5 ms·
Air France crash 'due to pilot & technical failure' (Final report on 2009 crash)
- mtgx 14y agoI can't imagine the horror of knowing you're going to die in a couple of minutes when the plane crashes.
- philjohn 14y agofrom the reports it appears that most people onboard would have been blissfully unaware of their impending doom - which is some solace.
- simias 14y agoYes, even the pilots didn't seem to realize they were going to crash seconds before hitting the water. I can't begin to imagine the shock of this realisation though.
- viraptor 14y agoFortunately you can't be sure. On average around 2/3 people die in a plane crash and you can improve your chances a lot by sitting in the right place (near the aisle, a couple of rows from the back is safest if I remember correctly) with seatbelts on. While still terrifying, I was surprised about those chances of survival and so were most of the people I talked to about it.
- finnw 14y agoReally? I can understand how the front of the aircraft (as it collapses) can cushion the impact if you are in that position, but after that you still have to avoid being killed by hypothermia or drowning (if you hit water) or fire (if you hit land.)
- Pinckney 14y agoThe average plane crash is not a 10km stall into the ground.
- rogerbinns 14y agoIt is remarkably hard to tell especially as your senses get mislead in a plane. This is why there is a very big distinction between VFR and IFR. With VFR (visual) you look out the window and can clearly see the horizon, which way is up etc and cannot fly at night or in weather/visibility conditions. With IFR (instrument) the training is to ignore your senses because they will mislead you and use your instruments instead even if they seem wrong based on your senses. Here for example is a plane rolling while tea is being poured. If you couldn't see out the window you wouldn't even know what was going on http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xp2Uc9XvmjY http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xp2Uc9XvmjY There have been crashes where VFR pilots have flown into instrument conditions and ask which was is up. It sounds incredulous to us on the ground but it really does happen. The net effect is that the passengers and crew on the plane would not have felt as if anything is wrong.
- gouranga 14y agoThe root cause was Technical failure, not pilot error. The instruments were wrong and the burden of accuracy on such a technically complicated machine is on the aircraft. But that's too easy to sue for so the manufacturers of the systems press to blame the dead crew. This is standard corporate culture.
- raldi 14y agoThe fact that the pilot ignored the continuous audible "Stall! Stall! Stall!" alarm and kept the control stick pulled fully back (the opposite of what you want to do in a stall) suggests to me that it's legitimate to place some of the blame on human error.
- ZoFreX 14y agoIt's worth pointing out that the stall alarm goes off both when you go into a stall and when you come out of it, and you have to do very different things in those situations.
- jt2190 14y ago> The fact that the pilot ignored the continuous "Stall! Stall! Stall!" alarm > and kept the control stick pulled fully back The fact is that the black boxes recorded this behavior. Can we be 100% certain that the copilot actually did this? My concern is that we're still trusting the output of a system that has proven to be suspect.
- raldi 14y agoOther than the airspeed sensors freezing up, I'm not aware of any other known malfunctions. What makes you say the system was "proven to be suspect"?
- jt2190 14y agoI'm quoting Wikipedia's summary of the Report: * The stall warning deactivates by design when the angle of attack measurements are considered invalid and this is the case when the airspeed drops below a certain limit. * In consequence, the stall warning stopped and came back on several times during the stall; in particular, it came on whenever the pilot pushed forward on the stick and then stopped when he pulled back; this may have confused the pilots. * Despite the fact that they were aware that altitude was declining rapidly, the pilots were unable to determine which instruments to trust: it may have appeared to them that all values were incoherent. Personally, I'm not sure whether to believe that the copilot simply made an amateur mistake .
- raldi 14y agoCan we clarify the title to "2009 Air France crash 'due to pilot and technical failure'"? The way it is now makes it sound like there was another crash.
- daeken 14y agoThe crash was in 2009. This story is from 2012 -- today, in fact.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ColinWright 14y agoI've amended the title to observe that this is the July 1012 publishing of the final report for the crash that was in 2009.
- raldi 14y agoHmm, it didn't seem to work.
- ColinWright 14y agoSilent failure hitting the 80 char limit, lack of change not noticed on mobile device. Now fixed - sorry.
- rubyrescue 14y agoThe fact that airbus AVERAGES the control inputs, with no indication of conflicting inputs, when one pilot is pulling back and one pilot is pushing down is just a perfect example that even at the most critical points, where the stakes are the highest, we as engineers and designers fail to think through the implications of bad design.
- cjrp 14y agoBut would adding an extra caution light / sound to the already-stressful situation have helped? I agree that averaging the inputs seems like an imperfect solution, but what would the alternative be... ignore both or ignore just the Captain/First Officer's inputs? edit: Re: physically-linked controls (à la Boeing), with one pilot pulling back as hard as he can Vs. the other pushing fwd, isn't the result still (approximately) an average of the two inputs? Obviously they'd feel that the controls weren't moving, but that could be attributed to a number of factors (e.g. icing of the control surfaces).
- rubyrescue 14y agoan alternative would be to move the sticks together, the way non-fly-by-wire planes work.
- rogerbinns 14y agoThey could also make the sticks move together even on fly by wire planes (Boeing does it) using force feedback. That is one thing that Airbus really should have done instead of providing no physical feedback. The expectation is that you would use your eyes instead, but the visual channel is already heavily loaded.
- yesimahuman 14y agoWell the alternative is what planes with yokes were doing before: they move together. However, I feel this behavior would be odd on a joystick...
- simias 14y ago
- kenver 14y agoThere was an interesting discussion on here about this nearly a year ago, after the data recorders turned up. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3327202 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3327202
- joezydeco 14y agoThat HN submission links to a Popular Mechanics article that goes over the last 10-12 minutes of AF447's voice recorder, line by line. It's a very detailed read and worth the time. It will also chill you to the bone.
- crikli 14y agoI wrote an explanation of how flight instruments are powered that is germane to this discussion (and IMO helps clarify what happened). http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2595230 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2595230