3 ms·
It's not that "busy" though, is it? My understanding is that asteroids are pretty damn small and very far away from each other. It's always funny to see an "Ast
by ryandrake 2y ago
It's not that "busy" though, is it? My understanding is that asteroids are pretty damn small and very far away from each other. It's always funny to see an "Asteroid Belt" in Sci Fi movies and TV, where it looks like they're flying their spaceships through a raging river of rocks dodging one every second. In reality: if you were standing on any asteroid in the belt, would you even be able to see any other one with the naked eye?
- dylan604 2y agoSo you have a gripe about sci-fi for not being realistic about asteroid fields, but the ability to fly a space craft with the agility of a fighter jet on Earth is okay? I love the arbitrary nature every single sci-fi person has in their application of suspension of disbelief. There's a lot of times I end up thinking, "oh I didn't think about that" after someone mentions a hang up they have, and there's other times where I'm laughing at the ridiculous nature while someone else thought it was much more acceptable.
- ARandumGuy 2y agoI think it's less "this asteroid belt is unrealistic," and more "I assumed asteroid belts were dense because that's what it's like in movies." For a lot of people, they know that super nimble spaceships aren't real, but they may have never thought about asteroid belt density. People often see something in media that seems plausible, and assume that's what it's like in reality, even if the media portrayal was way off. I can guarantee it's happened to you at some point.
- dylan604 2y agoThe asteroid belt around Sol might be sparse, but what about other solar systems, other galaxies far far away?
- dotancohen 2y agoThen gravity would condense it all down into a planet in very short order, geologically speaking. For an example in our own system, see Saturn's rings.
- shiroiushi 2y agoGeologically speaking, sure. But humans don't live in geological timescales: it seems possible that, if humans could somehow explore other star systems on a regular basis, they might come across some systems where there was a relatively recent collision leaving lots of close-together asteroids that haven't yet had enough time to condense into a new body.
- adastra22 2y agoYes, like Saturn's rings.
- dotancohen 2y agoIf such collisions are common, then yes.
- gus_massa 2y agoIf the density of the asteroid belt is too high, I guess it (slowly) collapses and you get a planet.
- kadoban 2y agoA belt like shown in many movies would become a damn black hole with how dense and large they are. They're not just unlike Sol's, they're completely ridiculous.
- jiggawatts 2y agoTo be fair, in at least some movies they only say “asteroids” instead of “asteroid belt”. The aftermath of a recent collision between large bodies might be attractive to future spacefarers because it could expose the differentiated insides of planetoids in a convenient high-density but accessible form for mining. So it wouldn’t be entirely unrealistic for “future stories” to be playing out in these rich and dense regions instead of the space equivalent of the middle of a barren desert. A statistically representative locale for a story on Earth would be in the middle of an ocean, but that’s not where most stories come from.
- andrewflnr 2y agoTrue, but that's not what they usually depict on screen. We see lots of "normal looking", i.e. rounded, well-aged, thoroughly cratered asteroids, neither the fresh shards or glowing/molten material we would expect from a collision. I do like the idea of prospectors diving into the debris of a recent asteroid collision to gather halfway pre-refined resources. With the rarity of asteroid collisions relative to human lifespans, I imagine the response the way deep sea creatures respond to a whale fall, sudden massive availability of resources. I might try to write that someday.
- jiggawatts 2y ago> neither the fresh shards or glowing/molten material we would expect from a collision. That's also an undesirable "area" of space for mining. A too-recent collision would be a dangerous area because of the excessive density. A "just right" area for mining might be a hundred thousands years old, but not tens of millions or older. The terran analogy would be a volcano: Too soon and you're still ankle-deep in lava. Some decades later you have the most fertile land on the planet for your crops. A billion years later it's no different to any other part of the planet and not especially productive. > whale fall That's precisely what I was thinking of! > I might try to write that someday. I'd read that story! It's a ripe context for drama: the luck of discovery, the gold rush, the fight over the territory by rival groups, the "frontier" aspects and lack of civilized law and order, etc...
- ForOldHack 2y agoYou should ask them.
- buran77 2y ago> the arbitrary nature "Sci-fi" already tells you what's the fictional part of the story: the science/tech, and maybe some fundamental rules around those. Fantasy is where you get to rewrite the basic rules of the universe. In the span of a few decades we went from no planes to flying at almost Mach 10 in air (X-43) and 600.000km/h in space (Parker probe), and from AM radio to a super-computer in everyone's pocket. So you can bet any person can reasonably imagine that in a few centuries we could be advanced enough to build today's sci-fi. That's because they have a few real anchor points in the history of human civilization or even their own lifetime and an easy assessment of the progress of science between them. Most people also actually think asteroid belts are that dense. But that's because even basic concepts about gravity aren't immediately apparent from day to day experience. Basic grasp of gravity will never allow you to believe it naturally "wears off" in an asteroid field so the chunks stay close enough to even collide but magically never clump together, or that 1000 years "in the future" will change what was constant for billions of years. It only seems arbitrary if you don't bother to think about it.
- everforward 2y agoI feel like most people grasp the decay of gravity because of space, and because the moon doesn’t crash into us, etc. I would wager it’s because the space involved is incomprehensible. It’s not obvious why rocks being 600k miles apart forms any kind of feature. That’s 24 trips around the circumference of the earth. I had honestly presumed they were closer. Not sci-fi movie close, but maybe a few miles in between? Space is incomprehensibly large to me.
- haccount 2y agoIf they grasp how gravity is "decaying" because things are in orbit then they've failed to understand both orbital mechanics and how gravity drops off at distance.
- adastra22 2y agoI think what you're saying is right but the explanation is backwards. I think of "science fiction" as being fiction in which the science is held constant--the universe works more or less the same way, but with humanity and their technology exploring a different landscape of the possibility space. So the science is real, not fictional. The plot is fiction. Of course this assumes we're talking about hard sci-fi, which doesn't include stuff like Star Wars.
- andrewflnr 2y ago> but the ability to fly a space craft with the agility of a fighter jet on Earth is okay? What makes you think that GP thinks that? The mere fact that they didn't mention that, among all extant silliness in scifi media, in the context of a discussion about asteroids?
- dylan604 2y agobecause they said "where it looks like they're flying their spaceships through a raging river of rocks dodging one every second.
- dpedu 2y agoWikipedia puts the average distance between 'roids at about 600,000 miles, so I'm going with no. Also mentioned is the estimate that the mass of the entire belt is thought to be 3% of weight of the moon. That's crazy tiny, considering how much space it is spread out over. It would been like seeing an object 1/3000 the size of our moon at twice the distance away.
- shiroiushi 2y ago>Also mentioned is the estimate that the mass of the entire belt is thought to be 3% of weight of the moon. That's crazy tiny It's worse than that: 60% of that mass is contained in only 4 asteroids, the largest of which is the dwarf planet Ceres. So if you ignore those 4 bodies for a moment, the rest of the asteroids are only around 1.2% of the Moon's mass.
- mandevil 2y agoI remember doing the math once years ago and if you presume that all of the asteroids are pure Fe, you have on the order of 100 atoms/m^3 of density in the "asteroid belt."