5 ms·
Apex Legends is taking away its support for the Steam Deck and Linux
- Centigonal 2y agoI wish there was a model for anti-cheat that wasn't "grant irrevocable full control of your hardware via rootkit to the developer and anti-cheat manufacturer via a secure boot chain that you're not allowed to touch (on your device!)" I don't think trust is a bad thing, but this feels forced and unpleasant.
- RunSet 2y agoThe model is this: Let players run their own servers and host their own playgroups as they did before game servers were monetized. Then when someone cheats you ban them until they apologize in person and sing the Very Sorry Song. This has been proven to work time and again. The only reason it is not the default is that some value extractor just has to feed their kids.
- mulmen 2y agoFeed their kids… on a yacht.
- mjr00 2y agoHow do dedicated servers work with skill-based matchmaking and ranking systems?
- cherryteastain 2y agoYou go on a server. You're getting smoked. They kick you or you leave because the people there are way above you. Alternatively, you're too pro and you get bored and look for a server with higher average skill.
- VyseofArcadia 2y agoI think they are orthogonal models. With dedicated servers, people sort of self-organize into groups of people they want to play with, maybe based on skill or fun or something else. Maybe you know who runs the server IRL, or you just randomly tried the server. Maybe you just get along with that group of people, maybe they're a group that is dedicated to improving and that's exactly what you want. I think parent's point is that you don't need skill-based matchmaking and ranking systems if you give players the ability to self-organize.
- mjr00 2y agoThe question was somewhat facetious. Being able to click "Find Match" and be able to match up against someone close to your skill level in a few seconds is a feature that players want. A ranked leaderboard that's somewhat legitimate and has prestige in climbing is a feature that players want. You don't need this stuff, of course, but people (who don't play games) love to dismiss these things as if they don't matter.
- VyseofArcadia 2y agoSo, then, why not both? The players that want to just jump into a match can deal with the kernel anticheat, and the players that are willing to find a dedicated server don't have to deal with rootkits. I mean, I know the answer, it's because doing both would be significantly more work for unproven returns, but still, a guy can dream.
- cortesoft 2y agoWe do have both… some games have centralized servers, some games have player hosted ones. You are free to play either kind.
- surgical_fire 2y agoPeople want the weirdest things. The rise of those things you describe matched the decline of my interest in any form of online multiplayer.
- Spunkie 2y agoRanking/competitive systems truly are a cancer on games. So many quality of life standards have been sacrificed just to let jackasses feel superior to others in what is supposed to be a fun game.
- mjr00 2y agoOn the contrary, skill-based matchmaking is a godsend for casual players, as long as they don't care about their rank. If you're a bottom 50% player, you really don't want to get matched up against a Challenger League of Legends player or Master Street Fighter 6 player or The Wazzler in Marvel vs Capcom 2.
- Spunkie 2y agoI played plenty of unranked LoL back in the day, it was generally a better over all experience. Mostly because ranked games were full of tryhards that raged constantly and in general didn't actually treat the game like a game. ___ In fact now that I think about it... some of my funnest LoL games back in the day was when I got paired with someone way out of my league in unranked and they would spend a lot of the game mentoring teammates. And when the opposite happened, we would get stomped quickly and would be able to into a new match quickly. No one felt the need to drag out a unfun/mismatched game because their ranking would get hurt. Wasn't really an issue.
- valval 2y agoYes, people of competitive nature like competing.
- surgical_fire 2y agoThis does not match my experience. By far, the best time I had in online multiplayer was playing Dota (the WC3 map, not the standalone atrocity that exists nowadays). No ranked whatever. Every game was a blank slate. Nobody really cared, everyone was having fun. People tried weird builds, odd team composition, etc. You sometimes played with nice people and added them to friends. With ranked matchmaking everybody is pissy if you are not playing optimally, everyone moans and hisses when they lose, etc.
- valval 2y agoI played a game called Wolfenstein: Enemy Territory at the pro level (of course making small amounts of money even as a teenager like things were back then). A lot of the time in the game was spent scrimming on private servers against other teams. Public games were played on the team’s public server, where people of all skill levels would meet. The highest skilled players would always look to be challenged and would switch to the weaker team all the time. Of course on the scoreboard you’d have people who had a K/D of 40/2 and people who were 1/12. People who weren’t looking to improve and got stomped would of course leave. After a while of playing on a server you’d know the good players and they’d also self select to form teams with each other and move to private servers.
- extr 2y agoNo. This model doesn't really work for Battle Royale games, plus the userbase of modern gaming is so much larger and more casual than it was back in CS2 days or whatever you're imagining. People who only have time to play a couple matches at the end of the day do not want to spend half the time available hunting around for a "good server" appropriate to their interest/skill level or develop a personal relationship with the mods.
- thot_experiment 2y agoCorrect. 1000% correct. This is also how you build community. Also the f2p model isn't doing us any favors by making new accounts cost zero, though iirc cheats can cost like $100/mo so I assume dedicated cheaters would still cheat if games all cost money.
- Notatheist 2y agoAny community smaller than 200 people is going to have you typing !add in an mIRC channel and waiting 20 minutes during prime-time for a pickup game between 10 mismatched players. Any community larger than 200 people is going to be unmanageable cheat wise. If I had the option of Quake 3 Arena-style "matchmaking" and no cheats, or 2024 matchmaking and cheats I'd choose option 2 every time.
- cortesoft 2y agoI have been playing online games for 30 years, and you are leaving out a TON of the value you get from centralized hosting and matchmaking. At any time of day or night, I can just sign in and immediately find a match. In addition, it can match me against players that are close to my skill level so the games I play are fair and challenging. I can keep my statistics to see how I do over time in those fair and challenging games. This is a very valuable service. I have played on plenty of community hosted servers, and the experience is hit or miss. Sometimes, you will get power hungry mods who ban anyone who is better than them, or won’t ban the cheaters because they are friends. Without the anti cheat tools, it is often very hard to distinguish people who are really good and people who are cheating, so you leave it up to the whims of the moderators. Yes, you could tell me to just go and find a different server, but I don’t want to spend my time trying to find a good server I just want to play… and who knows if the good server I find will still be around the next time I play. I have thousands of hours on both types of games, and for any sort of competing games (whether FPS, RTS, or sports), I get a lot more enjoyment out of centralized matchmaking with anticheat.
- ThatPlayer 2y agoIt doesn't because server operators don't want a unpaid full time job moderating a server. If anything, community servers have more anti-cheat not less. ESEA and FaceIt servers for CS2 have additional anti-cheat. FiveV community servers for GTAV rolled their own anti-cheat before Rockstar added one recently. I even remember ICCUP for Starcraft 1 had 'anti-hack'. Being able to host your own playgroups is generally possible in modern games still. Private lobbies on their public servers exist, but that's still more effort than people are willing to do versus hitting the 'play game' button. We used to call those PUGs.
- foresto 2y agoThere is. At least two, actually. 1. Allow community-hosted servers, as were common 20 years ago. These can be moderated with greater attention than a massive global server, and tend to eject cheaters quickly. 2. Server-side analysis. This is arguably more expensive to implement than forcing every player to accept a rootkit, but machine learning might reduce the cost. Moreover, it is more effective in at least one dimension: it can't be circumvented* like a rootkit can. * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RwzIq04vd0M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RwzIq04vd0M
- oliwarner 2y agoThere is. It's a hybrid of recording, cooperative state/action validation and community moderation (overwatch, votekicks, VAC bans on external review). Each of these allows you to see if people are doing things they're able to. The rest is just matchmaking. But this approach takes up server disk space and client CPU time. It's also reactive. Snooping at hardware is easy. You don't even have to do it game-by-game. That's the reason.
- andreareina 2y agoTrust goes both ways.
- dmitrygr 2y agoThere is. Console gaming. Since you have no expectation of running your own code on the console, locked down is the expected state.
- Raymond122 2y ago[dead]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ChocolateGod 2y agoWhat makes you doubt this? It's true, anti-cheat on Linux is ridiculously harder than it is on Windows. You have many more hard to detect methods for a cheat program to interact with the game and fool-proof way to verify the environment.
- cevn 2y agoNice, another game I can uninstall..
- zoklet-enjoyer 2y agoIt's just a game. So what if there's cheating? Ban them if they get caught
- ChocolateGod 2y agoThe issue is that it's hard to catch it on Linux and it ruins the game for other players.
- moomin 2y agoDoesn’t work that way. Cheaters ruin regular player’s experience, bans are easily circumvented. This is a recipe for “No-one plays your game.” I think kernel-level anti-cheat is a security nightmare, but denying there’s a genuine economic motive here seems naïve.
- imtringued 2y agoI'm pretty sure nobody plays a game that actively prevents you from playing it.
- jajko 2y agoHow do cheaters circumvent bans? I would presume you have some unique copy key which is activated, and once it gets revoked should never ever allow you to connect to their game servers. Company runs entire ecosystem, how apart from hacking their DBs you can ever get back?
- jlamberts 2y agoWith free games (which make up a pretty large portion of competitive online games), cheaters who get banned usually just make or buy new accounts.
- Spunkie 2y agoNaw this is all bullshit. If apex legends released a real dedicated server tomorrow, within a month there would be a large selection of well moderated community servers and cheaters would be mostly a non-issue. EA doesn't care to actually moderate cheating, because that either takes ongoing money to pay people or a loss of control by releasing dedicated servers. They instead just want to pay 1 time to "automate" their "solution" to cheating... even though that pretty much never works long term.
- Spunkie 2y agoSometimes it's silly to think about EA being voted the most hated/worst company of the year, multiple years in a row. And then I remember they literally spend their free time thinking of ways to piss off their own customers.
- mvdtnz 2y agoAn overwhelming majority of players (not the noisy ones on internet forums) prefer anti cheat and don't care about the details of how the software is installed.
- SapporoChris 2y agoProgress has not followed a straight ascending line, but a spiral with rhythms of progress and retrogression, of evolution and dissolution. — Johann Wolfgang von Goethe
- fullspectrumdev 2y agoI might be old or something, but I really don’t give a fuck if someone’s cheating in a video game. It was basically the norm when I was growing up, there was always someone using wall hacks or whatever, it was just kinda funny and never ruined the fun.
- Dilettante_ 2y agoPeople get sweaty in competitive online these days, especially on the AAA titles.
- bravetraveler 2y agoI didn't even really care when it mattered. For money. We could dispute, an investigation would happen. Life went on.
- Coolbeanstoo 2y agoI kinda feel the same way.. I imagine games not having community servers and focusing heavily on rank/seasons etc makes it feel a lot more serious? Idk I used to find community on dedicated servers, it was part of the game, with in game text/voice chat, now the community exists entirely outside of it in discords etc.
- lasc4r 2y agoGetting a win is the intermittent reward players get from these battle royale games against 20 or so other teams, when a hacker ruins that it's pretty annoying.
- beastman82 2y agoI mean try to play TF2 with the bots and report back. The game is ruined. Thank Jeebus for community servers
- chikenf00t 2y agoI haven't touched TF2 in almost a year. The joy I felt playing that game has left since the cheating epidemic and I don't think it's ever coming back.
- bogwog 2y ago> While the population of Linux users is small, their impact infected a fair amount of players’ games. So Linux users are malware?
- Dilettante_ 2y agoLinux users have cooties
- jampa 2y agoThis sucks, but makes sense, nothing kills games community faster than cheating. And I don't think publishers spent time enought on combating it. I used to play Counter Strike since 1.5 era, and quit CS:GO entirely because there was a blatant cheater every match, even with the phone verification and AI trust factor (which Valve brags about it, but it doesn't work at all). PUBG also had an era with lot of cheaters and lot of people dropped the game. Like the article says, when Linux gets critical mass, with the Steam Deck's broader adoption for example (their market is still very limited) it will make more sense to support this.
- riversflow 2y agoI really wish we would see some legislative action on this. Selling and publishing cheats should be completely illegal and punished heavily.
- steveklabnik 2y agoYou might enjoy this story from earlier this year: https://www.theverge.com/2024/5/25/24164679/bungie-anti-cheating-lawsuit-jury-trial-aimjunkies-copyright-violation-victory https://www.theverge.com/2024/5/25/24164679/bungie-anti-chea...
- ggu7hgfk8j 2y agoIs this casually related to the previous kernel anti cheat story https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41999314 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41999314?
- pixelpoet 2y agoSince it's for exactly that reason I'd assume so.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- GiveOver 2y agoI always struggled with Apex Legends on Linux. It didn't pre-load shaders, which led to a very jittery experience for the first round or two. Even after that you still get jitters here and there when it needs to load something new. It wasn't worth doing every time there was a new update.
- PaulHoule 2y agoThat’s about as smart as releasing an AAA title as a console exclusive.
- stonogo 2y agoI said this in the other thread, but KLA isn't about preventing cheaters. It's about protecting the artificial scarcity of products for sale via microtransaction.
- zeta0134 2y ago> “You can freely manipulate the kernel, and there’s no user mode calls to attest that it’s even genuine,” says Koskinas. “You could make a Linux distribution that’s purpose-built for cheating and we’d be smoked.” These are features, not bugs. Cheating must be detected serverside. Never trust the client, this is basic security. Breaking the user's client security is not a valid solution, and I get increasingly frustrated with these gaming companies that insist that a rootkit is "fine" and "normal" and "something a regular user should install without question"
- yodon 2y ago>Cheating must be detected serverside. Never trust the client, this is basic security. As long as rendering happens on the client, it's going to require client-side anti-cheat to stop players from looking through walls or adding aimbots. Client side rendering means the client has information like the location of the opponent even when the opponent is not visible. The server is unable to tell on its own whether the client is using this information inappropriately.
- Spunkie 2y agoServer side cheat detection is not just about actually detecting active cheating on the server side. It's also about the server providing the client the absolute minimum amount of information needed to function/render.
- zeta0134 2y agoYes, for an FPS I don't really see a practical way around having the server do some rendering work, in order to detect occlusion and stop sending visual updates when it's pretty sure the client isn't able to see that object. There's a balance to be struck. Other techniques include simple statistical analysis: it's usually pretty damn obvious when a player is making inputs that shouldn't be humanly possible consistently, or reacting to information they shouldn't be able to see. That doesn't have to be done in realtime, it can be stored and reviewed later. (That might even be a feature on its own: delayed bans make it harder for cheaters to know if their techniques were detectable.)
- cortesoft 2y agoI really don’t understand all the people on this thread acting like gamers should just deal with cheaters. Anyone who plays online games knows how quickly it becomes not fun when there are obvious cheaters. It isn’t like 10% less fun, it is 100% less fun. Online games where you play against other people are fun because of competition, and cheating makes it so there is no competition. There are a lot of games where cheating wouldn’t be an issue, but games like Apex legends aren’t those.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- VyseofArcadia 2y agoI feel like eventually most genres of competitive game will just have to end up adopting the model that the fighting game community came up with organically. Online play is fine for practice and unofficial tournaments, but if you really want to get good and make a name for yourself, you need to play at weeklies, monthlies, and in-person tournaments where the hardware and software are controlled by the tournament organizers. It does help that cheating can only help so much in fighting games. I haven't thought about it much, but I guess you could have a macro that executes a devastating combo? Even then you need to be skilled enough at defense and hit confirming to even know when to press the "win the game" button. And most of the games I play have enough defensive options[0] that the player executing the combo might still need to react to something. [0] E.g. bursts in Guilty Gear
- mjr00 2y agoThe FGC has a really interesting history with online play. Besides having a long tradition of in-person PvP in arcades, online fighting games were largely unplayable until the mid-late 2010s until GGPO/rollback[0] became popular. For a long, long time, the FGC largely (and rightfully) didn't see online play as legitimate. Now rollback is basically standard and you do see competitive tournaments happening online frequently. Obviously the big events like EVO are still offline, but you could say the same about the majors for DotA, LoL, even Brood War, which are all very "online-first" games. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GGPO https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GGPO
- VyseofArcadia 2y agoOnline play has definitely gotten bigger in the FGC, but the people I know in the community[0] still largely consider offline play king. In a game scene where individual frames matter, the preferred way to play for keeps is offline on a CRT. But, you know, halfway decent online play is fun and good for making sure you don't get too rusty. I think the big difference between EVO and e.g. DoTA offline majors[1] is that anyone can show up at EVO and jump into the pools. For other esport events, to play in an offline event, you first have to have qualified online. If the whole process were offline beginning to end, that would be closer to the FGC model. [0] I myself only dabble, somewhere between filthy casual and semi-serious [1] and do correct me if I'm wrong, I don't know that much about the competitive MOBA and FPS scenes
- lenerdenator 2y agoI was into vidya about 15 years ago when I was in college. Now that I've got all of the money to build a bitchin' system... I'm not into vidya. The MBAs got to it and we now _must_ have a multiplayer game with anticheat because if we don't have anticheat how are we supposed to sell the tournaments surrounding the game to streaming audiences as a way to monetize an otherwise free-to-play* game? We let people make this hobby into their whole lives and when you do that, it has to be monetized, and it begins to suck.
- gary_0 2y agoWhat online pastime we enjoyed 15 years ago hasn't been monetized all to shit? Making goofy YouTube videos? All about the big bucks now. Fuckin' blogging? Now there's Medium/Substack. Dicking around on a message board? Sorry, spez needs his billions. And if you're a gamer, don't forget to run some ads on your Twitch stream for easy money! The Internet is no fun anymore.
- citizenpaul 2y agoIf only the steam deck were owned by a company with mountains of cash and could afford to pay a team dedicated to making the platform cheat resistant.
- Snacklive 2y agoExplain your reasoning here, because as i see it. It should be every game dev responsibility to ensure their game is not vulnerable no matter the platform you are using to play.
- citizenpaul 2y agoNot really my reasoning. The article has some quotes that basically the openness of linux means it is not difficult to compile your own distro that is purpose built for cheating. I have no personal exp with cheating systems or game dev. Assuming the quotes are true it would be beneficial to everyone(including themself)if valve took on the burden of making an anti cheat distro of linux for their gaming platform. Sure the game devs need to worry about security too.
- Ferret7446 2y agoUnfortunately the steam deck is owned by a company with mountains of cash and pays a team to make it as open and consumer friendly as possible.
- greatgib 2y agoMaybe these companies should think why people are cheating in the first place and work on that. I have the feeling that recent games that push you to loot box and equivalent might be a big incentive. What are the incentives? - Global leaderboard? - you need to play hours or spend money to have better gears then other players? - Winning sequence allows to humiliate the looser. Like end game video. ...
- Raymond122 2y ago[dead]