5 ms·
The Internet Gopher from Minnesota
- bayareacommie 2y ago[dead]
- jhbadger 2y agoInteresting that the article brings up the original 1990s GopherCons (which were conferences for discussing the Gopher protocol). I'm mildly annoyed that the Go programming community (which uses a gopher as a mascot) has reused the name for their conventions, but I guess it's been unused for a while.
- halestock 2y agoThey also took the name of a programming language that predated Google’s go as well. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Go!_(programming_language) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Go!_(programming_language)
- nateb2022 2y agoThe only notoriety this language has appears to be because of a naming clash, not for any legitimate technical merit.
- The_Colonel 2y agoGo's success is there only because of Google, not for any technical merit. Without Google, Go would be a forgotten niche language.
- nateb2022 2y agoI would suggest you take a look at https://go.dev/solutions/case-studies https://go.dev/solutions/case-studies Whether or not Google’s backing is part of the equation, Go’s success in the real world speaks for itself.
- jhbadger 2y agoNot to mention the Chinese board game weiqi (known in English as Go from the Japanese).
- anthk 2y agoGoogle's Go? Go itself predates Google, as it's founded upon plan9 C's compiler/linkers and then Alef/Limbo.
- jandrese 2y agoIt seems to me that Gopher just failed to keep up with the times. Embedding images into the page was a killer feature for HTML and Gopher was still doggedly text based because they were still supporting the VT100 users that had been the core userbase. Plus the web went on to support text formatting, tables, and even eventually layout. The article isn't entirely correct about the early web being completely free. Netscape was not free software, at least on paper. In practice they didn't try to stop people from spreading it far and wide and I think the sales were somewhat modest despite being the core element of a technological revolution. Also, I guess NCSA Mosiac was technically around, but it lacked enough features to make it a second class citizen compared to Netscape Navigator.
- snvzz 2y agoNot allowing embedded appearance-restricting stuff (such as image or stylesheets) is, in hindsight, what makes gopher great. And, conversely, the popular WWW crap.
- parl_match 2y agoGopher was a much more highly structured format. Even if they'd included inline images, they didn't really have a day 0 formatting or layout language that allowed for nesting. There were other locked in choices too, like using a 8 bit value for file type.
- ryukoposting 2y agoGopher was built for a pre-HAL world, where you couldn't just assume that every user had a graphics card that your software supported - hell, a lot of them might not have graphics at all. In that environment, lack of embedded multimedia was a selling point due to interoperability. If you had a computer and a phone line, you could access Gopher's primeval web. Graphics and sound be damned. For what it's worth, I have a copy of Netscape on a CD-ROM that came with a copy of PC/Computing sometime around 1994-1995. For those magazine subscribers, it was "free" if you squint a little.
- detourdog 2y agoMore than graphics card one needed an an ip address for the graphical web.
- a1o 2y agoCool seeing the Archie Comics references!
- dwheeler 2y ago> At GopherCon 1993, it was announced that Gopher servers would need to pay for the privilege of using the protocol... Well, that didn’t work out. People were angry and many felt betrayed. They weren’t quiet about any of it either. > If one were to attempt to identify a single failure of Gopher in competition with the web, it would be the licensing costs. No such fee existed for the World Wide Web. This, a thousand times. I watched as this happened. The instant that announcement was made, gopher was finished. Gopher might have lost later as HTML kept adding features, but by the time those features were added to HTML, gopher had already lost.
- hinkley 2y agoSimilarly, Bertrand Meyer killed Eiffel by trying to charge money for the compiler, and missing the nascent OSS movement. Java was an inferior language in a few important ways but the compiler and runtime were free. He could not compete with both C++ and Java. A number of people in that era thought this was a fad and that business as usual would prevail.
- SeenNotHeard 2y agoThe licensing fee wasn't the sole reason, but it certainly sounded the death knell for Gopher and gave users reasons to look elsewhere. For all the gauzy what-could-have-been speculations about Gopher, it really was more like a hierarchical wiki. WWW's freestyle document model quickly expanded to an application platform that could support all manner and style of services. Fees or not, Gopher didn't have a chance.
- msla 2y agoTo expand on this: The Gopher standard mixes a document format with a networking protocol. The HTTP standards don't say a damn thing about HTML, but the Gopher standard defines a standard for sending directory information to a client, right down to the fixed list of file types that can occur in a directory. (MIME Type? What's that?) This is the hypertext part of Gopher, as only those directories can link to other places, so constraining that gives you a nice, simple way to have pretty plain-text sites with an enforce separation of lists of links, one one hand, and images and documents, on the other, which HTTP has no equivalent for. (Not just file types, in fact, in that they have a special type for tn3270 telnet sessions. Yep, those IBM mainframes with block-mode terminals were quite important back then, but it's a bit out of place now. They also have a type for GIF and a generic 'client-figures-it-out' image type. How forward-thinking.) https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc1436 https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc1436
- jmclnx 2y agogopher is still active, see gopher://sdf.org, access via lynx
- snvzz 2y agoEfficient too. Even the original IBM PC can comfortably browse gopher sites with gopherus[0]. 0. https://gopherus.sourceforge.net/ https://gopherus.sourceforge.net/
- rickcarlino 2y agoIf the idea of a text first structured hyper text protocol interests you, consider taking a look at the Gemini protocol, a modern equivalent. https://geminiprotocol.net/ https://geminiprotocol.net/
- akira2501 2y agoOr if you're interested in the old school mainframe equivalent. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISPF https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISPF
- snvzz 2y agoNot modern nor equivalent. More of an artistic statement of some sort. Gemini cannot be upgraded (or fixed). It was done as a one-off. Gopher lives on.
- doublerabbit 2y agoBetamax instead of VHS 8-Track instead of cassette Minidiscs instead of CDs Yahoo instead of Google Gopher instead of HTTP I want to believe that such alternative universe exists. How do I get there? I'm tired of this one...
- anthk 2y agoWell: gopher://hngopher.com HN gopher://magical.fish Huge portal, the news section is big gopher://gopherddit.com Reddit gopher://sdf.org SDF blogs gopher://gopher.icu Nice site gopher://hoi.st Retroprogrammer
- hulitu 2y ago> Yahoo instead of Google TBH i never understood the Google hype: i grew up with Altavista and Yahoo. (and astalavista.box.sk FWIW)
- relistan 2y agoGopher was how I first got on the Internet in 1991. Cleveland FreeNet (like an Internet BBS) supported connecting to other FreeNets and Buffalo FreeNet had gopher. I searched lots of ftp sites, read lots. You also had 1.5MB of space you could use to download software to temporarily on Buffalo FreeNet. With gopher, two freenets, and zmodem, I downloaded and installed my first Linux system in 1992: 0.95a running on a 386sx16 with 4mb of memory and a 40mb HD. Gopher opened up the Internet when I was a kid in high school and the web wasn’t a thing. I’ll forever be grateful.
- eichi 2y agoI thought it was about Golang mascot.
- anthk 2y agogopher://gopher.com gopher://magical.fish As for the client, you can use Lynx under Unix/Linux and Lagrange under everything else.
- icedchai 2y agoI first got involved with the Internet in the early 90's (summer of 1991, I think), right when Gopher was taking off, but before the WWW. Times were so much simpler.
- navanchauhan 2y agoShameless plug but I maintain a gopher client for iOS/macOS/visionOS: https://web.navan.dev/iGopherBrowser/ https://web.navan.dev/iGopherBrowser/
- danslacker 2y ago[flagged]
- lindner 2y agoConfirmed! I was a big metalhead \m/ and was responsible for all the Unix-y things and spent a lot of time maintaining the community. Other hostnames we had from bands and SciFi huskerdu / nirvana / supernova / arcwelder hafnhaf (big bonus points if you can figure this one out, lol!) ashpool / tessier / joeboy / countzero
- FerretFred 2y agoCheck out my gopher server using lynx gopher://gopher.petergarner.net ... Enjoy!