8 ms·
Social Security: The Biggest Ponzi Scheme on Earth (By Milton Friedman)
- harpastum 18y ago"In 1964, Barry Goldwater was much reviled for suggesting that participation in Social Security be voluntary. I thought it was a good idea then. I still think so." A guess why Goldwater was reviled? Voluntary Social Security would be DOA. It doesn't make fiscal sense for the upper class to pay social security, so they wouldn't. That leaves the lower class' taxes going to pay for it--somehow I don't think there's enough there. . Yes, Social Security as is sucks. No, we shouldn't kick it while it's down.
- byrneseyeview 18y agoI don't understand why it would only make sense for one class to buy into Social Security. If it's a good investment, it's a good investment; 'rich' means less than 'has a particular set of risk/return preferences'. And I think you validate his point if you claim that social security is only solvent because it redistributes money from the rich to the poor. If the system is unsustainable without giving some people a lower return to subsidize other investors (i.e. soaking the rich to pay off the electorate), it's a ponzi scheme.
- mattmaroon 18y agoSocial Security isn't a good investment for anyone and it never has been. It wasn't meant to be. It was meant to prevent our seniors from plunging into poverty because that would have many negative effects on society as a whole. If you made it opt out, people would fall into two categories. One would be smart enough to manage their own money and opt out because they can get a better rate of return putting it in a money market. One would be too dumb to manage their own money and opt out because they don't want to pay 12.4% extra income tax. Either way, Social Security would be opted out by almost everyone and totally fail to accomplish the objectives it was created for. At least the way it is, it has a chance, assuming it can remain adequately funded. I'm actually against Social Security (at least in its current incarnation) but recognize the need for some form of it that is forced.
- dantheman 18y agoWhy can't we let people live with their decisions? Obviously those who opt out have better things to do with their money @ least from thier pov?
- tptacek 18y agoBecause pooling risk and providing a baseline standard of living helps everyone, not just the direct beneficiaries of entitlements; for instance, current entrepreneurs aren't paralyzed in steady corporate jobs out of fear that they will need to supplement their parents income to prevent them from eating cat food. Again: of course it is true that skilled investors can net a better return on their FICA dollars than Social Security can. Social Security isn't an investment program.
- mattmaroon 18y agoSkilled investors? You'd get a better return from the CD at your bank.
- tptacek 18y agoConceded. I think my point still stands, though.
- dantheman 18y agoI'm still going to have to disagree. You are only looking at one side of the equation, those receiving the benefits and ignoring those who are harmed. How many companies go out of business because they can't compete due to these taxes, how much investment is lost/misdirected since an individual cannot decide where to invest their funds. I could have invested in a store in my neighborhood, but instead the money will be spent by someone in some other area. It's hard to know exactly what we're missing out on because of the massive amount of wealth redirection.
- tptacek 18y ago
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- viggity 18y agoSS is supposed to pay benefits in proportion to how much you put into the system (each dollar YOU specifically put in, you supposed to get out). It wasn't meant as a wealth redistribution scheme and so far it isn't a hardcore redistribution scheme. The "rich" are capped at paying 15% of their income up to ~$100k. Not much money from the rich currently goes to the poor via SS (Medicaid is a different beast) Now, Obama has floated the idea to remove the $100k cap, WITHOUT paying any additional benefit. With the economy in its current condition, he has backed off that idea, but I won't be surprised if he resurrects the idea if we have a quick recovery. SS is a scam because on average it pays roughly 1% interest per year, versus an 8% average return in stock market. Furthermore it is scam because the government feels compelled to hide half of the money it takes from you by making your employer pay for half of your FICA taxes.
- mattmaroon 18y agoIt's not really a Ponzi scheme. A Ponzi scheme pays interest to attract investors so it needs significantly more customers with each iteration. Madoff's infamous one paid out 12% annually, so it needed to grow by 12% each year just to achieve stasis (or it would have if cash outs equaled profits anyway, some years it was probably more or less). Social Security isn't a Ponzi scheme because it would work perfectly well if the population remained stable over time, or shrank. And it would even be alright if it grew slowly and linearly. What really throws a wrench in the cogs is when the generation retiring is much larger than the ones still working, especially the one or two before it. This is why the Baby Boomers leaving the work force is so problematic. The good news (in a sick sort of way) is that our diet and health care are so bad that we save a little due to lifespans actually shrinking. People mistakenly attribute the problem to longer lifespans, but the expectancy of a working-age adult (the only group that matters for the purposes of entitlements) has barely budged since before Social Security was invented, and is now quite possibly shrinking. Lifespan from birth (as it is typically expressed) has risen almost entirely due to lower infant mortality.
- chaostheory 18y agothe main problem with Social Security isn't really changes in population size (though it still is a problem). The core problem of Social Security is this: "Taxes paid by today’s workers are used to pay today’s retirees. If money is left over, it finances other government spending—though, to maintain the insurance fiction, paper entries are created in a “trust fund” that is simultaneously an asset and a liability of the government. When the benefits that are due exceed the proceeds from payroll taxes, as they will in the not very distant future, the difference will have to be financed by raising taxes, borrowing, creating money, or reducing other government spending." Basically politicians (of both parties) raid the Social Security fund and just leave IOU notes behind to fund their pork projects. If the money was untouchable and only used for Social Security, the problems we'd see with just population changes wouldn't be nearly as bad... hence (I could be wrong but I feel) this is one of the core arguments that Social Security is a Ponzi scheme.
- mattmaroon 18y ago
- gislebertus 18y agoSeems like there's an awful lot of polemical posts on Hacker News lately from Conservative political organizations. Guess they figured out that here they could promote their agenda for free. Is that really what Hacker News wants to be? A political forum? If so, I'll encourage the folks at Media Matters, Center for American Progress, and Campaign for America's Future to start posting here. It's bad enough that Conservative political groups are hijacking a startup news aggregator. It's worse that the ideas they're pushing don't work. Conservatism--the political philosophy promoted by AEI, Hoover, Heritage et al--is the flip side of Communism. With Communism, the purpose of people is to serve The State. In Conservatism, the purpose of people is to serve The Market. Thus, popular New Deal programs such as Social Security are anathema to them. Both Communism and Conservatism work badly, producing similar effects. Our unregulated Conservative markets have crashed and burned just as badly as the Russians' hyper-regulated Communist markets did. States and countries run on Conservative principles are typically backward and stagnant: --Mississippi and Alabama have Conservative state governments, and have practically no startup activity. Massachusetts and New York are not Conservative, which makes them capable of spawning MIT and Silicon Alley. --Conservatives say that the keys to a strong economy is low taxes on rich people and unregulated markets. We've had them for the past decade, just as we did in the 1920s, and just as it did in the 1920s, our economy has melted down. What happened when we had sky-high taxes on rich people, and highly regulated markets? We got the U.S. economic boom of the 40s, 50s, and 60s, and built the world's biggest middle class. The fact that their political philosophy has produced poor results doesn't give the folks at AEI/Hoover/Heritage pause, however. Just like the old Communists, these Conservatives are now complaining that "Conservatism DOES work! It's just never been tried!" Just as with Communism, Conservatism never fails, it is only failed. As for the ideas of Milton Friedman that these Hacker News Hijackers are pushing, we may want to read what a Nobel Prize-winning economist has to say about them: http://www.nybooks.com/articles/19857 http://www.nybooks.com/articles/19857
- byrneseyeview 18y agoI have seen a lot from libertarians; few from conservatives or Conservatives. Which particular anti-abortion, pro-war, pro-Drug War, traditionalist, or otherwise conservative articles were you referring to? I think it's really funny that when you see some viewpoints with which you disagree, it is because some big, anonymous agglomeration ("Conservatives!") must be abusing their freedom of speech by saying things with which many HN readers agree (and your solution -- telling an actual big, anonymous agglomeration to push their viewpoints here -- just seems to exacerbate the problem). A few other points: In Conservatism, the purpose of people is to serve The Market. What does it mean to 'serve' the market? The market is an abstraction -- you can't make 'it' better or worse-off, though you can do that to participants. Our unregulated Conservative markets You're referring to how the unregulated hedge funds produced much worse returns than the highly-regulated commercial- and investment-banking industries -- and how the only safe spot in the current financial turmoil is the highly-regulated, government-created, government-subsidized mortgage industry, right? Right? Mississippi and Alabama have Conservative state governments, and have practically no startup activity. Massachusetts and New York are not Conservative, which makes them capable of spawning MIT and Silicon Alley. Has it not occurred to you that you have the cause and effect wrong, here? New York and California can have more abusive governments because even if you pay 50% of your marginal income in taxes, you're still better off starting a startup in CA than in Mississippi, or trading derivatives in New York rather than Alabama. What happened when we had sky-high taxes on rich people, and highly regulated markets? Some day, you will be introduced to the term 'loophole'. You will wonder why the three-martini lunch and the company car used to be so common, and are now so rare. You will run the numbers on the Reagan tax cuts and find that the reduction in nominal rates would imply gigantic cuts in total income received, which is not what happened -- and then you'll realize that, in general, tax cuts are accompanied by loophole-closing, and tax increases are accompanied by loophole creation. That's just how things work. Thank you for linking to Paul Krugman, well-known as the first person to be awarded the Nobel Memorial Prize for his political rants in a popular newspaper, rather than his academic papers. I haven't actually read what the prize committee said about him, but everyone I've met who agrees with Krugman's polemics seems to see the prize as new evidence in their favor, so I am assuming that this is what the award was for. Right?
- tokenadult 18y ago"The present discounted value of the promises embedded in the Social Security law greatly exceeds the present discounted value of the expected proceeds from the payroll tax. The difference is an unfunded liability variously estimated at from $4 trillion to $11 trillion--or from slightly larger than the funded federal debt that is in the hands of the public to three times as large." The mismatch between the promised benefits that many voters think they have "earned" by "saving" money in their personal "Social Security accounts" and the actual funding capacity of the Social Security system is why it looks like Mr. Ponzi was the designer of the system. The overall societal effect of Social Security as it is currently funded is a massive wealth transfer from the working young to the nonworking old, which is excellent politics but rather poor economics.
- mattmaroon 18y agoEven if it wasn't for the anomalous population boom that is causing the problem, you would essentially be being forced by the government to put a portion of your salary into an investment with a 0% interest rate. Which granted, would look good to a lot of people right now, but is bad financial planning on the whole. On the other hand, I reject his cries of paternalism for the simple reason that other people's poverty has a negative effect on my life, liberty, and pursuit of happiness. Poor people have incredibly high rates of criminal activity, drug use, etc. Granted, I don't see a lot of retirees selling crack or robbing banks, but the effect it could have on their families, who sometimes they support or sometimes support them, could create a serious ripple down through generations. Which doesn't necessarily mean I'm for Social Security or forced savings of any kind, but the issue is not nearly so simple as paternalism.
- Retric 18y agoIn defense of social security: It pays significant disability and survives benefits which has little to do with investing and everything to do with insurance. So consider SS as insurance in case of a long life. Some people will live well over 100 so finding the "correct" amount of money to save is overkill for most people who die far younger than that. If you invested a portion of your savings each year and pooled you money with 10,000 other people your age then paid dividends from that to the survivors you could save less money and still not worry about running out. Granted if to many people lived until retirement age you might need to reduce benefits. Granted you would not be able to give people money at the time of your death but if your single what's the point? Now the implementation of social security is broken in several ways but minor changes in retirement age will fix the "benefit gap" long before it runs out of money. The basic problem is people are living longer so they need to increase average retirement age. The surplus was also invested in government bonds with terrible long term returns etc, but when you consider how much more important the first 20k/year is over the next you might consider guaranteed benefits even at high cost are worth a lot more than the simple math would suggest. PS: There are a lot of things I hate about SS, but it's not really a Ponzi scheme.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 18y agoOnce every couple years, a "new" group of people gets all huffy about the fact that Social Security taxes "aren't really invested at all", but rather pay off current retirees. It's a false controversy. That's the intent of the system. The people collecting Social Security today paid for the previous generation's baseline defined benefit retirement. Social security isn't an investment plan, and it isn't a welfare plan. It's not a sports car either. It's an easy, cheap, intellectually flimsy argument to snipe at it by saying it's bad at being something it isn't intended to be.
- mmmurf 18y agoYou may be right, but the intent of the system doesn't really matter. When SS began the tax was 1%, now it's 12.5% and benefits have been decreasing every year. Sadly, the planners didn't anticipate just how population trends would play out, and so the initial idea -- that everyone pays 1% and then no old folks have to worry about poverty if they choose to retire -- just doesn't quite work out any longer. The trouble is that people can't really rely on social security for (guess what?) security! Will congress increase the payroll tax to 30%? Will it decrease social security benefits drastically? Will it fund SS out of general revenue at the expense of other programs? Will American taxpayers decide that SS is worth a middle class income tax rate of 55%? The answer to all of these things is the same: maybe. But that's not security. Obama has wisely advocated converting SS into a welfare program, but that hasn't gotten much traction. The point is, with population trends doing what they are, somthing has to give. When people running for office talk aobut "saving Social Security" they are not honest about the impending outcome of obvious demographic trends. Meanwhile, all of us pay 12.5% of every paycheck into something that will probably offer us ZERO security in retirement.
- gislebertus 18y agoAs a long-time entrepreneur, I'm concerned most about a market: are there people able and willing to buy what I'm selling? Social Security helps with the "able" part, by making sure that no American lives in abject poverty if they're old or crippled. Before Social Security, this was a big problem. About a quarter of Americans lived in poverty, and about half of old people. More people with more money to spend means a bigger market for whatever I'm selling. That's why Social Security is good. That's why markets are bigger in places with lots of Social Security-type programs (Europe, the U.S.) than in places without them (South America, Africa). Social Security also helps make it possible for me to be an entrepreneur. I know that I can take risks and not plunge my family into abject poverty if I'm crippled and can't work. Why did I write about Conservatism in relation to this article? Because when someone is attacking Social Security, it's almost always as part of a larger political agenda they're promoting: Conservatism. This article was from the Hoover Institution, a politically Conservative organization that pushes to eliminate New Deal programs like Social Security (not just SS). They also push for unregulated markets, and flat or regressive taxes. So does the American Enterprise Institute. So does the Heritage Foundation. These groups call themselves "think tanks," which implies objective research. Unfortunately, they aren't averse to pushing false information or abandoning their principles to promote their interests. For example, For example, the Heritage Foundation sharply criticized Malaysia's government for years. After a consulting firm owned by Heritage's president began representing Malaysian business interests, Heritage assessments of Malaysia turned positive. (http://thinkprogress.org/2005/04/17/money-talks-at-heritage/ http://thinkprogress.org/2005/04/17/money-talks-at-heritage/)
- antiismist 18y agoI'm not sure why you are writing about the Heritage Foundation or "Conservatism": Milton Friedman is a classic liberal (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Classical_liberalism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Classical_liberalism), so it's a strange vicarious ad hominem attack. His laissez-faire ideas have been extremely influential and have a stunning track record of success where they have been used.
- nihilocrat 18y ago
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- spkthed 18y agoIt may not technically be a Ponzi scheme but it is in effect. If you're not able to take out what you put in, you're losing money. If you work 40 years, putting in 12% of your salary (companies have to pay it, otherwise it would be part of your salary) you should get all that 12% back for 40 years. Since most people don't live to 108, SS pays very low monthly payments and pays back about half of a lifetime. If you die however, you don't. Sure there's exceptions but... you can do better on our own. Mutual funds, Money Market accounts... heck, even bonds and CD's would enable you to pass it down. In addition, from 15 on, 12% of your income even if you only make $8 an hour for 52 years and only invest it in something that nets 10% would easily make you a multi-millionaire. You could retire comfortably and still pass it down. Since we're facing massive shortfalls, isn't that about the same as a Ponzi scheme? Also, I've been reading this site for probably close to a year. I greatly appreciate having intelligent people post comments. Sites like Digg or Reddit not only have very biased commenters, they also usually only parrot whatever HuffingtonPost or Keith Olbermann said the night before. It's mindless. Intellectual comments, even if they're not ones I agree with are interesting to read. Kudos to you guys!
- tptacek 18y agoFirst, the words "ponzi scheme" don't mean "anything where you put X in and get X - n out." Second, Social Security isn't an investment program. The goal of Social Security is to provide each generation of retirees with a baseline level of income. It has succeeded at this task. Third, we're not facing massive shortfalls. We raised taxes on the baby boomers in the early '80s to build up the social security trust fund to pay for their retirement. As it stands, social security is a small part of the entitlements problem moving forward --- Medicare has more than 7 times its liabilities in the projected future. Fourth, this "small payments" thing is a myth. 2/3rds of Social Security beneficiaries derive more than half their income from Social Security; more than 1/3rd of them derive the overwhelming majority of their income from it.
- dantheman 18y agoThere is no such thing as a social security trust fund. The government uses that money to fund other programs and puts IOUs in there; that means when more are receiving than contributing there will be a massive tax burden on those contributing they get hit with both their normal SS tax, plus the taxes to cover the shortfall.
- alecco 18y agoA shame it is impossible to down-vote stories.
- patrickg-zill 18y agoSS started as a scam and will end as a scam. SS was set up with rules based on actuarial tables, used by all insurance companies. The rules for 65 as the start of collection were because the actuarial tables at the time showed that only about 25% of the population would reach that age. And since white women live the longest, black men were paying for a benefit it was unlikely they would ever receive. SS did not originally have survivor benefits and disability either, those were added by FDR in the years after SS originally passed. Unlike either term or whole life insurance, SS pays nothing if you die before your time for payments to start. With term, you would get paid, with whole life, there would be other investment benefits involved, like the ability to borrow against a certain amount of the policy while still alive.