4 ms·
I don't believe this even in the most charitable reading.
by tptacek 2y ago
I don't believe this even in the most charitable reading.
- Supermancho 2y agoSome people are convinced that healthcare initiatives are so corrupt as to be theater, in regard to finding new treatments, somehow forgetting that the competition is measured on a race to the highest survival rating (both in large populations and small populations looking to grow - ie Israel). Billions of dollars is nothing if you have billions of people paying even 20$ a month for the duration of their extended lives, going forward through history (since cancer wont stop). It's a purile fantasy that their is a cabal of mustache twirlers, sabotaging medical discovery. Do you know what motivates hedges to fund new startups effectively? Success in previous investments. Drug cures have nothing but upsides for every economic strata.
- xk_id 2y agoExcept there is an overabundance of historical evidence of hedge funds giving almost exclusive preference to research which is highly predictable and has negligible impact, as long as it can result in a patent. See for example below. Aging research is one of the most eclectic areas, because it touches on virtually all biological systems. There are countless promising directions which are grossly underexplored. Yet this massive hedge fund chose to invest in discovering new analogs to older drugs. Why? Because the older drugs are effective, discovering new analogs is easy and the patented products can then be marketed. For general overview of the fund: https://www.technologyreview.com/2022/06/07/1053132/saudi-arabia-slow-aging-metformin/ https://www.technologyreview.com/2022/06/07/1053132/saudi-ar... Their first major investment was in analogues of a decades old drug called rapamycin: https://www.hevolution.com/en/web/guest/w/hevolution-foundation-announces-20-million-impact-investment-to-advance-promising-aging-therapies-leading-a-50-million-series-a-extension-in-aeovian-pharmaceuticals https://www.hevolution.com/en/web/guest/w/hevolution-foundat... So, yes. There is a provable cabal of mustache twirling investors who optimise for profit, at the cost of impact. Why you would defend them, in spite of your self-professed rational interest in the positive externalities of revolutionary healthcare, is beyond me.
- Retric 2y agoFunding in addition to not too the exclusion of. People still fund new restaurants and strip malls not just startups. Closely related drugs may not cure new diseases but they do help. There’s a lot of drugs like Morphine but the thing is that give doctors options for better treatment. Fast acting and fast metabolizing is beneficial when an EMT is helping someone deal is massive trauma, post surgery recovery and you want a different drug. Cialis and Viagra may both make your dick hard, but millions of people benefit from the options from having both.
- xk_id 2y agoFunding is the essence of scarcity. Funding one thing means those money will not be funding anything else. But you're free to be content with countless minor variations on existing treatments [0]. Curing cancers will require an actual breakthrough. [0] https://duckduckgo.com/?q=capitalism+breeds+innovation&t=ftsa&iar=images&iax=images&ia=images https://duckduckgo.com/?q=capitalism+breeds+innovation&t=fts...
- Retric 2y agoTotal funding for all human activities is scarce, but can go to anything. Money spent on video games could instead be used to fund cancer research. Thus the percentage of that funding going to medicine isn’t fixed. We essentially spend extra money on this kind of research rather than diverting cancer funding to look for new pain medications. Further, people with sage IV cancer really have benefitted from better pain meds it’s not as useful as a cure but it’s still useful. Capitalism has freed 90% of humanity to do something other than farm food. We’re in the 3rd stage of human history first almost everyone was hunter gatherer, then nearly everyone was farmers, now people do all kinds of things. How we spend that seemingly boundless surplus of labor may not seem efficient, but it doesn’t need to be to be dramatically better.
- xk_id 2y agoProgress is exponential. So looking in the past and saying we should be content with a 90% improvement is misleading, because it is dwarfed by how much more potential there is.
- zxexz 2y agoThat’s good, because it’s total nonsense. There are many things that hold back cancer research, but this story of conspiracy is not one of them. Cutting edge pharma companies, believe it or not, have an incentive to cure cancer. Even from a naive supply and demand argument it makes no sense.