5 ms·
The transition from GIMP 2.x to GIMP 3.0 took two decades
- 2Gkashmiri 2y agoAm I the only one who feels this "article" which is most probably an llm made and could have been a tweet only ?
- omoikane 2y agoThe main news is that Gimp made a release candidate for 3.0: https://www.gimp.org/news/2024/11/06/gimp-3-0-RC1-released/ https://www.gimp.org/news/2024/11/06/gimp-3-0-RC1-released/ I see that a few people have submitted that link, but they don't seem to be getting much attention: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=gimp%203.0%20rc1&sort=byDate&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que... So this article is boosting some visibility to the original news, while having little content otherwise.
- wrs 2y agoWhy, because the only 3.0 features it mentions are SVG icons in the toolbar and the plugin API? No, you're not the only one.
- mikae1 2y agoAnd not the non-destructive editing that is the big thing IMO. I will likely finally say bye to Photoshop. Lightroom was replaced with darktable two years ago.
- eco 2y agoI remember excitedly reading the announcement for gegl that was finally going to bring non-destructive editing to gimp. If I'd been told it was going to take at least 20 years to actually happen I would not have believed you. But whatever, I'm glad it's finally here.
- archerx 2y agoIf you want to replace Photoshop with something open source, I recommend Krita, everytime I give gimp a try it ends up being a frustrating waste of time.
- echelon 2y agoWhy is Gimp failing to reproduce the successes seen by Blender? Blender is huge, Gimp is miniscule. And why won't they change the name? It means not one, but two derogatory things.
- cookiengineer 2y agoNote that this was the case for Blender pre-2.8, too. The issue with any software of this complexity is tech debt. If anything, GIMP should be a big warning sign about what happens if you bet on e.g. a UI framework which moves on without you. GTK's development and release schedule is pretty aggressive, especially with the even releases being stable and the odd releases being unstable (which no other library on the planet decided to do so). A lot of cross platform software decided to a refactor to QT because of that, and I'd argue that the problem lies with upstream GTK and its failed API stability promises along the way. In open source projects, you cannot afford to bet on unstable UI frameworks because you don't have enough time to spend on refactors like this. If every second subminor GTK version breaks your code, it's just not possible to keep up with that. I'm actually impressed that GIMP wasn't fully abandoned because the sheer amount of code that needed to be rewritten is massive.
- bobajeff 2y agoLately, I was thinking that flatpack wouldn't be needed as much for Gnome dev if the libraries were more stable.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bonzini 2y agoPersonally I use Flatpak for two Electron apps (VSCode and Ferdium) and one GTK+ app that was never had issues with major versions (LibreOffice). GNOME apps in my case are all installed via rpm, so my experience seems to be the opposite. GTK broke API twice in over twenty years (2->3 and 3->4), and you can parallel-install older versions. I have never heard anyone having to install specific minor releases of GTK due to breakages in the application API (theming is a different story).
- brylie 2y agoI honestly quit recommending Gimp due to its name. Name changes are challenging of course, but not impossible. I understand the developers have a lot on their plates with the 3.0 transition and keeping up with GTK, but I really hope they can make a bit of time to prioritize a more community-friendly name for the project.
- vfgfg 2y agoI recommend not being so bothered about trivialities like names being misinterpreted.
- Arainach 2y agoNames matter a ton. I would never recommend a product called "Gimp" in a professional environment. The fact that the GIMP team has heard this feedback for multiple decades and ignored it says a lot - both about their ability to take community feedback and about how much they care about ever being a professional tool. There are two tools: BoringThing and Ninja Sex Death Cult. They both accomplish the same task, but I can recommend one to friends and family without immediately having to explain the name. So I'll use and recommend BoringThing.
- rzzzt 2y agoThe justification is present in the FAQ: https://www.gimp.org/docs/userfaq.html#i-dont-like-the-name-gimp-will-you-change-it https://www.gimp.org/docs/userfaq.html#i-dont-like-the-name-... This is very much the same notion that comes up whenever CockroachDB is mentioned. IIRC at one point they had a "white-label" project generator where you could come up with your own name and branding, and it would bake it into the checked out sources. It might make sense to create one for the photo editor as well. Edit: Ninja Sex Death Cult is a pretty good band name though!
- stephen_g 2y agoWhy would the name ‘CockroachDB’ be an issue? Cockroaches are just insects, but the word ‘gimp’ is actually a slur in some cultures (Cambridge dictionary labels the first definitions from both the US and UK as “informal offensive”). So I think it is worth changing the name in this case. Actually being a slur is a problem, in stark contrast to another recent example, where as far as I can see the reasons around changing Git’s ‘master’ branch name are totally artificial - the word ‘master’ is of course not a slur, and despite claims that it necessarily invokes the idea of slavery, it clearly has a multitude of uses that have nothing to do with slavery, such as ‘master recording’ or ‘masters degree’ so the idea that the word by itself is ‘not inclusive’ is quite baseless in my opinion. So being a slur is a real problem in a way that being the name of a slightly unpleasant insect (like CockroachDB) or hypothetically (but not really) invoking the idea of slavery really shouldn’t be.
- indulona 2y agomaybe in next 10 years it will be actually usable.
- ChoHag 2y ago[dead]
- wruza 2y agoLinux Desktop never needed GIMP like a regular Windows user never needed Photoshop. Photoshop is “start at work in the morning” software and GIMP is its “artist’s impression”. What Linux Desktop needed was Jasc/Corel Paint Shop Pro and its modern reincarnation Paint.NET. But it was never made, imo. Most tools are either too heavy and similar to GIMP, or indistinguishable from mspaint, or simple photo filters for “editing” photos.