5 ms·
Apple iPhone 16 Is Now Illegal in Indonesia, Ban Leaves Tourists in the Lurch
- schiffern 2y ago>The ban stems from Apple’s failure to fulfill its investment commitments in Indonesia. Reports indicate that the tech giant has invested approximately 1.48 trillion Rupiah (around $95 million) of the promised 1.71 trillion Rupiah, resulting in a shortfall of about 230 billion Rupiah ($14.75 million). So it's a classic shake-down, neat.
- Sakos 2y agoErm, the US, EU, China and others do this exact same thing. I guess it can be construed as a shakedown, but it's pretty normal globally. The context you conveniently left out: > Earlier this month, the minister had already indicated that the iPhone 16 could not be sold in the country due to the pending TKDN certification, which requires that 40 percent of a product’s content be sourced locally. This certification is crucial for Apple as it is linked to the company’s commitment to establish research and development facilities in Indonesia, known as the Apple Academy
- threatofrain 2y agoWhat is the leading example of the US banning consumers from owning a product unless you invest? This isn't just banning someone from selling, this is asking you to report your neighbor if you see them owning an iPhone.
- talldayo 2y ago> What is the leading example of the US banning consumers from owning a product unless you invest? DJI, Chinese electric cars/phones, mass-produced solar and battery tech and firearms manufactured abroad to name a few. All of which are being considered for bans under the pretense that they're not domestic enough to trust and import. Indonesia is right to take a strong approach here; Apple is a documented tax dodger in the EU and would have likely ignored lesser action.
- threatofrain 2y ago> DJI, Chinese electric cars/phones, mass-produced solar and battery tech and firearms manufactured abroad to name a few. All of which are being considered for bans under the pretense that they're not domestic enough to trust and import. Consumers can own all these things without fear of being reported. I work with an official DJI reseller and I automate DJI gear for government. What is the leading example of the US banning consumers from owning a product unless you invest?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- earnesti 2y agoUS is crazy rich and powerful Country that has plenty of tools to pressure companies to do what they want. Indonesia is a poor ass country that has to resort to cheap tricks like this one.
- elzbardico 2y agoCuban Cigars.
- threatofrain 2y agoIt's legal for citizens to own and use Cuban cigars, and Cuba is not going to invest its way into getting cigars into the US.
- lesuorac 2y agoThat's not an example of the US banning a company for not investing into the US. USG is banning (only passed House) [1] DJI because Chinese law requires DJI to hand over data and USG is not a fan. This may be a bit like calling the kettle black because of various US laws but again it's not an example of the US banning a company for not investing. [1]: https://www.commercialuavnews.com/us-house-approves-dji-drone-ban-bill https://www.commercialuavnews.com/us-house-approves-dji-dron...
- 0xbadcafebee 2y agoThere are many examples, but the most famous is TikTok. They had to either sell part of their company [to an American company] or be banned in the US. They didn't sell so now they're being banned. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Restrictions_on_TikTok_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Restrictions_on_TikTok_in_the_... Much more common than an outright ban is simply egregious tariffs. (Which didn't do anything to stave off foreign competition or increase local competition, but it did line our pockets)
- seanmcdirmid 2y agoYou are still leaving out that using TikTok still won't be illegal in the USA, it won't be blocked either, just that TikTok won't be able to do businesses in the US (i.e. sell ads), or having other companies do business with it (so no app on the iPhone). It is not like the states are going to block TikTok with a GFW that doesn't exist. Of course, the inability for TikTok to make money in the USA is going to be a huge hit that the company probably can't get out of.
- max51 2y ago> but the most famous is TikTok Are they proposing to arrest people who have TikTok on their phone and encouraging you snitch to the police of you see people using tiktok? what Indonesia is doing is on a completely different level.
- BlueTemplar 2y agoWeren't egregious tariffs what allowed the USA to develop its own industry, instead of being smothered by the much bigger British industries ?
- no_wizard 2y agoThat’s not what the US does. The US has bigger infrastructure, and typically more pull in the financial sphere. They’ll usually seize funds directly if they really need to, and they have, or pressure governments in numerous other ways. Different ballgame altogether The only real exceptions have been chips and electronics from China particularly regarding wireless infrastructure and computing. TikTok also comes to mind
- threatofrain 2y agoThe US fears Chinese military and economic capability. TikTok cannot invest its way out; there is a smell of conflict in the air. TikTok selling or leaving is the same as leaving or leaving.
- transcriptase 2y ago“The US fears Chinese military capability” is one of the funniest things I’ve read in ages. There’s a limit to how capable the leadership of a military can be without any real world experience aside from harassing the ships and aircraft of other nations with dangerous interception maneuvers.
- BlueTemplar 2y agoWell, it's true in the sense that a direct military attack in unimaginable either way because of nuclear weapons. Before them, Great Powers didn't shy from directly attacking each other !
- talldayo 2y agoBut ICBMs don't do anything besides launch nukes. The parent comment has a point - China can "harass" the United States with their materiel across thousands of miles of seawater, but America generally doesn't care. There is no Chinese threat to American airspace when both countries are thousands of miles away from each other. The Pacific ocean itself is so large that preemptive long-range shipping attacks are considered to be technologically impossible too. And I'll even go a further step to argue that China copied the United States' nuclear scheme to be deterrent rather than aggressive. Their ICBMs are clustered in uninhabited lands in the northwest of the country, forcing potential aggressors to either nuke China's nukes or strike fast enough that China can't respond. The goal of China's nuclear program, it would seem, is not to enable a panoply of tactical effects like the US or USSR, but just to remind the world not to attack their soil.
- elzbardico 2y agoThe US has the pull to make foreing companies not sell their products to countries sanctioned by the US. TSMC can't sell a lot of products to China, neither ASML. You can't fly to Cuba directly from the US, neither can import their Cigars. Venezuela, Iran and Russia along other's can't access their international reserves deposited in American Banks. It is just a different scale and for completely different reasons. If anything, other countries are learning to play by the same playbook for their particular reasons.
- jepler 2y agohttps://www.flightconnections.com/flights-from-iah-to-hav https://www.flightconnections.com/flights-from-iah-to-hav there are direct flights from USA to Cuba these days
- coliveira 2y agoUS sanctions are basically an illegal scheme. They're not supported by any kind of foreign law or treaty, unless such a sanction has been agreed by the UN. In general, the US just takes that out their own *ss and shove into other peoples throat. No wonder other countries are banding together to avoid these criminal practices altogether.
- phatfish 2y agoIf something has to be approved by the UN it will never happen. Especially any action against Russia. The UN secretary-general was recently bowing to Putin at the BRICS get together. Putin has an ICC arrest warrant issued for the invasion of Ukraine. I believe the UN endorses the ICC, at least it used to.
- coliveira 2y ago> If something has to be approved by the UN it will never happen Include there any action against Israel for killing thousands of children and starving millions, and against the US for supplying these weapons. Prosecutors in the international war crimes court asked for Netaniahoo to be arrested for crimes against humanity.
- pverghese 2y agoTiktok huawei...so many more
- theshrike79 2y agoSo the government said you can't use your Huawei phone even in private anymore? When?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- uh_uh 2y agoApple has invested $95M, and missing $14.75M. So they have reached 86% of the 40% target. Based on this logic, 34% of the iPhone 16 was sourced from Indonesia? Not trying to be snarky, I'm probably misunderstanding this. Sidenote: this website is unreadable on a mobile browser due to popups, auto-playing videos, etc.
- crossroadsguy 2y agoNo, it's like missed payment, missed taxes and then being told to pay up. When a company promises to invest money in a country it's not from the bottom of their charitable hearts. It's because they get tons of benefits, preferences, cuts for that. If you don't invest after that you basically are going for a free ride. In fact this looks like least of a shake-down. Shake down was what was done in Brazil to X (and I actually loved that shakedown - that's a different story), shakedown is what India did to TikTok (again, it was needed), what US did to Huawei (and rightly so) etc. Also you have generously not included parts of the article that clarifies things.
- HeatrayEnjoyer 2y agoI think they meant Apple is doing the shake-down.
- JoshTriplett 2y agoThere's a huge difference between prohibiting the import and sale of a product (much more reasonable) and prohibiting the ownership and use of a product (much less reasonable).
- FabHK 2y agoI’d think that importing and using for example an aviation band transceiver is regulated in most countries, and prohibited unless both the device and the user fulfil certain requirements. As such, prohibiting the ownership and use of a device is nothing extraordinary.
- JoshTriplett 2y agoThat's an entirely different case, and absolutely an extraordinary one. The prohibited thing there is transmitting on an aviation band without fulfilling the requirements to do so; that prohibition would apply just as much whether you hand-built a transmitter yourself, or bought a domestically produced one, or imported one.
- transcriptase 2y agoNah, see it’s just like the 30% cut of revenue Apple demands for the privilege of being in their App Store under the guise of it being for the greater good. Indonesia just needs to take a page out of their playbook and make a statement along the lines of: “Indonesia is committed to fostering a secure and equitable marketplace that upholds the highest standards for consumer protection and quality. By partnering with Apple through a certification program, we support the integrity of Apple’s products and ensure they align with our local regulatory standards, creating a trusted environment for our citizens. In exchange for this certification, their investment enables us to maintain rigorous oversight, build public safety infrastructure, and continue fostering an innovative ecosystem where global tech leaders like Apple can deliver safe, high-quality products to our market.”
- xvector 2y agoYou can be arrested for even owning the iPhone 16, and are encouraged to report people owning it - this is some real authoritarian loser energy. No one is gonna want to invest in Indonesia if they keep doing shit like this. Indonesia will relax real fast if the US imposes some harsh tariffs (which it should.) We let other countries rent seek from our companies way too much.
- fhdsgbbcaA 2y ago[flagged]
- xvector 2y agoDo you really think the US is incapable of asserting economic or policy pressure over some random third world country? These countries' economic health is practically completely at our whims. Look at Cuba.
- andrewinardeer 2y agoThis 'random third world country' is the largest Muslim country in the world and has a population of 278 million people.
- rowanG077 2y agoShake-down? The article is relatively light on details. However if Apple promised these payments and didn't go through with them it's a simple case of Apple not fulfilling their obligation.
- latchkey 2y agoIt is a shake-down because they are threatening to go after regular people who should have the freedom to choose to own an iPhone 16. Who knows. Maybe Apple refused to pay them after they made the threat. If Apple caves at that point, then they will be seen as giving in.
- r00fus 2y agoI mean they did commit to paying this tax, so I'm not sure if it's a "threat" as much as a promise kept (to ban use/sale of the devices).
- latchkey 2y agoWe actually don't know what happened exactly because this is all just news articles, but having lived in SE Asia and a decent understanding of the culture... my point is that I could see it actually working out this way: 1. Indo: pay us a bunch of money 2. Apple: how much? 3. Indo: $X millions. 4. Apple: ok... pays them. 5. Indo: We actually want more and if you don't pay us, we will make it illegal to carry an iphone and we will start arresting people. 6. Apple: screw you, thats a human rights violation and we won't stand for that. One article on bloomberg [0] said there was only about 9,000 iphones that have been brought into the country so far and mostly hand carried. Apple has paid out $95m. The math isn't adding up. [0] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-10-28/indonesia-blocks-sale-of-apple-iphone-16-in-bid-for-investment https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-10-28/indonesia...
- catlikesshrimp 2y agoI am not saying Indonesia is being either fair or right, but from the bloomberg you posted: > "Rivals Samsung, Xiaomi have set up local factories to comply" Looks like the policy might work for Indonesia. Disclaimer: only read the first paragraph. The bloomberg is paywalled
- stefan_ 2y agoWhy does a certification require local investment?
- aleph_minus_one 2y agoBecause the government decided it.
- infecto 2y agoSort of referenced above. TKDN in Indonesia requires a substantial part of the product to be sourced internally. I guess the way around this in the case of special goods is to invest in the country. Sounds effectively like a tariff but maybe not.
- 0xbadcafebee 2y agoIt's a protectionist trade scheme, like tariffs, but instead forces foreign business to actively invest in local business or R&D, to level up the country's production capability. It might not have its intended result, but it's no worse than the US's exorbitant trade tariffs, which were actually increased under Biden after Trump introduced them. People always act shocked when developing countries act just as unscrupulously as the dominant powers. They learned from the best!
- burnt-resistor 2y ago2 wrongs don't make a right, but 3 lefts do. Collective punishment is terrible no matter who does it. And most tariffs are sanction-adjacent stupidity that largely leads to reprisal counter-tariffs and trade wars accomplishing nothing.
- mschuster91 2y agoWell, radio is a shared medium, so governments typically require passing some sort of certification to allow radio devices to operate in their jurisdiction. Most governments are pretty lenient, pass a set of clearly defined emissions thresholds or compliance to communications protocols verivied by a third party, others may choose to add additional requirements. The general exception to this are ham (amateur) radios, they usually have exemptions carved into frequency plans so they can run anything from fully original designs over kit builds to ready-to-operate stuff.
- mynameisvlad 2y agoWhat is the "International Mobile Equipment Identity (IMEI) certification"? I've heard of IMEI numbers, but not a "certification".
- aleph_minus_one 2y agohttps://www.quora.com/What-is-the-IMEI-certification/answer/Benjamin-IT-Certifications-Hotcerts https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-IMEI-certification/answer/...
- lucb1e 2y agoCan also just give the answer > a process that verifies that a mobile device complies with the technical specifications of a particular network operator. This certification is typically required before a device can be used on that network.
- jozza 2y agoNot really anyone's responsibility to deliver answers on a platter though.
- lucb1e 2y agoSure, just seems weird at this point to do the effort of finding a source but not just saying what it is
- mynameisvlad 2y agoIt also... Just isn't an actual answer. It's just a link to an unsourced Quora "answer" that seems to be a best guess, as well as a response that talks about the Indian process.
- mynameisvlad 2y agoThat is seemingly the only result for "IMEI certification" and is wholly unsourced and just seems to be a best guess based on the phrase. Is there an actual source, perhaps from the Indonesian authority that requires it that explains it? Because I certainly can't seem to find it.
- petesergeant 2y agoThe traditional solution is to slap a big tax on imports cf Thailand and cars. Somehow I don’t see the governor of Bali instituting checks at DPS for this.
- Andaith 2y agoWhat I find surprising about this is that the amount is so little to Apple. Their net operating cash flow is something like 120bn, and they've let their flagship product be banned in a country of 270 million people, and all the negative press, and the public perception of them, all just by not paying out 15m. I can't believe this is deliberate, so I wonder what really happened?
- Aperocky 2y agoAfter reading the article I think this reflect more negatively on the business environment of Indonesia than Apple.
- pointlessone 2y agoIndonesia is big but is it a big market for Apple? I mean even western consumers are a bit miffed by $1k phones and average salary in Indonesia is ~$227/mo [1]. Is there enough buyers to sell $15m worth of iPhones, let alone make that much profit? [1]: https://investinasia.id/blog/salary-in-indonesia/ https://investinasia.id/blog/salary-in-indonesia/
- new_user_final 2y agoThird world country mindset is a bit different. People making over $500/month will save over a year and buy $1500 phone. People of the first world country making $4000/month be like $1500 phone is too expensive.
- rangestransform 2y agoif they let a country extort them, others will follow
- jamesy0ung 2y agoIs Indonesia even a big enough market for Apple to need to worry about losing it? Looks like Asia Pacific in general is a very small portion of Apple's revenue. https://www.statista.com/statistics/382175/quarterly-revenue-of-apple-by-geograhical-region/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/382175/quarterly-revenue... On a side note, iPhone's seem to last quite a while. I still have a Xr and it runs the latest iOS quite well, so people might be good for a while if they stick with the 15.
- codybontecou 2y agoIndonesia is the 4th most populated country in the world.
- cr125rider 2y agoThat doesn’t mean the residents have the means to buy a premium product, however.
- HeatrayEnjoyer 2y agoIt's a phone, not a yacht.
- triyambakam 2y agoYeah what's a banana cost, like $10?
- theshrike79 2y agoIt's a phone that costs about 4x the gross monthly wage of an average Indonesian. About in line for an American to buy a new car.
- kredd 2y agoIf 5% of population (14M people) can afford an iPhone, it's already bigger than a lot of potential markets around the world. I'm sure they do a much more thorough analysis at Apple though.
- thomas-st 2y agoUse (and shipping via mail) is allowed according to this article, so one of the articles is wrong/outdated: https://www.straitstimes.com/asia/se-asia/iphone-16-allowed-into-indonesia-for-personal-use-not-to-be-sold-says-govt https://www.straitstimes.com/asia/se-asia/iphone-16-allowed-...
- EMCymatics 2y agoIs it political for Apple to forgo investment?