5 ms·
Boeing ends crippling strike as workers accept latest offer
- toomuchtodo 2y agohttps://archive.today/YWHmq https://archive.today/YWHmq
- pixelatedindex 2y agoRead somewhere that they get 12% match on 401k. No pensions, but there’s almost none of that in today’s world.
- brightball 2y agoPensions are absolutely crippling to a company long term.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoNah, Boeing management and shareholder comp crippled the org on its own just fine. Getting rid of pensions is what enabled more comp to go to these folks. "401k experiment failure" are the keywords you can search for on the topic. Are we going to claw back all the comp and shareholder returns from the folks who stole from Boeing while it went down the drain? No, we'll just say that's the cost, even though it is obvious that is what crippled the org. "Pensions are absolutely crippling" while orgs are strip mined in plain site, with a noticeable lack of hand ringing over said strip mining. https://www.epi.org/publication/retirement-in-america/ https://www.epi.org/publication/retirement-in-america/ https://www.pionline.com/defined-contribution/401k-experiment-has-failed-fueled-us-retirement-crisis-labor-economist-says https://www.pionline.com/defined-contribution/401k-experimen... https://www.nytimes.com/2024/05/08/magazine/401k-retirement-crisis.html https://www.nytimes.com/2024/05/08/magazine/401k-retirement-... https://www.nbcnews.com/business/retirement/great-401-k-experiment-has-failed-many-americans-n327321 https://www.nbcnews.com/business/retirement/great-401-k-expe...
- blackeyeblitzar 2y ago> Boeing management and shareholder comp crippled the org on its own just fine Don’t get me wrong, I think the private equity model of financially oriented management is a problem. Employees and unions do share blame though. Remember, an IAM worker forgot bolts on the door plug. And SPEEA workers (the other union) designed MCAS poorly and didn’t build redundancy on dirt cheap sensors where there was no reason to avoid it. Boeing’s floor is inefficient and a shock to anyone who works with Boeing, due to union territorial issues and frankly a lazy culture. All these things have contributed significantly to Boeing’s decline, in addition to bad leadership.
- koolba 2y agoPensions are fine if you actually pay for them by purchasing guaranteed annuities to offload the liability. Except nobody wants to do that because they’re insanely expensive. Even more so if they’re going to be inflation adjusted. In reality if workers want pensions, the company should give them a fix annual amount that the worker can use to purchase an annuity.
- Manuel_D 2y agoGuaranteed annuities have the same problem: who's paying workers in their old age, and what happens when that entity becomes insolvent? Nothing is truly guaranteed in finance, especially when life expectancies rise faster than the pension scheme assumed.
- michael1999 2y agoLongevity is not what did them in. It was regulators allowing them to PAYGO on medical costs. Only cash pensions were required to be actuarially sound. Medical benefits were yolo.
- Manuel_D 2y agoLongevity is absolutely a big factor in underfunded pensions. "Actuarially sound" is based on projections of how long retirees will draw from pension funds. When retirees start consistently outliving those projections, a sound pension rapidly becomes unsound.
- rangestransform 2y agosome public transit agencies spend over half of their operating budget on pensions
- Eisenstein 2y agoAnd?
- rangestransform 2y agoIt’s problematic, it means a politician can offer pensions to make themselves look better and kick the can down the road
- Eisenstein 2y agoWhat does that have to do with their budget?
- doctorpangloss 2y agoIf it's so obvious, why offer them? Why do deferred compensation? Why promise to pay in the future for anything?
- mrmetanoia 2y agoHedging your bets some will die before they get it/all of it? Keeping your employees sustained while also not giving them enough immediate overhead for creating any kind of wealth? I'm not serious, these are just the first cynical thoughts that came to mind, but I feel like this question should be one we can actually answer? We've had both pensions and time to see varying degrees of successes and failures regarding them.
- johnnyanmac 2y agoNo, you're right about the death thing. That's how all life insurance works. They bet on the statistics that most people will die by Y, so the retirement age of X means they will make money if (Y-X) is positive. Pensions are basically just "rest of your life" insurance before the real life insuarance kicks in for your family. And you see why they died out. Y-X consistently became negative as people lived longer, especially when we moved to a service industry. So they ended it and front-loaded the money. There's probably a lieu of tax codes and other benefit they get from matching 401ks as well that I do not know of without researching.
- renewiltord 2y agoBecause of the principal-agent problem and the fact that there is no structure to reward future success reliably? If the Chicago parking meter plan is so outrageous, why do it? It's obviously bad. So why do it? You know why. There's a guy with controls over a lot of money. He's going to find a way to access some of it.
- doctorpangloss 2y ago> So why do it? You know why. I don't get it. Maybe every single S&P500 CEO has a deferred compensation plan, but when a union asks for it, it's always corruption?
- rootusrootus 2y agoThe unstated implication is that retirement is not economically feasible except to a privileged few. Our healthcare system has a similar implication. Cannot afford universal healthcare, meaning the system only works if we can allow some people to go without.
- asdasdsddd 2y agoyes, this is what happens when you dont work on the next generation
- ImPostingOnHN 2y agoThe resolution seems to be for governments, not random private companies, to look after our people in their old age.
- Steuerheaven 2y agoIf a company can't calculate something like this, you should not work there. Otherwise absolutly not. You just have a company doing the pension plan for you and thats it.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoAnd to governments, not just companies. Public sector pensions in America are basically scamming and stealing from taxpayers.
- michael1999 2y agoPensions only hurt companies long term if they are lying about the long-term cost. If the pension is funded, how can it hurt a firm? A fully-funded pension attracts employees, and encourages retention in a competitive market. Unless your argument is that management will always lie about the cost, and under-fund. Which is more of a comment about American management and the regulators than about pensions. Normally I'd say corporate pensions are a terrible idea because no firm around today can credibly promise to be good for its debts in 40 years. But Boeing really is TBTF, so a pension from Boeing might actually be worth something.
- ImPostingOnHN 2y agoA "fully funded" pension requires ongoing contributions made into the fund by the company to make sure returns are high enough, especially during a market downturn, when the company can least afford to make such top-up contributions.
- toast0 2y agoPensions seem nice to have, but IMHO, it's generally better for employer and employee when compensation is paid immediately. The accounting is simpler, accountability is easier, and there's no long term entanglements.
- plussed_reader 2y agoSo it's better to assume my current employer is insolvent and to just follow that old conservative truism, "Fuck you, got mine."?
- spywaregorilla 2y agoIt's better to not gamble your retirement on the assumption that your company will be solvent in 40 years. That's not really antagonistic in any way.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoYou require the company to fund a pension held at a custodian. If the company goes bust, your pension benefits are not impacted. Importantly, the retirement contributions are on top of your wages, versus being expected to find the cash for retirement exposure out of your own wages such that a 401k requires. Australia's system is a model: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superannuation_in_Australia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superannuation_in_Australia
- MajimasEyepatch 2y agoEmployers match employee contributions to a 401(k), so it's not purely out of one's own wages. In this case, Boeing is matching up to 12% of the employee's income, which is very high.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoBased on a preponderance of the evidence, how successful has that token match been in achieving successful outcomes? It is a match, if you don't contribute, there is no match. That is not how pension contributions and benefits work.
- bluedino 2y agoThat's crazy. 4% is a pretty common match.
- vundercind 2y agoWhich sucks absolute ass because 401ks working as a replacement for pensions requires employer contributions more like this 12%. The plans are clearly structured on the assumption that’s what would happen—there are separate limits for how much an employee can contribute, and how much an employer can, and the employer limit is significantly higher. Even if an employee wants to max out the plan, they can’t, because their contribution level is capped way under the hypothetical max. The idea was plainly that employers would contribute heavily to these. Instead they barely do, making them better than nothing, but kinda shit considering how they were supposed to work. [edit] to put some numbers on it, for 2025 an employee maxes out at $23,500 contribution. Meanwhile, the overall max is $70,000. An employee isn’t allowed to contribute more than 1/3 of the max allowed. In fact, with straight matching only and no fixed or multiplier-based matching from the employer, you can still only hit about 2/3 of the max. It’s hard to overstate how entirely the 401k has failed to achieve its apparent purpose in practice.
- buildsjets 2y agoWow, that sucks! You should form a union and strike for more.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoPensions are very rare in private industry because they’re incredibly expensive and amount to a Ponzi scheme due to chronic underfunding. In the US everyone has moved onto 401k, except government jobs. But almost all state pensions are in a bad shape. Taxpayers are wasting tons of money paying out pensions that simply never made sense and were never deserved - after all offering up something that is “risk free” would be insanely expensive in theory. Unfortunately some states like California make it impossible for states to get out of those of obligations. Private companies can go bankrupt, but the state will keep taking from taxpayers
- carabiner 2y agohttps://www.boeingbenefits.com/employee/emp-retirement.html https://www.boeingbenefits.com/employee/emp-retirement.html Regular nonunion employees get 10% match, immediately vested.
- doublerabbit 2y agoWell, thats good news that striking still works in this semi-dystopian world.
- fhdsgbbcaA 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- dontlaugh 2y agoStriking will always work under capitalism, because profits are a portion of the value workers create through their labour. Withdrawing labour will always cripple production.
- kylebenzle 2y agoJust "semi-" dystopian?
- doublerabbit 2y agoI still have a job, can sleep and eat. Prices are hiking and we are all being slowly replaced. Once I loose all those three things I'll ring the bell of dystopia.
- baron816 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- tareqak 2y agoSame story from the Associated Press: https://apnews.com/article/boeing-contract-vote-strike-machinists-union-5237a31660b0a06381457e33f9a72369 https://apnews.com/article/boeing-contract-vote-strike-machi...
- johnnyanmac 2y ago>Although she voted “yes,” Seattle-based calibration specialist Eep Bolaño said the outcome was “most certainly not a victory.” Bolaño said she and her fellow workers made a wise but infuriating choice to accept the offer. >“We were threatened by a company that was crippled, dying, bleeding on the ground, and us as one of the biggest unions in the country couldn’t even extract two-thirds of our demands from them. This is humiliating,” she said. Yeah. I never expected the pensions to return, sadly. But 38% over 4 year after a 2 month walkout seems like this strike more or less settled. For reference: >Machinists voted down another offer — 35% raises over four years, and still no revival of pensions — on Oct. 23, the same day that Boeing reported a third-quarter loss of more than $6 billion. I can't blame them at the end of the day because mouths need to be fed, but this paints a grim picture in my eyes. The only way this can be salvaged is if someone in the background is giving other deals like what happened with the train strike (which we wouldn't hear about for months on end).
- nisegami 2y agoConsidering Boeing's prospects, what faith could there be in a pension plan tied to their company?
- johnnyanmac 2y agoBoeing is a vital defense contractor, despite all the PR disasters. They are definitely in the territory of government bailout if they were truly to go under. Would I bet on Boeing being alive in 40 years? Not really, not without a huge overhaul in their business. Would I bet on them being alive in 15 years when I retire? Probably.
- 2y ago
- starfleet_bop 2y agoI wonder how much money Boeing could have saved by averting the costly strike action if it had just agreed to the original proposal from the union.
- ImPostingOnHN 2y agoThey probably would have lost way more by agreeing to the pension plan the union demanded.
- dingi 2y agoWhy these pension plans needs to be so complicated? 8% from the employee, 15% from the employer. Paid to a separately managed fund each month. That's how its being done where I work.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoA true pension provides a guaranteed benefit in retirement (regardless of contributions). You get a certain amount of income, no matter what. So it is not based on the amount of contribution, but what you are given in a risk-free manner. That’s what makes it overly expensive and problematic - nothing is truly risk-free and such a generous benefit end up functioning more like a Ponzi scheme.
- buildsjets 2y agoThe issue is that the defined benefit pension was replaced with a 401k, where your retirement income is subject to the vagaries and collusions of the market as well as your own investment choices and skills over time. The 401k just passes the risk from the employer to the employee, but the employee is playing the game at a significant disadvantage. Pension funds can afford to hire full time money managers to play this game, I cannot. The other problem is that the investment choices in the 401k are extraordinarily limited. You get your choice of - two index funds that track the S&P and R2K, two "actively managed large / small company funds" that really just track the S&P and R2K but with higher fees. You can choose from 10 different target date funds with high fees and low returns. You can choose the company's own stock, if you did not learn the lesson of ENRON. There are also a few "international company funds" and "bond market index funds" and similar that consistently under perform all the other choices. There's no way to invest in individual stocks other than the employer's stock, sector targeted mutual funds, REITs, SPACs, actual real estate, annuities, non-US companies, precious metals, or numerous other investment vehicles that leave one less exposed than just "Follow the DJIA". You can't even gamble your money away on Crypto.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y ago> where your retirement income is subject to the vagaries and collusions of the market Isn’t this normal and expected? Pensions are also subject to the same thing since they’re invested in the same stock market, right? It is why most pensions don’t have enough money. You simply can’t make something totally risk free. I think pensions are misleading by offering this guarantee and it always results in the company having difficulties for unrealistic obligations or people not getting their pension that they expected when the company collapses. > as well as your own investment choices and skills over time 401k plans usually have a default investment suggestion that provides a reasonable place to start. People can choose to stick with those recommendations or not. But the 401k is required by some regulation to make responsible choices as a default strategy. Not all companies have the same flexibility in what you can invest in, but mine have always had low cost funds available. I do agree they should have the ability to freely invest in anything though.