7 ms·
Argentina bans dollar purchases for savings
- thdn 14y agoAnd why is this on HN ?
- hackNightly 14y agoHN isn't only for tech articles. It's for articles that may interest the tech community. You'll often find posts on politics, finance, and other obscure topics as well.
- davidw 14y agoThe guidelines indicate that most political articles are off topic: > Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon. it's probably off-topic. Political articles really should not be here: it's a poisonous topic that, on a site like this, usually just rehashes the same old things, which makes them not particularly 'gratifying of one's intellectual curiosity'. This article isn't really obscure, it appeared on Bloomberg.com, and the Argentinean government fooling around with foreign exchange, banks, and statistics is not really news either. An example of an article that I think would be more in the spirit of hacker news might be something about options trading evolving between medieval Florence and Flanders, or something like that...
- eragnew 14y agoI'm not trying to be argumentative here, but in my view, the article isn't just 'political'. With currency and money involved, there is an 'economic' angle that I, personally, want to learn about. And with a government being involved, there are moral/philosophical issues that I, personally, want to learn about. So for me, this article gratifies my intellectual curiosity. I guess what I'm trying to say is that the link may seem off-topic to you, but it's highly relevant to me. And there's nothing wrong with any of that. And of course, just because an article shows up here doesn't mean you have to read it :)
- scott_s 14y agoThe front page is a zero-sum game. Every article that appears does so at the expense of another article. The articles that appear on the front page get the most comments, which drive the community. I'm not arguing against this article, nor am I arguing that all articles on the front page should appeal to me. However, I am arguing that your final line of reasoning does not hold in general.
- mikeash 14y agoI disagree that the front page is a zero-sum game. A front page filled with good variety has more value than a front page filled with repetitive articles on the same basic subjects. Whether this particular article is good variety or not is beyond what I'm willing to address, but I don't think it's correct to describe the front page as a zero-sum game, and too much conformity can be harmful.
- scott_s 14y agoI think you're correct that I misused "zero-sum," since the utility of the front page is not always the same; it can increase or decrease based on the quality of the articles. I incorrectly used it to describe a situation where the gain for one is the loss of another, which is a necessary but not sufficient condition for a zero-sum game. Regarding your point, I think we're dangerously veering into platitudes. Of course I agree that a front page with "good" variety is better than a page with "repetitive" articles. And of course I agree that "too much conformity" is a bad thing. But I was originally countering the commonly spoken notion "If you don't like it, don't read it!" Because of the gain-for-one-is-loss-for-another nature of the front page, exactly what appears on the front page drives the community. If too many off-topic posts become the norm, HN will become a general interest site, and lose the community that makes it so valuable. edit: There is zero reason to downvote mikeash. I tried to correct with an upvote of my own, but apparently at least two HN readers are mistaken.
- heelhook 14y agoThat makes me wonder about what the economics of having a dynamic number of articles in the front page instead of the fixed 30 would look like.
- Thrymr 14y agoBecause of the opportunity to promote Bitcoins.
- forinti 14y agoThis has always been the rule in Brazil. In Uruguay you can open an account in pesos, dollars, or euros (but it is a very small country that depends on banking, like the swiss). Are there other countries where you can open an account with a foreign currency?
- to3m 14y agoYou can open dollar and euro accounts in the UK. Don't know if it gets any more niche than that (aside from being able to open accounts in £ ;).
- _delirium 14y agoI believe it's the rule in the U.S. as well; deposit accounts must be in dollars. Several American banks offer business accounts that let you maintain multiple currencies, but they do so by storing (on paper) the other currencies in the care of a foreign branch (see the asterisk note at the bottom of Wells Fargo's info: https://www.wellsfargo.com/com/international/businesses/accounts/multi-currency https://www.wellsfargo.com/com/international/businesses/acco...).
- rprasad 14y agoIt's not the rule in the U.S. that deposits must be in dollars. (Most banks will let you open up foreign-currency accounts...they just charge more. A lot more.) However, foreign currency-denominated accounts are subject to yearly gain/loss recognition as the value of the foreign currency changes compared to the dollar. This could potentially trigger income taxes on the unrealized gain, effectively (and usually) reducing or eliminating any interest earned. It's also a PITA for banks to deal with the compliance paperwork.
- babblefrog 14y agoIn the US, Everbank offers accounts in several currencies.
- eigenvector 14y agoYou can open US dollar accounts in Canada.
- jerguismi 14y agoBlatant advertisement: start your local bitcoin exchange today, escape the tyranny! http://localbitcoins.com/cash_exchange_howto http://localbitcoins.com/cash_exchange_howto ;)
- javert 14y agoThis is one reason why Bitcoin can be useful. Maybe this will lead to additional Bitcoin adoption in Argentina.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- martinrd 14y agoThis is one of a couple moves by the Argentinian government that slows down tech innovation and development. You neither can import any electronics (or anything at all, except you also export for an equivalent amount). So you're stuck with what the government held companies provide.
- dysoco 14y agoSadly, yep... that's true. I recently moved back to Argentina from Spain, and for example they just released the Samsung Galaxy S II, and it's really expensive. Don't even think of buying a Tablet, Phone or whatever, you just can't. Plus, they want us to buy the shitty laptops/netbooks that are manufactured here in Argentina, like Bangho for example, I think we also produce Lenovo, but I like them. Not to mention we also have restrictions importing books... yes, books!
- digitalengineer 14y agoI'm very curious why you would want to move to Argentina. I've just read a blog from a guy (Ferfal) about moving out of Argentina because of all the violence, repression and hardship. 'Surviving Argentina' He predicted this news as well. http://ferfal.blogspot.nl/search/label/Argentine%20Collapse http://ferfal.blogspot.nl/search/label/Argentine%20Collapse "They investigated your finances if you bought a big screen TV for the world cup or send your kids to a private school. In a way they “nationalized” and ruined private health care by including every crappy social medical plan into private health care services that used to be of acceptable quality. They banned the purchase of foreign currency, pretty much froze importations even taking a Fahrenheit 451 twist when they banned the importation of books, like a poor taste Bradburian joke. No one saw this coming? Really? Hey, those guys that said Argentina was great for expats and that expropriation wasn’t a risk, I suppose they crawled back under a rock in Salta or somewhere." Is Spain in such a terrible state that Argentina looks better? Any thoughts?
- rdl 14y agoA friend of mine recently moved from California to Argentins to be with a guy (sigh). It is even worse because she is ethnically Chinese, so people see her on the street and assume she works in a laundry, when in fact she is a PhD holding research scientist and manager at a Fortune 50. Unless you have weird ties to Argentina like this, it seems irrational to move there.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- pmelendez 14y agoThis happens in Venezuela since 10 years ago and it has been proved to be a very bad idea. However, this is should not be in HN. This kind of politics articles just brings undesired controversy.
- rubyrescue 14y agoAs I live here and have a consulting company here, I'm familiar with the complexities of dealing with dollars. I'm a hacker by nature and spend a lot of time now trying to 'hack' the financial world of the Argentine peso. In that sense I think the article is worth posting. Incidentally, Argentina must do this because they have no access to foreign capital markets due to things like seizure of YPF, devaluation of the peso in 2001, and failure to pay back the lenders they still owe, etc. Foreign currency reserves just keep dwindling. As China slows down and demand for soybeans drops, Argentina is really, really going to have a hard time. So though it seems crazy there is some "reason" for it (I'm not trying to make a political comment, I personally think it's crazy and they should radically open the market, but my point is that it's not exclusively xenophobia that is driving this policy). Unfortunately the policy just pushes the trade to the black market. One of the interesting things here is that if you need pesos, and you have some access to USD, you make an instant 20-25% on your money. The "black market" (they call it "blue" here because it seems nicer) continues to diverge. If you're a hobbyist economist like myself, it's really fascinating to watch market risk priced into a currency in realtime as seen by the "blue"-vs-official rate spread.
- kokey 14y agoHaving to fake an exchange rate sounds like the economic conditions in badly run countries like Venezuela, Zimbabwe, Russia, etc. What I am wondering is, with a depressed economy like that in Argentina, what is crime and personal safety like? I am particularly wondering about violent crimes for money, because how people react to a bad economy is determined quite strongly by culture and not just the economic situation alone.
- rkaplan 14y agoAll the economic talk these days is about Greece and Spain, but Argentina seems to be on its knees economically based on the kind of measures they've pursued as of late. A few months ago, they deployed cash-sniffing dogs in airports to prevent people from bringing large amounts of money out of the country. Yes, cash-sniffing dogs. They have a tax evasion rate of around 40%, and they routinely lie about economic statistics and go after watchdog groups that try to publish the real numbers. I'm not sure how long that can last as a national economic policy. Sources: http://www.globalpost.com/dispatches/globalpost-blogs/que-pasa/argentina-deploys-dogs-sniff-out-cash http://www.globalpost.com/dispatches/globalpost-blogs/que-pa... http://www.economist.com/node/21548242 http://www.economist.com/node/21548242
- janus 14y agoMeanwhile, the president says "we're resisting while the world collapses on top of us", so many lies.
- jswinghammer 14y agoThe US banned using foreign coins in the mid 19th century as a misguided attempt to bolster patriotism. Americans routinely used Spanish coins in private transactions up until this point. I think (don't entirely remember if) part of the reason was to encourage the use of US silver coins which had been driven out of circulation due to the US government overvaluing gold relative to silver. The basic problem was that by having the US dollar fixed to two exchange rates that one was always being driven out of circulation as the exchange rate changed. This lead to the free silver movement and the Populists getting excited about seeing only silver used to back dollars. This is a misguided attempt to trap people into their own crappy currency. The US currency isn't any better fundamentally but as of now we don't force citizens to hold dollars for savings.
- maeon3 14y agoThe argentine peso inflates very rapidly, then the government slashes zeros off the end of the money. Why on earth would I work hard to exchange toil for receipts that don't hold their claim on human labor? If people convert the peso to the dollar then they can store wealth. What kind of monster forces people to store labor in recipts made up in diappearing ink? Isn't that watered down slavery? To toil and be unable to save any excess for later? Its a fate worse than death for me.
- batista 14y agoThe kind of "monster" that wants the country as a whole to survive, not just the few lucky ones that can "store wealth".
- ninguem2 14y agoThese monsters should then vote for someone with economic sense, not the clusterfuck of idiots that you've been putting in power since the 1940's.
- Uchikoma 14y agoStoring "wealth" is by many regarded as the most promising way for people out of poverty.
- janus 14y agoIf you can't store wealth, how are you supposed to buy something like a house if the only way you could do it is by saving for many years?
- Spooky23 14y agoI'd ask you the inverse question. What monster keeps inflation so low as to make it impossible for regular people to earn anything on modest savings, yet provides a powerful incentive for wealthy individuals and corporations to hoard capital. Right now, people and small businesses are being starved of capital, because the folks with capital have no incentive to spend it. Question: Do you think that Microsoft would make a business decision to park nearly $60,000,000,000 in cash if there were a 6% inflation rate?
- abtinf 14y agoThis is a pretty standard example of capital controls being implemented in non-free countries by the bureaucratic elite in order to impose hidden costs on their people and to prevent the people from responding rationally to terrible economic policy. The reasons are easy to understand. People are willing to take on the risk of owning hard currency (gold, dollars, euros) if they believe that their nominal currency has greater risk. For example, if a government is spending recklessly, there is serious risk of inflation. Or, if the government has forced interest rates to be too low (well below inflation), then people want to hedge against that too. By forbidding the ownership of hard currency, the government forces individuals to use the local currency. They must save in this currency, which drives down interest rates and provides cheap capital to their government. And it prevents (for a short time) exchange rates from significantly changing, because it effectively limits the supply of the local currency and reduces demand for hard currency. EDIT: I forgot to mention the other reason governments do this - it's a great way to force the people to bear the burden of paying down national debt. If the country has significant debt, then the bureaucratic elite have a huge incentive to pursue a policy of inflation, so that the debt becomes less burdensome over time. This well written article from The Economist explains how the west used this technique in the post-ww2 era: http://www.economist.com/node/18834259?story_id=18834259 http://www.economist.com/node/18834259?story_id=18834259
- adjwilli 14y agoArgentina has direct elections of the president, multiple political parties, and mandatory voting. How does that make them a "non-free country"? If anything that makes Argentines more free than citizen of the United States. Also what is your criteria for a hard currency vs a soft currency? It seems weird to group the US Dollar and Euro with gold and put the Argentine Peso in a separate group.
- JumpCrisscross 14y agoA hard currency is a globally traded currency expected to serve as a reliable store of value. The Argentine peso isn't widely enough traded, not to mention subject to devaluation, to even remotely qualify as a hard currency.
- jan_g 14y agoIs this stuff still going on in the world? I thought that such rules died with the fall of east European regimes around 1990. Well, I'm glad I can open a savings account in all major world currencies (at the moment, following currencies are possible at my bank: CHF, GBP, USD, AUD, CAD, DKK, NOK, SEK, JPY and of course EUR, which is official currency). More, it's possible to mix different currencies in one account.
- gaius 14y agoThe North Koreans did something similar a couple of years ago: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/8394987.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/8394987.stm
- digitalengineer 14y agoCorrect, and all those currencies float. Guess in what direction? Down. Have a look at 'Currency Wars' and see how all country's drive down the value of their currency in order to export more easily. As they do, paying off debt becomes easier. However, for people that actually save money (or who are on fixed income like pensioners) it means their purchasing power becomes much smaller. Link to Currency Wars: http://www.amazon.com/Currency-Wars-Making-Global-Portfolio/dp/1591844495 http://www.amazon.com/Currency-Wars-Making-Global-Portfolio/...
- jan_g 14y agoThe problem is always this: what can I buy with the money I have? If all major currencies (including home currency) float down, then I don't lose very much. However, if my home currency loses 10% or more per month relative to other currencies, then I would very much like to have access to foreign currency. This was true 30 years ago in my country and this is probably true in Argentina today.
- kokey 14y agoThe problem with them all moving down is that it affects the value of your savings. At the same time the fact that they are all moving down is supposed to make investing them in things that creates or retains value more attractive.
- dlapiduz 14y agoThis strategy has been tried way too many times before. It never worked and you can tell it is the beginning of a new debacle. Stuff like this makes me glad that I left the country.
- janus 14y agoThis is not new, it's been almost impossible to buy dollars since last november, but it has been made official just recently. The problem with this ban is that there are really no ways to save money here, unless you have a significant amount of capital to buy a house or apartment. What are we salaried workers supposed to do with the percentage of our monthly income that we can save? The only alternative seems the black market, or spending everything in things you might need in the next few months but with no real resale value. With a 25% inflation rate, saving in pesos equals losing money. What can we do?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- adjwilli 14y agoI'm not always in favor of what Christina does, but it is generally good to have a diversity of economic models active in the world, for the same reason biodiversity is important. While most of the world struggled with the 2008 economic crisis - and Europe still struggles with it - Argentina shrugged it off. Imagine if another longer lasting crisis occurs within the US hegemonic sphere. Countries like Argentina, which have one foot outside that sphere, will be able to survive and perhaps even lead growth elsewhere. Life times of economic crises in Argentina have taught Argentines to depend on no one but themselves, which means protectionism sometimes.
- Daishiman 14y agoWe shrugged it off because soy prices are at a record high and the state gets huge amounts of cash from those exports. Living and dying by the sword of commodities prices is not progress.
- wslh 14y agoArgentina is applying the same model every time! Just when the country is growing it is not about the model but about International conditions (commodities prices increasing 2x)
- cs702 14y agoProhibited from saving in dollars through official channels, Argentines will turn to whatever other choices they have: black-market dollars, precious metals like gold, and (I would expect) even alternative currencies like Bitcoin.[1] [1] http://cs702.wordpress.com/2011/05/29/on-the-potential-adoption-and-price-appreciation-of-bitcoin-in-the-long-run/ http://cs702.wordpress.com/2011/05/29/on-the-potential-adopt...
- Uchikoma 14y agoFunny how nevertheless many people promote Argentina as a model for Greece.
- heelhook 14y agoA great model of what would happen if they go with the seemingly easy way out. http://www.cavallo.com.ar/wp-content/uploads/2011/10/Greece-should-restructure.-revised.pdf http://www.cavallo.com.ar/wp-content/uploads/2011/10/Greece-...
- rafaelm 14y agoSeems like Cristina wants to follow the venezuelan model. At least they have some real internal production, not like Venezuela where the only thing we produce is oil and everything has to be imported at black market dollar rates. Ultra high inflation, here we go!