7 ms·
Britain's postwar sugar craze confirms harms of sweet diets in early life
- waihtis 2y agoYeah, well modern diets also have a wildly imbalanced omega 3-6 ratio, which causes chronic inflammation which in turn is a central driver of diabetes. Funny how they just disregard it and try to pinpoint everything to a single variable.
- gordyp 2y ago[dead]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- christophilus 2y agoYou’re not wrong. Sugar isn’t the only thing that changed after rations were lifted. Caloric intake in general went way up. Environmental changes came about. Processed foods became mainstream. I just don’t know how you can pinpoint one thing and choose it as the chief villain.
- waihtis 2y agoIndeed. Its the same idiocy as was/is with cholesterole
- eastbound 2y agoHonestly, when I see the young generation in US, it seems it’s kind of a given than young males must bulk up, under penalty of not being instagrammable enough to find a girlfriend. That sentence may sound terribly superficial… but it’s a reality for a lot of young men. Long story short, bulking up is at odds with ecology, and we ask youngsters to do both.
- ipaddr 2y agoThe kids these days are beanpoles and lack muscle mass. Far cry from the 80s.
- kergonath 2y ago> Long story short, bulking up is at odds with ecology, and we ask youngsters to do both. How so? I would think that better nutrition and more physical activity is not at odds with being environmentally conscious, quite the contrary.
- hn_throwaway_99 2y agoI suggest you read the study in detail. I originally had a similar thought as you, but then seeing how the researchers were able to tease out specific effects based on minor differences in birth timing relative to the end of sugar rationing was strong evidence.
- willy_k 2y agoI don’t see how those are mutually exclusive, they said sugar isn’t the only thing, not that it doesn’t have a significant effect.
- hn_throwaway_99 2y agoBecause look at their argument: > Environmental changes came about. Processed foods became mainstream. Those are definitely true, but those happened over time. The lifting of the sugar restrictions happened immediately at one date, and what is interesting is that you see such vastly, statistically significant differences in later diabetes and hypertension rates in babies that were born so close together (within a couple years), the main difference being their amount of sugar intake in very early childhood. It's not like they just looked at "pre-war" vs. "post-war" babies.
- willy_k 2y agoYes, but sugar having a substantial effect as observed does not rule out fat type also having some effect, perhaps as a modulator or synergistic process, such as sugar being the main driver but the body being less capable of coping with sugar when most of what it gets is dead food high in linoliec acid.
- hn_throwaway_99 2y ago> sugar having a substantial effect as observed does not rule out fat type also having some effect Nobody is arguing that it isn't or couldn't. The study does a pretty good job, IMO, of pinpointing sugar intake as an infant as having substantial, significant impact on diabetes and hypertension rates in adulthood. It is not saying that it is the only possible causal factor.
- meiraleal 2y agoSugar raising blood sugar seems like a quite obvious effect but some people argue against it. Edit: it doesn't need much to be smarter than you, waihtis
- waihtis 2y ago[flagged]
- 462436347 2y agoExercise temporarily raises your heart rate and systolic blood pressure, yet avid exercisers have lower RHRs and SBPs; how do you know it isn't the same with carbohydrates, provided fat (especially saturated) is restricted?
- omikun 2y agoAsk an endocrinologist. Robert Lustig has written extensively on the subject. This stuff has already been figured out. Here's one of his famous talks on sugar: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gmC4Rm5cpOI&pp=ygUNcm9iZXJ0IGx1c3RpZw%3D%3D https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gmC4Rm5cpOI&pp=ygUNcm9iZXJ0I...
- EasyMark 2y agoThat is irrefutable. Eat 4 eggs fried in butter and then measure blood sugar an hour later vs eating the same amount of sugar by weight on separate days, on an empty (12 hour fast).
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- midtake 2y agoGood luck convincing anyone of that without being called a crackpot, a disinformation bot, or worse. At this point in my life, I keep such knowledge to myself and leave everyone else to the peril of their own incomplete understanding.
- oliwarner 2y agoRigorous scientific study is more effective than luck.
- inglor_cz 2y agoRigorous scientific study in the nutrition field is extremely hard to do. Most studies rely on self-reported data, and people aren't very reliable in confessing what they ate and in what quantity. We are also a long-lived species and many effects take decades to manifest. Differences in environment (e.g. water impurities), genetics and gut microbiome confound the issue further.
- kergonath 2y agoTo avoid any doubt: there is no scientific basis for “imbalanced omega 3-6 ratio, which causes chronic inflammation which in turn is a central driver of diabetes”. There is no indication that omega-6 in human diet cause inflammation (we don’t eat that much of them, and they are readily metabolised). And as a matter of fact, diabetes is more strongly correlated with sugar than any kind of fat. Actually, the only people I have seen claiming this are conspiracy theorists who jumped on a new boogeyman.
- EasyMark 2y agoIt’s highly likely not one thing. We’ve moved to trash foods, more sugar, worse fats, etc, plus we’re more inactive than ever and being constantly bombarded by stress 24/7 from news and the internet and consumerist mentality.
- waihtis 2y agothank you for reading & comprehending the point, and not somehow concluding I'm claiming sugar doesn't raise blood sugar
- sss111 2y agoIndia saw a similar thing with the sugar craze once the economy opened up in the 1990s— although the diabetes rate has only gone up 2% in three decades.
- FirmwareBurner 2y agoSimilar in Eastern Europe after the fall of USSR when western snacks came on the market and we fell pray to advertising after decades of isolation: "Those sugary western snacks can't be bad for you since they come from the developed west and rich westerners eat them". Oh boy, if we only knew back then what we know today. Probably why a lot of millennials today don't look very healthy.
- llm_trw 2y agoI imagine it has more to do with the smoking and drinking rates than sugar. I very clearly remember an aunt of mine losing her mind in the 90s about me drinking coke, while smoking when she was pregnant.
- Tade0 2y agoI'm from the region and to me it was always about "ooh, this is real chocolate, not Compound chocolate". Even as recently as a decade ago local producers would be using vegetable oils and less sugar so as to keep costs down. I remember being surprised how much sugar there was in plain cookies in Italy. British sweets I cannot touch to this day because they're commonly packed with salt as well as sugar. Same goes for American products - Reese's cupcakes are my holiday season guilty pleasure which inevitably gets me sick every time. They're violently flavourful. On the flip side when I visited Ukraine in 2006 I noted that the local pralines had barely any sugar. The Swiss and Germans seem to understand sweets on a deeper level than the rest. Notable exception is Lindt, which roasts the cocoa beans to seven hells for consistency, achieving a consistently sour-bitter aftertaste in its products.
- FirmwareBurner 2y agoLindt is bottom of the barrel slop with fancy branding attached to it. It's the McDoanlds/Starbucks of chocolate.
- b800h 2y agoThis isn't what the paper actually says, of course. Science by press release again.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Thorrez 2y agoHere's a quote from the abstract of the paper: > Using an event study design with UK Biobank data comparing adults conceived just before or after rationing ended, we found that early-life rationing reduced diabetes and hypertension risk by about 35% and 20%, respectively, and delayed disease onset by 4 and 2 years. Protection was evident with in-utero exposure and increased with postnatal sugar restriction, especially after six months when solid foods likely began. Which part of the title isn't supported by the paper?
- fidotron 2y agoThese things still don’t establish actual causation. For example, someone susceptible to later developing diabetes may consume unusually high quantities of sugar when available as a means to deal with some other insufficiency. (Guess where that idea comes from). The problem is not the sugar per se, but the fact that different people respond to the same consumed items completely differently, something that is very inconvenient for those that want to treat everyone the same way.
- dataflow 2y ago> The problem is not the sugar per se, but the fact that different people respond to the same consumed items completely differently, something that is very inconvenient for those that want to treat everyone the same way. Haven't diabetes rates been steadily rising until today though? How does one explain that away as "people respond differently to sugar"?
- fidotron 2y agoI know this from the simple fact that I respond completely differently to sugar than almost everyone else I know, except gout sufferers. The question is why people are guzzling so much sugar in the first place. The answer is they are malnourished. Post war britain was a particularly bad case they deliberately paper over, but my parents grew up with rationing and never snapped out of it, like many others, which led to many of my generation also being subjected to that diet. It simply fills you up but provides people with my metabolism with no energy at all.
- dataflow 2y agoI'm not disputing that people respond differently to sugar. I'm asking how that explains the diabetes epidemic becoming more and more widespread as time goes on.
- fidotron 2y agoBecause you have a blind spot over people responding differently, as indicated by your original question. If you look at the history of celiac disease the cause wasn’t recognized until a hospital of people were reduced to eating sawdust/dried up tulips, only to find a group of patients actually improved when this happened since they were no longer being actively poisoned. You are not alone in your blind spot, but it is amazing the enthusiasm with which it is promoted by those that should have worked this out years ago.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- 462436347 2y agoUS sugar consumption declined from 2000-2020 to 1970s levels, while its T2D prevalence only increased: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38094768 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38094768 And if sugar is so metabolically harmful, where are the RCTs showing this? All I've seen is that outside of a caloric surplus, it isn't especially metabolically harmful, and ironically, even outside of a surplus, saturated fat is much worse: https://diabetesjournals.org/care/article/41/8/1732/36380/Saturated-Fat-Is-More-Metabolically-Harmful-for https://diabetesjournals.org/care/article/41/8/1732/36380/Sa... https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00394-015-1108-6 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00394-015-1108-6 Meanwhile tribes of hunter-gatherers in Africa get 15-80% of their daily calories from honey during certain seasons; why aren't they obese and diabetic? https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0047248414000815?via%3Dihub https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S00472...
- nightski 2y agoReaders here probably aren't hunter gatherers in Africa though. If you live sedentary lifestyle with an abundance of food you may need to take a different approach to nutrition. Sure it would be ideal if we were all hyper athletes, but the reality is that probably isn't going to happen and I am not sure it's even better holistically.
- schmidtleonard 2y agoThe reason to do RCTs and establish causality isn't to generate excuses for a sugar diet, it's to head off bullshit alternatives that don't fix the problem but advertise like they do.
- amanaplanacanal 2y agoAlmost no RCTs are done when it comes to diet. They are outrageously expensive to do for any length of time, and nobody will fund them. Don't expect to see definitive studies done within your lifetime.
- 462436347 2y ago
- mmsc 2y agoAre there any studies about the harm of a craze in non-sweet diets? While I would generally agree with this "confirmation" based on my understanding of diabetes, I wonder if it's actually sugar that is the problem here. For example, what about the massive amount of caffeine in soda, chocolate, and other "sweet diet" food? Or, what about just general over-consumption of food in postwar regardless of what it is (which is much more a societal issue than anything else)
- omikun 2y agoplenty of studies on caffeine. Chocolate usually comes with loads of sugar unless you mean sugar alternatives? That wouldn't apply to just post war UK though. Also, it's hard to over consume non-sugar so that's not a lot of overlap. Remember carbs break down to sugar as well.
- gitaarik 2y agoCaffeine is not in so much products that it would be such an obvious smoking gun
- ajdude 2y agoDiscussion (39 points | 1 day ago | 64 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42019398 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42019398
- patrickhogan1 2y agoBrain needs glucose.
- smilliken 2y agoThe brain also runs well on ketones which are more energy dense and remove the oxygen bottleneck. It's easier to deliver a consistent level of ketones than glucose, avoiding spikes and crashes.
- patrickhogan1 2y agoKetones are a backup evolved to be used in short durations. How many people have you known who have stayed on a ketogenic diet for 10 or 20 years without ever coming out of ketosis? Before modernity, maintaining long-term ketosis (eg decade+ length) would have been extremely difficult. Some anti-sugar advocates portray sugar as inherently evil, suggesting that any consumption will lead to significant harm. However, moderation is often more practical: 1. Many marathon runners use glucose gels and still enjoy long, healthy lives, typically living about 7 years longer than non-athletes. 2. Most researchers at the National Institute on Aging do not recommend avoiding all sugar or focusing solely on ketogenic diets. In fact, studies show that intermittent fasting often leads to longer lifespans than ketogenic diets. 3. New data is showing that long term ketogenic diets lead to the death of healthy cells, increased adipose tissue, increased triglycerides https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.ado1463 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.ado1463
- gitaarik 2y agoActually, almost all of your body runs on glucose. Your muscles for example. But that glucose is made by your body from the food that you eat, at a steady pace. But if you eat sugary food, it will increase your blood sugar level too fast. Causing your body to produce lots of insulin. The insulin's job is to get the sugar out of your blood to restore safe sugar levels. The two ways in which insulin does this is: - Using the sugar for muscle cells that are active and need fuel. - If there are no muscle cells needing fuel, then it gets stored as glycogen in fat cells for later use, when blood sugar levels are too low. So even though almost all of your body needs glucose, it's not the best if you eat that directly. Unless you would consume the glucose in a constant way keeping your blood sugar level constant. That could be done with an IV, but our bodies have this mechanism that they can take high- protein/fat & low- sugar/carb contents food and use that as a constant source for several hours. Then you only need to refill the stomach once in a while instead of being connected to an IV all day. Edit: BTW, when the blood sugar level spikes from sugary food, insulin will spike thereafter, causing the sugar level to drop very fast, eventually making you feel tired and hungry, craving for a quick (sugary) snack, and the cycle starts again.
- AStonesThrow 2y agoRoald Dahl saw that coming: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charlie_and_the_Chocolate_Factory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charlie_and_the_Chocolate_Fact...
- alliao 2y agocomplimentary link to the book that's got a not so PC title also irate members of the Oxford comma brigade, still worth a read. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pure,_White_and_Deadly https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pure,_White_and_Deadly
- a_c 2y agoI didn't understand when I first moved to the UK. The dessert here is really sweet. I don't understand how people are able to eat that. How can things be tasty when it is that sweet. They are off putting.
- angry_octet 2y agoThis article does us a great disservice by ignoring industrial sugar. The end of sugar rationing also meant that sugar could be added to industrially produced products, like bread. Visitors to America gag on the unbearable sweetness of standard sliced bread, which is commonly sweetened with high fructose corn syrup. Bread in the UK switched to the Chorleywood rapid process in the 60s, which allowed them to use low quality low protein flour. The result is a high glycemic index white bread which is rapidly digested to glucose. That's only bread. Then consider breakfast cereals, baked products, baked beans, etc. Every staple suddenly has massive quantities of sugar.
- Philadelphia 2y agoLike environmental issues, this is a corporate problem being presented as an individual problem. It’s not going to be fixed by every single individual person monitoring every single thing they eat. It’s going to be fixed by removing the incentives for companies to do antisocial things.
- mckn1ght 2y agoIt can be both. Nobody is holding a gun to anyone's head and forcing them to buy sugary cereal, highly processed white bread, peanut butter with sugar, jellies and jams and "maple" syrup that is all just basically corn syrup, sodas, kool aid, and on and on and on. If people won't vote with their wallet, what makes you think they'll vote for someone who'll instate the necessary regulations? Both of those decisions stem from the same requirement to be educated and conscientious on the matter of diet.
- consteval 2y agoPeople are holding a gun, the gun is human nature. If you could buy meth at your local supermarket we'd have a LOT more meth heads. The human mind and body is not built to address addictive substances on a societal scale. We require policy, as we have done with tobacco in the past.
- sirsinsalot 2y agoMind boggling the mental gymnastics people are doing in this thread to deny to themselves the obvious fact that refined sugars are bad for you.
- sorokod 2y agoA timeline of the winding down of post WWII rationing in UK [1] TLDR, it was a gradual process, rationing of sugar ended in September 1953, rationing of meat almost a year latter. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rationing_in_the_United_Kingdom#Timeline https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rationing_in_the_United_Kingdo...