6 ms·
Why the Higgs Boson Discovery Is Disappointing
- ggchappell 14y agoA bit more meaty read is the followed blog post by Stephen Wolfram (which is linked to in the posted article): http://blog.stephenwolfram.com/2012/07/a-moment-for-particle-physics-the-end-of-a-40-year-story/ http://blog.stephenwolfram.com/2012/07/a-moment-for-particle...
- jakeonthemove 14y agoYep, it turns out our theories are true and there's no magical way to create an anti-gravity field or go faster than light. Disappointing, but definitely not unexpected...
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- geuis 14y agoThese theories are now further supported by evidence. The Standard Model isn't based on a couple of experiments. Its supported by thousands of independent observations over a multitude of points in physics. There's still a lot of stuff left unexplained, and currently unpredictable by the Standard Model. Dark matter and dark energy are just a couple of them. How the universe even started is still another. The big questions are still unanswered and may well surprise us all. Also remember that there is the Standard Model Higgs boson, the one predicted by theory, and what's just being seen in experimental data. The team doing the announcement the other day were very explicit in saying that they've found a Higgs-like particle, but it may not be exactly the one in the Standard Model. i.e. There may be multiple types of Higgs bosons. Its going to take years of more research to really nail down what's just now being glimpsed. Another good thing to keep in mind is the place of Newtonian physics in the Standard Model. Up until the late 19th and early 20th centuries, Newtonian physics were very well understood, and some scientists thought that may well have been all there was to know. Newtonian physics fits nicely inside the Standard Model. Its entirely possible, though who's to say if probable or not, that the current Standard Model will itself fit into an entirely new overarching branch of physics in the decades to come. The LHC will be operating for 3 more months so that even more data can be collected, then will be shut down for about 2 years for repairs and upgrades. When it comes back on line, it will be much, much more powerful and who knows what might be discovered yet.
- JumpCrisscross 14y agoTechnically, Newtonian physics estimates Einsteinian physics which observes the means of the Standard Model.
- eshvk 14y agoThe most depressing thing about this article is the top comment(s) on how this somehow is justification for an argument for intelligent design.
- jQueryIsAwesome 14y agoYou are going to live depressed If stupidity depress you; specially if you have internet access.
- Vivtek 14y agoDear God, now Stephen Wolfram is the smartest man in the world?
- davebees 14y agoHe certainly knows how to market himself.
- vl 14y agoQuality of this article appears to be below regular standard of The Atlantic. Not only added content is full of exaggerations and stupid epithets, it's mostly a quote of a blog post!
- Harkins 14y agoI've gotten the feeling the Atlantic has made a major change in publishing policy in the last two or three months. They now seem to have a lot of what the print world calls blogs, which is to say: linkbait by notables that is conspicuously below their long-established reputation for quality. I hope they're not in trouble, this is one of those metrics-driven last ditch moves that media companies having trouble moving to the web pull.
- gfodor 14y agoWolfram's ego really is a parody of itself at this point. Here we can read a grand tour of particle physics over 35 years and the only specific figure Wolfram manages to mention and give accolades to is Stephen Wolfram. His links to his own publications, his book, his his his, me me me, I I I. Unbelievable. Edit: Higgs gets a mention, but just to highlight Wolfram's complaints to him about his theory, which turned out to be correct!
- ajross 14y agoTo be fair: (1) he actually worked in the field and knows the material, and (2) it's a blog post, not a corporate communication. Talking about stuff you've done in a blog post isn't really notable. Obviously there's more to the story, and I wouldn't point anyone to it for a general overview of 70's physics. But I read it and was interested.
- beambot 14y ago"At some level I'm actually a little disappointed." That same sentiment was shared by Stephen Hawking...
- hammock 14y agoI agree that the Higgs mechanism feels like a hack. Something in my intuition raises a flag. Even more so when I was learning about theoretical particles called "gravitons" back in grade school. It's always seemed forced (no pun intended) the way many scientists shoehorn gravity in with the other three forces (weak strong and EM), which share much more in common with each other than with gravity. One of these things is not like the other... Likewise, and related, dark matter/energy is a total hack. It's a shortcut contrived to sweep something we don't fully understand under the rug. The idea of gravity as an emergent force, related to inertia, has been more appealing: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/13/science/13gravity.html?pag.. http://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/13/science/13gravity.html?pag.... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entropic_gravity http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entropic_gravity
- rpbertp13 14y agoWolfram and you both make the mistake of thinking that there is any value in saying that an established natural fact 'feels like a hack' or 'disagrees with your intuition'. One of the most important lessons of modern physics is that intuition is a terrible guide when it comes to understanding the physical world at its most fundamental level.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- javert 14y agoDiscovering the Higgs boson is a victory for physicists but a sad day for physics. That's just perfectly backwards. This is great for physics - now humanity knows that much more about the reality in which we live. Bad for physicists, becuase now they will have a harder time getting grants.
- DanielBMarkham 14y ago<rant> This submission is like a parody of HN. First, it's based on a Wolfram blog, which should have been submitted instead of this. Perhaps it was. I don't know. Second, cue up the "I hate Wolfram because he has a big ego" chorus which always runs on ad infinitum whenever the man's name comes up. Third, it's a post from The Atlantic -- yet again. Can a day go by without multiple posts from that place appearing on HN? Is The Atlantic so incredible to not even get the mandatory blogspam comment that any other attempt like this would receive here? </rant> Come on guys. We can do better than this.
- agentgt 14y agoI couldn't help but notice the Creationism flame-bait thread on that article (bottom). Thank god :) hacker news is at a higher level of thought.
- Roboprog 14y agoToo bad nobody asked him what was holding up that turtle... ... First Cause is inexplicable. Get over it. Ironically, I'd consider myself a believer, but some arguments are flat out cringe-worthy.
- monochromatic 14y agoYour smugness in this comment is cringeworthy.
- hrbrtglm 14y agoWhat would happen if you collide two Higgs Boson ? A different Boson ?
- sh4na 14y agoA Cleavage /me runs
- minikites 14y agoI don't actually know that much about Wolfram or A New Kind of Science, this was my first exposure to either: http://www.cscs.umich.edu/~crshalizi/reviews/wolfram/ http://www.cscs.umich.edu/~crshalizi/reviews/wolfram/ Would people who know the book or the man say this is accurate? It's all I associate with the name now.
- taliesinb 14y agoHere's a critique I wrote a few months ago about Shalizi's review: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3973173 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3973173 You know, when I was a teenager I was very excited about Stephen's book. Then I found and read Shalizi's review, and reluctantly changed my mind. At the time I didn't have enough background knowledge or intellectual confidence to really see it for what it is, which is a kind of weird character assassination masquerading as a scientific critique (it is interesting to note that Shalizi's PhD advisor and Stephen go way back). Much later, after some pure math and a bit of industry, I actually met Wolfram, talked to him at length, did some science in the NKS style, and in fact I found the whole thing so stimulating (and the other people so cool) that I applied for a job at Wolfram Research, where is where I now work. In fact, at this exact moment, I'm acting as an instructor at the Wolfram science summer school, supervising students around the world ranging from gifted high-school to PhD. It's a lot of fun. NKS -- both the book and the methodology -- isn't perfect, and hasn't delivered on some of its promises. However, I think it does represent a really cool network of ideas and insights, if you take the trouble to understand them, especially in their historical context. Many of them familiar, of course, but Wolfram puts them in a new light and unifies various ideas. And I think in the next few decades it will really come into its own, when we get memristor arrays that need to be programmed, universal constructors that need simple rules to operate, algorithmic drugs that have to be both simple and effective, and so on. "Watch this space", etc.
- aik 14y agoI agree with a lot of the sentiments here about Wolfram's ego. Aside from all that, I found his blog post interesting. The below items I found the most interesting (note: I haven't read NKS, and I'm aware of the criticisms, but his insistence on the significance of it is intriguing nonetheless): ----- > Was it worth spending more than $10 billion to find this out? I definitely think so. Now, what’s actually come out is perhaps not the most exciting thing that could have come out. But there’s absolutely no way one could have been sure of this outcome in advance. > Perhaps I’m too used to the modern technology industry where billions of dollars get spent on corporate activities and transactions all the time. But to me spending only $10 billion to get this far in investigating the basic theory of physics seems like quite a bargain. > I think it could be justified almost just for the self-esteem of our species: that despite all our specific issues, we’re continuing a path we’ve been on for hundreds of years, systematically making progress in understanding how our universe works. And somehow there’s something ennobling about seeing what’s effectively a worldwide collaboration of people working together in this direction. > That in fact there’s no reason all the richness we see in our universe couldn’t arise from some underlying rule—some underlying theory—that’s even quite simple. There are all sorts of things to say about what that rule might be like, and how one might find it. But what’s important here is that if the rule is indeed simple, then on fundamental grounds one shouldn’t in principle need to know too much information to nail down what it is. But what I suspect is that from the experimental results we have, we already know much more than enough to determine what the correct ultimate theory is—assuming that the theory is indeed simple.
- ChristianMarks 14y agoWolfram may be betting on the Nightmare Scenario, which is that the Higgs turns out to be exactly the standard model Higgs, and nothing else is learned.
- ck2 14y agoThe disappointment is because of the minds that don't know of any EXPECTED discoveries. But it's the unexpected that are the most exciting, no?
- chmike 14y agoThis is not true. Check http://www.meessen.net/AMeessen/STQ/STQ.pdf http://www.meessen.net/AMeessen/STQ/STQ.pdf for a new theory extending the standard model. Beside predicting a bunch of new elementary particles, it also propose a new organization of elementary particles equivalent to the mendeliev table, except that it's a 3D structure. These new particles have all no electrict charge and may combine together as quarks to form hadron like particles my father call neutralons. These could stand for black matter. I heard similiar pessimistic claims from physicist in my lab: there is nothing much left to discover in high energy physics. Maybe it's like a post partum depression thing. Just after a major and popular question has been answered, and before a new one, with a new theory, has been settled, some researcher may feel lost. From my father's work, many of which is not published yet, I know that there is still allot to be discovered and tested. They just need a new theory. That's all.