5 ms·
What's so horrible about CakePHP?
by Kiro 14y ago
What's so horrible about CakePHP?
- mikegirouard 14y agoIts legacy (who wants to still support PHP4?). AFAIK, it's no longer maintained; I believe all the core development is now taking place on the Lithium project: http://lithify.me/ http://lithify.me/
- Kiro 14y agoIsn't Lithium just a fork? CakePHP 2.2 was released just a few days ago and they dropped PHP4 support in 2.* I think.
- Kudos 14y agoIt's not a fork, it's a separate project by 2 former Cake developers.
- giulianob 14y agoCakePHP 2.x did a major rewrite of nasty parts and dropped support for PHP 4. It's actually very well done and much more consistent now.
- unavoidable 14y agoNone of these things are true, I don't know where anyone comes up with this stuff. Sounds like a smear job more than anything. CakePHP2 is PHP 5.2.8+[1]. It's still being maintained and 2.2 was released this week[2]. Lithium is not a real 'fork' from Cake - rather it is a project that two of the Cake devs were working on as a 'next gen CakePHP' but decided to make into a separate project - the two frameworks don't share any code in their 'production' releases. Lithium has a much smaller community and is still poorly documented (as far as I can tell having tried to use it for a project). [1] http://book.cakephp.org/2.0/en/appendices/2-0-migration-guide.html#php-version-support http://book.cakephp.org/2.0/en/appendices/2-0-migration-guid... [2] http://bakery.cakephp.org/articles/lorenzo/2012/07/01/cakephp_2_2_and_2_1_4_released http://bakery.cakephp.org/articles/lorenzo/2012/07/01/cakeph...
- mikegirouard 14y ago> Sounds like a smear job more than anything. Not at all. I'm sorry you misunderstood. Cake has been quite good to me over the years. Ever since I switched to Lithium I haven't looked back.
- sequoia 14y agoWrong wrong wrong wrong wrong. I can see you posted this without doing so much as a single google search pointing your browser to "cakephp.org". I am interested in hearing skrebbel's response to this question however (what makes cake so horrible).
- mikegirouard 14y agoGoodness. Sorry. Perhaps I just misunderstood. To me it seems sold as the successor to Cake. http://www.meetup.com/lithium/ http://www.meetup.com/lithium/
- sequoia 14y agoThe Lithium folks (nate & gwoo in particular) split off from the Cake core team. There was some contention but generally speaking I think everyone is still friends. As for lithium being the successor to cake 1.3... well certainly nate & gwoo feel that way, that's why they built it. :) And certainly phpnut & mark_story don't feel that way, that's why they are still driving forward with cake 2.0. Anyway they are both cool projects but I was reacting strongly to your assertion that cake is "no longer maintained", which is as accurate as saying RoR is no longer maintained and has been officially superseded by Node+Express.
- brendoncrawford 14y ago> AFAIK, it's no longer maintained False. Last commit was 18 hours ago.
- skrebbel 14y agoAdmittedly, I used it a long time ago. Back then, it was obviously never really used by any of its developers for things beyond the trivial "Blog Tutorial". For example, you couldn't reasonably put model-related code in your model classes, because the model data (coming in from the ORM as nested associative arrays) were structured subtly different depending on how it came in (i.e. on which ModelPeer the query originated). This effectively forced you to make fat controllers and useless models. Additionally, I know of no framework that reinvented more wheels than CakePHP.