12 ms·
The Google Nexus Q Is Baffling
- Zigurd 14y agoThe most interesting thing about the Nexus Q is that it enables sharing a device. That is, it has the ability to temporarily use accounts from Android devices. It can run Android apps, so it is, in fact, an Android device. It isn't tied to an individual. If this is well-implemented and secure, it's an interesting aspect of the Android OS that hasn't been exposed in other Android devices yet. If it is possible to build a similar system from the AOSP code-base, that would be very useful for people with a less-dogmatic idea of a feature set. Most other aspects are, as Pogue points out, full of WTF.
- fidotron 14y agoExactly. The more familiar you get with the Android API the more you think things like why does the activity I'm starting have to be on the same device? Can't I fire Intents to devices on my local network? Wouldn't it be cool if the YouTube activity I'm using on my phone could be migrated to the TV with all state preserved? You get problems in terms of where the data to drive it comes from, especially if it's the class of data you'd normally store on an SD card, which may be one slightly more reasonable explanation of the ludicrous cloud dependence of the Q.
- programminggeek 14y agoSometimes when you're wildly successful as Google is with Android and Search, you start doing things that don't make a lot of sense. Microsoft has done this many, many times as has Apple. With Microsoft you can see the ill fated Kin/Kin 2, Windows Media Center, Windows Tablet, Windows UMPC's, etc. that for various reasons just weren't good ideas, weren't priced right, etc. Apple had the G4 cube, iPod Hi-Fi, and the Motorolla ROKR (with iTunes). When you have billions of dollars in profit, you tend to throw money around at ideas that might not be ready yet, or just might not be very good ideas yet. Google has a history of doing this in software, but now that they're moving into hardware the problems seem more glaring.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- erifneerg 14y agoWith most of those products you mentioned, I can see some sense with them. I would say the Windows Media Center is the most successful of those examples. The Kin is only one I can say made no sense for the same reason the nexus Q doesn't make sense. It's really locked, not easy for the user put there own content on the device and relies too much on the cloud.
- meepmorp 14y ago> The Kin is only one I can say made no sense for the same reason the nexus Q doesn't make sense. From the articles I read at the time, the Kin did make sense, initially. All MS had to do was make a decent HipTop successor and get it out on time, and they'd had a decently successful product. Instead, internal politics wound up producing a wholly reworked, incredibly late product that missed the market window and earned boatloads of carrier ill will. The HipTop was very popular, and MS should've been able to capitalize on that; instead, they totally biff'd it and it cost them boatloads. To me, having watched large companies make massive screw-ups due to internal politics, the whole debacle was just too familiar and understandable.
- jaems33 14y agoG4 cube was pretty influential design-wise for future iterations, specifically Apple TV and the Mac Mini.
- r00fus 14y agoThe Moto ROKR was Apple's iPhone stalking-horse - the project was likely doomed to fail commercially, but Apple gets valuable industry experience in rolling working on a cell phone.
- AjithAntony 14y agoI did QA on the E398 ROKR. It was indeed designed to fail. Apple had a bunch of very limiting requirements. Most notable was the 100 song limit.
- myko 14y agoI think the Q is pretty sweet looking myself. I just wish it had Google TV functionality as well.
- barca_fan 14y agoyeah adding some other google functionnality in it would make it succeed a lot!
- aviraldg 14y agoThe Q is Google's attempt to pull an Apple.
- vibrunazo 14y agoThe Nexus Q is easily hack-able. That's an important feature. Just a few days after the Q launched you already had people transforming it into a game console with mind control and a projector: https://plus.google.com/117676109445965905583/posts/BRbJEQk41vU https://plus.google.com/117676109445965905583/posts/BRbJEQk4... This is probably not a mass consumer device supposed to replace the Roku. It's a premium product for a very specific use case (as google demoed). While at the same time a developer toy to explore what android can do in different devices.
- rwhitman 14y agoHmm, maybe its actually a gaming console in disguise?
- eupharis 14y ago... Wow that makes perfect sense. Especially when you considered how ridiculously overpowered the hardware is for its ostensible use case!
- spacemanaki 14y agoAt $300, "secretly it's a game console" doesn't seem like a great business plan. If that was the plan they should probably have lead with that.
- abraham 14y agoThe Android Nexus Q app is pretty rough still so it leads me to believe that Google launched what they could at I/O. Considering how they designed and built the Q in the USA because of the fast feedback loop it makes sense that they have bigger plans from what Google currently lets on to.
- rwhitman 14y agoThink about it this way - Google wants to get into the console gaming market but they know they can't compete yet. They need to innovate a new model. So they release whats effectively a prototype onto the market as a "media player" and let developers have at it. Its derided as bizarre until 3 years later when there are hundreds of super cheap indie games available on a number of ultra cheap Android-based console media/gaming devices... and then magically Google is crushing Nintendo
- zbowling 14y agoSo it does have a lot. At Apportable (YC11) we have been poking around with it and found it has the potential for being an amazing game platform. You can read about our exploits where I demoed the results our hacks at AnDevCamp this last weekend after Google IO: https://plus.google.com/117676109445965905583/posts/BRbJEQk41vU https://plus.google.com/117676109445965905583/posts/BRbJEQk4... We figured out it's also possible to transfer APKs to the device with NFC but it fails at random points. We also got a mouse working with one of the games we ported for Android: https://plus.google.com/117676109445965905583/posts/iAsNqGrXKmU https://plus.google.com/117676109445965905583/posts/iAsNqGrX... My thoughts are that google wanted to ship it by Google IO but have more plans for it upcoming.
- will_work4tears 14y agoHmm, could be interesting in a multiplayer game that uses your android smart phone as the controller.
- mjibson 14y agoThe Q's hardware is capable of much more than the software currently allows. Hacking it was explicitly encouraged at I/O. All of the negative points in the article can be fixed with software updates. Seeing as this is a brand new product, the software currently has minimum functionality to show off its two new features: control via tablet, social playlists. I predict that in the next year the Q will get software support for: - iOS devices as a controller - other computers on your network as a controller (web interface or chrome app or something) - netflix/hulu/other stuff streaming support - music/video streaming from local network devices - streaming all audio output from a device (like my desktop computer) to the Q, so it can be used as a stereo device instead of just an output device However, assuming all of those features were added, I'm still not sure I'd pay $300 for it.
- ConstantineXVI 14y agoThe feature it needs for $300 is an API. Tap your phone, and it sends over the app (not a stream, the .apk itself), while said app on your phone becomes a controller.
- apendleton 14y agoGoogle TV is another Android platform that plugs into an entertainment system, and Google recently revamped it, with third-party manufacturers expected to launch new iterations of it this year at or around the $100 pricepoint. I see no reason, hardware-wise, that a Google TV STB couldn't do all of the things in your list, with the right apps on top of it, so even if your predictions come true, of the $300 you'll be paying, $200 will be for it to come pre-installed with software that will probably be available from a third party for the GTV for $5. The only thing you get with this that doesn't ship standard with the GTV boxes announced so far is an amp, but the amp in the Q is pretty puny, and if you're hooking it up to an existing sound system, you won't use it anyway.
- brown9-2 14y agoHave there been products in the past that were underwhelming at launch but later software upgrades to it to add features made it a big hit? I think these devices, especially at $300, need to be attractive at launch to become hits. Adding features 6-12 months down the line doesn't seem to ever turn a lagging product around - launch is the time when potential consumers are paying the most attention.
- powerslave12r 14y agoThe thing I have felt about Google is they don't market their features well. They will show off a lot of potential but leave it to the imagination of the developers/users to figure out what they can do with it. I think they have improved upon that to some degree with the Jelly Bean presentation, but I really think their products would be more appreciated if they highlighted good use cases for all their new features.
- nicc_ap 14y agoQ looks nice, but how could they price it so high with devices like Roku, Apple TV available from $50-$100 range. Also, the main feature of friends adding to the Q is bogus, as we can anyways do it on Apple TV using airplay. As long as I am on same wifi, I can play music from my iPhone at my friend's place as long as he has airplay enabled on his Apple TV and connected to his home theater system
- dkhenry 14y agoI'm calling BS on this. You can play music that you have on your phone, you just need to upload it to Google Music. Also you don't need to plug it into your TV. I understand why people say this doesn't stack up against the Apple TV. In my mind its not supposed to its supposed to stack up against this http://www.amazon.com/Denon-DM38S-Micro-CD-System/dp/B003R6T0V4/ref=pd_sim_e_5 http://www.amazon.com/Denon-DM38S-Micro-CD-System/dp/B003R6T... Which is does very well. It is still a little pricey, but you get a lot of features, and the promise of more to come.
- kalid 14y agoI think I'm in the target market (tech geek, enjoy casual music listening) and I just can't wrap my head around the multi-playlist scenario: "The Q presumably gets its name from “queue,” or playlist, and Google is especially proud of its multi-participant playlist feature. If you’re having friends over, and they, too, have Android phones, and they, too, have bought songs from Google’s music store, then they can add their own songs to your Q’s queue. Sounds interesting in theory. In practice, there’s a lot of spontaneity-killing setup. You have to go into Settings to turn on the feature. Then you have to invite your friend to participate by — get this — sending an e-mail message. Then your friend has to download the Nexus Q app." When I'm hanging out, music is a background thing while we talk or play games. Not something people are fiddling with on a song-by-song basis (at most: "Hey, could you change the Pandora station?"). Apple has something similar (iTunes remote? can't remember the name, it's been that long) and I'd love to know how often that feature gets used. There's also the unspoken social rule that whoever is hosting the party generally picks the music.
- solutionyogi 14y agoThey should fire the PM who came up with this work flow. I own an Apple TV and hosted a party at home. My Apple TV is not protected by password, so all my friends with iPhones (the last one to own an Android got tired of it and replaced it with iPhone) could see the special 'Air Play' icon (http://cms.whathifi.com/Images/189140462bli.jpg http://cms.whathifi.com/Images/189140462bli.jpg) on their iPhone as soon as they join my WiFi network. Now anyone can play media on my TV, be it music from their library/photos from their camera roll/any other App which supports AirPlay. No set up required. When I bought Apple TV, I bought it only for Netflix but I have been using it a lot through AirPlay. It's a killer feature.
- zbowling 14y agoI think it was more problem of iterative design and having to pull out features before release. I think the Q does a lot more but Google wanted to ship by Google IO and would improve it with later software updates.
- adventureful 14y agoGoogle is attempting to build new brand value around design, so they can better compete with Apple directly in hardware. That's the entire point of the magic eight ball. It's intentionally unusual. They want props for design, not for function.
- mkaltenecker 14y agoApple doesn’t do stuff like that. Well, sometimes they do and fail spectacularly. Does anyone remember the iPod HiFi? Similarly expensive, point- and useless. If this is how they want to compete with Apple they haven’t understood Apple very well. (I do not think that’s their intention. Google is, in fact, pretty good at competing with Apple. Android does very well. They know what they are doing for the most part.) Apple is about making mass market products that differentiate themselves from the rest by their design – but they are not just design props. They are actual products people love to use, not put behind glass and stare at. The Nexus Q is Google’s iPod HiFi. Utterly stupid, doomed for failure but of no consequence for Google in the long run. I wouldn’t read anything into it. Even the best companies do stupid stuff from time to time. (Yes, this is a prediction. I recognize that I might be wrong and you can hold me to it.)
- czr80 14y agoGood comparison, I think. Tangent: Without any proof at all, I always thought the iPod hifi was some pet project of Steve's because he was into music. Anyone know the backstory there?
- jfb 14y agoI don't know the backstory, but I was working at iTunes when the Hi-Fi was announced and nobody could figure out what the hell it was for. If it had been a high-capacity iPod (rather than have merely been an admittedly nice speaker setup) many of us would have bought one. But it wasn't, and we didn't, and it died a quiet and deserved death.
- jamesaguilar 14y agoApple's brand of design comes from selling things that people like. Things totally unlike the Q in that respect.
- vibrunazo 14y agoAbout the price. Many people been blaming it on the "made in USA" + amplifier. I'm not american, and I don't understand patriotism. And I wouldn't think a product being made in USA as the main selling point, would ever work. But before the IO I saw this project on kickstarter where they were trying to sell underwear made in the US [1]. That's their only selling point, their product is made in the US, that's all. And guess what, it was immensely successful on kickstarter. The comments are filled with praises with how awesome it is to wear underwear made in america. Maybe someone here has better understanding of that market. Could the made in the US selling point of the Q actually be big enough to drive sales? Would americans actually pay more only because of that? [1] http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/jakehimself/flint-and-tinder-premium-mens-underwear?ref=live http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/jakehimself/flint-and-ti...
- postfuturist 14y agoMade in USA is about much more than just patriotism. In the USA, many people buy locally produced goods since it supports the local economy better, reduces carbon emissions from shipping goods half-way around the world, and isn't produced in slave-labor conditions of 3rd world countries. (Also, you don't understand patriotism? It's tribalism, something deeply encoded in our behavior from many thousands of years of tribal evolution.)
- SCdF 14y agoThis isn't on point with the main conversation, but anyway: other 'western' countries that are similar to the US (I'm talking about UK, Aussie and NZ here, I don't have much knowledge of the others) look at patriotism differently to the US, so it's a fair point. We still support our sports teams (those of us who care for sport) etc but it's not as extreme as the 'America fuck yeah!' style patriotism that seems to constitute US patriotism (it may not actually be like that, this however is what media teaches us).
- ars 14y ago> reduces carbon emissions from shipping goods half-way around the world That's actually not true, as counter intuitive as it may seem. Local stuff uses more energy, not less. Mainly because the large operations are so efficient, but the local ones are small.
- spudlyo 14y agoWake me up when XBMC runs on it. A device that only plays cloud media is a total non-starter for me.
- tdicola 14y agoI don't buy that this thing was built for hackers & makers. If you really wanted to build something for them, why not release something like the beagle board or rasberry pi but running Android? These ARM SoC based development boards are really getting cheap and are a lot more practical for building stuff since they have general purpose IO pins, are powered by a few volts DC, and include handy stuff like serial UARTs, single wire bus interfaces, etc. The Q is expensive, lives in a funky impractical case, and doesn't have a lot of useful IO. For $300 you could buy a few Arduinos, a beagle board/ARM SoC dev board, and even an FPGA dev board.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- brown9-2 14y agoWhy is the app to control the Q Android-only? Does Google genuinely think that iPhone users will switch platforms to Android just to have the chance to control this player? Seems like you are throwing out half the potential audience for this type of product by only supporting the Android OS.
- SCdF 14y agoGenuine question: can I control Apple TV / AirPlay / iTunes etc from an Android phone? Or a Windows phone?
- andybak 14y agohttps://play.google.com/store/search?q=itunes+remote https://play.google.com/store/search?q=itunes+remote
- SCdF 14y agoRight. sorry, my question should have made it clear that I meant built by Apple. The point I guess I was making was that it's not unusual for a company to not provide a client for their competitors platforms. It's crap, but it's not unusual.
- brown9-2 14y agoI'm not sure what the answer is but I think the same point applies if the answer is "no". For Apple it makes more sense though since they are all about the integrated experience; but I think Google is trying to be a disruptor here so I think they need a more open/easy-to-access solution.
- bathat 14y agoIt looks like another commenter possibly answered this question, but I would also point out something possibly more important: You don't need to. That's because Apple includes a cheap little 7-button remote with the Apple TV. The iPod/iPad/iPhone remote does greatly enhance the UX of the Apple TV, but you don't need it to use the Apple TV for its intended purpose. Just to reiterate: The reason people make a big deal about the fact that you need an Android to control a Q, but don't make a big deal about needing an iPhone to control an Apple TV, is that you don't need to buy anything extra (or already own anything in the Apple ecosystem) to use the Apple TV from the couch. For people who don't already own devices in the Android ecosystem, the Q is a $500 device, but the Apple TV is only a $100 device for those who don't already have an iThingy.
- drivebyacct2 14y agoMy Raspberry Pi will already stream all of my media for me remotely. With this guy [1], the Cubox, I can have even more power (1080p) video, in a small, nicely contained box. With a uPNP A/V or DLNA client, I would be in paradise (as I already am with my Raspberry Pi). Will play all of my movies and TV shows on my server, it works as a DLNA receiver so I can play content from my server or phone and use my phone as a remote and it will act as an Airplay client. Why, oh why, would I pay $300 for a Google Play-only device?
- jroll 14y agoYou forgot the link for [1], mind posting it?
- j_s 14y agoPre-order for $135 on the company website: http://www.solid-run.com/ http://www.solid-run.com/ Details: http://www.linuxfordevices.com/c/a/News/SolidRun-CuBox/ http://www.linuxfordevices.com/c/a/News/SolidRun-CuBox/ "This is probably the only Android TV box that is shipped in such a small form factor and the only development platform in the market that is packaged in an elegant plastic box and not provided as a barebones system or in a bulky enclosure." Edit: No official news or publicity posted by SolidRun in 6-month? http://www.solid-run.com/phpbb/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=640 http://www.solid-run.com/phpbb/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=640
- drivebyacct2 14y agoCrushing information if they really don't have the graphics drivers fully work and haven't shipped anything in 6 months :/
- jpxxx 14y agoYikes. This is a $300 product that is incapable of doing the single thing it says it does on the box. It directly competes with Google TV yet doesn't offer any integration with it. There's no official developer story, no promise of future features, no way of using it out of the box without already owning another Google product, and I don't even see an analog 3.5mm jack. Who is this for? Meanwhile Apple Airplay is not getting remotely enough attention. It's social, it's rock solid, it's zero-configuration, it's invisible, it enables desirable real-world media sharing scenarios, and it's already on a billion devices. Google should get out their checkbook and license it before they're permanently shut out of the living room.
- SCdF 14y agoCould they licence it? As in, would Apple give them a licence? The main reason I have no interest in Airplay is that it requires iTunes, and none of my media 'workflow' involves it, not to mention it being a horrible piece of software.
- jpxxx 14y agoIt is true that PCs only have the one workflow: airplay audio out of iTunes. And iTunes is a raging piece of shit. But it is basically a system service on iOS, which does not require iTunes. And with the next release of the Mac OS, display mirroring will be built in - how hard would it be to implement it in iTunes for windows and short-circuit Microsoft's Play-To and DNLA services? Every platform vendor needs this device-spanning mortar now. And Google doesn't have it.
- jimbobimbo 14y agoMicrosoft's Play To is DLNA: http://digitalmediaphile.com/index.php/category/dlna/ http://digitalmediaphile.com/index.php/category/dlna/
- jpxxx 14y agoApologies! I stand corrected.
- jiggy2011 14y agoI wonder what this conversation would look like if this was an Apple device? From the looks of the marketing, google are trying to tap the "shiny and expensive" niche. It's almost like this is supposed to be more of an ornament that happens to also perform a function, after all it's going to be an awkward shape to stack under the TV with all the other set top boxes.
- guelo 14y agoFriends at my house are able to seamlessly play music from their phone on my stereo by using the $2 mini stereo cable that is attached to it.
- mahmud 14y ago$2 gets you audio from phone. $298 gets you black matte sphere.
- prayag 14y agoThere are no issues presented here that can't be fixed by pushing a software update. It is definitely not a finished product but the design looks pretty unique and once the software is finished this can become a good product at least in terms of design and functionality. As far as the price point is concerned, $300 is a lot of money for a set-top box. However, if this can double up as a game console, it becomes competitive. Google is still an early player in the hardware field and they are still trying to get things right. This is probably a test device for them before they push for a much more competitive product.
- WiseWeasel 14y agoIf it's really not finished to this extent, you don't put it into a journalist's hands, let alone those of the public at large. Bad first impressions can kill a whole product line, especially when its value isn't clear to people.
- Someone 14y agoIt may well be, but there is a different view: "We do not know how to make a $500 computer that's not a piece of junk, and our DNA will not allow us to ship that." (Steve Jobs, October 2008; http://www.businessinsider.com/2008/10/apple-q4-earnings-analysis http://www.businessinsider.com/2008/10/apple-q4-earnings-ana...). About a year later, they did know and they shipped. I think that, for companies that have money (and, hence, time) in hand such as Apple, Google, IBM, Microsoft,..., that is the better approach. Also, "looking unique" can mean that you are the first in a new market, or that you are the first in a non-market.
- blhack 14y agoThis [the Q] is a solution hunting for a problem. We have a "problem" at our hackerspace where lots of people want to control the stereo. Usually there are 5-10 people in there working, there is always music playing, and the person controlling the music (or the "wubs" as they are affectionately called now) changes pretty frequently. We should be exactly the target market for the Q. Except we already solved this problem. We bought a really long cable off of monoprice, and we bought a bluetooth audio receiver. They both plug into a mixing board, and they allow everybody to play music. Switching between who "has wubs" involves going "hey, you want wubs?". It works really well, it almost never breaks down, it doesn't require anybody to install anything on their phones, computers, cassette players, arduino shields, theramins, contact microphones, or whatever else we decide we want to play over the PA. Most importantly, it doesn't cost $300. ...and then one of us bought one and brought it into the lab. Here is what happened: http://yfrog.com/z/oe42wqagj http://yfrog.com/z/oe42wqagj
- danilocampos 14y agoYes, the banana plug ports are a completely mystifying design decision. I honestly think they were chosen because they made the design look interesting, rather than because they served any common or essential use case.
- bathat 14y agoI agree, but banana plugs can be added to regular speaker wire pretty easily. Most just have a simple flat-head screw which holds the wire in place, so you don't even need to warm up the soldering iron.
- shasta 14y agoWarning: Pregnant women, the elderly, and children under 10 should avoid prolonged exposure to Google Nexus Q. Caution: Google Nexus Q may suddenly accelerate to dangerous speeds. Google Nexus Q contains a liquid core, which, if exposed due to rupture, should not be touched, inhaled, or looked at. Do not use Google Nexus Q on concrete. Discontinue use of Google Nexus Q if any of the following occurs: itching vertigo dizziness tingling in extremities loss of balance or coordination slurred speech temporary blindness profuse sweating heart palpitations If Google Nexus Q begins to smoke, get away immediately. Seek shelter and cover head. Google Nexus Q may stick to certain types of skin. When not in use, Google Nexus Q should be returned to its special container and kept under refrigeration. Failure to do so relieves the makers of Google Nexus Q, Wacky Products Incorporated, and its parent company, Global Chemical Unlimited, of any and all liability. Ingredients of Google Nexus Q include an unknown glowing substance which fell to Earth, presumably from outer space. Google Nexus Q has been shipped to our troops in Saudi Arabia and is also being dropped by our warplanes on Iraq. Do not taunt Google Nexus Q. Google Nexus Q comes with a lifetime guarantee.
- iso-8859-1 14y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Happy_Fun_Ball http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Happy_Fun_Ball
- carryon 14y agoI have an Airplay enabled receiver. I don't need an ugly black ball sitting on my shelf. Airplay is awesome and I dont need iTunes if I use Airfoil.
- danilocampos 14y agoThe banana plug ports are a completely mystifying design decision. I honestly think they were chosen because they made the design look interesting, rather than because they served any common or essential use case. I'd venture that, in descending order of adoption rate, these are the likeliest audio interfaces in people's homes: - 3.5mm - RCA - TOSLINK (optical audio) - HDMI - Coaxial digital audio - Tin can and string - Banana plugs Besides, if you've got speakers that are so good you're wiring them up with banana plugged-cables, you probably already have a pretty nice receiver. What purpose was served by adding an amp and making this thing into a mini receiver on its own? As it is, the Nexus Q embraces two sorta common connectors and one extremely high-end, therefore niche interface. The most common and obvious audio interface, the 3.5mm jack, is left in the cold. (An expansion on my reply to: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4205281 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4205281 Which includes an almost comical photo in support of this argument: http://yfrog.com/z/oe42wqagj http://yfrog.com/z/oe42wqagj )
- Daniel_Newby 14y agoAre they the banana jacks where the outside is a nut you can tighten down on bare wire or spade terminals? That's actually good—nearly all the speakers I have ever used have been bare wire.
- danilocampos 14y agoNo, that probably wouldn't have been, er, sexy enough. This article has a pretty decent shot: http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2406499,00.asp http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2406499,00.asp Same for me, and most folks with low- to mid-range home theater setups, I'd wager – shoving bare wire into the terminal seems pretty common.
- Daniel_Newby 14y agoThat is appalling. This cannot be a real product. It has to be like a concept car. Surely. Surely?
- gcb 14y ago
- pigboy 14y agoAnouncing: the Chromebook of media players!
- gcb 14y agoThe Q is the very same useless concept of the original nexus one desktop dock. The original dock at least came with 3mm plug and a cable to convert to 2 rcas.
- zitterbewegung 14y agoSomeone is confusing specs on a platform that the average user doesn't care about. This is REALLY exciting. If Google makes something easy to use that is a media platform then they finally have a compelling counter to Apple.
- swah 14y agoMarco.org referred to this product as the Nexus Ball - much better.
- rms 14y agoSo... anyone want to buy a Nexus Q, new in box?
- aneth4 14y agoPerhaps it is a doomed attempt to duplicate the iPhone's path, but in home entertainment. 1) Release revolutionary device, locked down with software that limits its use 2) Sell lots 3) Finally succumb to demands that your device be the center of an app ecosystem. If so, I suspect they will fail in all three.
- DanielHimmelein 14y agoMaybe you can do the same thing as the Nexus Q and even more using your Android handset and a 35$ Raspberry Pi: Check out the Android Transporter: http://esrlabs.com/android-transporter-on-the-raspberry-pi/ http://esrlabs.com/android-transporter-on-the-raspberry-pi/
- ZeroGravitas 14y agoI think the Q makes more sense if you pretend it doesn't have an HDMI out. If you're plugging it into a TV, then the TV already has built in speakers (for normal folks, nerds probably have a 5.1 surround system) and its amp is useless, and its ability to be controlled via smartphone is lessened since you could have a TV-based UI. You also probably start thinking about streaming video, which it isn't particularly good at and which they already have a competing product for. If you stick it in another room, one without a TV, then suddenly it makes sense. It's competing with a high-end iPod speaker dock. And like those, you're essentially paying for a bit of furniture, unlike an Apple TV or generic streaming box which hides in your media unit. For the iPod dock you have to put all your music into iTunes and copy to an iPod which then sits in the dock, for Google you put the music in the cloud.
- generalk 14y agoI can't help but wonder why Google didn't ship this thing with Google Now. A cool looking sci-fi sphere that hooks up to my TV and lets me and my Android-enabled guests stream stuff from Google's cloud? I have almost no need for this. A few cool looking sci-fi spheres around my home that wirelessly link all my speakers to the same content from Google's cloud? Eh. Interesting, but not worth $300. A cool looking sci-fi sphere in my bedroom that knows I usually go to work around 9am and can wake me up and give me spoken alerts that traffic is rough and I should leave at 8:15am, and is still a hackable Android device? Take my money, take it all.