6 ms·
Is it even vaguely price competitive with solar & battery at this point?
by IshKebab 2y ago
Is it even vaguely price competitive with solar & battery at this point?
- throwaway888abc 2y agoFor the H100/B200 AI clusters ?
- m101 2y agoThe price is a function of regulations. It is self imposed, so a concerted effort here could reduce prices. Also, economics are not equal to climate/carbon. If we want to reduce climate change only nuclear is the way to go - not solar/battery. I don't think solar+battery is cost competitive if you were to replicate nuclear completely, but I've not looked at the numbers. Need to consider a nuclear plant may have a 60 year life whereas panels would be 20 at best and batteries probably less.
- chgs 2y agoYou can’t mention price without including the externalities and the total cost of ownership. Regulations attempt to price those.
- m101 2y agoIf regulations priced carbon externalities then solar would be more expensive than nuclear, but they don't. Edit: I can't reply so adding this for context around my comments on carbon intensity: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_return_on_investment https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_return_on_investment
- ZeroGravitas 2y agoNo it wouldn't. Even decade old solar was competitive with nuclear on a carbon per watt basis: https://ourworldindata.org/safest-sources-of-energy https://ourworldindata.org/safest-sources-of-energy Pricing carbon would mostly drive fossil fuels from the grid (unsurprisingly). It might boost nuclear as a result but it would boost renewables far more.
- m101 2y agoUltimately it's about energy return on investment. Solar + battery requires plenty of materials and energy to put together. It also needs to work in the middle of winter for it to be a fair comparison. When you consider it in that way it favours nuclear. It also has a shorter lifespan than nuclear, so that should be included. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_return_on_investment https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_return_on_investment
- ZeroGravitas 2y agoEnergy return on investment is pure crankery. It's a meaningless number that has basically no impact on any decision. And, if you take that crankery seriously, then renewables vastly outperform fossils and are speeding past nuclear on this metric too. It's basically impossible for energy tech to come down in price by magnitudes and not have increasing EROI as energy inputs cost money. This is predicted to continue. And despite this metric being great for renewables, you don't hear anyone crowing about it, because it's meaningless.
- lmm 2y agoSolar has a great price per watt as long as you don't mind getting all of your watts on some days and none on others.
- chgs 2y agoDepends on your location. Alaska is somewhat different to Hawaii
- IshKebab 2y agoProbably not if you include the cost of decommissioning and dealing with nuclear waste (which is still an unsolved problem).
- mltvc 2y agoDo you have any calculations to back this up? With which carbon price is this calculated?
- svara 2y ago> I don't think solar+battery is cost competitive if you were to replicate nuclear completely, but I've not looked at the numbers. Why are you commenting then? This is a complex, deeply researched topic. It's contentious enough already, no need to add more noise. "Looking at the numbers" is literally the one thing one needs to do in order to be able to add to this discussion.
- m101 2y agoI don't know the exact numbers but I know that's how it shakes out. This is not noise - it's just the truth. Here's something on carbon: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_return_on_investment https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_return_on_investment The problem with economic arguments is that externalities are not priced in. We don't price in the carbon of china solar manufacturing for example. The other problem of economic arguments is that regulations are expensive in nuclear, and it is orders of magnitude safer than next best alternatives. Which means: economic arguments miss the point when considered in the broader context.
- svara 2y agoCouldn't disagree more. The point you're making boils down to saying that because it's complicated, we can't rely on reason and rather have to go with gut feeling. The fact is that state of the art research into this does very much consider those points you think aren't being considered, and has been doing so for decades. Here is a link to such research: https://op.europa.eu/s/zX4i https://op.europa.eu/s/zX4i This particular EU project started in 1995. You can easily find much more on Google, from US sources as well if you choose to mistrust EU publications. I'm not commenting with more details ("numbers") because I very much am not qualified to give a detailed, well-founded opinion on this that doesn't randomly leave out half the story. But I do know enough to tell you aren't either, that the way you are talking about this is way under-complex and totally misses the mark in terms of where the state of the art is. One specific way (possibly of many) in which it does so is in ignoring the absurd exponential learning curve that renewables + storage technology is on.
- roenxi 2y ago
- jay_kyburz 2y ago>The price is a function of regulations. It is self imposed, so a concerted effort here could reduce prices. In other words, if you cut corners you can make nuclear cheap.
- m101 2y agoIt's not about cutting corners but regulating nuclear only to the extent that it is as safe as the next best alternative rather than orders of magnitude safer and until the point it is uneconomic. This is good for regulatory discussions and historical context: https://gordianknotbook.com/ https://gordianknotbook.com/
- zahlman 2y agoThe regulations imposed on nuclear in many places are absurd and not justified by any actual risk incurred. Especially considering the implications if the same regulations were imposed on coal plants - see e.g. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/coal-ash-is-more-radioactive-than-nuclear-waste/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/coal-ash-is-more-... .
- hughrlomas 2y agoIt is worth investing a little more on nuclear in the interest of energy security. It isn't always a race to the bottom. A diverse and robust energy grid is composed of various generation sources that differ in capacity factors, environmental impact, stability, availability, etc.
- ChrisRR 2y agoEnergy security is way more important than people make out. You'd think that politicians would focus on relying less on the countries that they have political tensions with
- devjab 2y agoIt depends on how you regulate the market. Part of the reason solar is still expensive on the market in Europe is because of regulations. To counter this to not kill growth you have various forms of economic incentives like tariffs for solar where the various government’s subsidies make up for the regulation. It’s to keep the fossil and nuclear energy market in Europe sustainable. Since we still heavily rely on these sources when the sun isn’t shining and the wind isn’t blowing. The battery industry is expected to grow a maddening percentage in the coming decade. Germany moving their renewable goal from 60-80% by (I’m not sure about the year but I think it’s 2030), alone increased the expected economic growth for supplying battery storage by 800%. There is nowhere near enough storage to make nuclear and fossil fuels obsolete yet however. Especially not if we also increase the EV market share. Solar isn’t optimal in very hot regions, however, as the efficiency goes down 0.3-0.5% in efficiency for every degree Celsius above 0 degrees Celsius. So in some regions nuclear is going to be a good option. I’m not personally a fan of nuclear because its safety depends on governments being willing to regulate the safety, but there is no denying that it’s still a much, much, better alternative to fossil fuels as far as delivering power on demand. This is how it looks in Europe. I have no idea how it looks in the US.
- belorn 2y agoThe battery industry being built at the moment in Sweden is having some major issues right now when investment money and subsidizes are running dry. The biggest actor are close to bankruptcy and rushing to find new sources of money. There seems a general pattern that if you need to build it outside of china, be that batteries, nuclear power plants or solar panels, it becomes too expensive.
- actionfromafar 2y agoChina is not afraid of subsidies and central planning, for better and worse.
- devjab 2y agoThe market is consolidating in the wake of the Russian invasion of Ukraine, the challenges with the global supply lines and the increased interest rates. A lot of the smaller projects backed by semiprofessional investors will be picked up by larger investment fonds. There is also still a couple of years until the European battery factories that are under construction will actually be operational. Unless the economy picks up I suspect we’ll see a lot of bankruptcies in the coming five years. Currently it’s not just the price of solar panel production that is an issue, it’s also that you make equal and safer money on other investments. Back when the interest rates were basically 0% the 3-7% returns on solar were very attractive but now that is just not the case. This is why you see Japan picking up as an attractive place for solar these years, because in Japan a 3-7% return is still very good.
- panick21_ 2y agoThis is a difficult question because if you build 1 plant, it clearly isn't. But there are large learning effect. Any nation that builds many plants, shares workforce and management rapidly drops cost. If you look at UAE building South Korean plants, they were finishing plants pretty rapidly and if they had simply continued, they could have turned 100% green in just a few more years at quite a low cost overall. It also depends on your energy market and financing. If you have a lot of solar, that simply destroys the market during certain periods, nuclear isn't gone be that profitable. But if you don't have a bunch of wind/solar and you actually value stable energy production. Then its much more reasonable. A nuclear plant can run for 80+ years. So it depends on interest rates you use.
- haccount 2y agoMake a cost calculation of how much solar and battery you need to keep your lights on during peak summer and then do the same calculation for how much solar and battery you need to keep the lights on in the middle of winter when a large scale 5 day blizzard. Pretend you are a metal foundry. Good luck.
- ben_w 2y agoBig fat wire to somewhere which isn't in a blizzard. Or just build the metal foundry in the non-blizzard-prone area in the first place, because the blizzard takes out power lines even if there was a nuclear reactor on the other end. I've done the maths, and I'd it wasn't for geopolitics, China makes enough Aluminium to make an HVDC grid so thick that it would have so little resistance that they could usefully connect every grid in the world for a cost of 250e9 USD for the Aluminium. Scaled down to just the USA, no international stuff, it's something you can easily do if someone convinces Trump or Musk to delete any internal obstruction.
- actionfromafar 2y agoYour last sentence sounds optimistic. Load-bearing "easily". Any convincing needs to demonstrate that also the "libs are owned".
- ben_w 2y agoIf they need to make it a culture war thing, they could just call it the Keystone pipeline of electricity, or the Trump Powerline, or similar. (As a non American, I may be misjudging this: I don't care too much about US culture wars, they don't connect to me any more than the US or Chinese sports teams whose names I don't know). You may be correct that I am over-optimistic, though for what it's worth my optimism is not universal to all of the aspects of Musk let alone Trump (mostly pessimistic about him), and not with regard to other greenhouse gas emissions besides electrical, heating, and transportation.
- haccount 2y ago"Thousands of miles of big wires are free" Why don't we just assume that power will be free and infinite and plug our grid into that assumption? We can even write it down on the socket and paint it green, based on how these arguments always read out that's the only thing needed to maintain electrified high tech society.
- zahlman 2y agoFrance leads the world in this department, with 70% of their electricity generation coming from nuclear, and serving as the world's largest net exporter of electricity (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_sector_in_France https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_sector_in_France). The consensus among sources I can readily find is that home consumers pay around 25-30 euro cents per KWh for electricity, and electricity production wholesales at around 8 euro cents per KWh. I'd say it's competitive, yes.
- mgoetzke 2y agoThat does not include the deficit these reactors ran up, nor all the subsidies they got from tax payers in many forms
- zahlman 2y agoSee also Canadian data (https://www.cns-snc.ca/learn-nuclear/basics-of-nuclear/how-much-does-nuclear-power-cost/ https://www.cns-snc.ca/learn-nuclear/basics-of-nuclear/how-m...). We're blessed to have abundant access to hydroelectric energy which is even cheaper to produce here, but otherwise we should be outraged by the decommissioning of nuclear plants - and, indeed, there have been recent campaigns to revive old plants and step up production.
- KennyBlanken 2y ago> but otherwise we should be outraged by the decommissioning of nuclear plants No, we shouldn't. Pull up charts for energy generation by type for the US, Canada, and Europe. Notice that solar and wind (especially wind) has skyrocketed and far eclipsed the capacity loss of nuclear. In the US, 7 times as much wind power is going in as nuclear plants being taken offline. In the UK, 30% of power generation (and growing) is from wind. Now, who do you think knows better here? The power companies who have been shutting down nuclear and coal plants because they're more expensive than wind and solar? Or...uh...you? If your answer is "me", then clearly you should get a job in energy production, or become an investor, and make a bazillion dollars knowing more than everyone else in the industry, in nearly every country. US, EU, UK...all seeing massive capacity growth in wind, far eclipsing nuclear decommissioning. Several countries have hit days in the last few years where they didn't need to have any fossil fuel plants online. > indeed, there have been recent campaigns to revive old plants and step up production. That is because the nuclear industry is lobbying desperately to stay alive. If you need to lobby the government to force power companies to use you while also handing you a big fat check written by taxpayers, that is proof you're not market competitive.