4 ms·
I predict most AI developers will be out of a job soon. Say you are making a robot that puts nuts and bolts together using DL models. In a few years, Google/Op
by amelius 2y ago
I predict most AI developers will be out of a job soon.
Say you are making a robot that puts nuts and bolts together using DL models. In a few years, Google/OpenAI will have solved this and many other physical tasks, and any client that needs nuts and bolts put together will just buy a GenericRobot that can do that.
Same for radiology-based diagnostics. Soon the mega companies will have bought enormous amounts of data and they will easily put your small radiology-AI company out of business.
Making a tool to do X on a computer? Soon, there will be LLM-based tools that can do __anything__ on a computer and they will just interface with your screen and keyboard directly.
Etc. etc.
Just about anyone working in AI right now is building a castle in someone else's kingdom.
- hobs 2y agoI predict that the current wave of AI will be useful but not nearly as useful as you hope, requiring ever more people to pour their time and energy into the overarching system it creates.
- candiddevmike 2y ago> Just about anyone working in AI right now is building a castle in someone else's kingdom. Things are innovating so fast that even if you've convinced yourself that you own the kingdom, it seems like you're one research paper or Nvidia iteration away from having to start over.
- cryptonym 2y agoThis is not putting people out of a job, this is changing their jobs. As always, workforce will adapt. Just like all previous tech, this is trying to improve efficiency. LLM can't do "anything" on a computer that's a misunderstanding of the tech but they can already interface with screen/keyboard. You overestimate the innovations abilities of big tech companies. They'll buy a lot of companies designing robots that are putting nuts and bolts together, or diagnostics, that's a great opportunity.
- ben_w 2y ago> As always, workforce will adapt I was never a fan of the term "Singularity" for the AI thing. When mathematical singularities pop up in physics, it's usually a sign the physics is missing something. Instead, I like to think of the AI "event horizon", the point in the future — always ahead, yet getting ever closer — beyond which you can no longer predict what happens next. Obviously that will depend on how much attention you pay to the developments in the field (and I've seen software developers surprised by Google Translate having an AR mode a decade after the tech was first demonstrated), but there is an upper limit even for people who obsessively consume all public information about a topic: if you're reading about it when you go to sleep, will you be surprised when you wake up by all the overnight developments? When that happens, no workforce can possibly adapt. How close is that? Dunno, but what I can say is that I cannot tell you what to expect 2 months from now, despite following developments in this field as best I can from the outside, and occasionally implementing one or other of the recent-ish AI models myself.
- cryptonym 2y agoYou don't ask people to know everything about last tech, they just need to do their job. If a new cool tool benefit is high enough, everybody will know about it and use it. Based on what you said, one could infer Translate AR mode is a nice cool but not something that'll meaningfully change the life of the average joe. Humanity had been through multiple "event horizon" or whatever you want to call it. With industrialisation, one man with some steam could suddenly do the work of thousands, and it expanded to each and every activity. Multiple "event horizon" later (transport, communication, IT), we are still there with everyone working, differently than previous generations, but still working. We improved a bit reducing child labor but doubled the workforce by including women and we always need more people at work for longer time. The only constant thing is we keep people at work until we figure out how to burn the last remaining atom. People are far too optimistic believing a new tech will move people away from work.
- ben_w 2y ago> Based on what you said, one could infer Translate AR mode is a nice cool but not something that'll meaningfully change the life of the average joe. In every case I showed it to people, they were amazed and delighted because it absolutely did matter to them. This may be a biased sample because of how many of my colleagues (like myself) didn't speak German very well despite being in Berlin, but it was definitely the case that they benefited from me showing them a thing invented a decade earlier. > Humanity had been through multiple "event horizon" or whatever you want to call it. No: an event horizon is always ahead of you. That's why I'm choosing that name and rejecting the other. You can wake up to the news the world has changed unpredictably, or the stuff you thought was scifi turned out to be possible, but it doesn't happen every day, and even less so with your* job in particular. * generic "you" More common is e.g.: radio was invented, and almost immediately people started predicting that by 2000 there would be video conference calling — fiction writers can see possible futures coming well before it's possible. Plus some futures that aren't possible, of course. Radioactivity gets discovered, Victorian fiction talks about it being weaponised. Incorrectly as it happens, but it was foreseeable. When I was a kid, phone numbers were 6 digits, and "long distance" meant the next town over. It getting better and cheaper was predictable and predicted, as were personal videophones. Even the original iPhone wasn't much of a step change from everything around it, and no single update to the iPhone was either. Sputnik? Led to Star Trek, which even in TOS had characters using tablet computers that wouldn't be realised for 40-50 years. AI? The fiction is everything and anything from I Have No Mouth, and I Must Scream to The Culture, via Her, The Terminator, Colossus: The Forbin Project, Short Circuit, and Isaac Asimov, and the attempts to do "real" predictions are even more diverse and include precursors for each scenario and what to expect on the way. Nobody knows how close any of the speculation is, or how soon it is assuming it's right, or even when specific things such as full self drive is coming (despite being in 80s TV). We don't know how long it will take between FSD and humanoid robots passing same legal/safety standard (despite everyone already being familiar with the ideas since The Jetsons) or what having them would mean in practice. We don't even know what we're getting from the AI labs as soon as the US election is over. From what I've heard, neither do they.
- krisoft 2y ago> I predict most AI developers will be out of a job soon. Once AI developers will be out of a job everyone will be out of every job. If not then the AI developers still have a job to work on those jobs which hasn't been automated yet. > Just about anyone working in AI right now is building a castle in someone else's kingdom. This doesn't ring true to me. When do you feel we should circle back to this prediction? Ten years? Fifteen? Can you formulate your thesis in a form we can verify in the future? (long bets style perhaps)
- amelius 2y ago> Once AI developers will be out of a job everyone will be out of every job. If not then the AI developers still have a job to work on those jobs which hasn't been automated yet. Maybe so, but what if AI developments accelerate and since the big companies have all the data and computational power they put you out of business faster than you can see the next thing the market wants?
- krisoft 2y agoYou mean google who seems to be institutionally incapable to pick up anything less than a kings ransom develops a taste for it? :) I will continue worrying more about randomly slipping in the shower and breaking my neck. It feels like a more probable scenairo.
- jvanderbot 2y ago> Once AI developers will be out of a job everyone will be out of every job. If not then the AI developers still have a job to work on those jobs which hasn't been automated yet. Same for software devs: We'll all be working on AI that's working on our problems, but we'll also work on our problems to generate better training data, build out the rest of the automation and verify the AI's solutions, so really AI will be doing all the work and so will we.
- amelius 2y agoI thought about it some more. > Once AI developers will be out of a job everyone will be out of every job. If not then the AI developers still have a job to work on those jobs which hasn't been automated yet. This may not be true if data is the bottleneck. AI developers may be out of a job long before the data collection has been finished to train the models.
- bonoboTP 2y agoThe general models tackle generic tasks. There is a very long tail of highly specialized tasks that you have never even heard of and the generic AI won't pick up the necessary knowledge by reading books3 and watching YouTube. Just one example would be material fatigue analysis on CT scans of airliner wings. How much such data will be included in the GPT-6 that addresses such a use case? This is just one example that I've heard about the other day when talking to an ML engineer. The world consists of so so many diverse things that are not well documented, and the knowledge is closed off in a few companies globally. Things like pharma, physical engineering things, oil and gas, agriculture. There are companies for stuff like muzzle-based cattle identification systems or pig weight estimation from videos etc. Do you think these will become features in Gemini anytime soon? Most of the world works on very niche things. People who build generic consumer apps have a very distorted view of what's actually making the world run.