10 ms·
Singularity U, or Singularity Woo?
- dmix 14y agoThe main issue seems to be Vivek Wadhwa (not the whole University) for sending out one poorly thought out mass-email that is vaguely in support of homeopathy. If I remember correctly, Vivek Wadhwa also authored quite a few articles (on Techcrunch and elsewhere) that demonstrated a poor understanding of stats/science. For example: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2831195 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2831195 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2495012 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2495012
- drcode 14y agoThat's disappointing though. Nobody is going to give credence to the crazy-sounding core tenets of Singularity U if they allow pseudo scientists on their staff. If I were in charge of Singularity U I would view this as immediate grounds for firing Mr. Wadhwa.
- aroberge 14y agoWhen a VP Academic makes a statement, this statement is supposed to reflect the view of the entire institution. When a VP Academic makes such public statements demonstrating gross misunderstanding of science (which I would describe as incompetence), (s)he can normally expect to be fired if (s)he works for a reputable institution.
- demachina 14y agoWadhwa keeps putting out immigration studies, like this one, http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1348616 http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1348616 "Americas Loss is the World's Gain: America's New Immigrant Entrepreneurs" on why immigrant entrepreneurs and skilled tech workers are leaving the U.S. to return home, decrying the brain drain, and that it is devestating the U.S. economy. The studies consistently show visa issues are almost never the primary reason they are returning to their home countries. Many are going back to India and China because their economies are or at least were booming offering more opportunities, they are more comfortable in their homeland, nearer family and friends, less culture shock, etc. He will then immediately whipsaw around and insist its urgent the U.S. pass Startup Visa and increase H1-B quotas to somehow solve the pressing visa problem… which isn't actually the problem per his own studies. So if the guy is willing to ignore the results from his own study because its inconvenient to the agenda he is pushing, this latest episode surprises me not at all. Once he latches on to something he seems to stick to it, regardless of what the data says. His long running primary agenda seems to be he wants the U.S. to throw the doors open to all Indian engineers and entrepeneurs who want to come. This also happens to be a popular agenda with a lot of big tech companies and VC's which contributes to his popularity among certain circles.
- nodemaker 14y ago>The studies consistently show visa issues are almost never the primary reason they are returning to their home countries. Personally in my case, Visa issues were the no.1 reason that I moved back to India. It seemed unfair that while all other developers in the US could happily do indie and freelance work in their free time and even start their own company, while I had to be an H1-B slave and work for pretty much the same company for 6-8 years before I could even get permanent residency. Also even working for startups and getting equity is mostly out of question as most startups typically dont do H1-Bs until they are large enough. Your only choice is to work for a shitty megacorp and get confined to your cubicle and a mediocre pay for 6-8 years. Also make sure you are nice H1-B slave coz if you get fired you have to leave in 30 days. Seriously fuck that!
- jere 14y agoI really wouldn't expect this from Singularity U. I wonder if it a single rogue woo supporter or if Kurzweil has intentionally brought those kind of people in. Personally I think Kurzweil is the poster child for plausible sounding woo. Consider this. Kurzweil thinks he's going to be able to live forever and essentially reconstruct his dead father. He takes 150 (previously 250) supplements and 10 glasses of alkaline water per day. He wrote a nutrition book about avoiding fat, particularly butter, organ meats, and eggs. If you've read anything about nutrition in the last decade, you'll probably be aware these are some of the healthiest foods on the planet and the campaign against dietary fat was always lacking evidence. To be fair, he did backpedal on this point in a later book, but then again why would a computer scientist write two nutrition books in the first place? His predictions have always seemed rather silly to me too (turing test passed in 17 years) but they are a bit more debatable at least.
- drcode 14y agoI'm ambivalent about Kurzweil because he has been a great early popularizer of empirically/scientifically-founded futurism. But at this point he is probably doing more harm than good, for the reasons you describe.
- jere 14y agoSure. Even Isaac Newton had some crazy beliefs ("wrote more on Biblical hermeneutics and occult studies than on science and mathematics" according to wikipedia).
- bluekeybox 14y agoSure, but Newton formulated Newton's laws, built the first reflective telescope, explained motion of planets, developed differential calculus, and wrote Principia.
- jere 14y agoExactly. Newton is seen by many as the smartest scientist who ever lived. So I'm saying even those who contribute the most can have crazy ideas. It's typical. Not sure we disagree. Or are you saying Kurzweil's contributions are very small in comparison?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- sgt101 14y ago"First, the idea of false balance, suggesting that there are two sides to the current state of our knowledge on a scientific theory. No, the scientific method produces our best understanding of a subject to date. It does not produce both that and its antithesis." Well - no, science produces falsifiable hypothesis. Here is my hypothesis, you (or me) could falsify it by showing x. x could be shown, but I can't show it - can you? That's science. In this debate the homeopaths are asked time and again to show x, they never do, so the hypothesis that we have is that it's utter bunk. If some homeopath can show that their shit really works (with a double blind randomized trial with controls) then booooo yahhhh! it works! It's not about debates, it's not about who is right. It's about what can be shown to be true, or not.
- drcode 14y agoOP is saying that in science a hypothesis needs to be taken off the table once has been falsified. (Unless new evidence comes along saying otherwise.) Homeopathy deserves to be removed from the table.
- sgt101 14y agoIt's an interesting debate as to when things should come off the table. My usual metric is that respected people start to refuse to talk about it - at some point topics just stop being interesting to them and that's the point that it generally means that it's over. If for no other reason than because you know no one is going to be generating new evidence as they sure ain't going to be getting any grants! Crank science is different. I guess that The Media and capitalism are the problem. Homeopaths are probably never going to go away because there is money to be made, and The Media are probably going to keep reporting on it because it sells. Perhaps there will come a point (like with UFO's) where interest will simply dissipate and it'll stop being a story. Until then we have a problem - the process is the story, just like for AGW. Why aren't there grants for this? Why do wise professors simply dismiss it? What on earth are we doing supporting these massive drug companies with their expensive and somewhat poor therapies? We need to be aware that the processes of science (everyone I know thinks this is just uninteresting, therefore there is every reason to believe that anyone working on it is wasting there time - unless I have reason to think otherwise - so mehh) doesn't have the effect that we anticipate it to; so lots of careful, calm, open minded rebuttal based on cast iron facts and offers of changes of opinion if things can be proved other wise would be good.
- rfurlan 14y agoI am a SU alumnus and I can assure everyone this is not representative of Singularity University in any way.
- localhost3000 14y agocan someone explain the 'woo' reference? k thx.
- drcode 14y agoaka bullshit
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- natedsaint 14y agoSkeptic's dictionary has a pretty good definition: http://www.skepdic.com/woowoo.html http://www.skepdic.com/woowoo.html
- prodigal_erik 14y agohttp://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Woo http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Woo http://www.skepdic.com/woowoo.html http://www.skepdic.com/woowoo.html It's the non-denominational version of making stuff up while untroubled by complete lack of evidence. Also the sound effect that goes along with handwaving.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- choxi 14y agois "woo" a well known concept? I feel like this post would be much more popular if it didn't use such an obscure word in its title
- zargon 14y agoIt's well-known to the people reading skepticblog.
- unimpressive 14y agoYes. I had to pause a second to search my mental vocabulary database to make sure it was what I thought it was, but yeah. I wouldn't say it's the most common word used to describe the concept, but I would think that it would be well known.
- evincarofautumn 14y ago“Do you know what they call ‘alternative medicine’ that’s been proved to work? ‘Medicine’.” — Tim Minchin
- ippisl 14y agoThere's a huge economic imbalance between the economic resources and motivations given to prove and market traditional medicine and alternative medicine. Sometimes this leads to a situations that non-fully proven alternative treatments can offer better results with less side effects than current medicine practice. And since risk for many alternative medicines is low it makes sense to try them. This of course doesn't apply to homeopathy.
- tatsuke95 14y ago>"Sometimes this leads to a situations that non-fully proven alternative treatments can offer better results with less side effects than current medicine practice." Maybe you're right. Care to point to some specific cases?
- lmm 14y agoSt John's Wort for depression is the poster child; it's in the process of gradually becoming ordinary medicine as more studies are performed, but it's not yet something your doctor would prescribe you. We err far too much on the side of not approving new treatments (it's like we think harming someone by giving them bad medicine is thousands of times worse than doing the same harm by not giving them good medicine), particularly when there are no patents so no drug company profit motive to push them through trials.
- tatsuke95 14y agoI'm in the pharmacy business, so this is of obvious interest to me. >"but it's not yet something your doctor would prescribe you." Because it doesn't require a prescription. There is nearly unlimited information on the product (including efficacy), and I can go into any pharmacy in North America and buy it off the shelf, no questions asked. >"particularly when there are no patents" The idea that you can't make money without owning the patent on something flies in the face of everything done in the hacker world, doesn't it? I don't buy into that theory, but can't really back up my opinion. The world is filled with companies who sell commodity products at a mark up, though.
- blackjack160 14y agoDisclosure: SU Alumnus here. Being from India, it is not unusual for all natural remedies (Neem leaves to soothe burns) to be classified as "Homeopathic". More Examples Here: http://hpathy.com/materia-medica/indian-homeopathic-drugs/ http://hpathy.com/materia-medica/indian-homeopathic-drugs/ Note: I am not saying everything in the URL is gospel, just that there are some natural remedies that work. Hanhemann's description of Homeopathy is: "based on the hypothesis that a substance that causes the symptoms of a disease in healthy people will cure that disease in sick people." (Wikipedia) This theory is nonsense and proven to be quackery. In summary: I suspect that Professor Wadhwa's interpretation of Homeopathy was culturally biased. There is nothing wrong or revolutionary with giving natural cures a closer look, just not under the Woo of Homeopathy. If Wadhwa was advocating Hanhemann's Homeopathy then that is indeed disappointing given prevalent evidence.
- spitx 14y agoIs it fair to call it quackery or should it be more fairly called a placebo-based remedy system? Can it be slotted in the same league as naturopathy? After all naturopathic formulations don't always have the same efficacy in controlled trials. Do they?
- jaekwon 14y agoit blows my mind that this got downvoted.
- nodemaker 14y agoIt is fair to call it quackery because placebo is not what the homeopaths claim their medicines are working on. They claim some BS around "Law of the simlars" and "Like cures like".
- rbanffy 14y agoBut wouldn't the placebo effect disappear if they called it what it is? ;-)
- Mystitat 14y ago
- realize 14y agoWow, I've always enjoyed Vivek Wadhwa's articles, but he just lost all credibility with me. This is the same level as finding out he is a scientologist.
- waterlesscloud 14y agoI honestly don't understand this. Do you not evaluate each of his points on their own merit, or have you been relying on reputation alone?
- MartinCron 14y agoCredibility isn't exactly the same thing as reputation. Some authors have more credibility than others. If someone positions themselves in the realm of the incredible (which is what homeopathy is), they lose credibility, as they should.
- realize 14y agoOf course I evaluate each of his points on its merit, and may continue to do so. But part of how much mental "weighting" to put on his points is based on how much I respect how his thinking process goes, and how it lines up to mine. That weighting just got significantly reduced.
- gwern 14y agoIt's very difficult to weigh each point on its 'own merit'; for example, if someone is writing an article on diet, it's relatively easy for them to construct a very impressive looking article, each citation of which is genuine and does indeed match the description, and which is logical - but also completely wrong because they cherrypicked the few dozen results which supported the thesis and ignored all the other studies and meta-analyses which reveal the thesis is complete bullshit. For example, take dual n-back. Just with the materials in http://www.gwern.net/DNB%20FAQ http://www.gwern.net/DNB%20FAQ I could construct a case that dual n-back is a fantastic intervention which will boost children's grades, help cure ADHD, help addicts kick drugs, increase your IQ, etc - or I could construct a case that it's a statistical artifact contributed to by financially compromised researchers which has failed replication and ought to be kicked to the trashheap of history. Both would be true if you 'evaluate of my points on their own merit'. When someone says that him believing in pseudoscience X reduces their confidence in any of the articles on topics Y or Z, they are quite correct. They have learned reasons to think that he left evidence out, or twisted it, or didn't look for counter-evidence, or engaged in any of the myriads of sins of omission or commission that lead a reader to falsehood.
- Alex3917 14y agoJames Randi's explanation of homeopathy is incredibly intellectually dishonest. In the video Randi says that homeopathy involves extreme dilution to the point where virtually none of the original substance is left. But this isn't true. There were two schools of homeopathy, high dilutionists and low dilutionists. Only one school of homeopathy believed in dilution like this. It was homeopathy that pioneered evidence-based medicine, which is why mainstream medicine eventually merged with low dilution homeopathy and began to use its methods. But Randi doesn't mention that either.
- MartinCron 14y agoNote: I don't want to be the [citation needed] asshole here, but this is the first time I've heard of the distinct schools of homeopathy and I'm skeptical (of course). Can you point me to an article about this history?
- Alex3917 14y agoFrom JAMA: http://jama.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=202602 http://jama.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=202602 "19th-century homeopaths pioneered systematic drug-testing research, challenged the dangerously depleting procedures of mainstream physicians at that time, established rigorous professional standards, and valued advanced education at least as highly as their mainstream counterparts did. It was not without reason that homeopaths considered the bases of their approach to medical problems to be more logical and more promising than the inherited tradition of the ancients, upon which mainstream physicians still based their practices. [...] This book will be useful primarily to scholars looking for specific information about particular people, events, and developments within the homeopathic movement during the period covered. Among other things, readers will find the names—and often the opinions—of hundreds of previously invisible homeopathic practitioners, publicists, and professors; they will follow fierce debates between the so-called high-dilutionists (whose therapeutic commitment to infinitesimally small doses of supposedly energized substances verged on spiritualism) and the low-dilutionists (who ultimately merged with mainstream physicians in the early decades of the 20th century); they will explore the founding and fate of homeopathic medical schools; they will listen to well-intentioned homeopaths defend themselves against attacks from the American Medical Association; and they will learn about regional variations in the character, reception, and legal standing of homeopathy around the country." Anyway not to defend homeopathy, but I just find it sad that so many people view James Randi as a credible source despite the fact that he can rarely go five minutes without lying about something.
- nickpinkston 14y agoI'll echo the sentiment of others here in saying that this isn't representive of anyone I know at SU. I'd say it's quite a rational crowd and while Kurzweil and others are a bit on the edge of reason in some of their work on Singularity stuff - it's vastly not blatant wrong facts a la homeopathy. It's at most overoptimism in the factors of exponential growth and supporting tech like cryogenics being more useful than is likely. The Newton reference below is apt - let's judge people on their best contributions - and let only heinous stuff (if Newton ended up a violent dictator) count against them.
- akiselev 14y agoNewton's dablings in the occult SHOULD be considered and count against him. The thing is, we've confirmed calculus and universal gravitation through centuries of experimentation. Whadwha's situation is different. He is alive, a PROFESSOR AT STANFORD, and the VP of academics at SU. His contributions of the past should not be muddied by his current stances, especially if others have corroborated his work (although I don't know if Whadwha does real research). However, if he chooses to believe in homeopathy, something which has been shown time and time again to be as effective as a placebo, it shows a certain lack of intellectual integrity that is not acceptable of a practitioner of higher education. Some of the greatest scientists in the world have been corrupted by their personal biases and if people like Einstein can waste decades in a hunt for something that doesn't exist (i.e., his denial of Bell's theorem and search for a deterministic hidden variable) then surely Whadwha too can fall prey to his biases (which he seems to have shown today). The difference is that Einstein did research that could be corroborated, while Whadwha teaches, which can impact the intellectual integrity of his students.
- abecedarius 14y agoEinstein died before Bell discovered his theorem. Careful with the rants about integrity.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- rmc 14y ago"We need more research" / "We don't know yet" is the homoepathic eqivalent of creationisms "Teach the controversy" ploy. Homoepathy doesn't work. They've done studies on it. They haven't tested vague "things related to homeopathy" like "does water have a memory?", they have actually tested the 'drugs' themselves. They don't work.
- jessedhillon 14y agoIt's not my mind that's closed, it's the book that's shut on homeopathy. It has been thoroughly tried and debunked as nonsense. What more is it, exactly, that you think an open mind should entertain vis-a-vis homeopathy? Before you trot out the tired "flat world" defense, read Isaac Asimov's essay on degrees of wrongness. Our ideas have been getting better over time -- it's preposterous to propose that we could be as wrong about molecular biology, germ theory and medicine as we were about the earth's shape. We are wrong, but we know we are not that wrong.
- jere 14y agoBitcoin is an actual thing that works (just 2 years after invention). Homeopathy has found no supporting evidence in 150+ years and it completely lacks even a reasonable mechanism. Apples and oranges. That paper you mentioned is complete bollocks: http://www.quackometer.net/blog/2009/10/why-i-am-nominating-luc-montagnier-for.html http://www.quackometer.net/blog/2009/10/why-i-am-nominating-... And finally hiding nonsense behind "everyone believed the world was flat" is quite aggravating. Scholars have known the earth was spherical and even its approximate circumference for over 2000 years.
- jacoblyles 14y agoAll universities should have a "defense against the dark arts" class where students learn how to weigh evidence, arguments, and logic. Outside of that, I believe class should be opinionated and biased. If that were the case, then quacks would find themselves without an audience. I do worry that by casting quacks out of polite society, we will also cast out iconoclasts and free thinkers.
- eavc 14y ago>weigh evidence, arguments, and logic Philosophy 101
- Jach 14y agoWhat school even just mentions Bayes' theorem in Philosophy 101?
- gwern 14y ago> "All logic texts are divided into two parts. In the first part, on deductive logic, the fallacies are explained; in the second part, on inductive logic, they are committed." --Morris Raphael Cohen, quoted by Cohen in "The Earth Is Round (p < 0.05)"
- Eliezer 14y agoThe Singularity Institute is working on it (or rather, the spinning-off Center for Applied Rationality is working on it); and indeed, we have literally been known to refer to it as "Defense Against the Dark Arts".
- paulsutter 14y agoSeems like Singularity U needs something like Hacker News as a platform for discussions. Email proclamations to successively larger mailing lists are not exactly an efficient approach. Should they just use Hacker News itself? Build their own? Or can Hacker News sprout channels? I'd be fascinated by the topics they cover.
- olalonde 14y agohttp://www.lesswrong.com http://www.lesswrong.com is probably what comes closer to what you are describing.
- bfrs 14y agoRichard Dawkins made an excellent documentary, The Enemies of Reason, which covers homeopathy. Parts of the it can be found on youtube: http://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=dawkins%20homeopathy http://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=dawkins%20homeop...
- technotony 14y agoDisclosure Singularity U alumnus here. My hypothesis here is that Vivek was trying to open a debate, to challenge the students to accept the possibility of alternative views, rather than pushing those alternative views. This is strongly aligned with his role as VP of Academics where he is trying to encourage the students to consider alternative possibilities and that there are different perspectives, this is within his role remit. Not to defend homoeopathy but it's when you examine and challenge existing hearsay that you can make great strides of innovation.
- justsaying99 14y agowrt to his nutritional /supplemental writings in his latest books Kurzweil provides evidence in form of studies etc, or if not available or study was limited in relevance etc, he plainly acknowledges this. I thought it was obvious he was trying to fill gaps with what was available. He also acknowledges he is choosing to reinterpret some findings, and gives his rationale for this too. He also rejects a raft of homeopathic and modern medical treatment with same rationalization. He never claims to be a scientist, rather he says he is just a guy doing his best to leverage science from an engineer and inventor perspective for his own personal health benefit, and sharing it with the rest of us.
- jaekwon 14y agoFallacy. Vivek Wadhwa has the better perspective on the matter. The author is assuming that "because people who believe in homeopathy are believing in something that does not follow from our scientific models, homeopathy must not work." But this is fallacious. We all know about the placebo effect. Do we know the efficacy of homeopathy in the realm of the placebo effect? Perhaps a pill with a bogus (but plausible to the naive) reason has more power than a sugarpill with no explanation at all as to why it works. If so, by some definitions of efficacy (say, "works better than a sugarpill"), you would have to conclude that homeopathy works (albiet in the context of our world, where many are scientifically illiterate). The universe does not follow our scientific model. Rather, it is always(1) the model that follows the universe. There will always(2) be inexplicable (and apparently scientifically impossible) phenomena, and the purpose of science is to find them. (and also to simplify the axioms. Wolfram might be disappointed with the LHC outcome, but I'm hopeful that somebody will find a new model -- equivalent to the standard model, or at least one that leads to the standard model in other scales of physics -- that I can actually understand ;) ) (1) Well, never say neither always nor never, and mileage may vary based on unexpected factors. (2) This I've concluded from Goedel's Incompleteness Theorem, but then again I don't actually buy that 100% either. I don't buy that (X implies X) implies (X is true), which I think is assumed in GIT. Input appreciated.
- chris_wot 14y agoIf x, then x. x can be true or false! It is true that if false, then false. It is also true that if true, then true.
- disgruntledphd2 14y agoYou're quite right. If you actually read the Shang et al 2006 paper you'll discover that homeopathy was discovered to be better than placebo but less good than the best conventional treatment. The PR and media coverage around the paper missed this entirely. The Ernst paper mentioned by the article also could not determine if homeopathy was entirely due to placebo. Its worth noting that this is the current state of scientific knowledge regarding homeopathy. It appears to be somewhat better than placebo judging from meta analysis. Now, this doesn't mean its real (or fake), it just means we need more research. Its also worth noting that the trials of homeopathy in the Shang 2006 article were rated as higher quality than those of conventional treatment (but there were less of them).