6 ms·
MIT engineers make converting CO2 into useful products more practical
- VyseofArcadia 2y agoTime scale is also something I want to know about. "Can I remove CO2 from the air and turn it into something valuable in a way that is cost effective?" is one question. Another question is, "Can I remove CO2 from the air and turn it into something valuable faster than a tree?"
- ben_w 2y agoAs this is more of "can we make carbon sequestering commercially viable, or at least less lossy", I'm less worried about that and would be more concerned about the global market for ethylene being "316.8 Million Tonnes in the year 2023"*, compared to the tens of gigatons of CO2 emissions — though on the plus side, I'm optimistic about removing most of those emissions and this kind of thing is still fine for the last 10%. As for "less lossy" even if it's not always a commercial winner alone: my guess would be there's always going to be an easier way to get CO2 than "from the air", unless you're on Venus or Mars: take tree (or coal), cut up, put chips in oven, set on fire. Much higher CO2 concentration than air, likely to make most things that need CO2 much easier. * https://finance.yahoo.com/news/global-ethylene-industry-report-2024-091700936.html# https://finance.yahoo.com/news/global-ethylene-industry-repo...
- r-bryan 2y agoA little stoichometry suggests that, ignoring oxygen, hydrogen, and energy input, the cited worldwide market for C2H4 would be satisfied by just about 1 gigaton of CO2. So if "we need to process gigatons of CO2 annually", that ethylene's gonna pile up.
- sampo 2y ago> "Can I remove CO2 from the air and turn it into something valuable faster than a tree?" In some climate zones, grasslands do it better than forests. https://climatechange.ucdavis.edu/climate/news/grasslands-more-reliable-carbon-sink-than-trees https://climatechange.ucdavis.edu/climate/news/grasslands-mo...
- criddell 2y agoA tree gives you wood. What are the valuable outputs of grasslands?
- Kostic 2y agoChernozem.
- thechao 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chernozem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chernozem
- lupusreal 2y agoDoes bamboo count?
- criddell 2y agoMaybe. I know it actually is grass, but are bamboo growths called grasslands?
- nostromo 2y agoYou can make it into a carbon-neutral heating fuel. You can make paper products including things like cardboard and packaging. You can put livestock on it and produce meat. Or if you just want to sequester carbon, you can harvest it and bury it deep in the ground.
- sampo 2y ago> What are the valuable outputs of grasslands? If you use grasslands for grazing cattle you get meat, or also wool with sheep. Sequestering carbon into grassland soil (or into any soil, really) makes them better at absorbing and retaining rainwater, reducing the risks of catastrophic floods in the watershed area.
- criddell 2y ago
- not2b 2y agoMy guess is that it would be much more effective to capture and remove CO2 directly at the source, for example at a cement plant. While this could be done at a fossil fuel plant as well, it seems a lot less attractive: you give back most of the energy you just got from burning the fuel.
- Suppafly 2y agoThey should sell it to people for their car tires with a specially colored valve cap like they do for nitrogen. It'd be stupid, but so is paying extra for a slightly higher nitrogen content and people do that.
- jandrese 2y agoThat sort of application is just spitting into the ocean when you're talking about global CO2 emissions and sequestration.
- BenjiWiebe 2y agoPlus it all comes out of the tires in the end anyways.
- danbruc 2y agoI have not thought about this too carefully so I might be overlooking something. With that out of the way, a quick search indicates that we burn about 90 % of gas, oil, and coal for one purpose or another. Let's round this and pretend we burn it all. To undo this we will essentially need the same amount of energy again that we got out of it when we burned it, we would need to use all the energy coming from fossil fuels to undo burning them. Conservation of energy essentially. Which makes it obvious that the entire idea is pretty pointless, burn fossil fuels to generate energy to then use it to unburn fossil fuels. To do it with renewable energy, we still need the same capacity as the fossil fuel capacity and when we have that - ignoring issues like fluctuations in renewable sources - it makes more sense to just use the renewable sources directly instead of using them to undo burning fossil fuels. If you want to use the process to pull carbon out of the atmosphere, then you first have to replace all fossil fuels with renewable ones, then you can use additional renewable capacity to remove carbon. Add additional 10 % capacity to the world energy capacity to undo one year of carbon emissions every decade, at least to a first approximation. To come back to the initial question, you essentially need an industry the same order of magnitude as the fossil fuel industry to have a meaningful impact. Not going to happen anytime soon.
- TSiege 2y agoThe point that you're missing is that changes this equation a bit is that burning fossil fuels wastes most of the energy as heat another waste of energy is the amount of FFs we use to ship FFs to other places. So together that means we don't need the same amount of electric power to do the same amount of work. That being said, keeping fossil fuels in the ground will always be better than removing CO2 for the reasons you said. We also seem to be growing energy demands instead of shrinking or stabilizing them which also makes the transition harder.
- axus 2y agoLots of solar on-site that doesn't need to transfer it's power elsewhere could be used; maybe the real winner would be 100% solar-powered solar panel factory :)
- toss1 2y ago>>we would need to use all the energy coming from fossil fuels to undo burning them This would true if we need to re-create the original molecule with it's stored energy (plus losses of course). However, it seems this is a misapprehension of the task. Instead of trying to recover the entire hydrocarbon molecule, we're "just" trying to extract or recombine the CO2 reactant. Without doing the chemistry or the math, it seems likely that a variety of methods of either preferentially attracting CO2, or combining it into simpler lower-energy-dense molecules to be collected, would require less energy as was in the original hydrocarbon, often substantially less. Seems it should be an inequality, not an equality. Or am I missing something?
- userabchn 2y agoHave there been any recent developments in "lab-grown wood"? The last time I looked into it there had been some research on it (also at MIT), but there didn't seem to have been any updates for a few years.
- Clippybara 2y agoPermeating the PTFE layer with copper electrodes in order to get both hydrophobicity and conductivity seems stupidly simple, but the best ideas often are. I also greatly admire how their model looks like a s'more lol
- mchannon 2y agoThe writer appears to be under the impression that CO2 is not a valuable commodity. In fact, it is, so long as it's under enough pressure, and in the right place. In Montezuma County, Colorado, sits the McElmo dome, an ancient underground CO2 well. They pump it out, down a 500 mile pipeline, to Denver City, Texas, where it gooses oil wells into pumping more crude out. Other than making more oil and making it cheaper, not really much in terms of greenhouse gas contributions- the CO2 starts underground and ends up underground. Kinder Morgan won't just let you back up your truck and buy some (it's already spoken for), and even if they would, they'd expect you to pay a pretty penny for what we widely consider to be waste gas. I think MIT is doing some good work. Just wanted everyone to be mindful of the massive scale under which CO2 is already getting bought and sold.
- ulrikrasmussen 2y agoIsn't it also used as input to basically every e-fuel which can replace fossil hydrocarbons?
- analog31 2y agoNo. The value of commercial co2 is its energy content -- what it takes to process it into useful form. There is no useful form of co2 for making fuel. The energy has already been extracted.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jvanderbot 2y agoYou're right (current state of the art), but also wrong (in the spirit of the question as I read it). If energy prices go down, e.g., from continuing decline of solar, then it may be very cost effective to store energy as hydrocarbons which are synthesized from cheap energy + CO2. E.g., make natural gas from the air and sell it cheaper than it could be extracted and transported. In this scenario, rather than paying exorbitant fees for CO2, the cheap energy could be used to extract it from the atmosphere where it is abundant. Before anyone bites my head off - consider the tyranny-of-the-rocket-equation problem of burning gas to transport gas from source (wells, refineries, etc) to consumers. Then consider that the sun shines most places, and CO2 is effectively uniformly distributed. So Synthesis wouldn't have to be cheaper at the source if it can beat the price at the consumer via avoiding huge distribution costs.
- poaosdpasdpo 2y ago[flagged]
- poaosdpasdpo 2y ago[flagged]
- guiriduro 2y agoWell, it uses PTFE which is a kind of PFAS which doesn't have a clear future and shouldn't be scaled up for good reasons, e.g. : https://www.gmp-compliance.org/gmp-news/restrictions-for-ptfe-used-in-pharmaceutical-plant-engineering https://www.gmp-compliance.org/gmp-news/restrictions-for-ptf...
- idunnoman1222 2y agoOnly carbon matters
- outworlder 2y agoInteresting. PTFE tubes are used for 3D printers (although it's a small quantity and they aren't consumable), but I didn't know it was so much more harmful than other plastics. Edit: just realized that PTFE is Teflon. Makes more sense now.
- travisporter 2y agoBut isn't copper quite expensive? I didn't see them address this
- jandrese 2y agoDepending on how long the electrodes last the cost of the system will probably be dominated by the electricity, not the raw materials used in the construction. I have not done the chemistry, but my gut feeling is that breaking all of those O2s off of the CO2 and all of the O2s off of the H2Os is going to be the expensive part of this process.
- kokanee 2y agoElectrochemical cells (especially PEM electrolyzers) are notorious for containing materials far more expensive than copper (noble metals). But they pay for themselves much more quickly than you might think, if you can get offtakers to actually purchase and use the resulting products. The biggest challenge facing these climate tech industries right now is the chicken-and-egg problem. You can't make anything cheaper than the centuries-old fossil-based competition unless you do it at scale; you can't scale it without offtakers; offtakers won't participate unless it is cheaper than the status quo. There are compounding issues with expensive infrastructure upgrades (e.g. airplane or maritime engines that need to be upgraded to handle new fuels; pipelines or fuel trucks that need to be build to handle hydrogen, etc) that further push out the break even date. And then you have oil & gas companies inserting themselves into these efforts in order to greenwash their businesses, causing many would-be supporters to oppose entire clean technologies due to the perception that green tech startups are in bed with the fossil industry.
- outworlder 2y ago> The biggest challenge facing these climate tech industries right now is the chicken-and-egg problem. You can't make anything cheaper than the centuries-old fossil-based competition unless you do it at scale; you can't scale it without offtakers; offtakers won't participate unless it is cheaper than the status quo. That's the exact sort of thing governments are supposed to solve.
- jandrese 2y agoThe article annoyingly failed to close the loop from the $1,000/ton figure at the top and do the math on the economic efficiency potential of this approach. How much electricity is required to sequester each ton of CO2 using this method, assuming you can amortize the construction costs over some long duration? I assume the intended installation is on the exhaust of a fossil fuel burning facility, but is it possible to install this next to a solar field and generate ethylene from excess mid-day production? Large scale carbon sequestration is one of the major unsolved problems of the 21st century and we have to expect many false starts before the really viable technologies emerge.
- slwvx 2y agoOne place to look for some math on the economic efficiencies is the blog of Terraform industries. Here's a start: https://terraformindustries.wordpress.com/2024/04/01/terraform-makes-carbon-neutral-natural-gas/ https://terraformindustries.wordpress.com/2024/04/01/terrafo...
- jandrese 2y ago> There is no hand waving about economies of scale or subsidies here, though we are eligible for the full IRA 45V green hydrogen tax credit, worth $3/kg-H2. Their business model may have a slight problem.
- bryanlarsen 2y agoThey're saying that they don't need the green hydrogen tax credit. The tax credit makes their product profitable sooner, but as long as solar keeps following it's cost curve for a couple more years they'll be fine without it.
- fao_ 2y ago> Their business model may have a slight problem. Oil is subsidized to a much higher amount by the US government
- 2y ago
- bitwize 2y agoMy wife actually has established a cheap, energy-efficient facility for converting CO2 into useful materials right in our yard. She planted a garden. I was thinking about that the other day, how our beautiful trees, flowers, and bushes draw a few minerals from the soil, but are really mainly knitted together from the components of water and CO2. Yes, yes, I know, planting more trees won't do much about the greenhouse gas problem at scale, but the only thing that will are the three P's: powerdown, permaculture, population control. I do not expect industry to solve the problem industry created in a way that doesn't create more problems.
- zelphirkalt 2y ago> Yes, yes, I know, planting more trees won't do much about the greenhouse gas problem at scale, but the only thing that will are the three P's: powerdown, permaculture, population control. I do not expect industry to solve the problem industry created in a way that doesn't create more problems. But I am always wondering: Couldn't we have planted forests, from which we take the grown trees and put them back down under the earth, in some old mining facilities or dig some tunnels that lead deep down and put that stuff there? Or perhaps build lots of long term use furniture from the trees? Anything, except burning them or letting them rod? Then we would use nature's mechanism for capturing and prevent releasing, by putting it deep down, or making meaningful long term use of it. And couldn't this be done on a bigger scale as well?
- jjmarr 2y ago> Couldn't we have planted forests, from which we take the grown trees and put them back down under the earth, in some old mining facilities or dig some tunnels that lead deep down and put that stuff there? This is basically how coal was created in the first place. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coal_forest https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coal_forest Assuming carbon in = carbon out, we'd have to plant trees for millions of years on virtually all arable land and bury them underground to undo our burning of coal, since that's how the coal (which is almost pure carbon) was originally created.
- tmtvl 2y ago
- rhelz 2y agoTo remove the co2 we put into the atmosphere will always take way more energy than we got out of putting it into the atmosphere in the first place. That is just thermodynamics. To remove all the co2 we put into the atmosphere would take more energy than we extracted from fossil fuels since the industrial revolution. And all that energy would, of course, have to be produced in an absolutely carbon-free manner. So this is and will remain an entirely impractical method of combatting global warming. MIT engineers know this. The people who funded this research know this. Why are they doing this?
- zelphirkalt 2y agoPositive interpretation: Because they hope to find a method of doing it, that does not require too much energy, so that that method can be done using renewables. Negative interpretation: Because of look/appearances/prestige.
- rhelz 2y ago// That does not require too much energy // It inherently takes more energy to "unburn" co2 than you got from burning it in the first place. We burn co2-producing fuels just because of this fact--they give us tons of energy! But it would take yet more tons of energy to unburn it. That is just thermodynamics. There is no magic science wand to wave here.
- jgrossholtz 2y agoFrom the article : "The work was supported by Shell, through the MIT Energy Initiative." Would it only exist to make people believe we can burn fossil fuels since a solution is around the corner ?
- HappMacDonald 2y agoThink of carbon in the atmosphere as a debt. Obviously you cannot effectively pay off debt using the money that you borrowed: that just leaves you with a net loss of the interest/friction/inefficiency. But if you can earn enough money to pay down the debt (which naturally also requires weaning off of the deficit spending in the first place) via other means such as renewable energy sources in great excess to the quantity of fossil fuel energy we have produced thus far, then figuring out how to pay down the debt as efficiently as possible as soon as possible absolutely makes sense.
- tempfile 2y agoIt can never be as practical as leaving it in the fuel it came from. This is a waste of time, and only deepens the pit of climate catastrophe.
- HappMacDonald 2y agoCarbon concentrations in Earth's atmosphere are a problem: a mess. Weaning off of fossil fuel use and transitioning to sustainable energy production and storage is among the biggest steps to stop making more of a mess. Carbon sequestration is cleaning up after the mess that has already been made. I see no reason to hold off on performing one of these steps until after the other has been finished: both should be done at the same time.
- tempfile 2y agoI think the risk that carbon capture gives governments an excuse not to properly regulate emissions outweighs the possibility they actually succeed in removing carbon from the atmosphere. On top of that, removing diffuse CO2 from the atmosphere requires far more energy than the bare minimum (i.e. the energy it released as fuel), because it is diffuse. The energy harnessed to do this (e.g. electricity from solar) would be put to better use doing actual work. I think we would require an enormous surplus in power generation before carbon capture even registers on the scale of useful interventions.
- trueduke 2y agoIn mice?
- yarg 2y agoWorst case scenario, you can always still turn it into wood.
- mempko 2y agoIt's always going to take more energy to convert CO2 to anything useful than it is to burn energy and release it as pollution. That means to requester all the extra CO2 in the atmosphere will require more energy than it took to put it there in the first place. Good luck humanity.
- orthecreedence 2y agoHumans passively polluted the atmosphere. Perhaps they can passively clean it up as well. Electric cars that spend 10% of their energy on sequestration or something like that. Exchange your CarbonBricks for a discount on useless consumer trinkets. Ultimately, it doesn't matter whether it's distributed or not, the real meat is that the energy used to sequester carbon needs to not come from carbon fuels. Once that can be scaled up, we can clean up at least some portion of this disaster.
- hn_throwaway_99 2y agoPerhaps someone with more knowledge can comment on why solutions like these can't be used to solve the energy storage problem. Is it just economics? That is, renewables are now the cheapest form of energy by a significant margin, but they are unreliable with respect to timing, so a storage solution is necessary in order to provide electricity on cloudy days when the wind isn't blowing, at night, etc. Most of the research I've seen into solving the storage issue involves batteries or things like pumped hydro. If things like solar and wind were "overbuilt", could a solution like this be used to create hydrocarbons when there is excess electricity? Power prices already go negative in some places when it's particularly sunny/windy. If the excess energy at that time could be used to make gas that could then be utilized by gas plants, well then there is your net 0 storage solution. I'm assuming solutions like this are uneconomic (and similarly with hydrogen plants, e.g. by using the excess renewable energy to generate green hydrogen by electrolysis for storage and later use), but I'd like to understand better why.
- gbasin 2y agoyep it should be possible. check this out: https://terraformindustries.com/ https://terraformindustries.com/
- rawgabbit 2y agoThere actually have been several solutions and some proofs of concept offered. However except for things like batteries, the purists object to all of them as green washing. Why, I don’t know. Off the top of my head, I believe someone demonstrated you can add thermocouples to your water to generate electricity. The idea was that during excess electricity generation during the day by a homeowner’s solar panels, use that to heat up the existing water tank. At night, use the thermocouple to generate electricity from the hot water. Granted the efficiency is abysmal. But 5% of something is better than 0% which is what happens when the electricity is thrown away.
- gipp 2y ago> I'm assuming solutions like this are uneconomic You kinda answered your own question already, I feel. The energy efficiency of cycling a battery (70-90% for grid scale) or pumped hydro (70-85%) is simply much, much higher than chemical storage. Here's a pretty recent one [1] showing 23% efficiency even at lab scale, and as described in the article scale is a big drain on efficiency. [1] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-022-29428-9 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-022-29428-9
- chris_va 2y ago(disclaimer that I do work in a related area) The novelty of the underlying paper notwithstanding, a quick scholar search for "gas diffusion electrodes ptfe copper" will show that this is hardly an unexplored space.
- thereisnospork 2y agoIndeed, this is at least a decade behind the state of the art for CO2 electroreduction and adding PTFE to gas diffusion electrodes is hardly a novel concept (see: H2 fuel cells which likely pre date it's inclusion in CO2 cells). It might be a good or even the best implementation of the concept, but if so it would be inches, not miles, better.
- newsclues 2y agoplant trees wait cut them down now you have wood to build stuff repeat
- rgrieselhuber 2y agoTrees also convert CO2 into something useful
- ikekkdcjkfke 2y agoUsing quantum technology
- asdf123qweasd 2y agoWhat is needed is a Graphene Lightmill, turning driven by light alone, capturing CO^2 spinning out graphene as a monofiber, no in between steps, no conversions.
- csours 2y agoI'm very curious about how bioelectrochemistry might be used, eg [0]. I dream of artificial lichens on silicone wafers making sheets of graphene. 0: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2589299119300977 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S258929911...
- trebor 2y agoOkay, but why not work on making atmospheric methane more useful/practical? CO2 is less of a warming influence than methane, and there have been huge natural gas leaks (of methane) in the last 10-20 years. Even MIT admits that Methane is more important: https://climate.mit.edu/ask-mit/what-makes-methane-more-potent-greenhouse-gas-carbon-dioxide https://climate.mit.edu/ask-mit/what-makes-methane-more-pote...
- regularfry 2y agoSomething that's not quite clear to me and is probably a stupid question if you know enough chemistry to be familiar with a gas diffusion electrode, but: can you run this thing on atmospheric air? Or will it only work if the gas in question is pure CO2?
- burnt-resistor 2y agoTotal waste of money and energy. For the small amount of CCS we need, oceanic bio CCS is the way to go. We're better off simply not emitting as much GHGs or digging up any more, and switching to renewables and distributed storage.
- andrewstuart 2y agoSo….. turn it into more crap to pollute the earth.