoly to establish a market advantage in an adjacent domain be different than Google using Chrome's monopoly to establish a market advantage in an adjacent domain?
- maronato 2y agoBecause the relationship between Google and Chrome goes both ways. Chrome helps Google keep their monopoly on search and ads, and Google helps Chrome keep its monopoly via Android and its other products. After the separation, Google won’t have an incentive to promote Chrome - so it’ll lose market share eventually, and Chrome won’t have an incentive to require things like Google accounts or use Google search by default - opening space for other companies to compete.
- throwaway2037 2y agoYou raise some very important points. Specifically, this one: > browsers aren't really a self funding product I feel the same. I also feel the same about a modern C library and C compiler (and C++, if you like). They are essential to build any modern system and applications. Yet, those are also (mostly) no longer self-funding products. What do you think will happen if Google is forced to divest Chrome?
- criddell 2y ago> What do you think will happen if Google is forced to divest Chrome? The new Chrome company will struggle for a year or two then Apple will try to buy it but lose out after Oracle submits a higher bid.
- polishTar 2y agoOracle Chrome, Ha! I wouldn't even be surprised if that's exactly how it plays out.
- Suppafly 2y ago>The new Chrome company will struggle for a year or two then Apple will try to buy it but lose out after Oracle submits a higher bid. We're in the worst timeline, so I could see that happening.
- gambiting 2y agoElon buys it to "preserve free speech everywhere" then turns it into the same swamp twitter is. So you know, could be worse.
- rawgabbit 2y agoThe issue is who controls Chromium. I would create a non profit and staff it with a handful of maintainers. Their primary job would be to ensure safety and squash exploits. Their other job is to curate and approve pull requests from volunteers for enhancements. They should make it open source with the caveat if it is used for commercial purposes, there will be a licensing fee to pay for security enhancements, bug bounties, and the like.
- kernal 2y agoDo you think Google will continue to invest money and resources into the development of Chromium if they were forced to sell Chrome? I don't. The first thing I would do is close source the Chromium project and work on a new closed source browser to compete with Chrome. I also don't see Chrome surviving when all of the Google/Chromium developers have left.
- rawgabbit 2y agoI beg to differ. Google will go where the users are; their ad business depends on it.
- rollcat 2y agoSo more or less what Mozilla was supposed to be all along?
- rawgabbit 2y agoYes.
- Ferret7446 2y agoWhoever contributes to it controls Chromium. If 90% of the contributors were non-Google, then it would effectively be controlled by non-Google, because they could fork it and their fork would still get 90% of development. See Terraform for a live example. The only reason Google "controls" Chromium is because Google funds almost, but not quite, 100% of its development. On a similar note, there's nothing stopping Microsoft from investing equal or greater amounts and forking Chromium (well, arguably they might already have with Edge). Except that they're benefiting from all of Google's investment, for free. Why turn down a massive developer investment from your competitor with no strings attached?
- fluidcruft 2y agoSort of sounds like you are one step short of suggesting a browser is critical infrastructure.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- maeil 2y ago> browsers aren't really a self funding product They are, see how both Safari and Firefox, the 2nd and 3rd most popular browsers, have brought in tens of billions of revenue per year. Safari is immensely profitable, Firefox too would be if Mozilla wouldn't be run in an absurdly poor manner. > the user gains a huge amount of value by a browser being integrated into the OS, webviews in other applications, etc What is the huge value gain that e.g. Safari being integrated into MacOS is bringing me? Why couldn't webviews be backed by a browser of my choice?
- echoangle 2y agoIn what way is Safari profitable? How is that even measured? Has any consumer in the last 10 years ever specifically paid for safari? Or do you mean the payments by google to be the default search engine?
- LgWoodenBadger 2y agoIf Safari didn't exist, Google wouldn't be paying Apple ~$20-Billion a year to default Safari's search to Google
- echoangle 2y agoWhy not though? Apple could still install Firefox and set Bing as the default search engine. Or even just Chrome, without selecting google. They don’t get the money for making a browser but configuring their browser in a specific way. That would work with any browser.
- lukas099 2y agoCan Apple force Mozilla to make Google the default browser in Firefox?
- echoangle 2y agoNo? But why does it matter? They can include Firefox in their OS and set the default search engine to anything they want. The point was that developing Safari isn't what makes apple the money, it's setting Google as the default search engine of the default browser. So if Apple would stop maintaining safari tomorrow and would switch to preinstalling Firefox, they would still get the Google money (for setting Google as the default search engine of their Firefox installation). So Safari isn't profitable for Apple, as was claimed before.
- astrodust 2y agoFirefox has made a mountain of money off of their tiny market share. Chrome as a company would instantly rake in billions.
- scarface_74 2y agoFrom making Google the default search engine…
- neodymiumphish 2y agoAnd probably even more if they made Google the only option, assuming it was otherwise perfect for most users.
- singleshot_ 2y agoI’m consistently fascinated to look at Chrome/Google and think of all the things we lost when we broke IE/Microsoft. To what extent and I holding a stupid belief, and why? I think I might like to be talked out of this, if reasonable. Want to try?
- GoblinSlayer 2y ago>browsers aren't really a self funding product You can use Firefox 3, programs don't rot.
- sebastiennight 2y agoNot really true... In this specific case I'd be willing to bet that Firefox 3 probably doesn't handle current HTTPS/TLS standards and might not be able to browser the modern Internet at all (let alone display modern webpages, HTML5 video players, single-page web apps, WebRTC live calls, etc.)
- Mr_Minderbinder 2y agoFirefox 3.5 was actually the first browser to support HTML5 video and audio. In general for old browsers TLS is the main issue. Most websites that don't rely on JavaScript or newer CSS still render well enough or "fail gracefully" but are still readable.
- GoblinSlayer 2y ago>HTTPS/TLS Put it behind privoxy. All those SPA blogs exist solely due to google. No google - no SPA.
- sebastiennight 2y agoI'm curious about the logic there. - Why would Google (which famously didn't index Javascript well, and liked clear super-optimized URLs) have contributed to the existence of single-page applications (which used to have terrible drawbacks for SEO)? Where's the incentive? - And what is a SPA blog? That seems like such a far-fetched idea.