8 ms·
>And that would be fine, prices go up over time after all, but all of that is on the back of pay, that for most people, has not gone up anywhere close to enough
by gruez 2y ago
>And that would be fine, prices go up over time after all, but all of that is on the back of pay, that for most people, has not gone up anywhere close to enough to cover all of that, if it's gone up at all.
BLS data shows real (ie. inflation adjusted) wages has gone up since the pandemic.
https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LES1252881600Q https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LES1252881600Q
- AnimalMuppet 2y agoThe data may show that. The people don't feel that. (Many of them don't see it in their budgets, either.)
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- croes 2y agoYou don’t feel earth rotation either but it still exists. You can’t argue about feelings
- psychoslave 2y agoPeople definitely can feel the impact of earth rotation on a daily basis. They literally would not even have the notion of a day without it actually. https://sciencenotes.org/what-would-happen-if-the-earth-stopped-rotating/ https://sciencenotes.org/what-would-happen-if-the-earth-stop...
- croes 2y agoYou can measure the effects but people don’t feel it, just ask flat earthers
- pupppet 2y ago[flagged]
- InDubioProRubio 2y agoReality is always a social construct, and by having air superiority you can talk anything into reality.
- no_wizard 2y agoBut it’s a skewed picture of the actuality, which that those wage gains didn’t make up for the 40 years of stagnation preceding it. If wage gains kept pace with productivity gains it’d be a very different and vastly better economic story for the average American
- gruez 2y ago>which that those wage gains didn’t make up for the 40 years of stagnation preceding it. It stagnated in 2008-2016 but they still voted for obama, but when it finally started rising in 2016 they voted for trump?
- no_wizard 2y agoIt wasn't really rising in 2016. The flat wage growth lasted past 2020, with a relatively recent blip, but it has not meaningfully risen to outpace the stagnation that existed for decades. If wages increased with productivity increases we'd be in better shape overall as a society, but here we are.
- ZeroGravitas 2y agoVoting for the guy that complained American wages were too high and thinks tariffs are paid by other countries will definitely not help. Please be more specific if you are explaining why American voters have got angry and done something stupid that will make things worse or if you are defending that stupidity as a good thing that will help the situation you are talking about.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoLike Brexit, you have to let the electorate find out the hard way.
- schnebbau 2y agoMy theory is that social media has given people this skewed perspective of reality where everyone else appears to be rich and living in luxury. This makes their own lives, in which they are still better off than 99.9% of the history of humanity, feel worse.
- no_wizard 2y agoor you know, wages stagnated for 40 years and haven't kept pace with productivity gains, and it was inevitable that this would wear most American citizens down and we'd feel it more and more over time. The most recent wage gains failed to make up for this fact https://www.cnbc.com/2022/07/19/heres-how-labor-dynamism-affects-wage-growth-in-america.html https://www.cnbc.com/2022/07/19/heres-how-labor-dynamism-aff...
- nsxwolf 2y agoWhen your lifestyle suddenly has to change in drastic ways because of a rapid increase in prices none of this makes anyone feel any better. "Think about how much worse it COULD be, kids!"
- gruez 2y ago>When your lifestyle suddenly has to change in drastic ways because of a rapid increase in prices Where's the evidence this is happening for a majority (or even something vaguely resembling one) of people? I've already posted official statistics that show inflation adjusted median wages are up.
- nsxwolf 2y agoOk, well, my wages aren't up, and everybody I know's wages aren't up either. Being told this over and over again, that everything is great, despite what's obvious to our own personal experience is why you got the result you got today.
- otteromkram 2y agoWe're still at 390 levels of cost in a 370 world.
- gruez 2y ago>real (ie. inflation adjusted) wages
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- no_wizard 2y agoBut still haven’t matched productivity gains since the 1970s[0] Everyone likes to point this out like it somehow made up for all the wage stagnation of the last 40 years and it most definitely did not. Not to mention these wage gains are slowing fast. [0]: https://www.cnbc.com/2022/07/19/heres-how-labor-dynamism-affects-wage-growth-in-america.html#:~:text=Published%20Tue%2C%20Jul%2019%202022,to%20suppress%20their%20workers'%20wages https://www.cnbc.com/2022/07/19/heres-how-labor-dynamism-aff....
- gruez 2y ago>But still haven’t matched productivity gains since the 1970s[0] The gap might be real, but it's existed for decades. Moreover at least when it comes to explaining why people voted for Trump: while I have no data to support it, "we're poorer because of inflation" is a much more popular sentiment/election issue than "the top 1% are taking the gains for themselves", especially among republican voters.
- no_wizard 2y agoConsidering his very pronounced and persistent support of broad tariffs on all imports, I'm not sure why people would vote for Trump and the Republican platform he steers if they're worried about the economy and prices. This will absolutely drive prices up across the board, exacerbating the situation, while the Republican platform has no proposal for even attempting to offset that, they also want to put the boots on the neck of labor, as it were (see Project 2025 or even the miniaturized version Agenda 47)
- endemic 2y ago> the top 1% are taking the gains for themselves They deserved it because they worked hard for it!
- ggu7hgfk8j 2y agoIt's worth keeping in mind that inflation is a theoretical construct based on assumptions and formulas that may not apply for every individual or subpopulation.
- gruez 2y ago>It's worth keeping in mind that inflation is a theoretical construct based on assumptions and formulas That might be so, but it's better than people's vibes, which famously flip-flops based on whether their preferred party is in power. >that may not apply for every individual or subpopulation I never claimed that, but the parent comment did imply real wages have not gone up "for most people".
- auggierose 2y agoSo, CPI adjusted it means that median people are "doing better" about $30 (also CPI adjusted) than in 1980 per week? Given all the "progress" in that time, that is just not enough, and that is what people feel. People feel they don't have the money to participate in modern life, and yeah, an extra $30 per week is definitely not enough to do that. Also, the median stats say nothing about how people below it are doing. By definition, that is 50%, and that is also about the number of people voting for Trump, alongside your run-of-the-mill racists and fascists.
- gruez 2y ago>So, CPI adjusted it means that median people are "doing better" about $30 (also CPI adjusted) than in 1980 per week? They're actually doing about $50 better, because there was a recession in 1980. Moreover, the $50 (or $30) dollars are "1982-84 CPI Adjusted Dollars", not today's dollars. In today's dollars it would be $158.28 (or $94.97). Moreover, given most people's expectation and discussion for income increases are the raw dollar amounts (ie. not inflation adjusted), it's not a fair benchmark for real wage increases. >By definition, that is 50%, and that is also about the number of people voting for Trump, alongside your run-of-the-mill racists and fascists. Given how the votes are roughly 50-50, you can make the opposite argument for Harris, replacing "racists and fascists" with "college students and woke activists".
- class3shock 2y agoTheir methodology produces results that are not representative of the economic situation of average american families. The average household income is 80k(ish) the average house is 420k(ish) In Bethlehem, PA (a fairly middle of the road place tax wise) that means $5050 take home pay a month and a mortgage payment (FHA 3.5 down, 6.7 interest) of $2650 a month. That is more than half your pay just on a mortgage, not pmi, not insurance, not utilities, not anything else. Do this calculation across the country with localized numbers, do it with rent instead. Add a car and insurance for it into the mix. Then try adding in health insurance, groceries, etc. You are going to find that the numbers result in average people being squeezed and guess what? That lines up with peoples actual experience. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/paycheck-to-paycheck-definition/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/paycheck-to-paycheck-definition... https://www.minneapolisfed.org/article/2024/amid-a-resilient-economy-many-americans-arent-ready-for-a-rainy-day https://www.minneapolisfed.org/article/2024/amid-a-resilient... My interpretation of this is that pay has not kept up with inflation. Edited to be less witty
- itissid 2y agoThere was a graphic in John Kings (CNN). Segment that showed a vast majority of the counties had wages falling behind inflation. This is just extremely real for the 5k(ish) takehome pay guy. I noticed the 4.5 ish $ eggs and milk. The overall situation of housing and college costs have been increasing for a while this last round of inflation really was a big part of the last straw.
- gruez 2y ago>There was a graphic in John Kings (CNN). Segment that showed a vast majority of the counties had wages falling behind inflation. Source? Is this simply because rural counties are doing worse than urbanized counties, and there are more rural counties than urbanized counties, such that if you don't account for population you'll come to the conclusion that "vast majority of the counties had wages falling behind inflation", even though that's not true for the country as a whole?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- oefrha 2y agoWhen (some) people feel they’re worse off and blame it on the government, telling them government produced statistics says they’re actually better off is totally going to make them trust the government more. /s Edit: Without the snark, lots of people believe their rent, grocery bills, energy bills etc. have gone up a lot more than official inflation numbers (and that can be true even if the inflation numbers are “accurate” for some definition of accurate), and you’re not going to convince them using anything derived from these inflation numbers.