4 ms·
How does one even expect to use €20M of physical paper cash? You're going to get scrutiny from the government and/or financial institutions if you try to deposi
by ryandrake 2y ago
How does one even expect to use €20M of physical paper cash? You're going to get scrutiny from the government and/or financial institutions if you try to deposit it into a bank. I guess you'd "launder" it somehow, but does that even work anymore? Major purchases with cash put a giant government bullseye on your back these days. That is if you could actually make those purchases. I'd imagine most major purchases that someone legitimate might make (like buying a house or a car or a private jet) cannot be done with physical cash. Does the local Mercedes dealership really accept a suitcase full of cash? Even if you were to use it for all of your normal routine spending like groceries, you'd never go through €20M in your entire lifetime. So, career-fraudsters, I ask: in case I ever get my hands on millions in cash, what is my plan for using it?
- CommanderData 2y agoThe best person to ask would be the an good fraud chief. Maybe not this one though.
- daveguy 2y agoAnd a good fraud chief probably isn't going to tell you what they're looking for. :)
- yieldcrv 2y agoVery easy to launder 20M Be a promotor or promotion company, sell VIP tables at big event or music festival for 20,000 euro each, 9 out of 10 clients don’t show up (because they don’t exist and you made them up) Do it all summer, our economy is big enough to support this Your money is now clean from selling VIP tables Deposit cash, pay taxes, move on
- jknoepfler 2y agoSo the suggestion is that uh... the former fraud chief of the Spanish police... become a highly connected event promotor... with access to high profile clients who will actually spend 20,000 euro for a concert ticket... which we inexplicably demand and receive IN CASH... in exchange for VIP tables at high profile events that we magically have access to... while supplying 20,000 worth of services to the one VIP that did attend... and then repeat this how many times? While forging receipts for cash payments, which will sustain scrutiny from a cursory audit? Is there a missing /s? Like this is neither easy nor a plausible way to get away with financial fraud.
- yieldcrv 2y agothe answer was how to launder it, not how the fraud chief could launder it but either way, the answer is yes, and yes, and no sarcasm first, the investigation is never going to happen. but okay, lets play auditor the auditor is like “wow you paid your taxes on time and properly, but I hate that you have made money, so lets check the receipts” “hmmm, big cash, who are these clients?” “What!? you didn't do KYC on a transaction of 20,000 euro cash, 1,000 times!? ah but the parties were in Luxembourg and Austria and Monaco where such cash transaction limits don't exist, well Monaco’s is 30,000 euro per transaction, sorry for the inconvenience, on behalf of the King of Spain I apologize for our hubris in thinking this had anything to do with our ridiculous AML regime”
- dumah 2y ago“I ask: in case I ever get my hands on millions in cash, what is my plan for using it?” The question wasn’t how the Spanish Anti-Fraud chief would launder. A number of high-profile acts in the US have had managers convicted for this in connection with drug trafficking and other organized crime. It’s absolutely plausible. I’m not sure why you think a cursory audit would reveal that a cash receipt was forged.
- AshamedCaptain 2y agoThe actual truth is not very far from this. He actually had a cab / private ride company. Most of his rides were fake.
- yieldcrv 2y agoHow did it go from that to cocaine bust? TAM?
- HnUser12 2y agoI'd assume the same way they collected that much cash. Illegal deals. You want to bribe someone? use cash. Buy something of high value, put low value on the books but pay the rest in tax free cash? This is pure guess work
- thenthenthen 2y agoWall insulation?
- Waterluvian 2y agoIsn’t that why it ends up in a wall?
- netcan 2y agoBecome a high class escort, where legal. Very high class. Accept only cash.
- SilasX 2y agoWhat is that responding to? The problem is how to safely spend/clean that much cash. You're describing how to accumulate cash, which makes the problem (in the parent comment) harder.
- rapnie 2y agoYou can put money in the bank as legal income and pay your mortgage with that.
- SilasX 2y agoIf the idea is to claim to be an escort that only accepts cash, and then report already-possessed cash as income, while also depositing into a bank, then that could have been phrased more clearly. As it stands, it says to actually be as escort and get more money that you have to launder. Plus, there has got to be more critical information -- left out of the comment -- on how to get such a scheme to work. I highly doubt that most countries have left a massive hole in their anti-money-laundering systems that allows a person to simply claim to have massive transactions in cash with no (or easily fakeable) documentation.
- immibis 2y agoPlus, have fun convincing the authorities that you, a middle-aged man, are a high-class escort.
- SilasX 2y agoHaha there's an episode of Better Call Saul where nerdy, middle-aged Dan is noticed by the authorities as spending far more than he earns, and he explains it away as being an escort for rich fetishists who like seeing him sit on pies.
- dgfitz 2y agoI’d probably “dig it up from my backyard because I’m a newly minted metal detector hobbyist” or something. If the bills were marked though I think your point is solid, it’s hard to make bad money clean. Find some millionaire to pay you your own money for a job or something, give them 10%? I guess you still need to launder the money somehow. Now I want to know how people can turn illegal cash millions into clean laundered money in 2024.
- vinni2 2y agoOzarks
- thaumasiotes 2y agoThe TV show seemed fairly incoherent in its treatment of money laundering. They're explicit about the mechanics, sort of: the idea is that Marty shows up in a rural area with a big bag of cash and he needs to make it appear legitimate - and he does this by taking ownership stakes in local businesses. So far so good. What you'd actually want, in that kind of setup, is to hand the active owner of the business you just partnered with a big bag of cash, see that distributed into the flow of legitimate income from the business, and then have it returned to you as dividends or whatever on your ownership stake. But in the show, the goal is to then book a bunch of fake expenses against the business. So: 1. Purchase ownership stake in a hotel, for cash. The cash doesn't need to be legitimate. Money is transferred from you to the active owner. 2. Book fraudulent expenses for the hotel, making it look like it's spent a lot more money than it really has. No actual money changes hands anywhere. 3. Now you have a piddling amount of legitimate money from the hotel, and a big bag of illegitimate cash that you still haven't laundered. We've skipped the step where you hand the owner some of your illegitimate cash under the table and then the owner gives it back to you above the table, which is the part of money laundering that launders the money. If you want to embezzle from a running business while making your expenses look like business expenses, you can just do that; you don't need to start with a pile of illegitimate cash.
- defrost 2y ago
- Cthulhu_ 2y agoI'd be happy just paying groceries with cash for the rest of my life tbh. Although I can imagine a lack of grocery shopping on anyone's bank account would be suspicious. But moving to a country where nobody knows you / nobody cares would be an option too. Of course, then you get the challenge of moving 20 million in cash abroad...
- em-bee 2y agowhy? i never pay with card except for online purchases. i withdraw cash from an ATM. pretty much my whole withdrawal history on my bank account is ATM, rent and utilities and almost nothing else.
- ratrocket 2y agoI think the point you're replying to still stands, it's just moved "up" a level: If someone cared to look into the financial history of someone with no grocery store payments on their credit card (why are they looking into this person's spending history? Maybe because they're suspected of embezzling a lot of cash, I don't know!), found no credit card payments, looked further and found not enough ATM withdrawals to account for the amount of groceries the person presumably would've needed, the suspicion is still the same. The "investigators" just had to take it a step further. I doubt the person you're replying to thinks not a single person in the world pays cash at the grocery store, but I think it's reasonable to think that a lot of people do use credit cards at the grocery store (for points/rewards OR for actual credit; not to mention the convenience of not needing to have the cash on hand).
- ryandrake 2y agoLack of data is also a data point, and could be considered suspicious if most "normal law abiding" profiles produce data. Imagine you're the IRS and you see 1,000 people living in the same neighborhood, with comparable lifestyle profiles. 999 of them report similar incomes and have similar banking/investment profiles, but 1 of them reports drastically lower income and has little-to-no banking presence. Who are you going to apply more scrutiny to? Not saying it's fair, but I know an outlier when I see one.
- chucksmash 2y agoLocal dealerships will take cash but if you show up with enough of it (even a very large down payment amount), it's not uncommon that the person you try to give it to isn't sure they are allowed to accept it and will disappear to run it up the chain to get permission.
- toast0 2y agoI dunno about Eurozone, but I bought some land from my US county recently, and they told me I could provide a cashier's check or come with about $50,000 in cash. I went ahead and paid my bank fees to get a cashier's check.
- jknoepfler 2y agoThe articles notes he laundered a portion of the money through crypto and business fraud.
- sneak 2y agoI know lots of people who live very nice lives ($300-750k/year spend) using nothing but cash and never showing ID. There are a million ways to convert it to crypto, and a million ways to convert crypto to many of the other things one might want to use: gift cards, airline miles, etc. Same goes for gold. There are lots of shops in many countries that will buy gold for cash. Many countries still have hotels that accept cash. You can pay for a surprising amount of things in cash. One friend of mine simply has a rich buddy buy his cars and insurance, and he gives him paper cash each year for the sum of payments+insurance. Many landlords are happy to accept cash, especially if you are willing to pay a year in advance. Why do you think someone with that much money would be driving a car that's titled and plated in their own name?
- bagels 2y agoCan you name the top three ways to convert it in to crypto? I don't think there are literally one million ways.
- washadjeffmad 2y agoThis is one of those "if you don't already know" topics. The feds cracked down on it earlier this year leading up to the election, but it's back.
- bagels 2y agoWhy can't anyone say what it is?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- pessimizer 2y agoStart a car rental company by buying a bunch of luxury cars. Drive two or three yourself, and let your friends and family drive them. Once the cash is clean, sell them and close the business. All you need to do is make sure you have an actual phone number that someone can call to rent a car, and make sure your prices are outrageous. Give the job of answering the phone to your sister's kid, or your girlfriend.
- teractiveodular 2y agoThis is literally what our Fraud Chief did. > "Part of the money Sánchez Gil amassed in recent years was laundered through the purchase of crypto-currencies and a large fleet of private hire vehicles registered in the name of one of his relatives"
- ano-ther 2y agoGood question. In Switzerland you could buy real estate with cash until very recently. You could also open a front, say a barbershop or a restaurant, though convincing authorities you earned a million or more through that could be a stretch.
- emmelaich 2y agoCan you not, still? It may be reportable under AML rules, but it's still possible?
- ano-ther 2y agoYou are right and it seems I misread the media articles. Wouldn’t recommend it to GP though because they asked about circumventing AML and this would catch the fraud chief from the article.
- lupusreal 2y agoGo on lots of vacations, booking modest hotels within your legitimate means but then live it up going to all the expensive restaurants/etc you desire. Unless you've got somebody following you keeping track of what you do, nobody would figure it out. You'll probably never get through 20M like this but you should have plenty of fun.
- ajxs 2y agoHere in Australia real estate transactions aren't covered by the national AML/CTF act. You can currently buy Australian real estate with millions of dollars stuffed into a duffle bag, and the realtor you gave it to is under no obligation to report who they got it from. You'd still need to declare your real estate assets for taxation purposes though. Our government has been so slow to fix this problem. There are new rules coming into effect in 2026. Long overdue. I've heard estimates from people working on AML in the banking industry that around 15% of Australian real estate transactions involve some form of money laundering.
- tim333 2y agoIn Spain that was basically the case till a decade or two ago. There was a big case "53 guilty in Spain corruption trial" which signalled a change https://www.express.co.uk/news/world/434384/53-guilty-in-Spain-corruption-trial https://www.express.co.uk/news/world/434384/53-guilty-in-Spa...
- potato3732842 2y agoYou buy groceries and fake papers and a beater car registered to your fake identity. The point isn't to be rich. The point is that you can have a modest retirement while being off the grid. It's basically an insurance police that might let you have a life and freedom if the state wants to take those away, which of course is why the state goes so hard trying to prevent it. I could live my whole life with cash easily if I rented instead of owned.
- hoppp 2y agoSlowly. Just pay for everything with cash. You can even buy a house with it. Real estates will accept it.
- davidwritesbugs 2y agoConvicted ex-money launderer here. It's easy. Never dealt with €20M but the principle is scaleable, you smurf the money in ~€10k amounts through a network of trusted money mules. You buy a cash-only/mostly business like a car wash, take-away etc., rent half-a dozen shops and pump the cash through those, banks won't usually complain about cash coming in like this. €5k * 52 * {y stores}. There are entire areas of shops in some cities where no-one goes in but the business has a healthy turnover. There are lots of other methods too but those are trade secrets. "I could tell you but" etc. Easy 'big bang' methods like houses Rolls-Royces and art no longer work easily in most jurisdictions (oddly, apparently still in Oz from other comments). I miss the days when you could walk ito a bank with a shopping bag full of bundles of notes, I've done that - fun.
- bigbones 2y agoMoney laundering conviction to tech worker sounds like a great story, I'm sure plenty more than just me would love to hear more about your background if you were willing to share.
- davidwritesbugs 2y agoThey were sorta related, but I'm not saying more.
- adtac 2y agoIn your opinion, what fraction of the small restaurants in a typical city are engaging in money laundering at this scale? And if weighted by volume, what fraction?
- davidwritesbugs 2y agoI think it's not so much restaurants, as the setup and operation costs are higher, but countertop takeaways I think. I'm not aware of any data but I'd guess from conversations & experience it was just a fraction - single percents? But I have no clue really. For a good ML operation you need agility: easy quick and cheap to set up & teardown and move - hence takeaways, hand carwashes etc.
- gosub100 2y agoGet an auto dealers license and buy a bunch of used cars, one at a time in cash, and sell them for less than you paid. But not too cheap to get other dealers upset and report you.