7 ms·
How US software ended up powering Chinese assault helicopters
- yaakov34 14y agoI think all this does is illustrate how ridiculous US export controls are, and how hypocritical the West's stance vis-a-vis China is. First, the idiocy of the export controls: maybe they made some sense when the US was a sole source for certain technologies, but right now, the US is not even the leading technological power in many fields in which it insists on export controls, let alone the sole supplier. If Turbomeca is standing in line to supply China with engines with FADEC, which can be put on civilian or military helicopters as China wishes, then what do these export controls do, other than impose paperwork and misery on anyone who is dealing with any US supplier? Not to mention that China will shortly be producing these engines by itself. Second, the hypocrisy: look, either the West can decide that the Chinese regime is evil, and refuse to do business with it, or it can do a trillion dollars a year worth of import/export with China, and stop trying to hide behind the microscopic fig leaf of not allowing military exports. With the world rushing to sell any piece of technology to China in order to counterbalance the Chinese exports, and with China being more than sophisticated enough to adapt technology for military use, this is fooling no one.
- drewcrawford 14y ago> then what do these export controls do, other than impose paperwork and misery on anyone who is dealing with any US supplier? They make the French supplier the only supplier, granting them a monopoly and making it impossible for china to source the parts at current market rates. Do you know how difficult it is to get ordinary, commonly-available stuff shipped to your door in a friendly country like Saudi Arabia? Think about that hassle, but on a governmental level. It's not a national security goal. It's a diplomacy goal. Now it's fine to ask whether or not private US companies should be roped into doing the state department's dirty work, of course, but that's a different conversation.
- raintrees 14y agoAnd yet my first take-away from the article is that this seems to be another example of profits being more important than anything or anyone else. To me, it seems to be similar to decisions like the profits from the installation and operation of a dam in certain localities is more important than the heritage/sustainability/subsistence of the local indigenous population that had been living in the now flooded valleys for many (in some cases thousands?) of years. Or getting some return on stockpiles of chemicals that are illegal in one country by selling them to a country where they are not yet illegal. The reason they were made illegal usually being damage to ecosystems/humans/animals/whatever not as important than the almighty unit of currency. I kind of knew I was going to be depressed by reading Jerry Mander's The Capitalism Papers... Gotta pay more attention to my instincts. Sigh.
- yk 14y agoFrance has export controls too [1], as most of the G20 [2]. However I do not believe that the entire export control regime is flawed, since it is primarily designed to prevent proliferation to less sophisticated countries who have to buy entire weapon systems. In the case of china these controls do not work well, since China can also integrate dual-use goods themselves. [1] http://www.diplomatie.gouv.fr/en/france-priorities/disarmament-arms-control/arms-control-and-arms-trade/export-control-the-instrument-for/war-material-export-control/ http://www.diplomatie.gouv.fr/en/france-priorities/disarmame... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wassenaar_Arrangement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wassenaar_Arrangement
- robomartin 14y agoHumanity has the ability to destroy all life on this planet many times over. As intelligent as we all think we are it is a sad note to realize that we are still in the caveman mental state of wanting the bigger stick. Will we ever turn the corner? Haven't we seen and caused enough death already? The problem isn't export controls. The problem is that we need to finally break away from the animals we think we evolved away from.
- ars 14y ago> Humanity has the ability to destroy all life on this planet many times over. Yah, that isn't even remotely true. It's often said, but completely false. And without competition there is no life. And competition often results in war. Notice how companies that trounce all competition then go on to completely stagnate. It happens to humans too. Once you have nothing you need to fight for you don't bother doing anything. Look what happens to every major artist once they no longer work - they have lots of money, and no need to work, so they destroy their life. Look at what happens to rich kids who got their money via inheritance, with no need to work for it. Or the prototypical story of a retiree that dies within a year. It's is essential to human survival to always have to fight. I know what you are thinking: Fight for good things, and stop war. But that isn't possible, you can't split human nature that way. (Plants are the same way: Prune a plant and you will trigger massive growth.)
- robomartin 14y ago>> Humanity has the ability to destroy all life on this planet many times over. > Yah, that isn't even remotely true. It's often said, but completely false. Really? You don't think that the nuclear arsenal in place around the world has the capacity to cause massive life loss on this planet? It's only a matter of time until the "bad guys" (whoever you choose to crown as such) escalate things up to bio/chem weaponry. Bio weapons are actually scarier than nukes. Don't say it won't happen. We have a proven capacity to cause untold death and destruction. The world wars and various genocides are proof enough.
- ars 14y ago
- losethos 14y agoYou want to fight God? God says... 8:14 Jesus answered and said unto them, Though I bear record of myself, yet my record is true: for I know whence I came, and whither I go; but ye cannot tell whence I come, and whither I go. 8:15 Ye judge after the flesh; I judge no man. 8:16 And yet if I judge, my judgment is true: for I am not alone, but I and the Father that sent me. 8:17 It is also written in your law, that the testimony of two men is true. 8:18 I am one that bear witness of myself, and the Father that sent me beareth witness of me. 8:19 Then said they unto him, Where is thy Father? Jesus answered, Ye neither know me, nor my Father: if ye had known me, ye should have known my Father also.
- Zenst 14y agoWOW and too think alot of people were worried about playstation PS/3's going to china as they were super powerful processing chips at one stage and at the same time well, just read the article. The whole aspect that you can sell something for non milatary use and it has a milatary use is crazy if you have a ban. A ban should be blanket or non. Allowing obvious abusable loopholes is just a silly position to be in. What next - they purchase a load of nukes on the pretence there to be used as christmas tree ornaments. Crazy.
- Volpe 14y agoChina (as usual) painted as an evil villain to the righteous U.S. A great startup idea, would be a media outlet that didn't push such a massive point of view on everything... Likely, a lot of media outlets probably started that way...
- seanmcdirmid 14y agoYou mean the high-quality unbiased news we can get from CCTV? China has a fairly opaque government that is not very sensitive to public opinion (and especially international opinion); that they are often painted as the bad guy has nothing to do with bias.
- Volpe 14y ago> You mean the high-quality unbiased news we can get from CCTV? No, I didn't mean that. I never mentioned such a thing... :\ > China has a fairly opaque government that is not very sensitive to public opinion (and especially international opinion); that they are often painted as the bad guy has nothing to do with bias. I'm curious where you got this view from, from the varied news sources I've read, the Chinese govt is VERY sensitive to public opinion... hence why it runs 24 hour propaganda platforms like CCTV. But regardless, is it 'bad' to be a non-democratic government? Why? What is the 'bad guy' view based on, if not bias? (Of course in the context of how the U.S itself operates, given that was the basis of my comment).
- seanmcdirmid 14y agoJust for the record, I'm not downvoting you (only have 200 karma points, can't downvote) and disagree that you need to be downvoted. The CCP is not sensitive to real public opinion since they censor/hide/or simply ignore facts. They are very much vested in shaping opinion, of course, but they care nothing about honest opinions. Consider that they don't even want to perform scientific polls (or have them performed by third parties), since they don't care about the results and would find them embarrassing regardless. That China is the bad guy has nothing to do with them being non-demecratic, and everything to do with just being overtly dishonest about world truth. If the CCP tomorrow started being honest about everything, good and bad, we would see them in a much more sympathetic light even as we contined to disagree with them and bad things continued to happen (we want clarity, not perfection). But the CCP contines to see face as being much more important to their continued existence than truth, and so I doubt this will end very soon.
- ars 14y agoWhy is there an implied assumption that Russia and China have no ability to develop this stuff on their own? And an even bigger question is why do Russia and China think it too. I've never heard of the US trying to steal technology at a national level - it wouldn't even occur to them. So why do Russia and China do it? They have tons of engineers, there is no way that can't invent this stuff too.
- Volpe 14y ago> I've never heard of the US trying to steal technology at a national level - it wouldn't even occur to them. What exactly is the CIA then? I'm pretty sure it occurs to them. Just because a) they aren't caught or b) it isn't reported. Doesn't mean it's not happening. Even if you suspected your tech was more advanced, you would still steal your opponents in order to gauge where they were at.
- ars 14y agoI assume the CIA looks for intelligence, i.e. plans, advancements, capabilities, stuff like that. Not engineering plans to actually make a product. > Even if you suspected your tech was more advanced, you would still steal your opponents in order to gauge where they were at. Kinda missed my point there didn't you? I'm talking about stealing tech in order to use it. Stealing tech to find out about it is not the same thing.
- Volpe 14y agoI don't think I missed your point. I suspect the CIA do a multitude of things, encompassing what we've both said. I was simply illustrating that just because you haven't heard about it. Doesn't mean it didn't happen.
- sasvari 14y agoI've never heard of the US trying to steal technology at a national level - it wouldn't even occur to them. Never heard of ECHELON [0] before? There even was a European Parliament Committee investigating ECHELON effectively stating that the U.S. used ECHELON to eavesdrop on private and commercial communication of befriended nations, thus that the NSA (responsible on the U.S. site for ECHELON) is performing industrial espionage. If the U.S. is doing that with their partners, you can bet on that they try to do that with RUS, CHN et. al. [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ECHELON http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ECHELON
- chj 14y ago4 or 5 years ago, fedex was fined because it shipped a flight simulation game to a Chinese student in Bejing University of Aeronautics. US always complained about CN export/import imbalance, OTOH it simply doesn't want to export any high tech products.
- wtracy 14y agoThe part that struck me as most ridiculous about this was that the technology export was legal as long as it was "dual use". If China had just done a better job of covering up their true intentions, then UTC wouldn't have broken any laws in the first place. I'll be the first to admit that I'm not an aerospace engineer. I imagine that some of the required "customizations" would have been difficult to request without revealing the true purpose of the aircraft. Still, the Chinese are pretty good at reverse-engineering, and something that does 90% of what you need has got to be a good starting point.
- gaius 14y agoThank God they didn't include software for downloading movies, or someone would be in Guantanamo Bay right now.