4 ms·
Consumption per se does not incentivize it, though; procurement does. It's not unreasonable to causally connect one to the other, but I still think that it need
by int_19h 2y ago
Consumption per se does not incentivize it, though; procurement does. It's not unreasonable to causally connect one to the other, but I still think that it needs to be done explicitly. Strict liability for possession in particular is nonsense.
There's also an interesting question wrt simulated (drawn, rendered etc) CSAM, especially now that AI image generators can produce it in bulk. There's no individual suffering nor social damage involved in that at any point, yet it's equally illegal in most jurisdictions, and the penalties aren't any lighter. I've yet to see any sensible arguments in favor of this arrangement - it appears to be purely a "crime against nature" kind of moral panic over the extreme ickiness of the act as opposed to any actual harm caused by it.
- jjk7 2y ago[flagged]
- int_19h 2y agoIcky things were historically made illegal all the time, but most of those historical examples have not fared well in retrospect. Modern justice systems are generally predicated on some quantifiable harm for good reasons. Given the extremely harsh penalties at play, I am not at all comfortable about punishing someone with a multi-year prison sentence for possession of a drawn or computer generated image. What exactly is the point, other than people getting off from making someone suffer for reasons they consider morally justifiable?
- jampekka 2y agoThere's no room for sensible discussion like this in these matters. Not demanding draconian sentences for morally outraging crimes is morally outraging.
- programjames 2y agoI think their point was they think the law should be based off of harms, not necessarily "morals" (since no one can seem to decide on those).
- int_19h 2y agoGP is saying that people who want this to be a crime are morally outraged that someone else might disagree, and so it's impossible to have a reasonable debate with them about it. They're probably correct, but it never hurts to try.
- programjames 2y agoOof, I fell victim to Poe's law
- akira2501 2y ago> Consumption per se does not incentivize it, It can. In several public cases it seems fairly clear that there is a "community" aspect to these productions and many of these sites highlight the number of downloads or views of an image. It creates an environment where creators are incentivized to go out of their way to produce "popular" material. > Strict liability for possession in particular is nonsense. I entirely disagree. Offenders tend to increase their level of offense. This is about preventing the problem from becoming worse and new victims being created. It's effectively the same reason we harshly prosecute people who torture animals. > nor social damage involved in that at any point, That's a bold claim. Is it based on any facts or study? > over the extreme ickiness of the act as opposed to any actual harm caused by it. It's about the potential class of victims and the outrageous life long damage that can be done to them. The appropriate response to recognizing these feelings isn't to hand them AI generated material to sate their desires. It's to get them into therapy immediately.
- hnbad 2y ago> > Strict liability for possession in particular is nonsense. > I entirely disagree. Offenders tend to increase their level of offense. For an example of unintended consequences of strict liability for possession look at Germany where the legal advice for what to do if you come across CSAM is to delete it and say nothing because reporting it to the police would incriminate you for possession and if you deleted a prosecutor could charge you with evidence tampering on top of it. Also, as I understand it, in the US there have also been cases of minors deliberately taking "nudes" or sexting with other minors leading to charges of production and distribution of CSAM for their own pictures they took of themselves. The production and distribution of CSAM should 100% be criminalized and going after possession seems reasonable to me. But clearly the laws are lacking if they also criminalize horny teenagers being stupid or people trying to do the right thing and report CSAM they come across. > The appropriate response to recognizing these feelings is [..] to get them into therapy immediately. Also 100% agree with this. In Germany there was a widespread media campaign "Kein Täter werden" (roughly "not becoming a predator") targeting adults who find sexually attracted to children. They anonymized the actors for obvious reasons but I like that they portrayed the pedophiles with a wide range of characters from different walks of life and different age groups. The message was to seek therapy. They provided a hotline as well as ways of getting additional information anonymously. Loudly yelling "kill all pedophiles" doesn't help prevent child abuse (in fact, there is a tendency for abusers to join in because it provides cover and they often don't see themselves as the problem) but feeding into pedophilia certainly isn't helpful either. The correct answer is therapy but also moving away from a culture (and it is cultural not innate) that fetishizes youth, especially in women (sorry, "girls"). This also means fighting all child abuse, not just sexual. > It's effectively the same reason we harshly prosecute people who torture animals. Alas harsh sentencing isn't therapy. Arguably incarceration merely acts as a pause button at best. You don't get rid of nazis by making them hang out on Stormfront or 8kun.
- throwaway738716 2y agoAI-generated CSAM is real CSAM and should be treated that way legally. The image generators used to generate it are usually trained on pictures of real children.