7 ms·
Stop saying "just" (2019)
- mparnisari 2y agoHow do I send this to an ex co-worker that did this all the time and drove me bonkers?
- bberenberg 2y ago100% agreed. I set up an autocorrect rule to help me stop doing this. I also found “basically” to be another word to avoid.
- interestica 2y agoWhat's your rule? Does it eliminate it every time you type it? Or does it replace it with criticism? (You didn't just write just did you?).
- bberenberg 2y agoIt is replaced with “DONTWRITEJUST” and then I take advantage of the autocorrect not being great at understanding the context of backspaces and moving caret position to type it if I need it.
- kelseyfrog 2y ago[flagged]
- recursive 2y agoThis joke was better when it was in the post title.
- pooper 2y agoI am so glad I am not the only one who hated it when other people would try to imply the work I did was trivial. If you want to say my work is trivial or "just" 0.5 story points, you should be willing to pick up this story.
- cdchn 2y agoAny time I hear "just" I know something is going to be more difficult than it seems.
- ahazred8ta 2y agoThe answer to "can't you just" is invariably "no, you can't just".
- rocqua 2y agoThat should be the point of the question. Figure out what context the asker is missing. Not to diminish the work of the one being questioned.
- js2 2y ago"Nothing is impossible for the man who doesn't have to do it himself."
- idle_zealot 2y agoThe approach I take is to use "just" if and only if I mean to diminish something. I'll use it to refer to parts of my work that were easy, or to parts of unassigned work that should be easy, barring unexpected complications. I find it useful to have an easy way to signal which parts of a task need more effort.
- crabmusket 2y agoI think this makes a lot of sense, and also highlights why its use in e.g. documentation can be inappropriate. Lacking context for your user, you might not correctly anticipate which parts are easy for them. But often it is used in places where it's not useful to communicate that you think something should be easy. If I need to add a DNS record, you can tell me only that, instead of implying "add a DNS record, which should be easy for you".
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- cottsak 2y agoGood reminder.
- 8n4vidtmkvmk 2y agoFellow SWEs never do this to me, but my non-techie business partner uses this word and it drives me bonkers. Side note, I think the reason half of silicon valley has imposter syndrome is because they don't stick around for more than 1.8 years. It took me over a year for it to go away. Just chill out folks. You're doing fine. Stick around. Let's build up some knowledge and just make things better, okay?
- midtake 2y ago> the word “just” implies that an idea is simple. What's wrong with this? That seems like proper usage to me. What the author has an issue with seems to be snobby, snarky, or sarcastic usage of the word "just." Sometimes, the best answer is in fact "just add a DNS record." The author should just write that instead of this long blog-post that gives the impression of someone easily offended.
- cryptoz 2y agoAs someone who has added hundreds of DNS records, there is absolutely nothing “just” about it.
- apsurd 2y agowords mean things. What's really the benefit of adding in "just"? Your claim is that people are too easily offended and so maybe these people will be (too) easily offend by the word. So what's really the benefit of using the word?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- TylerE 2y agoIt adds clarity that you're proposing an alternate solution precisely because it's simpler/less work and not as a general alternative. It's a qualifier. think of it as shorthand for "Wouldn't it be easier if..."
- kevmo314 2y agoSaying something like "would it be easier to add a DNS record" seems effective too without the baggage?
- rocqua 2y agoTwice the words. But more importantly, if a DNS record is a bad idea, your version is likely to get a more detailed response. It can be valuable to get a compact answer like filtering rules or we don't have a local DNS server.
- nlawalker 2y agoRelated to the “implies simplicity” component, and posted here on HN multiple times: Reality has a surprising amount of detail https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38407851 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38407851
- __mharrison__ 2y agoWhen I was writing one of my first books, I created a list of common editorial feedback of words and terms that I need to stop using. "Just" was in that list. Removing it usually resulted in a better product.
- sovietswag 2y agoYES I FOUND IT, article on the same topic, not in the context of computers: https://thehealthygp.com/2021/04/28/why-i-stopped-using-the-word-just-and-why-the-justagp-narrative-has-to-stop/ https://thehealthygp.com/2021/04/28/why-i-stopped-using-the-... Why I stopped using the word “just” and why the #justaGP narrative has to stop
- DavidPiper 2y agoMy favourite related blog: https://squareallworthy.tumblr.com/post/163790039847/everyone-will-not-just https://squareallworthy.tumblr.com/post/163790039847/everyon... > If your solution to some problem relies on “If everyone would just...” then you do not have a solution. Everyone is not going to just. At no time in the history of the universe has everyone just, and they’re not going to start now.
- anileated 2y agoIt is possible to get everyone to just, it’s just that it only works with smaller sets of everyone. Everyone everyone would certainly never going to just, but you could just pick a smaller everyone (like everyone in this room or something).
- saulpw 2y agoIt's difficult for me by myself to just, and if the stars align I might be able to get a second person to just, but any group of N>2 it is impossible.
- anileated 2y ago> any group of N>2 it is impossible Not true.
- chii 2y agoso as long as it's not everyone, it just works.
- anileated 2y agoNo one really means everyone when they say “if everyone could just”. There is always an implied scope. The problem is only when scope is too large. Reduce it and everyone could literally just.
- hinkley 2y agoI can get a few people to do a lot of things, and a lot of people to do a few things, but it's rarely 'just'. You have to acknowledge that it isn't free and it might not be easy, but convince them the rewards are worth the effort often and significantly enough that if once in a while they aren't, it still comes out in the wash.
- lopatin 2y agoNike: Just do it. OP: Well it's not always as simple as that. How will you get to the gym? Will you drive or ride a bike? What if there are other people using your usual weight machines, do you wait or do cardio? If you're working out after work, will you need to bring a change of clothes? How will my diet affect my workout? And how can I track my fitness to ensure I'm making progress? Sometimes the answer is to just inject that JavaScript snippet. Of course all the follow up questions that OP mentioned to injecting that JS snippet are valid. But that is part of the "just". The person "just"ing that has assumed that you will consider all of those caveats and there should be no issues, because after all, why would there be if millions of people already use it without issue? It's up to the engineer to just do it, or push back if it's not actually as simple as it seems.
- rendall 2y ago> The person "just"ing that has assumed... Indeed. "Just" implies an assumption has been made, but it's not clear what assumptions nor whether they are justified.
- rocqua 2y agoGreat bit of semantic insight. Just signifies an assumption of simplicity. Which is different from signifying it IS simple. Which makes it very nice for getting your assumptions checked.
- alphazard 2y agoIf someone says "just", it means they believe the presented solution is less complicated than some existing proposal. That conversation should be a significant part of software development, and usually the answer is "no we can't just do that, because it wouldn't do what we are trying to do", or "yes, but it's not actually as simple as you seem to believe". Sometimes the answer is "yes, we can just do that" and everyone should be glad when that is the case. If you can't handle normal engineering criticism, then you are an imposter. Real engineers generate alternatives, and evaluate alternatives proposed to them.
- mistermann 2y agoAn engineering degree does not render Humans to be perfectly rational, though it can make it seem that way.
- Quothling 2y agoI really think you should consider what is implied by the word "just". When you say "no we can't just do that" it implies that you think someone will have missed the obvious. This may fall under "normal engineering criticism" to you, but I can assure you that some people will not see it as such and they won't like it. Which makes it a poor fit for good team communication. It will probably also make you disliked. It's obviously not always an negative word on its own. In your "yes, we can just do that" example it's fine. It's, however, also unnecessary as you could say: "yes, we can do that" and retain the full meaning. > If you can't handle normal engineering criticism, then you are an imposter. It's not normal engineering criticism though. "Just" is (in)famously known as a term that you use when you're overconfident while missing the whole picture. In many universities around here they will teach you about the dangers of it. Because it's really not good engineering to not do your analytics before suggesting solutions. I think most of us are guilty of using it. In my current team we laugh about it. We have a sort of swear jaw mentality when someone uses the term unironically, usually called out by the person who did it themselves. It's now a term we mostly use it as an internal joke, however, and people are never going to miss an opportunity to call the most complex challenges "just" in the most hilarious way they can.
- foobarbecue 2y agoWhen I worked in robotics at JPL, "just" was a running joke. We all tried to avoid using it, because we were all aware that it was a strong indicator of underestimating a challenge. We'd still catch each other using it all the time.
- ssl-3 2y agoWords are to be used whenever (and as often as) they are appropriate. Outside of slurs, blanket avoidance of words mostly just adds unnecessary obfuscation.
- foobarbecue 2y agoI agree. In this case, we felt that use of a particular word in a particular context reflected a mindset that many of us were trying to avoid. And, it became a fun game.
- renewiltord 2y agoThese are all small things. Say “just” because sometimes things are “just”. It applies the greedy simplicity approach to problems. This provides a baseline approach for one axis of performance. Also, everyone who claims impostor syndrome in software is just actually an impostor.
- pimlottc 2y ago> Also, everyone who claims imposter syndrome in software is just actually an imposter. Perhaps I misunderstand you here, but that is a frankly astounding claim. Anyone can have a crisis of confidence. It doesn’t mean you’re a fraud.
- 131hn 2y agoClaiming impostor syndrome is very different from having a crisis of confidence.
- User23 2y agoIndeed. For example "Why don't you just use Boyer-Moore or Knuth-Morris-Pratt?" It's straightforward way to say don't reinvent the wheel.
- spondylosaurus 2y agoThis reminded me of the advice to stop saying "simply" in marketing copy, or (god forbid) in your actual docs: > If someone’s having to read your docs, it’s not “simple” https://justsimply.dev/ https://justsimply.dev/
- ttpphd 2y agoJust is all you need.
- ok123456 2y agoJust is all you need considered harmful.
- RpFLCL 2y agoI'm so happy to see this post. One of my professors back in college mentioned that "just" was a "four letter word" (akin to a cuss word) and that's stuck with me since. "How long should this take? It's JUST calling an API." "Why did it take so long to fix that bug? It was JUST a one line change." "Stripe handles payment stuff, we JUST need to add it in!" What a devious little word. It just papers over all the complexity!
- satisfice 2y ago"Just" is a useful word and concept. The main reason people say it is that it promotes clear communication. Sometimes, I wonder if people who don't like the word "just" just don't like what the word implies. Of course, one can use the word "just" in a cynical or abusive way. Banning the word does not in any way solve that problem. Some people are cynical and want to say things cynically. Some people want to do some abusing. Don't curtail English itself to solve a problem with bad intentions. I often use the word "just" when I want to communicate that I think there might be a simple solution. It is not wrong to communicate that! I often use the word "just" to indicate that one reason is much more important than any other reason as in "maybe you just don't like people to imply that you've missed an obvious solution." This may be the truth. Don't try to tell me I cannot speak the truth. Do not unjustly criticize the proper use of "just."
- xarope 2y agoGlad to see I use it in the proper context then. "we just have to..." from me, means it will take just[0] an order or two magnitude more work than you expect. [0] see what I did there?
- throwawee 2y agoI think there's a missing distinction here between "Just do X!" and "Can we just do X?" The latter is a legitimate question and positive thing. I was once asked if I could just do X and I said I'd have to spend hours ripping out Y and debugging its replacement. It'd slow down development and if there were any features from X they wanted, it'd be faster for me to write them for Y. Did they still want X? They didn't. Another time I was prepared to build a robust, modular system with its own interface for everyone on the team to use. I mean, really put in the hours and design the hell out of that thing. And somebody said "Hey, can't you just do X?" Sure, it'd take me five minutes. But you wouldn't get features A through F--you don't want any of those? They didn't. I just did X.
- v3ss0n 2y agoHow about No? There are a lot of things people missing and suggesting a simple solution that solves a lot of problem that they may forgetting or haven't checked justify usage of just. Many of those are already in OP post. Looks like OP just too burned out.
- DonHopkins 2y agoSo "In Time" compiler instead of "Just In Time" compiler?
- nine_k 2y agoMany people agree that while justice is important, mercy is often superior to it. Let's replace the usages of "just" accordingly! "It's just so simple" -> "I's mercifully simple". "It's just only a tiny change" -> "By mercy, it's but a tiny change". "Just do it" -> "Have mercy, do it". </ha-ha-only-serious>
- inquisitor27552 2y agowhere's jart ill sell her ine.lol
- spaceguillotine 2y agoWhen femme presenting people stop saying 'Just' in their emails, they get called into HR for being aggressive.
- rendall 2y agoI internalized not using just after having read this post, or something similar, several years ago. I do think it's helpful not to use just (nor simply). Now, if I hear them, I'll probably ask questions. Often enough, OP is right, and the term hand-waves difficult implementation.
- kazinator 2y agoYou can just answer it. "The reason why we can't just X is that if we do X, we also have to Y, Z and W. Not literally just (as in nothing but) X."
- khana 2y ago[dead]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- rocqua 2y agoI love the word just in a question, exactly because of what the article points out. Just means, my suggestion seems unreasonably simple to me. It means I am looking for, and expecting, a reason it doesn't work. The downside is if the suggestion does work, you can make someone feel stupid. But it is a great tool to get up to speed on a hatd problem to learn why the 'obvious' solutions won't work.
- tomcam 2y agoTo me, a more effective way to handle this situation is to convert these requests into a change order. Explain that this is a previously unplanned addition, and give it an estimated cost. Then ask the person requesting it if they want to pay for the upgrade.
- brhsagain 2y agoI agree that the word “just” carries that connotation but I disagree that it’s a bad thing. When I ask if we can just do something my intent is exactly to communicate that I think the thing is simple, that the details are unimportant (to me, to us) and that it ought to be easy to do (and if it’s not, that’s a problem in and of itself). A lot of things are like this, and so to excise the word “just” would be to stop using a word that often concisely and accurately conveys what I’m trying to say. It would be better if the article just said “this is rude.”
- btschaegg 2y agoThere are nuances to this, too, though: You can be communicating > I think the thing is simple, that the details are unimportant (to me, to us) …and simply be ignorant of a lot of the details that make this not simple for the person who has to "just". I had such a "discussion" with someone who did exactly this and then refused to even acknowledge there are technical details in their "just" and that their "just" involves multiple wasted person days of effort (in this case for little benefit, as their "just" was to paint over them having to do something themselves). It's infuriating. Now, the "just" isn't the only part of the problem here, but it will most likely the part where any useful discussion breaks down. And, while I can blame my encounter on a person with… problematic particularities, it isn't obvious to me that one would always be able to discern easily if one is walking into the same trap.
- rascul 2y agoJust stop saying just
- aorth 2y agoI'm a native English speaker. Since reading a discussion about this a few years ago and paying attention to the way we speak colloquially I've stopped saying "just" as often. In most cases you can communicate your point with the same meaning minus the implied condescension or whatever. A similar one would be not adding excessive superlatives. It's up to you to be a better communicator!
- digital_voodoo 2y agoAmen to this (no religious meaning implied) I'm a self-taught tech savvy, I'm aware of where I come from and how far I've come. And I'm deeply annoyed when I see this almost condescending expression in various tech communities online. Very reassured that I'm not the only one feeling that way.
- binary132 2y agoJust stop coming up with hot takes.
- notacoward 2y agoSimilar feelings about "should". If software always behaved as it should, half of us would be unemployed.
- xtiansimon 2y agoI blame Nike.
- novoreorx 2y agoHow about replacing “just” with “try to”?
- throwaway4220 2y agoI think it’s related - the use of the word simply in any new software description. Simply install… simply click on… Just open up… When it doesn’t work it’s so condescending/patronizing?
- GrantMoyer 2y agoFor some reason, I found myself unreasonably upset at the suggestion that I should avoid a word solely because people will assume it indicates malintent. But after taking a step back to reflect, I realize it's not a big deal to avoid one word. I'm perfectly capable of condescension without having to rely on any specific word.
- squidgedcricket 2y agoI've come around to that conclusion on other verboten words, if other people don't like them it's not a big deal for me to stop using them. And I suppose it's less typing to push to main than it is to push to master.
- vosper 2y agoAgreed, and I've also come around to the inverse conclusion: if there are words people would like me to use (someone's preferred pronouns, the in-house terminology, the name someone introduced themselves with) then it's not a big deal for me to use them.
- pizzafeelsright 2y agoPlease stop using contractions. As a non-native English raised English learner the use of the contractions is difficult to hear the distinction at times.
- hildolfr 2y agoFine, kudos to you for being so pliable, but I hope you and parent realize that's essentially the road to nuspeak. Our language matters more than just linguistically, it matters culturally. So, when someone wants to delete a word or usage, well it requires a lot of thought about the implications. Sometimes it's a good thing, a lot of times there is a charged , sometimes political, motivation behind the desire for change.
- atoav 2y agoYeah, but usually it isn't about the "deletion" of a word (however that would look like) it is about becoming aware about the way that word impacts the world around us — and then potentially wielding it with more care — or wielding it to hurt and stump people — if that is what we want. There is always a gap between what we mean to say and how the actual words we use are received on the other side. Only if we are able to anticipate how our choice of words might be received within different contexts we have a chance to narrow that gap. And since language is an interpersonal, intercultural, intergenerational beast that is not an easy achievment. The worst we can do is assume language as a fixed static thing that isn't allowed to evolve over time and has one definitive meaning for all people always. That means understanding how words are received is always beneficial to people who want to communicate effectively — whether you avoid words because you know what thoughts/feelings theh produce in others is more a question of your character and your upbringing.
- havblue 2y agoDoesn't the use of the word "just" frequently imply that someone is violating the yagni principle? Being rude can certainly be unproductive as well, but an infinite amount time and money can be wasted on unnecessary features and process. I think the question of whether effort actually helps move a task to completion is a crucial one, so getting down to brass tacks "just do this task and stop talking about metrics" has to happen eventually. "I can't spare this man. He fights." -Lincoln
- pseingatl 2y agoThe two adverbial diminutives in English are "just" and "only."
- krunck 2y agoTry using "simply", "basically", or "only" instead.
- mycall 2y ago"I mean" is another good one to just stop.
- MathMonkeyMan 2y agoWhy are you bothering me with this supposed problem? In my desire to resolve the tension, I imagine that there is no difficulty, and that instead you are incompetent. Why don't you just do the first thing that comes into my mind? I would not have the problem you claim to have. Shut up.
- pmg101 2y agoA shame to remove the joke in the original title of including the word "just": "Please just stop saying 'just'"
- SansGuidon 2y agothis reminds me of a similar blog https://bradfrost.com/blog/post/just/ https://bradfrost.com/blog/post/just/
- um1 2y agoJust stop oil. Just kidding. But maybe we should just get rid of ‘should’.
- scudsworth 2y agoif only we word filtered just to simply. that will surely change the underlying behavior
- frays 2y agoThis article is so true, not just others saying it but also myself. I often say to myself, "Can't this problem be fixed with just <x>.." then when I go to fix it implement the solution it takes way longer than expected.